Key Takeaways
1. The rise of intelligent machines is transforming work and wages
Average is over is the catchphrase of our age, and it is likely to apply all the more to our future.
Technological revolution. The increasing productivity of intelligent machines, economic globalization, and the split of modern economies into stagnant and dynamic sectors are driving fundamental changes in the job market. These forces are creating a divide between workers who can effectively collaborate with machines and those who cannot. The result is a polarization of the workforce, with high-skilled workers seeing wage increases while others experience stagnation or decline.
Impact on various sectors. This transformation is affecting a wide range of industries:
- Manufacturing: Increased use of robots and automation
- Service sector: AI-powered customer service and data analysis
- Healthcare: Machine learning for diagnosis and treatment planning
- Finance: Algorithmic trading and risk assessment
- Transportation: Development of self-driving vehicles
2. High earners will increasingly work with machines, while others face stagnation
Human–computer teams are the best teams.
Freestyle model. The future of high-earning work will resemble the "Freestyle" chess model, where humans and machines collaborate to achieve superior results. This approach combines the strengths of human intuition and creativity with the processing power and data analysis capabilities of machines. Key characteristics of successful human-machine teams include:
- Deep understanding of machine capabilities
- Ability to interpret and apply machine-generated insights
- Skills in managing and directing machine resources
Wage polarization. As the demand for workers who can effectively collaborate with machines increases, wage inequality is likely to grow. This trend is already evident in various sectors:
- Technology: High salaries for software engineers and data scientists
- Finance: Premium pay for quants and algorithmic traders
- Healthcare: Increased compensation for specialists using advanced diagnostic tools
- Education: Growing divide between tech-savvy educators and traditional teachers
3. Education and skill development must adapt to the new technological landscape
Machine intelligence is the friend of the educational parvenu, albeit the disciplined, gutsy parvenu with high IQ.
Revolutionizing learning. The education system must evolve to prepare students for the new world of work. Key changes include:
- Integration of online and digital learning tools
- Focus on developing skills that complement machine capabilities
- Emphasis on lifelong learning and adaptability
Emerging educational models:
- MOOCs (Massive Open Online Courses)
- Gamification of learning
- AI-powered personalized learning paths
- Hybrid models combining online and in-person instruction
The role of human teachers will shift towards motivation, mentorship, and fostering critical thinking skills that machines cannot replicate.
4. Freelancing and self-employment will become more prevalent in the job market
Many of society's lower earners will reshape their tastes—will have to reshape their tastes—toward cheaper desires.
Gig economy growth. The traditional employment model is giving way to a more flexible, project-based approach. Factors driving this shift include:
- Technological platforms enabling easy connection between workers and clients
- Companies seeking to reduce fixed labor costs
- Workers desiring greater autonomy and work-life balance
Adapting to new realities. As stable, high-paying jobs become scarcer for many, individuals will need to:
- Develop multiple skills to remain competitive
- Build personal brands and networks
- Learn to manage irregular income streams
- Adjust lifestyle expectations and consumption patterns
This shift will require a reevaluation of social safety nets and benefits traditionally tied to full-time employment.
5. Geographic location will play a crucial role in economic opportunities
We will move from a society based on the pretense that everyone is given an okay standard of living to a society in which people are expected to fend for themselves much more than they do now.
Economic clustering. High-earning jobs and opportunities will increasingly concentrate in specific geographic areas, leading to:
- Growth of "superstar" cities with high costs of living
- Decline of traditional industrial centers
- Emergence of new tech hubs and innovation districts
Adaptation strategies:
- Relocation to areas with better job prospects
- Remote work to access opportunities in high-cost areas
- Development of local economies to create new opportunities
- Investment in infrastructure to attract businesses and talent
This trend will have significant implications for housing markets, urban planning, and regional economic development policies.
6. Scientific research and understanding will evolve with machine intelligence
We will increasingly become doers and participants rather than comprehending observers.
Transformation of scientific inquiry. Machine intelligence will revolutionize how scientific research is conducted and understood:
- Analysis of vast datasets beyond human comprehension
- Generation of hypotheses and experimental designs by AI systems
- Acceleration of discovery in fields like drug development and materials science
Challenges and opportunities:
- Need for new skills to interpret machine-generated results
- Potential for breakthrough discoveries in complex systems
- Risk of reduced human understanding of underlying scientific principles
- Emergence of new ethical considerations in research
This shift will require a reevaluation of scientific education, peer review processes, and the communication of scientific findings to the public.
7. A new social contract will emerge, reshaping politics and society
We'll pay for as much of a welfare state as we can afford to, and then no more.
Fiscal realities. The combination of demographic changes, rising healthcare costs, and technological disruption will force a reconsideration of the social safety net:
- Pressure on traditional entitlement programs
- Exploration of new models like universal basic income
- Shift towards more individual responsibility for financial security
Political implications:
- Growing influence of high-earning tech workers and entrepreneurs
- Potential for increased social tension due to inequality
- Emergence of new political coalitions based on economic interests
- Need for policies addressing technological unemployment and retraining
This evolving social contract will require careful balancing of economic growth, social stability, and individual opportunity in an increasingly automated world.
Last updated:
FAQ
What's Average Is Over about?
- Economic Changes: Average Is Over by Tyler Cowen explores the shifting economic landscape in America, focusing on how intelligent machines and globalization are transforming job markets and income distribution.
- Hyper-Meritocracy: The book introduces the concept of a "hyper-meritocracy," where success is increasingly tied to one's ability to work with intelligent machines and leverage unique skills.
- Winners and Losers: Cowen highlights the divide between those who will thrive in this new economy and those who will struggle, leading to a widening gap between high earners and those with less marketable skills.
Why should I read Average Is Over?
- Future Work Insights: The book provides valuable insights into the future of work and the skills needed to succeed in an automated world.
- Economic Predictions: Cowen offers a compelling analysis of economic trends, essential for understanding the implications of technology on employment and wages.
- Practical Advice: It contains practical advice on adapting to these changes, making it relevant for students, professionals, and policymakers.
What are the key takeaways of Average Is Over?
- Skill Complementarity: Individuals who can complement intelligent machines will have better job prospects and higher wages, while those with easily replaceable skills will struggle.
- Education Reform: Cowen advocates for rethinking education systems to prepare individuals for the new economy, emphasizing critical thinking and adaptability.
- Inequality Trends: The book highlights growing income inequality, suggesting a future with a greater divide between high earners and those in stagnant sectors.
What are the best quotes from Average Is Over and what do they mean?
- "Average is over.": This encapsulates the book's thesis that mediocrity will no longer suffice in the job market; only those who excel will thrive.
- "The key questions will be: Are you good at working with intelligent machines or not?": Emphasizes the importance of adaptability and skill in working alongside technology for future employment.
- "Lacking the right training means being shut out of opportunities like never before.": Highlights the necessity of continuous learning and skill development in a rapidly changing economic landscape.
How does Tyler Cowen explain the relationship between technology and job markets in Average Is Over?
- Technological Displacement: Intelligent machines are displacing traditional jobs, especially those involving routine tasks that can be automated.
- Creation of New Jobs: While some jobs are lost, new opportunities will emerge in sectors requiring human creativity, emotional intelligence, and complex problem-solving.
- Skill Mismatch: There is a growing mismatch between the skills workers possess and those needed in the new economy, emphasizing the need for retraining and education.
What is the hyper-meritocracy described in Average Is Over?
- Definition: Hyper-meritocracy is a system where success is determined by one's ability to leverage technology and specialized skills.
- Impact on Employment: Individuals who can effectively collaborate with intelligent machines will rise to the top, while those without such skills will face challenges.
- Societal Implications: This leads to greater income inequality, as economic growth rewards those with the right skills and education.
How does Average Is Over address income inequality?
- Growing Divide: Cowen points out that income inequality is likely to increase as the economy splits into high earners and low-wage workers in stagnant sectors.
- Impact of Globalization: Globalization exacerbates this divide, with workers in developing countries competing for jobs once secure in the U.S.
- Social Implications: The book raises concerns about the social consequences of rising inequality, including potential unrest and a decline in social mobility.
What role does education play in the future economy according to Average Is Over?
- Need for Reform: Cowen advocates for significant reforms in education to align with the skills required in a technology-driven economy.
- Focus on Critical Skills: Emphasizes teaching critical thinking, adaptability, and technical skills that complement intelligent machines.
- Lifelong Learning: Promotes the idea of lifelong learning, suggesting individuals must continuously update their skills to remain competitive.
How does Average Is Over explain wage stagnation?
- Historical Context: Cowen provides a historical overview of wage stagnation in the U.S. since the 1970s, attributing it to globalization and technological advancements.
- Impact of Outsourcing: Outsourcing has contributed to wage stagnation by shifting lower-value jobs to countries with cheaper labor.
- Technological Displacement: Technology has had a more significant impact on wages than foreign competition, as machines replace human labor in many sectors.
How does Average Is Over discuss the concept of meritocracy?
- Meritocracy and Income Inequality: Meritocracy will become increasingly important in a world of rising income inequality, with self-motivated individuals finding it easier to succeed.
- Challenges for the Underprivileged: While some will rise through meritocracy, many will struggle due to systemic barriers.
- Social Implications: Emphasis on meritocracy may lead to a lack of empathy for those who do not succeed, with the wealthy class gaining more influence.
What does Average Is Over predict about the future of social contracts?
- Redefining the Social Contract: The social contract will need to be rewritten in response to economic changes, particularly wage stagnation and technological displacement.
- Increased Individual Responsibility: Individuals will be expected to take more responsibility for their economic well-being, leading to a shift in societal values.
- Emergence of Two Nations: Cowen foresees a future where society is divided into the wealthy elite and the struggling majority, highlighting potential for increased inequality.
How does Average Is Over address the impact of technology on jobs?
- Job Displacement: Intelligent machines are capable of performing tasks traditionally done by humans, leading to job displacement in various sectors.
- New Skill Requirements: Workers need to develop new skills that complement technology, such as creativity and emotional intelligence.
- Polarization of Employment: Cowen predicts a polarized job market where high-skill jobs flourish while low-skill jobs diminish.
Review Summary
Average is Over receives mixed reviews, with praise for its thought-provoking ideas about technology's impact on the economy and job market. Cowen's predictions about growing inequality and the importance of working with intelligent machines are seen as insightful by some. However, critics find the book's heavy focus on chess analogies tedious and argue that Cowen's arguments lack sufficient evidence. Some reviewers appreciate the book's engaging writing style, while others find it superficial and overly speculative.
Similar Books
About the Author
Other books by Tyler Cowen
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.