Key Takeaways
1. Systematic trading overcomes human biases and emotions
"Creating a trading system removes the emotion and makes it easier to commit to a consistent strategy."
Cognitive biases hinder performance. Humans are prone to numerous cognitive biases that can negatively impact trading decisions. These include:
- Overconfidence: Believing we're better at predicting markets than we actually are
- Loss aversion: Holding onto losing positions too long and selling winners too early
- Recency bias: Giving too much weight to recent events or data
Systematic approach provides discipline. By implementing a rules-based trading system, investors can:
- Remove emotional decision-making from the process
- Consistently apply proven strategies across various market conditions
- Avoid impulsive trades based on fear, greed, or temporary market noise
Backtest and validate strategies. Systematic trading allows for thorough backtesting of strategies, helping investors:
- Understand how a strategy would have performed historically
- Identify potential weaknesses or risks in the approach
- Gain confidence in the system's ability to weather different market environments
2. Simple trading rules often outperform complex strategies
"I am not a fan of complex fitting methods and I prefer not to use them."
Simplicity promotes robustness. Simple trading rules tend to be more robust and less prone to overfitting than complex strategies. Benefits include:
- Easier to understand and implement
- Less likely to break down in changing market conditions
- More likely to capture persistent market inefficiencies
Examples of effective simple rules:
- Trend following: Buy assets with positive momentum, sell those with negative momentum
- Mean reversion: Buy assets that have fallen significantly, sell those that have risen sharply
- Carry: Profit from yield differentials between assets
Avoid over-optimization. Complex strategies with many parameters are often over-optimized to past data, leading to poor future performance. Instead:
- Focus on well-established, theoretically sound principles
- Use a limited number of parameters in your trading rules
- Prioritize out-of-sample testing to validate strategy performance
3. Diversification is crucial for managing risk and improving returns
"Diversification really is the only free lunch in investment."
Benefits of diversification:
- Reduces overall portfolio risk
- Improves risk-adjusted returns
- Smooths out performance across different market conditions
Diversify across multiple dimensions:
- Asset classes: Equities, bonds, commodities, currencies
- Geographies: Developed markets, emerging markets
- Sectors: Technology, healthcare, finance, energy, etc.
- Trading styles: Trend following, mean reversion, carry, value
Correlation is key. Focus on combining assets and strategies with low or negative correlations to maximize diversification benefits. Tools for measuring and optimizing diversification include:
- Correlation matrices
- Principal component analysis
- Risk parity approaches
4. Avoid overfitting by using ideas-first approach and limited data
"I prefer to come up with a relatively small number of ideas for trading rules."
Ideas-first approach. Start with a sound theoretical basis for your trading strategies, rather than mining data for patterns. This method:
- Reduces the risk of finding spurious relationships in historical data
- Focuses on persistent, explainable market phenomena
- Improves the likelihood of future strategy success
Limit data used in strategy development:
- Use a subset of available data for initial strategy development
- Reserve a significant portion of data for out-of-sample testing
- Implement expanding window or walk-forward optimization techniques
Be wary of data mining pitfalls:
- Avoid testing an excessive number of parameters or variations
- Be skeptical of strategies with unusually high historical performance
- Consider the theoretical basis and economic rationale behind each strategy
5. Position sizing and risk management are critical for long-term success
"Deciding your overall trading risk is the most important decision you will have to make when designing your trading system."
Volatility targeting. Use a consistent approach to position sizing based on the volatility of each asset:
- Set a target portfolio volatility (e.g., 10% annualized)
- Adjust position sizes to maintain consistent risk exposure across assets
- Regularly update volatility estimates to adapt to changing market conditions
Risk management techniques:
- Stop-losses: Automatically exit positions that move against you by a predetermined amount
- Position limits: Cap the maximum exposure to any single asset or strategy
- Correlation-based sizing: Reduce position sizes for highly correlated assets
Kelly criterion and half-Kelly. The Kelly criterion provides a mathematical framework for optimal bet sizing, but in practice:
- Use a more conservative "half-Kelly" approach to account for estimation errors
- Adjust overall risk based on your personal risk tolerance and financial situation
6. Trading costs can significantly impact performance
"To avoid this scenario it's better to start with significantly lower trading capital and gradually increase it until you have the full amount invested."
Types of trading costs:
- Commissions: Fees paid to brokers for executing trades
- Spreads: Difference between bid and ask prices
- Slippage: Price movement between trade decision and execution
- Market impact: Price changes caused by your own trading activity
Strategies to minimize costs:
- Trade less frequently: Implement longer-term strategies when possible
- Use limit orders: Aim to capture the spread rather than crossing it
- Choose liquid instruments: Focus on assets with tight bid-ask spreads
- Optimize execution: Use algorithmic trading to minimize market impact
Cost-adjusted performance evaluation:
- Always consider trading costs when backtesting strategies
- Set realistic cost assumptions based on your trading size and frequency
- Monitor actual trading costs and adjust strategies if necessary
7. Combine multiple trading rules for robust performance
"I think that a balanced combination of trading rules, with different styles that work in different environments, is better than any single alternative."
Benefits of multi-strategy approaches:
- Improved diversification across different market regimes
- Reduced reliance on any single strategy or market inefficiency
- More consistent overall performance
Combining strategies effectively:
- Use strategies with low correlations to each other
- Allocate capital based on risk-adjusted performance and diversification benefits
- Implement a systematic approach to weighting and rebalancing strategies
Example strategy combinations:
- Trend following + mean reversion
- Momentum + value
- Carry + volatility strategies
8. Regularly rebalance and adjust your portfolio
"You should also reduce your trading capital, and hence your cash volatility target, if you withdraw money from your trading account or investors redeem."
Importance of rebalancing:
- Maintains target risk levels across assets and strategies
- Captures profits from outperforming assets
- Ensures diversification benefits are preserved over time
Rebalancing approaches:
- Time-based: Rebalance at fixed intervals (e.g., monthly, quarterly)
- Threshold-based: Rebalance when allocations deviate beyond a certain percentage
- Volatility-based: Adjust positions based on changes in asset volatility
Adapting to changing market conditions:
- Regularly review and update volatility estimates
- Adjust overall risk exposure based on market regime indicators
- Consider incorporating dynamic asset allocation strategies
9. Be realistic about expected returns and drawdowns
"Assume your trading will go badly, be prepared for that eventuality, and be pleasantly surprised if it doesn't."
Setting realistic expectations:
- Historical Sharpe ratios for diversified portfolios typically range from 0.5 to 1.0
- Expect significant drawdowns, even with well-designed systems
- Understand that past performance does not guarantee future results
Preparing for drawdowns:
- Use conservative position sizing to avoid blowing up during tough periods
- Maintain sufficient cash reserves to weather extended drawdowns
- Psychologically prepare yourself (and your investors) for periods of underperformance
Continuous improvement:
- Regularly review and analyze system performance
- Identify areas for potential improvement without overfitting
- Stay informed about new research and market developments
Last updated:
FAQ
What's Systematic Trading by Robert Carver about?
- Systematic Strategies Focus: The book introduces a method for designing trading and investing systems that minimize emotional decision-making by using structured rules.
- Behavioral Insights: It discusses how cognitive biases lead to poor trading decisions and advocates for systematic approaches to counteract these flaws, rooted in behavioral finance principles.
- Practical Framework: Carver provides a modular framework that allows traders to adapt their strategies based on individual needs and market conditions, including components like trading rules and risk management.
Why should I read Systematic Trading by Robert Carver?
- Improved Decision-Making: The book helps develop a disciplined approach to trading, reducing the influence of emotions like fear and greed.
- Comprehensive Guidance: It offers a detailed roadmap for both novice and experienced traders, covering basic concepts to advanced strategies.
- Real-World Applications: Carver draws on his extensive finance industry experience, providing insights applicable across various asset classes and trading styles.
What are the key takeaways of Systematic Trading by Robert Carver?
- Systematic Approach: Emphasizes the importance of creating a trading strategy that relies on rules rather than intuition for consistency and discipline.
- Risk Management: Highlights effective risk management techniques, including setting volatility targets and position sizing based on risk tolerance.
- Modular Framework: Introduces a framework that allows traders to customize their systems according to preferences and market conditions.
What are the best quotes from Systematic Trading by Robert Carver and what do they mean?
- Effectiveness of Simplicity: “In every case the accuracy of experts was matched or exceeded by a simple algorithm.” This suggests that simplicity can often yield better results in trading.
- Cognitive Biases: “Humans should be great traders, but... the research that tells us why humans make bad decisions.” This underscores the need for systematic approaches to mitigate biases.
- Emotional Benefits: “Creating a trading system removes the emotion and makes it easier to commit to a consistent strategy.” This highlights the emotional control gained through systematic trading.
What is systematic trading according to Systematic Trading by Robert Carver?
- Defined Methodology: Systematic trading is a structured approach relying on predefined rules and algorithms, aiming to eliminate emotional biases.
- Components: Includes trading rules, risk management, and position sizing, each playing a crucial role in the strategy's effectiveness.
- Back-Testing: Emphasizes back-testing trading rules against historical data to validate their effectiveness and avoid overfitting.
How does Systematic Trading by Robert Carver address the flaws of human decision-making?
- Cognitive Biases: Discusses biases like overconfidence and loss aversion, explaining how they lead to irrational decisions.
- Behavioral Finance: Incorporates principles from behavioral finance, particularly prospect theory, to explain the effectiveness of systematic trading.
- Emotional Control: Highlights the importance of emotional control, advocating for a structured approach to avoid impulsive decisions.
What is the modular framework in Systematic Trading by Robert Carver?
- Flexible Design: Allows traders to customize their systems by separating components like trading rules and risk management strategies.
- Transparent Components: Designed to be transparent and easy to understand, building trust in the system.
- Integration of Strategies: Facilitates the integration of multiple trading strategies, enabling diversification and improved performance.
How can I implement the strategies from Systematic Trading by Robert Carver?
- Start with a Plan: Define trading goals and risk tolerance to guide strategy selection.
- Use the Framework: Implement the modular framework to create a customized trading system.
- Back-Test and Adjust: Regularly back-test rules against historical data and adjust strategies based on results and market conditions.
What are the risks associated with systematic trading according to Systematic Trading by Robert Carver?
- Overfitting Risks: A primary risk is overfitting, where rules are too tailored to historical data and fail in real-time trading.
- Market Changes: Strategies may become less effective if market conditions change significantly, requiring adaptation.
- Emotional Challenges: Traders may struggle with sticking to rules during losses, making discipline crucial for success.
How does Systematic Trading by Robert Carver suggest managing risk?
- Volatility Targeting: Emphasizes setting a volatility target based on trading capital and risk tolerance.
- Position Sizing: Provides guidelines for determining position sizes based on instrument volatility.
- Continuous Monitoring: Regularly review and adjust risk management strategies as market conditions change.
What is the no-rule trading rule mentioned in Systematic Trading by Robert Carver?
- Constant Forecast: Assumes a constant forecast of +10 for all assets, simplifying decision-making.
- Simplicity in Execution: Focuses on capital allocation rather than predicting market movements.
- Risk Management: Emphasizes risk management and position sizing to protect capital.
How does Systematic Trading by Robert Carver address trading costs?
- Standardised Cost Measurement: Introduces a method for standardizing costs, crucial for informed asset trading decisions.
- Cost Implications: High trading costs can impact performance, with a recommendation to limit costs to a third of expected profits.
- Turnover and Costs: Discusses how turnover affects costs, recommending a speed limit on trading to avoid excessive costs.
Review Summary
Readers praise Systematic Trading for its comprehensive approach to building trading systems, emphasizing risk management, position sizing, and avoiding common pitfalls like overfitting and overtrading. The book is lauded for its fusion of statistical tools and skepticism, practical advice, and clear explanations. Some readers find it particularly valuable for those interested in trend-following and automated trading. However, a few critics argue that the content may be too basic for financially literate readers or question the effectiveness of the proposed methods. Overall, the book receives positive reviews for its unique and detailed approach to systematic trading.
Similar Books









Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub
digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.