Key Takeaways
1. Brexit: A Fusion of Imperial Nostalgia and Imagined Oppression
The incoherence of the new English nationalism that lies behind Brexit is that it wants to be both simultaneously.
Imperial nostalgia meets victim complex. Brexit represents a paradoxical fusion of two seemingly incompatible narratives: the desire to reclaim Britain's imperial greatness and the perception of Britain as an oppressed nation under EU rule. This contradiction stems from the unresolved trauma of losing an empire and the need to find a new identity in a post-imperial world.
Imaginary oppression as political fuel. The Brexit movement capitalized on a sense of imagined oppression by the EU, despite the UK's privileged position within the union. This narrative of victimhood allowed for the mobilization of nationalist sentiments and the promise of liberation from a non-existent tyranny.
Key elements of this fusion:
- Nostalgia for imperial power and global influence
- Perception of EU membership as a form of colonization
- Reframing of economic and political realities through the lens of oppression
- Appeal to both imperial pride and underdog status
2. The Paradox of Self-Pity in English National Identity
Self-pity thus combines two things that may seem incompatible: a deep sense of grievance and a high sense of superiority.
The duality of English self-perception. Brexit reveals a paradoxical self-image within English national identity: a simultaneous belief in inherent superiority and a deep-seated sense of victimhood. This combination allows for the indulgence in self-pity while maintaining a belief in national greatness.
Historical roots of self-pity. The cultivation of self-pity in English national identity can be traced back to the loss of empire and the perceived lack of recognition for Britain's role in World War II. This sentiment has been nurtured and exploited by political forces to create a narrative of national decline and the need for resurgence.
Manifestations of this paradox:
- Exaggeration of EU influence and control over British affairs
- Romanticization of past glories and achievements
- Perception of unfair treatment by international institutions
- Desire for both isolation and global significance
3. Heroic Failure: From Empire to Brexit
Brexit is a strange hybrid – a genuine national revolution against a phoney oppressor.
The allure of glorious defeat. The English tradition of celebrating heroic failures, from the Charge of the Light Brigade to Scott of the Antarctic, has found a new expression in Brexit. This cultural tendency to romanticize defeat and struggle has been repurposed to frame the decision to leave the EU as a noble, if potentially disastrous, endeavor.
Reimagining national identity. Brexit represents an attempt to redefine English national identity in the absence of empire and in the context of a diminished global role. By casting the EU as an oppressor and Brexit as an act of liberation, proponents tap into a deeply ingrained narrative of resistance and resilience.
Key aspects of heroic failure in Brexit:
- Framing of EU membership as a form of national humiliation
- Celebration of potential economic hardships as necessary sacrifices
- Invocation of historical struggles against continental powers
- Romanticization of isolation and self-reliance
4. The Power of Trivial Grievances in Brexit Rhetoric
This is not as trivial as it sounds.
Magnification of minor irritations. Brexit rhetoric often focused on seemingly trivial issues, such as regulations on prawn cocktail crisps or the shape of bananas, and inflated them into symbols of EU oppression. This strategy tapped into a deeper well of resentment and frustration with perceived loss of sovereignty.
The politics of the mundane. By focusing on everyday items and regulations, Brexit campaigners were able to make abstract concepts of sovereignty and bureaucracy tangible to the average voter. This approach allowed for an emotional connection to the issue that transcended more complex economic and political arguments.
Examples of trivial grievances in Brexit rhetoric:
- EU regulations on food products and packaging
- Standardization of weights and measures
- Perceived interference in British traditions and customs
- Bureaucratic red tape and its impact on small businesses
5. Sadopopulism: Pain as Political Currency in Brexit
Brexit is often explained as populism, but it is driven more by what Timothy Snyder in The Road to Unfreedom calls 'sadopopulism', in which people are willing to inflict pain on themselves so long as they can believe that, in the same moment, they are making their enemies hurt more.
The politics of shared suffering. Brexit embodies a form of sadopopulism, where supporters are willing to endure economic hardship and social disruption if they believe it will cause greater pain to perceived enemies or elites. This mindset transforms potential negative consequences into badges of honor and signs of commitment to the cause.
Displacement of responsibility. By focusing on the pain inflicted on "others" – be they EU bureaucrats, immigrants, or domestic "elites" – Brexit supporters can justify their own suffering as necessary and noble. This allows for the continuation of support even in the face of clear negative consequences.
Key elements of sadopopulism in Brexit:
- Willingness to accept economic downturn as a price for sovereignty
- Celebration of hardship as a sign of national resilience
- Belief that EU member states will suffer more from Brexit than the UK
- Framing of opposition to Brexit as unpatriotic or treasonous
6. The Medieval Imaginary and the Myth of Vassalage
Given the fact of servitude, the feudal relationship is the only tolerable one.
Romanticization of medieval power structures. Brexit rhetoric often invoked medieval concepts of sovereignty and vassalage, framing the UK's relationship with the EU in terms of feudal subservience. This anachronistic language tapped into deep-seated notions of national pride and independence.
The allure of simplistic hierarchies. By framing complex international relationships in terms of medieval power dynamics, Brexit proponents offered a simplistic and emotionally resonant narrative of oppression and liberation. This allowed for the bypassing of more nuanced discussions about the realities of modern global interdependence.
Elements of medieval imagery in Brexit discourse:
- Use of terms like "vassal state" to describe EU membership
- Invocation of historical battles and conflicts with continental powers
- Romanticization of national sovereignty as analogous to feudal independence
- Portrayal of EU bureaucrats as modern-day overlords
7. The Resurgence of English Identity and Its Political Implications
The most dramatic evolution of national identity in Britain in the last two decades is the resurfacing of the idea of England as a distinct political community.
The awakening of English nationalism. Brexit has both revealed and accelerated the resurgence of a distinct English national identity, separate from the broader concept of Britishness. This shift has profound implications for the future of the United Kingdom and its constituent nations.
Political realignment along national lines. The rise of English nationalism has led to a realignment of political allegiances, with traditional left-right divisions being superseded by questions of national identity and sovereignty. This has challenged established political parties and created new fault lines in British politics.
Key aspects of resurgent English identity:
- Increased self-identification as English rather than British
- Growing support for English-specific political institutions
- Correlation between strong English identity and support for Brexit
- Tension between English nationalism and the maintenance of the UK
8. Brexit as Displacement: The Misdirection of English Discontent
Deeply disaffected with Westminster and Whitehall, England-without-London unleashed its fury on Brussels and Strasbourg.
Redirected frustrations. Brexit served as a vehicle for expressing deep-seated frustrations with domestic political institutions and social changes. By focusing on the EU as the source of national problems, the Brexit movement redirected anger away from Westminster and onto a more distant and easily vilified target.
The limits of symbolic rebellion. While Brexit provided a cathartic moment of rebellion for many English voters, it fails to address the underlying issues of political representation and economic inequality that fueled discontent. The displacement of these frustrations onto the EU may ultimately leave the root causes unaddressed.
Factors contributing to the displacement of English discontent:
- Lack of distinct English political institutions within the UK
- Growing regional inequalities and sense of neglect outside London
- Perception of a disconnected political elite in Westminster
- Erosion of traditional industries and ways of life in many English regions
Last updated:
FAQ
What's "Heroic Failure: Brexit and the Politics of Pain" about?
- Exploration of Brexit: The book delves into the phenomenon of Brexit, describing it as an act of national self-harm and exploring the reasons behind Britain's decision to leave the European Union.
- National Masochism: Fintan O'Toole examines the concept of national masochism, where a country indulges in self-pity and the dangerous pleasures of perceived victimhood.
- Cultural and Political Analysis: The book provides a cultural and political analysis of how trivial journalistic lies became national obsessions and how English nationalism silently rose.
- Historical Context: O'Toole draws parallels between historical events and the current political climate, such as the Charge of the Light Brigade and the idea of heroic failure.
Why should I read "Heroic Failure: Brexit and the Politics of Pain"?
- Insightful Analysis: The book offers a deep and insightful analysis of the cultural and political factors that led to Brexit, making it essential for understanding contemporary British politics.
- Humorous and Engaging: O'Toole's writing is mordantly funny and engaging, making complex political issues accessible and entertaining.
- Historical Parallels: The book draws fascinating parallels between historical events and modern politics, providing a broader context for understanding Brexit.
- Critical Perspective: It offers a critical perspective on the political elite and media's role in shaping public opinion and national identity.
What are the key takeaways of "Heroic Failure: Brexit and the Politics of Pain"?
- National Self-Pity: The book highlights how self-pity and a sense of grievance have become defining features of English nationalism.
- Heroic Failure: O'Toole discusses the cultural phenomenon of celebrating failure as a form of heroism, rooted in historical events like the Charge of the Light Brigade.
- Political Manipulation: The narrative explores how political elites and media have manipulated public sentiment and historical narratives to serve their agendas.
- Impact on Vulnerable Populations: The book emphasizes that the costs of Brexit will be borne by the most vulnerable supporters and those affected by potential border issues in Ireland.
How does Fintan O'Toole define "heroic failure" in the context of Brexit?
- Cultural Phenomenon: Heroic failure is described as a cultural phenomenon where failure is celebrated as a form of heroism, often masking the realities of power and dominance.
- Historical Examples: O'Toole uses historical examples like the Charge of the Light Brigade and the Franklin expedition to illustrate how failure has been romanticized in British culture.
- Modern Application: In the context of Brexit, heroic failure is seen as a way to cope with the loss of empire and global influence, turning national setbacks into narratives of resilience.
- Critique of Nationalism: The concept is critiqued as a dangerous form of nationalism that indulges in self-pity and avoids addressing real issues.
What role does English nationalism play in "Heroic Failure: Brexit and the Politics of Pain"?
- Silent Rise: The book discusses the silent rise of English nationalism, which has been a significant force behind the Brexit movement.
- Identity Crisis: O'Toole explores how English nationalism is rooted in an identity crisis, where England struggles to define itself post-empire and within the UK.
- Cultural Narratives: The narrative of English nationalism is tied to cultural myths and historical events, which have been manipulated to foster a sense of grievance and victimhood.
- Political Consequences: The rise of nationalism has significant political consequences, influencing public opinion and policy decisions related to Brexit.
How does Fintan O'Toole use historical events to explain Brexit?
- Parallels with History: O'Toole draws parallels between Brexit and historical events like the Charge of the Light Brigade and the Franklin expedition to illustrate the concept of heroic failure.
- Cultural Continuity: The book suggests that the cultural narratives of past failures continue to influence modern political decisions and national identity.
- Lessons from the Past: By examining historical events, O'Toole highlights the dangers of romanticizing failure and the need to learn from past mistakes.
- Contextual Understanding: The historical context provides a deeper understanding of the cultural and political forces that shaped the Brexit movement.
What are the best quotes from "Heroic Failure: Brexit and the Politics of Pain" and what do they mean?
- "A great democratic country tears itself apart": This quote encapsulates the central theme of the book, highlighting the self-destructive nature of Brexit.
- "The dangerous pleasures of national masochism": O'Toole uses this phrase to describe how a sense of victimhood and self-pity have become ingrained in national identity.
- "Heroic failure, once a self-deprecating cult": This quote reflects on how the celebration of failure has shifted from a self-deprecating humor to a dangerous political narrative.
- "The silent rise of English nationalism": This phrase underscores the book's exploration of how nationalism has quietly but powerfully influenced the Brexit movement.
How does "Heroic Failure: Brexit and the Politics of Pain" critique the political elite?
- Indifference to Truth: O'Toole criticizes the political elite for their indifference to truth and historical fact, which has come to define their style.
- Manipulation of Narratives: The book highlights how the elite have manipulated cultural and historical narratives to serve their political agendas.
- Failure to Address Real Issues: O'Toole argues that the political elite have failed to address the real issues facing the country, instead indulging in narratives of grievance and victimhood.
- Impact on Vulnerable Populations: The critique extends to the consequences of their actions, which disproportionately affect the most vulnerable supporters of Brexit.
What is the significance of the "prawn cocktail flavour crisps" in the book?
- Symbol of Trivial Grievances: The prawn cocktail flavour crisps serve as a symbol of how trivial grievances have been inflated into national obsessions.
- Cultural Identity: O'Toole uses this example to illustrate how food and consumption have become tied to cultural identity and national pride.
- Manipulation by Media: The narrative shows how the media has manipulated such trivial issues to stoke fears and influence public opinion.
- Broader Commentary: The crisps are part of a broader commentary on how minor issues are used to distract from more significant political and economic challenges.
How does "Heroic Failure: Brexit and the Politics of Pain" address the concept of "sadopopulism"?
- Definition of Sadopopulism: Sadopopulism is described as a political strategy where leaders inflict pain on their own supporters while promising to hurt their perceived enemies even more.
- Brexit as Sadopopulism: O'Toole argues that Brexit embodies this concept, as it involves self-harm with the promise of greater harm to the EU and immigrants.
- Psychological Appeal: The book explores the psychological appeal of sadopopulism, where voters find meaning in their suffering by believing it will lead to greater pain for others.
- Critique of Leadership: O'Toole critiques the leaders of the Brexit movement for exploiting this dynamic to gain and maintain power.
What impact does "Heroic Failure: Brexit and the Politics of Pain" suggest Brexit will have on Ireland?
- Hard Border Concerns: The book discusses the potential consequences of a hard border in Ireland, which could disrupt the fragile peace process.
- Economic Impact: O'Toole highlights the economic impact on Ireland, particularly in terms of trade and cross-border relations.
- Cultural and Political Tensions: The narrative explores how Brexit could exacerbate cultural and political tensions between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland.
- Historical Context: The book places these concerns within the historical context of Anglo-Irish relations, emphasizing the importance of maintaining peace and cooperation.
What does "Heroic Failure: Brexit and the Politics of Pain" suggest about the future of English nationalism?
- Continued Influence: The book suggests that English nationalism will continue to be a significant force in shaping the country's political landscape.
- Identity Crisis: O'Toole argues that the identity crisis at the heart of English nationalism will persist, as the country struggles to define itself post-Brexit.
- Potential for Change: The narrative acknowledges the potential for positive change if English nationalism can be redirected towards more inclusive and constructive goals.
- Need for Addressing Issues: O'Toole emphasizes the need for addressing the underlying issues driving nationalism, such as economic inequality and cultural identity.
Review Summary
Heroic Failure is praised for its insightful analysis of Brexit's cultural roots in English nationalism and the British psyche. O'Toole argues that Brexit stems from a combination of post-imperial nostalgia, self-pity, and masochism. Readers appreciate the author's wit, cultural references, and ability to dissect complex issues. While some find certain analogies strained, most reviewers consider the book a compelling examination of Brexit's underlying causes. Critics note its timeliness and relevance, though some feel it occasionally veers into psychoanalysis and may not appeal to Brexit supporters.
Similar Books
About the Author
Other books by Fintan O'Toole
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.