Key Takeaways
1. Game Design is a Multifaceted Art
The tricks and techniques found in this second edition of Level Up! are MY WAYS of creating game design.
Game design is diverse. There's no single "right" way to approach game design; what matters is effectively communicating your ideas. The book presents one perspective, acknowledging that many valid approaches exist. The key is to find methods that work for you and your team.
Teamwork is essential. Video games are collaborative creations, involving many talented individuals. Attributing success solely to one person, like the designer, is inaccurate and egotistical. Acknowledging the contributions of programmers, artists, testers, and others is crucial.
Gameplay is paramount. Every aspect of game development, from cutscenes to monetization models, should be considered in terms of its impact on gameplay. The player experience should be at the forefront of every decision.
2. Ideas are Everywhere, Marketable Ones are Gold
Every good idea borders on the stupid.
Inspiration is abundant. Game ideas can come from anywhere: books, movies, personal experiences, or even bad games. The key is to consume widely, let ideas percolate, and apply your unique perspective. Don't dismiss seemingly silly concepts.
Marketability matters. While passion is essential, game ideas must also be marketable to a broader audience. Balancing personal vision with commercial viability is a constant challenge for game designers.
Iteration is key. Building upon existing ideas and gameplay mechanics is a proven strategy for success. Even innovative games draw inspiration from their predecessors. Understanding the evolution of game design is crucial for creating something new and engaging.
3. Storytelling Enhances Gameplay
If gameplay is the meat of the game, then story should be the salt: just enough will add flavor, but too much can ruin everything and kill you.
Story serves gameplay. While not all games require a complex narrative, a well-crafted story can significantly enhance the player experience. The story should always support the gameplay, not the other way around.
Narrative vs. Story. Every game generates a narrative, an order of events experienced by the player. Designers should focus on creating multiple enjoyable narratives, even in games without a traditional story.
The Triangle of Weirdness. When crafting a game's story, choose only one element to be truly "weird": characters, activities, or world. Overdoing it can alienate players.
4. Documentation is Key to Game Development
GAME DESIGNERS HAVE MORE FUN
Game design documents are essential. A game design document (GDD) outlines everything in your game, serving as a blueprint for the development team. While creating a GDD can be time-consuming, it's a crucial step in ensuring a cohesive and well-defined final product.
Communication is paramount. The primary goal of game design documentation is clear communication. The GDD should be written in a way that is easily understood by all team members, regardless of their discipline.
The One-Sheet and Ten-Pager. Before writing the full GDD, create a one-sheet and a ten-pager to outline the core concepts of the game. These shorter documents can help to refine the idea and get buy-in from stakeholders.
5. Characters Drive Gameplay
GAME DESIGNERS HAVE MORE FUN
Character is key. Compelling characters are essential for engaging players and driving the narrative. Invest time in developing characters that players care about, even if they are destined to die.
The Yorda Effect. Creating a co-dependent relationship between the player character and a non-player character (NPC) can foster a strong emotional connection. Make the NPC's survival critical to the player's success.
Character-driven humor. Humor in games should stem from the characters' personalities, not from cheap gags. Consistent character traits and actions can create genuinely funny moments.
6. Camera and Control are Paramount
GAME DESIGNERS HAVE MORE FUN
The Three Cs. Character, Camera, and Controls are the three fundamental elements of game design. These elements should be established early in preproduction and remain consistent throughout development.
Camera choice matters. The camera view significantly impacts gameplay, level design, and art creation. Choose the right camera for your game and stick with it.
Control is king. Ergonomic and intuitive controls are crucial for a positive player experience. Consider the player's hand position and the physical limitations of the controller.
7. Level Design: Theme Parks and Dungeons
GAME DESIGNERS HAVE MORE FUN
Levels tell stories. Levels should be designed to transport players through a narrative, much like the attractions in a theme park. Use foreshadowing, goal setting, and a clear sense of progression to create engaging experiences.
Alleys vs. Islands. Level design can be broadly categorized into two types: alleys (linear, directed experiences) and islands (open, explorable environments). Choose the style that best suits your game's gameplay and narrative.
Weenies guide players. Use architectural landmarks and visual cues to guide players through the level and prevent them from getting lost.
8. Combat: More Than Just Violence
GAME DESIGNERS HAVE MORE FUN
Combat is a core element. Combat is a popular and engaging element in many video games. A well-designed combat system requires careful consideration of character abilities, enemy AI, and level design.
Balance is key. Combat should be challenging but fair. Avoid creating situations that feel cheap or unfair to the player.
Variety is essential. Offer players a range of combat options, including melee attacks, ranged weapons, and special abilities. This keeps combat fresh and engaging.
9. Enemies: More Than Just Target Practice
GAME DESIGNERS HAVE MORE FUN
Enemies define the challenge. Enemies are more than just targets; they are integral to the gameplay experience. Their size, behavior, speed, and attacks should be carefully designed to create engaging and challenging encounters.
Enemy combinations create complexity. Design enemies to complement each other, forcing players to adapt their strategies and make tactical decisions.
Boss battles are climaxes. Boss battles should be memorable and challenging encounters that test the player's skills and reward their progress.
10. Mechanics: The Nuts and Bolts of Gameplay
GAME DESIGNERS HAVE MORE FUN
Mechanics define interaction. Mechanics are the building blocks of gameplay, the objects and systems that players interact with to create meaningful experiences.
Variety is key. Offer players a range of mechanics to interact with, from moving platforms to switches and levers. This keeps the gameplay fresh and engaging.
Timing is everything. Timing puzzles can create tense and exciting moments, but they must be fair and predictable.
11. Power-Ups: Rewards and Progression
GAME DESIGNERS HAVE MORE FUN
Power-ups enhance gameplay. Power-ups provide temporary boosts to the player's abilities, adding variety and excitement to the gameplay.
Variety is key. Offer a range of power-ups, including defensive, offensive, and movement enhancements. This allows players to customize their play style and adapt to different situations.
Balance is essential. Power-ups should be powerful but not game-breaking. Carefully consider the duration and effects of each power-up to maintain a balanced gameplay experience.
12. Multiplayer: The Social Dimension of Gaming
GAME DESIGNERS HAVE MORE FUN
Multiplayer adds depth. Multiplayer modes add a social dimension to gaming, allowing players to compete and cooperate with others.
Variety is key. Offer a range of multiplayer modes, including competitive, cooperative, and conjugate gameplay. This caters to different player preferences and play styles.
Balance is essential. Carefully balance the gameplay to ensure that all players have a fair and enjoyable experience.
Last updated:
FAQ
1. What is Level Up!: The Guide to Great Video Game Design by Scott Rogers about?
- Comprehensive game design manual: The book is a detailed, practical guide covering all aspects of video game design, from basic concepts to advanced topics like character, camera, controls, level design, enemies, music, and monetization.
- Industry experience and anecdotes: Scott Rogers draws on over 20 years in the industry, sharing real-world lessons, personal stories, and examples from well-known games.
- Structured for learning: The book is organized into "levels," each focusing on a specific area of game design, making it accessible for both beginners and experienced designers.
- Focus on actionable advice: Emphasizes practical tips, clear communication, and iterative development, helping readers apply concepts directly to their own projects.
2. Why should I read Level Up!: The Guide to Great Video Game Design by Scott Rogers?
- Learn from a veteran: Scott Rogers has worked on hit games like Pac-Man World and God of War, offering insights grounded in real-world development.
- Balanced theory and practice: The book combines foundational design principles with hands-on advice, making it valuable for students, hobbyists, and professionals.
- Engaging and accessible style: Uses cartoons, humor, and a breezy tone to make complex ideas easy to understand and enjoyable to read.
- Universal truths and clever ideas: Each chapter ends with key takeaways, helping readers internalize best practices and avoid common pitfalls.
3. What are the key takeaways and universal truths from Level Up! by Scott Rogers?
- Gameplay is central: Every element, from story to monetization, should serve and enhance gameplay.
- The Three Cs: Character, Camera, and Control are the pillars of game design; changing any during production can cause major issues.
- Everything is liquid: Game designs evolve constantly, and documentation must be updated to reflect changes.
- Communication is critical: Clear, concise documentation and visual aids are essential for team alignment and successful development.
4. What are the "Three Cs" (Character, Camera, Control) in Level Up! and why are they important?
- Character: Design characters whose appearance, movement, and abilities reflect their gameplay role and personality, using distinct shapes and customization to foster player attachment.
- Camera: Treat the camera as a participant, using cinematic techniques and player-friendly controls to enhance immersion and avoid disorientation.
- Control: Prioritize ergonomic, intuitive control schemes that respond immediately to player input, allowing customization and accessibility.
- Interdependence: Changing one "C" affects the others, so all must be planned and tested together for a cohesive player experience.
5. How does Scott Rogers define and use game design documentation in Level Up!?
- Comprehensive blueprint: The Game Design Document (GDD) details every aspect of the game, from mechanics to story, serving as the team's primary reference.
- Iterative and flexible: Rogers stresses that "everything is liquid," so the GDD must be updated regularly as the design evolves.
- Multiple formats: Use storyboards, diagrams, animatics, and wikis to make documentation engaging and accessible to all team members.
- Effective communication: The goal is to ensure everyone—producers, designers, artists, programmers—understands the vision and details of the game.
6. What methods does Level Up! by Scott Rogers recommend for generating and refining game ideas?
- Diverse inspiration: Draw ideas from a wide range of media and experiences, not just games, to avoid derivative concepts.
- Collaborative brainstorming: Encourage group sessions where all ideas are welcome, recording and exploring each one fully.
- Theory of Un-Fun: Start with a fun core idea, then iteratively remove un-fun elements, even if it means discarding good ideas that don't fit.
- Player focus: Always consider what will be enjoyable and engaging for the player, not just what seems cool on paper.
7. How does Level Up! by Scott Rogers approach story and narrative design in games?
- Flexible story structure: Not all games need a deep story, but every game has some form of narrative, even if it's player-driven.
- Player as hero: Design multiple enjoyable narrative paths and choreograph emotional experiences, letting players create their own stories through gameplay.
- Triangle of Weirdness: Make only one aspect (character, activity, or world) "weird" to avoid alienating players and maintain accessibility.
- Balance depth: Cater to both story-driven and action-focused players by providing optional narrative layers.
8. What are Scott Rogers' principles for character and enemy design in Level Up!?
- Form follows function: Characters and enemies should look and behave in ways that reflect their gameplay roles, using clear silhouettes and visual cues.
- Player attachment: Allow customization and naming to increase emotional investment; design companions and multiple characters to complement each other.
- Enemy design: Enemies should be fun to fight, with telegraphed attacks, vulnerabilities, and varied behaviors to keep combat engaging.
- Boss battles: Bosses need memorable introductions, multiple attack patterns, and clear vulnerable states, emphasizing drama and player agency.
9. How does Level Up! by Scott Rogers address level design and world building?
- Levels vs. worlds: Levels are individual gameplay environments; worlds are collections of levels with a shared theme, organized using maps and beat charts.
- Creative use of clichés: Combine classic themes in unique ways ("Mexican pizza" technique) to keep environments fresh.
- Alley vs. island design: Choose between linear (alley) and open (island) structures based on gameplay goals, providing variety and player choice.
- Reward exploration: Include multiple paths, side areas ("fingers"), and rewards to keep players engaged and motivated.
10. What advice does Level Up! by Scott Rogers give on gameplay mechanics, hazards, and power-ups?
- Mechanics: Design interactive elements like platforms, switches, and puzzles that challenge and engage players, reusing them creatively.
- Hazards: Use predictable dangers (spikes, flames) that punish mistakes but are clearly signaled to avoid frustration.
- Power-ups: Offer temporary or conditional enhancements (health, weapons, speed) that are visually distinct and balanced to empower but not overpower players.
- Anti-power-ups: Use sparingly for surprise, but avoid overuse to prevent player frustration.
11. How does Level Up! by Scott Rogers cover multiplayer, combat, and player health systems?
- Multiplayer modes: Categorizes gameplay into competitive, cooperative, and conjugate, with tailored design for each mode and player count.
- Combat design: Focuses on context, variety, and player empowerment, using attack matrices, lock-ons, and balanced enemy groups.
- Health and death: Communicate damage clearly with HUD, animations, or effects; use checkpoints and quick restarts to keep players engaged.
- Fairness and feedback: Avoid excessive punishment, provide immediate feedback, and design for excitement and satisfaction.
12. What production, pitching, and marketing strategies does Level Up! by Scott Rogers recommend for game designers?
- Pitch preparation: Create concise, visually appealing pitches that highlight gameplay and unique selling points, tailored to the audience.
- Production realities: Plan for people, schedules, and unexpected issues; communicate clearly, iterate, and be ready to revise or cut content.
- Marketing collaboration: Work closely with marketing teams, using clear documentation (one-sheet, ten-pager) to ensure accurate promotion.
- Avoiding pitfalls: Beware of overpromising, designer blinders, and crunch; use vertical slice or horizontal layer production methods for better project management.
Review Summary
Level Up! receives mostly positive reviews, with readers praising its comprehensive overview of game design principles. Many find it accessible, humorous, and well-illustrated. It's particularly recommended for beginners and those curious about the industry. Some experienced developers, however, consider it too basic. The book covers various aspects of game creation, from mechanics to documentation, and is appreciated for its practical advice. While some critics find it shallow, most readers value its insights into making games engaging and fun.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
