Key Takeaways
1. Nomadic childhood shaped a unique worldview
Like any nomadic child, I learned to apprehend places differently than settled people do.
Global perspective. Growing up in 17 homes across four continents before age 17, the author developed a unique lens through which to view the world. This nomadic lifestyle, driven by her father's work on international engineering projects, exposed her to a kaleidoscope of cultures, landscapes, and ways of life.
Fluid identity. The constant movement created a sense of rootlessness but also adaptability. The author learned to quickly adjust to new environments, languages, and social situations. This experience fostered a global mindset and the ability to find connections across seemingly disparate cultures and places.
Fragmented sense of home. The author's childhood homes included:
- Double-wide trailers in Alaska, Saudi Arabia, and Colombia
- A hotel suite in London
- Various apartments and houses across the United States
This diversity of living situations contributed to a complex and multifaceted understanding of "home" that transcended traditional notions of permanence and stability.
2. Home is a fluid concept, not tied to a single place
A mobile home is nothing new: humans as a species have built temporary shelters since our days roaming around as hunters and gatherers.
Redefining home. The author challenges the conventional idea of home as a fixed location, instead presenting it as a dynamic and portable concept. This perspective is rooted in both her personal experiences and the broader history of human habitation.
Historical context. The book explores various forms of mobile and temporary dwellings throughout history:
- Bedouin black tents
- Native American tepees
- Modern mobile homes and trailers
Psychological impact. The author reflects on how this fluid concept of home affects one's sense of self and belonging. While it can lead to a sense of displacement, it also offers freedom and adaptability. The ability to create "home" in diverse settings becomes a valuable skill and source of resilience.
3. Architecture reflects cultural values and personal histories
Buildings, too, are children of Earth and Sun.
Cultural mirrors. The author examines how different architectural styles and building practices reflect the values, beliefs, and histories of various cultures. From the open-air designs of Bedouin tents to the sleek modernism of Eichler homes in California, architecture serves as a tangible expression of cultural ideals.
Personal meaning. Throughout the book, specific buildings and architectural features become touchstones for personal memories and family history:
- The Marin County Civic Center designed by Frank Lloyd Wright
- The author's childhood "Likeler" home in Terra Linda
- Sarah Winchester's sprawling mansion in San Jose
Evolution of spaces. The author explores how buildings change over time, both physically and in terms of their cultural significance. This evolution mirrors the ways in which personal and collective identities shift and adapt to new circumstances.
4. Archaeology reveals hidden narratives of place and time
What I'd needed help with was the unfolding self-destruction of someone I loved.
Unearthing stories. The author draws parallels between archaeological excavations and the process of uncovering personal and family histories. Just as artifacts can reveal forgotten narratives about a place, exploring one's past can unearth hidden truths and connections.
Layers of meaning. The book examines several archaeological sites and their significance:
- The African Burial Ground in Lower Manhattan
- The Five Points excavation in New York City
- Ancient trade routes in Saudi Arabia
Preserving the past. The author reflects on the importance of preserving and interpreting archaeological findings, both for their historical value and for the insights they offer into human nature and cultural development.
5. Family dynamics influence one's relationship with home
Our home was our trailer, and the machinery of its construction fascinated me and made me feel safe.
Parental influence. The author's relationship with home is deeply shaped by her parents' attitudes and behaviors. Their constant relocations and home renovation projects create a sense of impermanence but also excitement and possibility.
Sibling bonds. The shared experience of frequent moves strengthens the connection between the author and her brother. Their ability to adapt to new environments together becomes a source of stability in an otherwise changing world.
Intergenerational patterns. The book explores how family histories of movement and displacement can influence subsequent generations:
- The author's grandparents' frequent relocations
- Her parents' globetrotting lifestyle
- The author's own journey to create a stable home for her son
6. Alcoholism's impact on family and sense of belonging
Alcoholism is an illness. Everyone says it; I'll bet few truly believe it.
Personal struggle. The author candidly discusses her father's battle with alcoholism and its profound impact on the family. This addiction becomes another destabilizing force in an already nomadic life.
Societal perceptions. The book examines the complex and often contradictory views on alcoholism:
- As a disease requiring compassion and treatment
- As a moral failing deserving judgment
Legacy of addiction. The author reflects on how her father's alcoholism shapes her own relationship with alcohol and her approach to creating stability for her own family.
7. The power of objects and artifacts in connecting to the past
Almost everything—but not everything—disappeared.
Tangible memories. The author explores how physical objects can serve as anchors to past experiences and lost places. From ancient pottery shards found in the Saudi desert to family heirlooms, these items become touchstones for personal and cultural histories.
Preservation and loss. The book grapples with questions of what should be preserved and why:
- The destruction of Five Points artifacts on 9/11
- The author's collection of ancient objects from Saudi Arabia
- Family mementos carried from place to place
Meaning-making. Objects and artifacts become vehicles for creating narratives and understanding one's place in a larger historical context. The author uses these tangible links to the past to construct a sense of identity and belonging that transcends geographical boundaries.
8. Stonehenge as a symbol of human ingenuity and mystery
Time is the medium through which we live. It's the messages we shape from it—our arts, cultures, technologies—that change the myths we create, the structures we devise, the beauties we observe about it.
Enduring wonder. The author uses Stonehenge as a focal point for exploring humanity's relationship with time, mystery, and the desire to create lasting monuments. The ancient site becomes a metaphor for the enduring human impulse to understand and mark our place in the universe.
Evolving interpretations. The book traces the various theories and beliefs about Stonehenge over time:
- As a Druidic temple
- An astronomical calendar
- A place of healing
- A monument to the dead
Contemporary relevance. The author reflects on how Stonehenge continues to captivate our imagination and what it reveals about our current relationship with technology, spirituality, and the natural world.
9. The complexities of identity formation through constant relocation
Picture Stonehenge's layout like a huge target composed of nine concentric rings of earthworks, holes, or stones, all stretching more than three hundred feet in diameter.
Layered self. The author's experiences of constant relocation create a multi-faceted identity, much like the concentric rings of Stonehenge. Each place leaves its mark, contributing to a complex and sometimes contradictory sense of self.
Adaptability vs. rootlessness. The book explores the tension between the benefits of adaptability gained through frequent moves and the challenges of feeling rootless or disconnected from a specific place or culture.
Creating continuity. The author reflects on her efforts to create a sense of continuity and belonging for herself and her son, drawing on the lessons learned from her nomadic childhood:
- Valuing experiences over possessions
- Finding common threads across diverse cultures
- Creating "home" through relationships and shared stories rather than fixed locations
Last updated:
Review Summary
Mobile Home receives overwhelmingly positive reviews, praised for its insightful exploration of home, travel, and family. Readers appreciate Harlan's witty, thoughtful writing style and her ability to weave personal experiences with broader research. The essay collection is lauded for its global scope, philosophical depth, and poetic language. Many reviewers highlight the book's ability to connect personal stories to larger themes of belonging, addiction, and the impact of place on identity. A few readers found certain sections less engaging, but overall, the book is highly recommended.