Key Takeaways
1. The Resurrection: Cornerstone of Christianity
"If Christ has not been raised, your faith is futile; you are still in your sins."
Central to Christian faith. The resurrection of Jesus Christ is not a peripheral doctrine but the very foundation of Christianity. It validates Jesus' claims about His divine nature and mission, and provides hope for believers in their own future resurrection.
Historical investigation. The book presents a narrative of college students and professors examining the historical evidence for the resurrection. Through their discussions and research, they explore various arguments for and against this pivotal event, demonstrating that belief in the resurrection is not based on blind faith but on historical investigation and rational inquiry.
2. Historical Evidence for Jesus' Death and Burial
"We know more about the burial of the Lord than we know of any single character in all of ancient history."
Crucifixion confirmed. Medical and historical evidence strongly support the fact that Jesus died by crucifixion. The Journal of the American Medical Association concluded that Jesus had died before the spear was thrust into His side, based on the gospel accounts.
Burial details. The gospels provide specific details about Jesus' burial:
- Buried in a tomb owned by Joseph of Arimathea, a member of the Sanhedrin
- Wrapped in linen cloths with spices, following Jewish burial customs
- Placed in a new rock-hewn tomb near the crucifixion site
- The tomb was sealed with a large stone
3. The Empty Tomb: A Verifiable Fact
"The empty tomb stands, a veritable rock, as an essential element in the evidence for the resurrection."
Widely acknowledged. Both supporters and opponents of early Christianity agreed that Jesus' tomb was empty. This fact was not disputed, even by those who opposed the Christian message.
Verifiable claim. The empty tomb was a publicly verifiable claim. Anyone in Jerusalem could have easily checked the tomb's location and status. The early Christian preaching in Jerusalem, which began just weeks after the crucifixion, would have been impossible if the body was still in the tomb.
4. Multiple Post-Resurrection Appearances
"Note that when the disciples of Jesus proclaimed the resurrection, they did so as eyewitnesses and they did so while people were still alive who had had contact with the events."
Diverse witnesses. The New Testament records multiple appearances of the risen Jesus to various individuals and groups:
- Mary Magdalene
- Other women
- Peter
- Two disciples on the road to Emmaus
- The eleven apostles (multiple times)
- James (Jesus' brother)
- Over 500 people at once
- Paul
Extended interactions. These appearances were not mere glimpses but involved extended interactions, conversations, and even shared meals. This variety of witnesses and experiences makes mass hallucination or delusion highly unlikely.
5. Transformation of the Disciples
"They had nothing to gain by lying and starting a new religion. They faced hardship, ridicule, hostility, and martyr's deaths."
From cowards to bold preachers. The disciples underwent a dramatic transformation after encountering the risen Jesus. They went from hiding in fear to boldly proclaiming the resurrection in the face of persecution and death.
Willingness to die. Many of the apostles were martyred for their faith. While people may die for a lie they believe to be true, it's highly improbable that all the disciples would die for something they knew to be false if they had fabricated the resurrection story.
6. Early Christian Creeds and Eyewitness Accounts
"For what I received I passed on to you as of first importance: that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures, that he was buried, that he was raised on the third day according to the Scriptures, and that he appeared to Peter, and then to the Twelve."
Early formulations. Scholars have identified early Christian creeds, such as 1 Corinthians 15:3-5, that predate the written New Testament. These creeds contain core beliefs about Jesus' death and resurrection, indicating that these beliefs were formulated and circulated within a few years of the events.
Eyewitness testimony. The New Testament documents, particularly the gospels and Acts, claim to be based on eyewitness accounts. The early date of these writings and the public nature of the claims made it possible for contemporaries to verify or refute the testimony.
7. Refuting Alternative Theories
"Dead men just don't come back to life!"
Addressing skepticism. The book explores and refutes several alternative explanations for the resurrection, including:
- The hallucination theory
- The wrong tomb theory
- The legend theory
- The conspiracy theory (disciples stole the body)
- Pagan myth influence
Historical and logical problems. Each of these theories faces significant historical and logical problems when examined closely. For example, the hallucination theory fails to account for the group appearances and the empty tomb, while the conspiracy theory doesn't explain the disciples' willingness to die for their claims.
8. The Significance of the Resurrection for Believers
"Jesus didn't just teach about it. He actually demonstrated it and proved His claims by literally rising from the dead."
Hope beyond death. The resurrection of Jesus provides hope for believers in their own future resurrection and eternal life. It assures them that death is not the end and that they will be reunited with loved ones who have died in Christ.
Validation of Jesus' claims. The resurrection validates Jesus' claims about His divine nature and His ability to forgive sins. It demonstrates God's acceptance of Jesus' sacrificial death as payment for sin and offers assurance of salvation to those who trust in Him.
Transformation of lives. Belief in the resurrection has the power to transform lives, giving purpose, meaning, and hope to believers. It motivates them to live for something beyond this temporal life and to share their faith with others.
Last updated:
FAQ
What is "Did the Resurrection Happen . . . Really?" by Josh McDowell and Dave Sterrett about?
- Fictional Dialogue on Resurrection: The book is a work of fiction that uses a dialogue-driven narrative among university students and professors to explore the historical and theological evidence for the resurrection of Jesus Christ.
- Apologetics Through Storytelling: It presents Christian apologetics in the form of conversations, debates, and personal struggles, making complex arguments accessible and relatable.
- Investigation of Evidence: The characters investigate historical, medical, and philosophical evidence for and against the resurrection, considering alternative theories and objections.
- Themes of Grief and Hope: The story is set against the backdrop of a campus tragedy, allowing the exploration of grief, hope, and the meaning of life and death through the lens of the resurrection.
Why should I read "Did the Resurrection Happen . . . Really?" by Josh McDowell and Dave Sterrett?
- Accessible Apologetics: The book makes scholarly arguments about the resurrection understandable for readers without a theological background.
- Engaging Narrative Format: By using fictional characters and real-life scenarios, it brings abstract debates to life and shows their relevance to personal struggles.
- Balanced Exploration: It presents both skeptical and believing perspectives, allowing readers to see how objections are addressed and why the resurrection matters to Christians.
- Practical Application: The book connects theological concepts to real emotional needs, such as coping with loss and finding hope.
What are the key takeaways from "Did the Resurrection Happen . . . Really?" by Josh McDowell and Dave Sterrett?
- Centrality of the Resurrection: The resurrection is presented as the foundation of Christian faith; without it, Christianity loses its meaning and power.
- Historical and Medical Evidence: The book details historical documentation, eyewitness accounts, and medical analysis supporting the death and resurrection of Jesus.
- Addressing Alternative Theories: It systematically examines and critiques alternative explanations, such as the hallucination, conspiracy, and wrong-tomb theories.
- Personal Transformation: The narrative shows how belief in the resurrection can transform grief into hope and skepticism into faith.
How does "Did the Resurrection Happen . . . Really?" by Josh McDowell and Dave Sterrett use fiction to explore apologetics?
- Campus Setting: The story unfolds on a university campus, with students and professors representing a spectrum of beliefs, from atheism to devout Christianity.
- Character-Driven Dialogue: Characters ask tough questions, challenge each other, and share personal stories, making the apologetic arguments more engaging and relatable.
- Realistic Objections: Skeptical characters raise common objections, which are then addressed thoughtfully by others, modeling respectful and reasoned debate.
- Emotional Resonance: The fictional tragedy (a campus shooting) provides a context for exploring the existential stakes of the resurrection question.
What is the "minimum facts" approach to the resurrection, as presented in "Did the Resurrection Happen . . . Really?" by Josh McDowell and Dave Sterrett?
- Core Agreed-Upon Facts: The "minimum facts" approach focuses on historical facts about Jesus that are widely accepted by scholars, regardless of their religious beliefs.
- Key Points Include: Jesus’ death by crucifixion, his burial, the empty tomb, post-crucifixion appearances, and the transformation of the disciples.
- Argument for Resurrection: The book argues that the resurrection is the best explanation for these facts, as alternative theories fail to account for all the evidence.
- Scholarly Consensus: The approach is based on the work of scholars like Dr. Gary Habermas, who is featured in the book’s climax.
How does "Did the Resurrection Happen . . . Really?" by Josh McDowell and Dave Sterrett address alternative explanations for the resurrection?
- Hallucination Theory: The book critiques the idea that the disciples hallucinated Jesus’ appearances, citing psychological evidence that group hallucinations are virtually impossible.
- Conspiracy Theory: It challenges the notion that the disciples stole Jesus’ body, arguing that the risk, lack of motive, and willingness to die for their claims make this unlikely.
- Wrong-Tomb Theory: The narrative points out that all parties (disciples, women, authorities) would have had to make the same mistake, which is implausible.
- Pagan Myth Theory: The book refutes the claim that the resurrection story was borrowed from pagan myths, emphasizing the historical context and Jewish background of the early Christians.
What historical and medical evidence for the resurrection is discussed in "Did the Resurrection Happen . . . Really?" by Josh McDowell and Dave Sterrett?
- Crucifixion Details: The book describes Roman crucifixion practices, referencing historical sources and medical studies (e.g., Journal of the American Medical Association) to confirm Jesus’ death.
- Burial Practices: It examines Jewish burial customs and the role of Joseph of Arimathea, arguing for the historical reliability of the burial account.
- Eyewitness Testimony: The narrative highlights the early and multiple eyewitness claims, including appearances to individuals and groups.
- Prophetic Fulfillment: The book discusses Old Testament prophecies (especially Isaiah 53) and their fulfillment in Jesus’ death and burial.
How does "Did the Resurrection Happen . . . Really?" by Josh McDowell and Dave Sterrett explain the importance of the resurrection to Christian faith?
- Foundation of Christianity: The resurrection is portrayed as the central event that validates Jesus’ identity and message.
- Apostolic Preaching: The book shows that the earliest Christian preaching focused on the resurrection as proof of Jesus’ divinity and the basis for forgiveness.
- Hope in Suffering: The resurrection provides hope for life after death and comfort in the face of tragedy, as seen in the characters’ personal losses.
- Transformation of Disciples: The radical change in the disciples’ behavior—from fear to bold proclamation—is presented as evidence of the resurrection’s reality.
What role do the Dead Sea Scrolls and Old Testament prophecy play in "Did the Resurrection Happen . . . Really?" by Josh McDowell and Dave Sterrett?
- Dead Sea Scrolls Discovery: The book recounts the discovery of the Dead Sea Scrolls, emphasizing the ancient copy of Isaiah that predates Jesus.
- Isaiah 53 Prophecy: It highlights Isaiah 53 as a detailed prophecy about the suffering, death, and burial of the Messiah, fulfilled in Jesus.
- Historical Reliability: The existence of these ancient texts is used to argue that the prophecies were not written after the fact.
- Impact on Skeptics: The fulfillment of prophecy is presented as a significant factor in convincing some characters of the truth of Christianity.
How does "Did the Resurrection Happen . . . Really?" by Josh McDowell and Dave Sterrett address the relationship between faith and evidence?
- Faith Not Blind: The book argues that Christian faith is not a leap in the dark but is grounded in historical evidence and reason.
- Open Investigation: Characters are encouraged to investigate the evidence honestly, regardless of their starting beliefs.
- Emotional and Rational Aspects: The narrative acknowledges both the emotional and intellectual dimensions of belief, showing how evidence can lead to faith and how faith can provide comfort.
- Transformation Through Evidence: Several characters move from skepticism to belief as they engage with the evidence for the resurrection.
What are the best quotes from "Did the Resurrection Happen . . . Really?" by Josh McDowell and Dave Sterrett, and what do they mean?
- "If Christ has not been raised, your faith is futile; you are still in your sins." (1 Corinthians 15:17) – Emphasizes the centrality of the resurrection to Christian faith.
- "People may die for a lie they think is true, but they won’t die for a lie they know to be false." – Highlights the sincerity and conviction of the disciples as evidence for the resurrection.
- "The resurrection turned catastrophe into victory." – Shows how the resurrection transformed the disciples’ despair into hope and boldness.
- "The resurrection of Jesus gives us assurance of heaven." – Connects the historical event to personal hope and comfort in the face of death.
What is the overall message and impact of "Did the Resurrection Happen . . . Really?" by Josh McDowell and Dave Sterrett?
- Invitation to Investigate: The book encourages readers to honestly examine the evidence for the resurrection, regardless of their current beliefs.
- Faith and Reason United: It demonstrates that faith in Jesus is compatible with intellectual integrity and historical inquiry.
- Hope in Tragedy: Through its narrative, the book offers hope and meaning in the midst of suffering and loss, grounded in the resurrection.
- Call to Decision: The story culminates in characters making personal decisions about faith, inviting readers to consider their own response to the evidence presented.
Review Summary
Did the Resurrection Happen . . . Really? receives mixed reviews, with an average rating of 4 out of 5. Readers appreciate the book's accessible approach to apologetics and evidence for the resurrection. Many find the conversational style engaging, though some feel it's distracting. The book is praised for its simplified explanations and logical arguments, making it suitable for beginners. However, some critics note that it lacks depth and relies heavily on previous works. Overall, it's considered a quick, informative read for those interested in exploring the historical evidence for Christ's resurrection.
Similar Books
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
