Key Takeaways
1. The Digital Age's Values Can Become Vicious
Moments of more may leave us with lives of less.
Speed, choices, and individualism. The digital age touts speed, choices, and individualism as improvements to human experience. However, these values, when unchecked, can lead to impatience, shallowness, and isolation. The constant connectivity and endless options of the digital world can erode our ability to focus, cultivate deep relationships, and find contentment.
Impatient, shallow, and isolated. The speed of the digital age fosters impatience, diminishing our capacity for long-term perspective. The abundance of choices leads to shallowness, hindering our ability to engage in deep work and meaningful relationships. The emphasis on individualism results in isolation, as digital connections often mask a lack of genuine human interaction.
The church is not immune. The church, in its attempt to remain relevant, has often adopted these digital values, sometimes at the expense of its core mission. The pursuit of relevance can lead to a superficial engagement with faith, prioritizing entertainment over genuine transformation and connection.
2. Worship Should Engage, Not Just Entertain
Worship is no longer worship when it reflects the culture around us more than the Christ within us.
Whole-body participation. Biblical worship involves whole-body participation, a reverent response to God that engages our hearts, minds, and bodies. It's more than just singing songs or listening to sermons; it's offering our entire lives as a living sacrifice.
Digital distractions. The digital age has introduced distractions into worship, such as dynamic lyric projections and flashy lighting, that can turn gatherings into performances rather than participatory experiences. These elements, intended to enhance worship, can inadvertently create a divide between those on stage and those in the seats.
Seeking transcendence. People, especially younger generations, are searching for transcendence, something beyond the superficiality of the digital world. Churches that prioritize relevance over transcendence risk repelling those who are seeking a genuine encounter with the divine.
3. Analog Worship: A Countervailing Thrust
Worship reminds us of the shape of true life.
Digital informs, analog transforms. Digital tools can inform and disseminate information, but they often fall short in fostering genuine transformation. Analog experiences, on the other hand, engage our senses and emotions in ways that can lead to lasting change.
Engage, don't entertain. In the singing life of the church, the goal should be to engage people in participatory worship, not simply entertain them with a performance. This involves thoughtful song choices, appropriate volume levels, and lighting that fosters a sense of togetherness.
Witness, don't watch. In the preaching life of the church, the aim should be to invite people to witness the transformative power of the gospel, not just watch a presentation. This requires a personal connection between the communicator and the community, as well as a willingness to address the specific needs and context of the audience.
4. Community Requires Presence, Not Just Connection
To be everywhere is to be nowhere.
Rebuilding Babel. The digital age, like the Tower of Babel, has created a global village where people are more connected than ever before. However, this connection often comes at the expense of genuine community, as individuals become scattered, babbling, and unwise.
Scattered, babbling, and unwise. The digital age has led to a decline in church attendance and engagement, as people prioritize individual needs and desires over communal life. Online interactions often lack the depth and nuance of face-to-face conversations, leading to superficial connections and a loss of empathy.
Church online or an online church? Many churches have embraced online platforms in an attempt to reach a wider audience. However, an "online church" can easily become a product to be consumed rather than a community to be joined. True community requires physical presence and shared experiences.
5. The Church as Family: Commitment Over Compatibility
Commitment matters more than compatibility.
Salvation is a community-creating event. The Christian faith is not just an individual experience; it's an invitation into the family of God. This new kinship disrupts our lives, calling us to prioritize commitment over compatibility and to show up for one another in real and tangible ways.
A tax collector and a zealot. The story of Matthew and Simon, two unlikely apostles with opposing viewpoints, illustrates the transformative power of Christian community. Despite their differences, they were united by their shared commitment to Jesus.
The art of gathering. Churches should create gathering spaces and opportunities that invite people to put down their screens and show up with their whole selves. This involves fostering presence in pain, creating opportunities for confession, and prioritizing shared meals.
6. Scripture: Transformation, Not Just Information
In the choices we have made, consciously or not, about how we use our computers, we have rejected the intellectual tradition of solitary, single-minded concentration, the ethic that the book bestowed on us. We have cast our lot with the juggler.
A bookish faith. Christianity has always been a "bookish" faith, centered on the reading and hearing of Scripture. However, the digital age has led to a decline in reading and a shift toward engaging the Bible in short, bite-sized bits.
Filtering the Bible. The filtering of Scripture, often through social media posts and truncated devotionals, can lead to a superficial understanding of its message. It's important to engage the Bible as a whole, diving deeply into its long story and complex themes.
Reading for the jackpot. Many people approach the Bible as a slot machine, hoping to hit the jackpot with a quick answer or a comforting verse. However, the Bible is not a self-help guide; it's a transformative story that requires slow, deliberate engagement.
7. Read Scripture Slowly and Communally
The more that you read, the more things you will know. The more that you learn, the more places you’ll go.
Learning to read slowly. The digital age has trained us to read quickly and efficiently, but this comes at the expense of deep comprehension. To truly engage with Scripture, we must learn to read slowly and carefully, allowing the words to linger in our minds.
How to read a book. Mortimer Adler's "How to Read a Book" offers a framework for engaging with any text, including the Bible. This involves asking four key questions: What is the book about as a whole? What is being said in detail, and how? Is the book true, in whole or part? What of it?
Reading transformationally. The ultimate goal of reading Scripture is transformation. This involves not only gaining knowledge and understanding but also allowing the Bible to shape our hearts, minds, and wills. It's about being mastered by the text, not mastering it.
8. Communion: The Tangible Center of Christian Life
We need more than talk, more than words on a page; we need a touch, a smell, a taste. . . . The sacrament is more than a medium of communication; it is a medium of action, God’s action.
Physical and sensory reminders. As physical, sensory creatures, we need tangible reminders of our faith. Communion, the meal Jesus shared with his disciples, provides a physical and sensory confirmation of our new relationship with God in Jesus Christ.
Eating and drinking our way into community. Communion is not just an individual act; it's a communal experience that binds us together as the body of Christ. It's an invitation to feast with family, dining among a people to whom we eternally belong.
The meal at the center of history. Communion connects us to the past, present, and future. It reminds us of Jesus' death and resurrection, as well as the promise of his return. In the midst of a hurried and frenzied world, it offers us a moment to pause and remember the meal at the center of history.
Last updated:
FAQ
What is "Analog Church" by Jay Y. Kim about?
- Central Thesis: "Analog Church" explores why the Christian church needs to prioritize real, embodied experiences—people, places, and things—over digital convenience in the digital age.
- Critique of Digital Trends: The book critiques the church’s rush to adopt digital technologies and the resulting loss of depth, community, and transformation.
- Call to Transcendence: Jay Y. Kim argues that the church’s unique value lies in offering transcendent, analog experiences that digital platforms cannot replicate.
- Practical Focus: The book provides practical insights on worship, community, and scripture engagement, urging churches to resist the lure of digital relevance in favor of authentic, in-person discipleship.
Why should I read "Analog Church" by Jay Y. Kim?
- Timely Cultural Relevance: The book addresses urgent questions about faith, technology, and community in a world increasingly shaped by digital media.
- Practical Guidance: It offers actionable advice for church leaders and members seeking to foster deeper relationships and spiritual growth.
- Critical Reflection: Readers are encouraged to critically assess their own church’s practices and the impact of digital technology on worship and community.
- Restorative Vision: "Analog Church" inspires hope by presenting a compelling vision for a church that is countercultural, rooted, and transformative.
What are the key takeaways from "Analog Church" by Jay Y. Kim?
- Digital Convenience vs. Spiritual Depth: The pursuit of speed, choice, and individualism in digital culture often leads to impatience, shallowness, and isolation, undermining true discipleship.
- Embodied Community Matters: Real transformation happens through embodied, analog experiences—gathering, singing, eating, confessing, and journeying together.
- Worship and Scripture Engagement: Worship should be participatory and transformative, not merely entertaining or informative; scripture should be read deeply and communally, not just in bite-sized, digital snippets.
- Church as Disruptive Witness: The church’s greatest witness is not digital relevance but offering a transcendent, countercultural community that meets people’s deepest needs for connection and meaning.
How does "Analog Church" by Jay Y. Kim define the problems with digital technology in the church?
- Impatience and Shallowness: Digital technology’s emphasis on speed and choice fosters impatience and a lack of depth in spiritual practices and relationships.
- Isolation and Individualism: The customizable, individual-focused nature of digital platforms leads to isolation, undermining the communal nature of the church.
- Spectacle over Substance: Many churches have adopted digital tools that prioritize entertainment and spectacle, resulting in passive audiences rather than engaged participants.
- Loss of Embodied Presence: Digital church models often replace real, embodied presence with virtual connection, which cannot replicate the transformative power of physical community.
What does Jay Y. Kim mean by "Analog Church" and why is it important?
- Analog Defined: "Analog Church" refers to a church experience rooted in real, physical presence—gathering in person, sharing meals, singing together, and engaging in tactile practices.
- Importance of Embodiment: Kim argues that Christianity is inherently incarnational—God became flesh—so the church must prioritize embodied, analog experiences.
- Countercultural Witness: In a digital world, the analog church stands out as a place of genuine connection, depth, and transformation.
- Restoring Human Flourishing: The analog approach helps people experience true human flourishing, which digital platforms cannot provide.
How does "Analog Church" by Jay Y. Kim critique the pursuit of relevance in modern churches?
- Relevance vs. Transcendence: Kim warns that the church’s obsession with being culturally relevant—mirroring trends in music, technology, and presentation—often leads to superficiality.
- Consumer Christianity: The focus on relevance can turn church into a product to be consumed, rather than a community to be joined and transformed by.
- Loss of Distinctiveness: By chasing what’s new and trendy, churches risk losing the timeless, transcendent qualities that make them unique and compelling.
- Call to Depth: Kim advocates for a return to practices that foster depth, intentionality, and spiritual formation, even if they seem "old-fashioned."
What are the main concepts of worship, community, and scripture in "Analog Church" by Jay Y. Kim?
- Worship: True worship is whole-body participation, not just passive consumption; it should engage people physically, emotionally, and spiritually in real time and space.
- Community: Authentic Christian community is built on commitment, presence, and shared life—not just digital communication or affinity-based groups.
- Scripture: Engaging scripture should be a slow, communal, and deep process, resisting the digital age’s tendency toward fragmented, shallow, and individualistic reading.
- Transformation over Information: In all three areas, the goal is transformation, not just information or entertainment.
What practical advice does "Analog Church" by Jay Y. Kim offer for church leaders?
- Prioritize In-Person Gatherings: Design church experiences that encourage people to show up, stay, and engage deeply with one another.
- Foster Participation: Create worship environments that invite engagement—singing together, sharing stories, and involving the congregation in meaningful ways.
- Encourage Slow, Communal Scripture Reading: Promote practices like communal Bible reading, discussion, and theological exploration rather than quick, individual consumption.
- Cultivate Spaces for Confession and Feasting: Make room for honest confession, shared meals, and presence in pain, recognizing these as essential to authentic community.
How does "Analog Church" by Jay Y. Kim address the use of digital technology in worship and preaching?
- Digital as Informative, Not Transformative: Kim acknowledges that digital tools can be useful for sharing information but insists that true transformation requires analog, embodied experiences.
- Dangers of Spectacle: Overreliance on screens, lighting, and performance can turn worship into entertainment, distancing people from genuine participation.
- Video Preaching Limitations: Watching sermons on screens, especially in multisite models, undermines the relational and contextual nature of preaching.
- Balance and Discernment: The book calls for wise, limited use of digital technology, always subordinated to the goal of fostering real, in-person connection and transformation.
What does "Analog Church" by Jay Y. Kim say about community and relationships in the digital age?
- Digital Illusion of Connection: Online platforms offer the illusion of community but often leave people feeling more isolated and alone.
- Commitment over Compatibility: True church community is built on commitment to one another, not just shared interests or digital convenience.
- Diversity and Unity: The analog church brings together unlikely people—across differences—to form a family, reflecting the radical inclusivity of Jesus.
- Practices of Presence: The book emphasizes the importance of showing up, being present in pain, confessing together, and sharing meals as foundational to real community.
How does "Analog Church" by Jay Y. Kim recommend engaging with scripture in the digital age?
- Slow and Deep Reading: Resist the digital tendency toward skimming and quick consumption; instead, read scripture slowly, deeply, and in community.
- Ask the Right Questions: Use Mortimer Adler’s four questions—What is the book about as a whole? What is being said in detail, and how? Is it true? What of it?—to guide Bible reading.
- Communal Engagement: Encourage practices like communal reading, discussion, and theological exploration to foster understanding and transformation.
- Transformation as the Goal: The ultimate aim is not just knowledge, but being mastered and transformed by scripture into Christlikeness.
What are the best quotes from "Analog Church" by Jay Y. Kim and what do they mean?
- "Digital informs. Analog transforms." – This encapsulates the book’s central argument: digital tools can provide information, but real transformation happens through embodied, analog experiences.
- "Worship is no longer worship when it reflects the culture around us more than the Christ within us." (A.W. Tozer, quoted) – Kim uses this to warn against churches becoming mere reflections of cultural trends rather than places of spiritual depth.
- "The church was never meant to be a derivative of the cultural moment but, rather, a disruption of it." – The church’s power lies in offering something different and transcendent, not just mimicking the world.
- "The secret ingredient is ‘slow.’" – Whether in cooking, worship, or scripture reading, depth and richness come from patience and intentionality, not speed and convenience.
What is Jay Y. Kim’s vision for the future of the church as described in "Analog Church"?
- A Return to Embodiment: Kim envisions a church that prioritizes real, embodied presence—gathering, singing, eating, and journeying together in person.
- Countercultural Community: The church should stand out as a place of depth, commitment, and transformation in a world obsessed with speed and digital connection.
- Restoring Sacred Practices: Practices like communal worship, confession, feasting, and slow scripture engagement are central to the church’s witness and vitality.
- Following the True Light: Ultimately, the church’s future depends on following Jesus—the true Light—rather than being blinded by the artificial lights of digital culture.
Review Summary
Analog Church receives mostly positive reviews for its timely message about the importance of in-person church gatherings. Readers appreciate Kim's insights on the limitations of digital technology in fostering true community and spiritual transformation. Many find the book particularly relevant during the COVID-19 pandemic. Some reviewers note inconsistencies in Kim's arguments about technology, but overall, the book is praised for encouraging churches to prioritize analog experiences and meaningful human connections in an increasingly digital world.
Similar Books
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
