Key Takeaways
1. Lean Six Sigma: The Ultimate Competitive Advantage
"Lean Six Sigma is a methodology that maximizes shareholder value by achieving the fastest rate of improvement in customer satisfaction, cost, quality, process speed and invested capital."
Holistic approach. Lean Six Sigma combines the best of two powerful methodologies: Lean, which focuses on speed and efficiency, and Six Sigma, which emphasizes quality and variation reduction. This fusion creates a comprehensive toolkit for process improvement that addresses all aspects of business performance.
Tangible results. Companies implementing Lean Six Sigma have achieved remarkable outcomes:
- Lead time reductions of up to 80%
- Manufacturing overhead and quality cost reductions of 20%
- On-time delivery improvements to above 99%
- Time-to-market reductions of 50% in product development
- Material cost reductions of 5-10%
Competitive edge. By simultaneously improving quality, speed, and cost, Lean Six Sigma provides organizations with a sustainable competitive advantage that is difficult for competitors to replicate quickly.
2. The Power of Process Cycle Efficiency
"A Lean process is one in which the value-add time in the process is more than 25% of the total lead time of that process."
Efficiency metric. Process Cycle Efficiency (PCE) is a key metric in Lean Six Sigma, calculated as:
PCE = Value-Add Time / Total Lead Time
Typical vs. world-class. Most processes operate at less than 10% efficiency. World-class performance targets:
- Machining: 20%
- Fabrication: 25%
- Assembly: 35%
- Continuous Manufacturing: 80%
- Business Processes (Transactional): 50%
- Business Processes (Creative/Cognitive): 25%
Impact of improvement. Increasing PCE from 5% to 25% can lead to a 20% reduction in manufacturing overhead and quality costs, directly impacting the bottom line.
3. Identifying and Eliminating Time Traps
"The activities that cause the customer's Critical To Quality issues and create the longest Time Delays in any process offer the greatest opportunity for improvement in Cost, Quality, Capital, and Lead time."
Focus on delays. Time Traps are the workstations or process steps that inject the most delay into the overall process. They are often not where inventory visibly piles up, but rather the root cause of those pile-ups.
Data-driven approach. Identifying Time Traps requires analysis of process data, often using specialized software or spreadsheet calculations based on the First Law of Lean Six Sigma:
Workstation Turnover Time = Batch Size (Min) / Customer Demand Rate
Prioritized improvement. By focusing improvement efforts on the top Time Traps, organizations can achieve dramatic reductions in lead time and cost with minimal resource expenditure.
4. The 80/20 Rule in Process Improvement
"80% percent of lead time delay is caused by less than 20% of the workstations (the Time Traps)."
Pareto principle in action. This Second Law of Lean Six Sigma for Supply Chain Acceleration embodies the famous 80/20 rule, providing a powerful focus for improvement efforts.
Efficient resource allocation. By identifying and addressing the vital few (20%) causes of delay, organizations can achieve 80% of the potential improvement with a fraction of the effort required to address all issues.
Universal application. This principle holds true across industries and process types, from manufacturing to service operations, making it a versatile tool for process improvement.
5. Value Stream Mapping: Visualizing Waste and Opportunity
"A value stream map starts with a 'pencil and paper' sketch of the process to understand the flow of material and information needed to produce a product or service."
Comprehensive visualization. Value Stream Mapping (VSM) provides a holistic view of a process, capturing both value-adding and non-value-adding activities.
Activity classification. VSM categorizes activities into:
- Customer Value Add (CVA)
- Business Value Add (BVA)
- Non-Value Add (NVA)
Improvement roadmap. By clearly identifying waste and inefficiencies, VSM serves as a powerful tool for prioritizing improvement efforts and envisioning the future state of the process.
6. Pull Systems: Capping WIP for Faster Lead Times
"Process velocity and lead time are absolutely determined by the amount of the Work In Process."
WIP control mechanism. Pull systems, such as Kanban, provide a practical way to limit Work-In-Process (WIP) and maintain optimal process flow.
Little's Law in action. The relationship between WIP, lead time, and throughput is described by Little's Law:
Lead Time = WIP / Throughput Rate
Benefits of pull. Implementing pull systems leads to:
- Reduced lead times
- Lower inventory costs
- Improved quality (fewer defects in smaller batches)
- Enhanced flexibility to respond to demand changes
7. The Critical Role of CEO Engagement in Lean Six Sigma
"When a CEO shows passion and support, I have never seen Lean Six Sigma fail. If however, the CEO does not show this passion, I have never seen it succeed."
Top-down commitment. CEO engagement is crucial for creating the cultural shift necessary for Lean Six Sigma success.
Resource allocation. Engaged CEOs ensure proper resource commitment, typically 1-3% of personnel dedicated full-time to improvement projects.
Strategic alignment. CEO involvement links Lean Six Sigma efforts directly to corporate strategy and shareholder value creation, ensuring organization-wide buy-in and support.
8. Batch Size Optimization: The Key to Flow and Speed
"Batch sizes should be determined based on process variables—setup time, the processing time per unit, and most importantly the number of different parts it produces, etc.—and should be changed as a process improves."
Dynamic batch sizing. Traditional fixed batch sizes based on EOQ formulas often hinder process improvement. Lean Six Sigma advocates for flexible batch sizes that evolve with process capabilities.
Setup time impact. Reducing setup times allows for smaller batch sizes, which in turn:
- Reduces WIP
- Shortens lead times
- Improves flexibility
- Enhances quality (faster detection of issues)
Continuous improvement cycle. As processes improve and batch sizes decrease, further opportunities for setup reduction and process enhancement emerge, creating a virtuous cycle of improvement.
9. Lean Six Sigma Applies to All Processes, Not Just Manufacturing
"Lean does not mean manufacturing, Lean means speed."
Universal principles. The concepts of waste reduction, flow, and variation control apply equally to service industries, administrative processes, and creative work.
Transactional process examples:
- Hotel check-in optimization
- Mortgage application processing
- Product development cycles
- Order fulfillment and customer service
Holistic improvement. Often, improving manufacturing processes requires addressing associated non-manufacturing processes, highlighting the interconnected nature of business operations.
10. The Synergy of Lean and Six Sigma Tools
"Lean cannot bring a process under statistical control... Six Sigma alone cannot dramatically improve process speed or reduce invested capital."
Complementary methodologies. Lean focuses on eliminating waste and improving flow, while Six Sigma targets variation reduction and process control.
Enhanced problem-solving. The DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control) framework from Six Sigma provides a structured approach to applying Lean tools and principles.
Comprehensive toolkit. Key tools include:
- Value Stream Mapping (Lean)
- Statistical Process Control (Six Sigma)
- Pull Systems (Lean)
- Design of Experiments (Six Sigma)
- Setup Reduction (Lean)
- Root Cause Analysis (Six Sigma)
11. Rapid Setup Reduction: A Cornerstone of Lean Manufacturing
"Setup Reduction techniques to reduce setup time by 80% with little if any increased capital expenditures."
SMED methodology. Single-Minute Exchange of Die (SMED) is a structured approach to dramatically reducing setup times.
Four-step process:
- Separate internal from external setup activities
- Convert internal to external setup where possible
- Streamline remaining internal setup
- Streamline external setup
Ripple effects. Reduced setup times enable:
- Smaller batch sizes
- Increased flexibility
- Reduced lead times
- Lower inventory levels
12. Linking Lean Six Sigma to Shareholder Value Creation
"NPV can be applied at many levels: to overall value streams (the sets of activities that transform a customer opportunity into a delivered outcome) or to individual projects."
Financial focus. Lean Six Sigma initiatives should be directly tied to measurable financial outcomes, particularly improvements in Return on Invested Capital (ROIC) and revenue growth.
Project prioritization. Net Present Value (NPV) analysis helps organizations select and prioritize improvement projects based on their potential impact on shareholder value.
Holistic value creation. Lean Six Sigma improvements contribute to shareholder value through multiple channels:
- Increased operating margins
- Reduced working capital requirements
- Enhanced revenue growth through improved quality and responsiveness
- Increased asset utilization and reduced capital expenditure needs
Last updated:
FAQ
1. What’s "Lean Six Sigma: Combining Six Sigma Quality with Lean Speed" by Michael L. George about?
- Integration of Lean and Six Sigma: The book explains how combining Lean methods (focused on speed and waste reduction) with Six Sigma (focused on quality and defect reduction) creates a powerful methodology for rapid and sustainable business improvement.
- Maximizing Shareholder Value: It positions Lean Six Sigma as a strategy to maximize shareholder value by improving customer satisfaction, cost, quality, process speed, and invested capital.
- Implementation Roadmap: The book provides a detailed roadmap for implementing Lean Six Sigma, including case studies and practical tools.
- Applicable Beyond Manufacturing: While rooted in manufacturing, the book emphasizes that Lean Six Sigma is equally effective in service and transactional processes.
2. Why should I read "Lean Six Sigma" by Michael L. George?
- Proven Results: The book presents real-world case studies showing dramatic improvements in cost, quality, lead time, and profitability using Lean Six Sigma.
- Comprehensive Framework: It offers a step-by-step guide for leaders and managers to implement Lean Six Sigma, making it accessible even to those new to the concepts.
- Competitive Advantage: Readers learn how to leverage slow improvement rates in most companies to gain a significant edge over competitors.
- Universal Application: The methods are shown to be effective in both manufacturing and service industries, making the book relevant to a wide audience.
3. What are the key takeaways from "Lean Six Sigma" by Michael L. George?
- Synergy is Essential: Combining Lean and Six Sigma yields faster, more sustainable improvements than using either method alone.
- Focus on Value Streams: Prioritizing projects based on their impact on shareholder value (using metrics like ROIC and NPV) ensures resources are used effectively.
- Cultural Change is Critical: Success depends on CEO and management engagement, resource commitment, and a robust infrastructure for execution.
- Data-Driven Improvement: The methodology relies on identifying and eliminating "Time Traps" and defects using data, not intuition.
4. How does Michael L. George define Lean Six Sigma in "Lean Six Sigma"?
- Maximizing Shareholder Value: Lean Six Sigma is defined as a methodology that maximizes shareholder value by achieving the fastest rate of improvement in customer satisfaction, cost, quality, process speed, and invested capital.
- Fusion of Methods: It is the fusion of Lean (speed, waste reduction) and Six Sigma (quality, defect reduction) principles and tools.
- Addressing Both Speed and Quality: Lean cannot bring a process under statistical control, and Six Sigma alone cannot dramatically improve process speed or reduce invested capital—both are required.
- Project Prioritization: The methodology emphasizes focusing on the highest value projects for rapid, organization-wide results.
5. What are the main differences between Lean, Six Sigma, and Lean Six Sigma according to the book?
- Lean Focus: Lean targets process speed, waste elimination, and reducing lead times, but does not ensure statistical control or address process variation in depth.
- Six Sigma Focus: Six Sigma aims to reduce defects and process variation, achieving near-perfect quality, but often does not directly address process speed or inventory reduction.
- Lean Six Sigma Synergy: Lean Six Sigma combines both approaches, enabling rapid improvements in both speed and quality, leading to significant cost and capital reductions.
- Implementation Infrastructure: Lean Six Sigma also incorporates a cultural and management infrastructure (from Six Sigma) to sustain and scale improvements.
6. How does "Lean Six Sigma" by Michael L. George recommend identifying and prioritizing improvement opportunities?
- Critical to Quality and Time Traps: The book advises first addressing customer Critical To Quality (CTQ) issues and then identifying process steps (Time Traps) that cause the most delay.
- Pareto Principle Application: Typically, 80% of delays are caused by 20% of process steps; focusing on these "vital few" yields the greatest impact.
- Data-Driven Analysis: Use data from MRP/ERP systems and value stream mapping to pinpoint and quantify sources of delay and waste.
- Project Selection by NPV: Projects should be selected and prioritized based on their potential to increase Net Present Value (NPV) and shareholder value.
7. What is the role of culture and management engagement in Lean Six Sigma, as described in the book?
- CEO and Leadership Involvement: The book stresses that Lean Six Sigma initiatives must be led by the CEO or COO, with active engagement from top management.
- Resource Commitment: At least 1% of the workforce should be dedicated full-time to improvement projects (as Black Belts and Champions).
- Structured Infrastructure: A hierarchy of roles (Champions, Black Belts, Green Belts) ensures alignment with business goals and effective project execution.
- Sustained Change: Cultural change, not just tools or training, is essential for lasting results and avoiding "program of the month" failures.
8. What are "Time Traps" and why are they important in Lean Six Sigma?
- Definition of Time Traps: Time Traps are process steps or workstations that inject the most delay into a process, often causing the majority of lead time and inventory buildup.
- Pareto Impact: Typically, a small number of Time Traps are responsible for most of the process delay (80/20 rule).
- Target for Improvement: Identifying and eliminating Time Traps using Lean and Six Sigma tools leads to rapid reductions in lead time, cost, and inventory.
- Data-Driven Identification: Time Traps are found through analysis of process data, not just by observing where inventory piles up.
9. How does "Lean Six Sigma" by Michael L. George link process improvement to financial performance and shareholder value?
- ROIC and NPV Focus: The book ties improvement projects directly to increases in Return on Invested Capital (ROIC) and Net Present Value (NPV), which are key drivers of shareholder value.
- Empirical Evidence: It presents data showing that companies with higher ROIC and revenue growth achieve much higher market-to-book value ratios.
- Project Selection: Value streams and projects are chosen based on their potential to improve these financial metrics, ensuring alignment with corporate strategy.
- Direct Impact: Improvements in speed, quality, and cost reduction translate into higher operating margins, lower inventory, and increased enterprise value.
10. What are the key tools and methodologies used in Lean Six Sigma, according to the book?
- DMAIC Framework: The Define-Measure-Analyze-Improve-Control (DMAIC) process is central, guiding teams through structured problem-solving.
- Lean Tools: Includes value stream mapping, pull systems (Kanban), setup reduction, and total productive maintenance to improve speed and reduce waste.
- Six Sigma Tools: Uses statistical analysis, process mapping, Pareto charts, control charts, and Design of Experiments (DOE) to reduce variation and defects.
- Integration of Tools: The book emphasizes using both Lean and Six Sigma tools together, selecting the right tool for each identified problem.
11. How can Lean Six Sigma be applied outside of manufacturing, as discussed in "Lean Six Sigma" by Michael L. George?
- Transactional Processes: The methodology is effective in improving sales, marketing, order processing, product development, HR, and administrative processes.
- Service Industry Examples: Case studies include hotel check-in processes, mortgage applications, and customer service, showing significant gains in speed and quality.
- Universal Principles: The focus on reducing wait times, eliminating variation, and improving process flow applies to any process, not just manufacturing.
- Overlooked Opportunities: Many companies find untapped value in improving non-manufacturing processes, which are often enablers of core business operations.
12. What are the best quotes from "Lean Six Sigma" by Michael L. George and what do they mean?
- “Variation is evil.” – Jack Welch. This highlights the core Six Sigma belief that reducing variation is essential for meeting customer expectations and achieving consistency.
- “It’s hard to be aggressive when you don’t know who to hit.” – Vince Lombardi, cited in the book. This underscores the importance of data-driven focus in improvement efforts.
- “Most material in a manufacturing process spends 95% of its time waiting…” – Michael L. George. This illustrates the massive opportunity to reduce waste and cost by targeting wait times.
- “Culture eats strategy for breakfast.” – Quoted in the book. This emphasizes that without the right culture and leadership engagement, even the best strategies will fail.
- “It’s not Lean or Six Sigma, it’s not Lean then Six Sigma, it’s Lean and Six Sigma.” – Lockheed-Martin. This encapsulates the book’s central thesis that only the combination delivers breakthrough results.
Review Summary
Lean Six Sigma receives mixed reviews, with an overall rating of 3.69 out of 5. Readers appreciate its guidance on project management and process improvement methodologies. However, some find it repetitive and difficult for beginners to grasp. The book is praised for its comprehensive coverage of Six Sigma and Lean principles but criticized for being wordy and lacking practical case studies. It's considered a valuable reference for those with prior knowledge of the subject, though its dense content may be challenging for newcomers to the field.
Similar Books
About the Author
Other books by Michael L. George
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
