Key Takeaways
1. Energy justice is the new frontier of civil rights
The struggle for energy justice, for revolutionary power, is about nothing less than freedom.
Energy connects to every aspect of life. The energy system defines nearly every aspect of socioeconomics and health. It determines who has access to affordable electricity, clean air, and economic opportunities. The transition away from fossil fuels offers a unique opportunity to upend existing socioeconomic inequality and foster lasting structural change.
Energy policy should be the domain of civil rights. By situating renewable energy policy within a broader civil rights discourse, we can address longstanding inequalities and access to justice. This framing connects energy issues to movements for civil rights, Indigenous rights, economic justice, and health justice.
A just energy system is a civil right. Communities of color, poor people, and Indigenous people must serve as the architects of the new energy system to upend the embedded and unequal power dynamics that are a direct outgrowth of the current system. This power revolution calls for the absolute transformation of fundamental aspects of the energy system:
- Renewable energy policy
- Financial institutions funding energy projects
- The utility sector itself
2. The fossil fuel-based energy system perpetuates racial and economic inequality
The energy system routinely sacrifices Brown, Black, and Indigenous bodies to keep the lights on for the majority.
Environmental racism is embedded in the energy system. Communities of color disproportionately bear the burdens of fossil fuel extraction, production, and waste. This leads to higher rates of pollution, health problems, and economic disadvantage in these communities.
Energy burden falls heaviest on the poor. Low-income households often pay a much higher percentage of their income for energy costs compared to wealthier households. This perpetuates a cycle of poverty and limits economic mobility.
The centralized energy model concentrates power and wealth. The current system, dominated by large investor-owned utilities, consolidates economic and political power in the hands of a few companies. This structure makes it difficult for marginalized communities to have a say in energy decisions that affect their lives.
3. Utility reform is crucial for transforming the energy landscape
Investor-owned utilities are deeply problematic. They threaten progress on both the clean energy and equity fronts.
The investor-owned utility model is outdated. It incentivizes selling more electricity and building unnecessary infrastructure, rather than promoting energy efficiency and distributed clean energy. This model often works against the interests of consumers and the environment.
Alternative utility structures offer promise:
- Public power providers
- Electric cooperatives
- Community choice aggregation
Concrete strategies for utility reform:
- Convert investor-owned utilities to public power entities
- Implement performance-based regulation that aligns utility incentives with public interest
- Transform utilities into distributed system operators that prioritize clean, local energy
- Increase opportunities for community choice aggregation
4. Climate change fundamentalism hinders equitable clean energy transitions
Climate change fundamentalism is the narrow focus on advancing climate and clean energy policy while failing to account for justice concerns or, more insidiously, deliberately delaying justice considerations.
Equity must be central to climate policy. Many climate advocates argue that we lack time to integrate justice concerns into efforts to avert catastrophic climate change. This approach perpetuates existing inequalities and misses opportunities for transformative change.
Big Green organizations must prioritize equity. Well-resourced environmental organizations often fail to advocate for equity-centered policy approaches in critical proceedings. They must develop complex environmental analyses that account for the historic burdens faced by communities of color.
Model legislation: New York's Climate Leadership and Community Protection Act (CLCPA).
Key features:
- Explicit recognition of equity and justice concerns
- Meaningful pathways for community participation
- Distribution of economic benefits to marginalized communities
- Targets 40% of clean energy benefits to disadvantaged communities
5. Rooftop solar access is a battleground for energy democracy
We have to fight for distributed energy.
Rooftop solar democratizes the energy system. It allows individuals and communities to generate their own power, reducing reliance on centralized utilities and fossil fuels. This distributed model increases resilience to climate impacts and can provide economic benefits to participants.
Utilities and fossil fuel interests are fighting to limit rooftop solar. They deploy misleading arguments about cost-shifting and grid stability to undermine policies that support distributed solar. These tactics disproportionately harm low-income communities and communities of color.
Strategies to advance equity in rooftop solar:
- Prioritize solar adoption in environmental justice communities
- Increase the overall value assigned to solar energy
- Provide financial and legal support for community intervention in regulatory proceedings
6. Community energy projects must prioritize local ownership and control
Community energy holds promise as a policy tool and a mechanism to lift folks out of poverty and reduce energy burden.
True community energy empowers local control. It should allow communities to own, manage, and benefit from local clean energy resources. Many existing "community solar" programs fail to deliver on this promise.
Key principles for equitable community energy:
- Local siting and community-scale development
- Community ownership and control
- Meaningful economic benefits for participants
- Prioritization of low-to-moderate income households
Policy design is critical. Many existing community energy policies replicate inequalities by favoring large developers over true community ownership. Advocates must fight for policies that center community needs and provide pathways for local wealth creation.
7. Innovative financing is key to ending "solar segregation"
We need explicitly antiracist financial instruments that aim to undo the troubling legacy of policies like redlining and the discourse of creditworthiness that succeeded it.
Traditional financing perpetuates inequality. Existing tax incentives and credit requirements for solar projects favor wealthy individuals and large corporations. This creates structural barriers to clean energy access for low-income communities and communities of color.
New approaches to finance are needed:
- Green banks with explicit equity mandates
- On-bill financing for distributed energy resources
- Alternative measures of creditworthiness beyond traditional credit scores
- Energy burden caps based on household income
Policy recommendations:
- Compensate communities for historical environmental burdens through energy bill reductions
- Create reinvestment zones that require community ownership in clean energy projects
- Facilitate on-bill financing programs for rooftop solar and energy efficiency upgrades
8. A just energy transition requires centering marginalized communities
Revolutionary power requires pushing against the narrative that we must save the planet first before saving the most vulnerable residents on it. We can and must do both, even when it is slow and even when it is frustrating.
Frontline communities must lead the transition. Those most impacted by the fossil fuel system should be at the forefront of designing the new clean energy system. This ensures that the transition addresses historical injustices and creates meaningful economic opportunities.
Equity should be baked into clean energy policies from the start. Rather than treating justice as an afterthought, equity considerations should shape the fundamental design of energy transition policies and programs.
Key areas for intervention:
- Utility reform
- Ambitious climate and clean energy targets
- Rooftop solar policies
- Community energy programs
- Access to clean energy financing
9. The COVID-19 pandemic exposed energy system vulnerabilities
The virus forced a reckoning with our unequal livelihoods and unjust mortalities. It changed us.
The pandemic revealed deep energy inequities. Low-income communities and communities of color faced higher energy burdens and greater health risks due to their proximity to polluting energy infrastructure.
Energy is a critical lifeline during crises. The pandemic highlighted the essential nature of reliable, affordable electricity for health, education, and economic stability.
The crisis creates an opportunity for transformation. As we rebuild from the pandemic, we have a chance to create a more just and resilient energy system that prioritizes the needs of the most vulnerable.
10. Revolutionary power demands courage and a radical reimagining of energy
Revolutionary power is, at its core, about love. It is about a love that looks forward—toward future generations, children unnamed, and possibilities unfurling—and a love that looks back—to ancestors hoping, believing, and praying that you might come into existence.
Transforming the energy system is an act of love. It requires courage to challenge entrenched power structures and imagine a radically different future.
Key principles of revolutionary power:
- Centering marginalized voices in energy decision-making
- Dismantling structural racism and oppression through energy policy
- Creating pathways for community ownership and control of energy resources
- Prioritizing resilience and local benefits in system design
The time for action is now. As the energy system undergoes a massive transition driven by climate change and technological innovation, we have a unique opportunity to reshape it in service of justice and equity. This requires sustained advocacy, coalition-building, and a willingness to dream big.
Last updated:
FAQ
What's Revolutionary Power about?
- Energy Justice Focus: Revolutionary Power by Shalanda Baker delves into the intersection of energy policy and social justice, advocating for an equitable energy transition that centers marginalized communities.
- Personal and Professional Journey: The book intertwines Baker's experiences as a Black, queer woman with her professional insights, highlighting systemic injustices in energy production and consumption.
- Call for Transformation: Baker urges a radical overhaul of the energy system, combining personal memoir with policy guidance to inspire activism that prioritizes justice alongside climate action.
Why should I read Revolutionary Power?
- Timely and Relevant: The book addresses pressing issues of climate change and social justice, making it essential for those interested in environmental advocacy.
- Empowerment for Marginalized Communities: Baker stresses the importance of empowering those most affected by the energy system to shape the new energy landscape.
- Practical Framework: It offers concrete strategies for energy policy advocacy, serving as a resource for activists, policymakers, and concerned citizens.
What are the key takeaways of Revolutionary Power?
- Energy as a Civil Right: Baker argues that access to clean, affordable energy is a fundamental civil right, linking energy justice to broader civil rights movements.
- Decentralized Energy Systems: The book advocates for local control over energy resources to mitigate vulnerabilities associated with centralized systems.
- Intersection of Climate and Justice: Baker emphasizes that climate action must prioritize social justice, ensuring marginalized voices are included in decision-making.
What is energy justice, as defined in Revolutionary Power?
- Equitable Access: Energy justice involves fair distribution of energy benefits and burdens, ensuring all communities have access to clean energy.
- Historical Injustices: It acknowledges systemic inequalities in energy policy, particularly affecting communities of color, and calls for addressing these injustices.
- Community Empowerment: Energy justice advocates for active participation of marginalized communities in energy decision-making processes.
How does Revolutionary Power address the concept of utility reform?
- Essential for Change: Baker sees utility reform as crucial for achieving energy justice, advocating for restructuring investor-owned utilities to prioritize community needs.
- Case Studies: The book examines reform efforts in places like Hawai‘i and California, illustrating challenges and opportunities in the utility sector.
- Advocacy Strategies: Baker provides strategies for advocating utility reform, emphasizing community engagement in the regulatory process.
What is climate change fundamentalism, as discussed in Revolutionary Power?
- Narrow Carbon Focus: Climate change fundamentalism prioritizes carbon reduction without considering social justice implications, potentially exacerbating inequalities.
- Critique of Environmentalism: Baker critiques mainstream environmental organizations for sidelining equity issues, undermining a just energy transition.
- Inclusive Solutions: She advocates for a holistic approach to climate action that integrates social justice concerns.
What are the specific strategies for community energy discussed in Revolutionary Power?
- Community Ownership: Baker emphasizes policies enabling local control over energy resources, empowering communities economically through renewable initiatives.
- Equitable Resource Access: The book highlights the need to remove barriers preventing marginalized communities from participating in the clean energy transition.
- Collaborative Models: Baker encourages partnerships between local organizations, governments, and residents to prioritize community needs in energy planning.
What are the implications of the Green New Deal in relation to Revolutionary Power?
- Alignment with Energy Justice: Baker aligns the Green New Deal's principles with energy justice goals, both seeking to address systemic inequalities.
- Advocacy Framework: The book positions the Green New Deal as a framework for advocating energy justice, emphasizing policies prioritizing marginalized communities.
- Holistic Approach: Baker highlights the importance of integrating environmental, economic, and social justice concerns in reimagining the energy system.
What are the best quotes from Revolutionary Power and what do they mean?
- "Solving the climate crisis...": This quote underscores the need for a radical rethinking of energy policy that prioritizes justice and equity.
- "Energy connects to every aspect...": It emphasizes the pervasive influence of energy systems on social, economic, and health outcomes.
- "The struggle for energy justice...": This encapsulates the book's theme, linking energy access to broader civil rights and social justice struggles.
What is the "value of solar" concept discussed in Revolutionary Power?
- Compensation for Solar Energy: The "value of solar" refers to compensation for solar energy producers, which should reflect social and environmental benefits.
- Value Stacking Critique: Baker critiques the undervaluation of solar energy's broader benefits, such as reduced pollution and enhanced grid resilience.
- Equity Considerations: The book emphasizes fair compensation for marginalized communities, acknowledging their historical burdens and contributions.
How does Revolutionary Power propose to reform utility models?
- Dismantling IOUs: Baker advocates for breaking up investor-owned utilities and transitioning to public or community-owned models prioritizing local needs.
- Community Participation: The book stresses the need for community involvement in governance to ensure policies reflect marginalized populations' interests.
- Innovative Models: Baker suggests exploring cooperatives and community choice aggregators to promote equity in energy access.
What is the significance of the "energy burden" concept in Revolutionary Power?
- Definition and Impact: The energy burden is the percentage of income spent on energy, disproportionately affecting low-income families.
- Community Impact: High energy burdens force families to choose between energy and essential needs like food and healthcare.
- Policy Change Call: Baker argues for policies capping energy costs relative to income and providing financial support to those most affected.
Review Summary
Readers generally praise Revolutionary Power for its insightful perspective on energy justice and equity in the renewable energy transition. Many appreciate Baker's personal experiences and policy analyses, finding the book thought-provoking and informative. Some criticize the repetitive nature of certain sections and organizational issues. Reviewers highlight the book's focus on centering marginalized communities in energy policy and its critique of current systems. While some find it challenging to read, most agree it offers valuable insights for those interested in energy justice and climate change.
Similar Books





Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub
digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.