Key Takeaways
1. Innovation Stacks: The Key to Entrepreneurial Success
An Innovation Stack is not something you bring home from some management retreat along with the embroidered fleece jacket. An Innovation Stack is not a plan, it is a series of reactions to existential threats.
Definition and importance. An Innovation Stack is a collection of interlocking and independent innovations that evolve in response to challenges faced by entrepreneurs. It's not a predetermined strategy, but rather a dynamic process of problem-solving that occurs when venturing into uncharted territory.
Key characteristics:
- Develops organically as entrepreneurs tackle new problems
- Consists of multiple interconnected innovations
- Difficult for competitors to replicate entirely
- Provides a strong competitive advantage
Examples:
- Square's Innovation Stack: free sign-up, cheap hardware, no contracts, beautiful software, fast settlement, low price
- Southwest Airlines: standardized fleet, open seating, direct routes, no frills service
- IKEA: self-assembly furniture, warehouse showrooms, global supply chain
2. Solving Perfect Problems: The Catalyst for Innovation
A perfect problem has a solution, but not a solution that exists yet.
Identifying perfect problems. Perfect problems are unsolved challenges that an entrepreneur is uniquely positioned to address. They often arise from personal experiences or observations of inefficiencies in existing systems.
Characteristics of perfect problems:
- No current solution exists
- The problem-solver has a personal connection or motivation
- Solving it could potentially create significant value
- It may be overlooked or dismissed by established players
Examples:
- Square: enabling small merchants to accept credit card payments
- Bank of Italy (later Bank of America): providing banking services to immigrants and working-class people
- IKEA: making stylish furniture affordable for the masses
3. The Power of Audacity: Leaving the Walled City
If you stay within this metaphorical wall, you are a sane businessperson. If you leave the world of the known, you are either an entrepreneur or a corpse.
Embracing the unknown. Audacity is the courage to venture beyond established norms and practices. It's the willingness to tackle problems that others deem impossible or not worth solving.
Key aspects of audacity:
- Willingness to challenge conventional wisdom
- Courage to pursue unconventional solutions
- Ability to persist in the face of skepticism and obstacles
Metaphor of the walled city:
- Inside: safety, predictability, established practices
- Outside: uncertainty, risk, but also opportunity for innovation
- Leaving the city: choosing to become an entrepreneur
4. Learning from Historical Entrepreneurs: Giannini, Kamprad, and Kelleher
There is no way to prove that a problem is unsolvable.
Case studies in innovation. The author examines three historical entrepreneurs who created successful Innovation Stacks:
-
A.P. Giannini (Bank of Italy/Bank of America):
- Focus on serving immigrants and working-class people
- Multilingual tellers, expanded hours, home mortgages
-
Ingvar Kamprad (IKEA):
- Self-assembly furniture, warehouse showrooms
- Global supply chain, low prices
-
Herb Kelleher (Southwest Airlines):
- Standardized fleet, open seating, direct routes
- No-frills service, low prices
Common themes:
- Identified underserved markets
- Challenged industry norms
- Built comprehensive Innovation Stacks
- Focused on customer needs rather than competitor actions
5. Copying vs. Creating: The Entrepreneurial Dilemma
Copy when you can; invent when you must.
Balancing imitation and innovation. While copying successful practices is often the safest and most efficient approach in business, true entrepreneurship requires the ability to create new solutions when existing ones are inadequate.
When to copy:
- Entering established markets
- Implementing proven best practices
- Addressing well-understood problems
When to create:
- Solving perfect problems
- Expanding into new markets
- Challenging fundamental industry assumptions
The innovation process:
- Identify a problem
- Research existing solutions
- Attempt to copy or adapt if possible
- Innovate when necessary
- Repeat as new challenges arise
6. Timing and Market Expansion: When to Innovate
If the timing feels right, you are probably too late.
Understanding market readiness. Successful innovation often depends on timing – launching too early or too late can lead to failure. Entrepreneurs must balance being ahead of the curve with ensuring the market is ready for their solution.
Factors influencing timing:
- Technological readiness
- Regulatory environment
- Customer awareness and demand
- Availability of key resources or infrastructure
Strategies for timing:
- Monitor the "Horizon of Possibility" for enabling technologies
- Be prepared to act quickly when conditions align
- Focus on expanding markets rather than disrupting existing ones
- Build flexibility into your Innovation Stack to adapt to changing conditions
7. Low Price Strategy: Building Trust and Competitive Advantage
Low price forges a stronger relationship with customers by building trust in the brand.
The power of low pricing. Consistently offering low prices, rather than the lowest prices, can create significant advantages for entrepreneurial companies.
Benefits of a low price strategy:
- Builds customer trust and loyalty
- Creates a barrier to entry for competitors
- Aligns the company's interests with those of customers
- Encourages focus on efficiency and innovation
Implementation guidelines:
- Set prices based on value to customers, not just cost
- Maintain consistency rather than frequent price changes
- Reflect efficiency gains in lower prices when possible
- Use low prices as a tool for market expansion, not just competition
8. Overcoming Fear and Embracing Humility in Entrepreneurship
If you are about to do something that has never been done, there is no way to rehearse the act itself. But you're probably going to be nervous when you do it, so at least practice that part.
Managing emotions in innovation. Fear and uncertainty are natural parts of the entrepreneurial journey. Successful entrepreneurs learn to work through these emotions rather than being paralyzed by them.
Strategies for managing fear:
- Acknowledge and accept fear as part of the process
- Practice operating under stress in low-stakes situations
- Focus on solving the problem rather than personal doubts
- Use fear as a motivator for thorough preparation
The role of humility:
- Allows for open-mindedness and continuous learning
- Helps in connecting with customers and team members
- Enables recognition of personal limitations and the need for help
9. The Myth of Expertise in Innovation
Qualification comes only from successful experience, and successful experience by definition cannot exist in the case of an unsolved problem.
Redefining qualifications for innovation. True innovation often comes from outsiders who are not constrained by industry norms or preconceptions. Expertise can sometimes hinder creative problem-solving.
Challenging traditional notions of expertise:
- Formal qualifications may be less relevant for solving new problems
- Fresh perspectives can lead to breakthrough solutions
- Lack of industry experience can be an advantage in questioning assumptions
Key qualities for innovators:
- Curiosity and willingness to learn
- Persistence in the face of challenges
- Ability to think creatively and connect disparate ideas
- Courage to challenge established norms
10. Disruption vs. Market Expansion: A New Perspective
Entrepreneurs distribute that future. The companies they build are not disrupters, they are market expanders for those people waiting for their slice of the future.
Rethinking the goal of innovation. Rather than focusing on disrupting existing markets, successful entrepreneurs often expand markets by serving previously underserved or unserved customers.
Advantages of market expansion:
- Creates new value rather than just redistributing existing value
- Reduces resistance from established players
- Aligns with solving perfect problems
- Often leads to more sustainable growth
Examples of market expansion:
- Southwest Airlines: made air travel accessible to new segments of travelers
- IKEA: expanded the market for stylish, affordable furniture
- Square: enabled small merchants to accept credit card payments
Shift in mindset:
- From "How can we beat the competition?" to "How can we serve more customers?"
- Focus on creating new possibilities rather than just improving existing solutions
Last updated:
FAQ
1. What is "The Innovation Stack" by Jim McKelvey about?
- Entrepreneurship and Innovation: The book explores the concept of true entrepreneurship, focusing on how world-changing companies are built by solving problems that have never been solved before.
- The Innovation Stack Concept: McKelvey introduces the idea of an "Innovation Stack," a series of interlocking inventions and solutions that together create an unbeatable business.
- Case Studies and History: The book uses the story of Square (co-founded by McKelvey and Jack Dorsey) as a primary example, but also examines historical cases like Bank of Italy (now Bank of America), IKEA, and Southwest Airlines.
- Surviving Competition: It details how these companies survived and thrived against massive competitors, including how Square beat Amazon at its own game.
2. Why should I read "The Innovation Stack" by Jim McKelvey?
- Unique Perspective on Entrepreneurship: The book challenges the conventional wisdom that entrepreneurship is about following checklists or copying others, instead emphasizing audacity and creativity.
- Practical Lessons: Readers gain insight into how to approach unsolved problems and why copying existing solutions is not always the answer.
- Inspiration for Innovators: It provides motivation for anyone who wants to make a significant impact, showing that you don’t need to be an expert to start something new.
- Real-World Examples: The stories of Square, IKEA, Bank of Italy, and Southwest Airlines offer concrete, relatable examples of the Innovation Stack in action.
3. What is the main concept of the "Innovation Stack" in Jim McKelvey's book?
- Definition: An Innovation Stack is a series of interdependent, original solutions that a company develops when facing problems that cannot be solved by copying others.
- Evolutionary Process: The stack evolves as each new solution creates new problems, requiring further innovation, until a unique, defensible business model emerges.
- Survival Mechanism: Companies build Innovation Stacks out of necessity, not by choice, often when entering uncharted markets or serving previously excluded customers.
- Competitive Advantage: The complexity and interdependence of the stack make it nearly impossible for competitors to copy, providing long-term protection.
4. How does Jim McKelvey define a "perfect problem" in "The Innovation Stack"?
- Unsolved but Solvable: A perfect problem is one that has not yet been solved, but is within the realm of possibility for you to solve.
- Personal Relevance: The magic ingredient is you—if you have the ability and motivation to solve it, it’s perfect for you.
- Catalyst for Innovation: Tackling a perfect problem forces creativity and leads to the development of an Innovation Stack.
- Not Always Obvious: You often only recognize a problem as perfect after you’ve solved it and others begin to copy your solution.
5. What are the key takeaways from "The Innovation Stack" by Jim McKelvey?
- Entrepreneurship is Rare: True entrepreneurship involves doing something genuinely new, not just starting a business.
- Copying vs. Creating: Most businesses succeed by copying, but transformative companies invent when they must.
- Innovation is Iterative: Solving one problem leads to new problems, requiring a chain of innovations.
- Survival Over Disruption: The most successful companies focus on survival and serving new markets, not on disrupting existing ones.
- Anyone Can Innovate: You don’t need to be an expert; audacity, humility, and perseverance are more important.
6. How did Square use the Innovation Stack to beat Amazon, according to Jim McKelvey?
- Multiple Interlocking Innovations: Square’s success was not due to a single invention, but a stack of innovations—simple pricing, free sign-up, cheap hardware, no contracts, beautiful design, and more.
- Difficult to Copy: Amazon could copy individual features, but not the entire interconnected system, making it nearly impossible to compete effectively.
- Customer Focus: Square focused on serving previously excluded small merchants, building trust and loyalty.
- Doing Nothing: When attacked by Amazon, Square chose not to react or change its core approach, relying on the strength of its Innovation Stack.
7. What are some historical examples of the Innovation Stack outside of Square, as discussed in "The Innovation Stack"?
- Bank of Italy (Bank of America): A.P. Giannini built a bank for the “little fellow,” introducing innovations like low minimums, branch banking, and simplified underwriting.
- IKEA: Ingvar Kamprad, after being excluded from trade fairs, developed catalog showrooms, overseas manufacturing, self-assembly, and a global supply chain.
- Southwest Airlines: Herb Kelleher’s team created a low-cost airline with fast turnarounds, standardized fleets, open seating, and a unique company culture.
- Common Pattern: In each case, the companies were forced to innovate due to exclusion or attack, resulting in a stack of interdependent solutions.
8. How does "The Innovation Stack" by Jim McKelvey differentiate between entrepreneurs and businesspeople?
- Entrepreneurs as Outlaws: Entrepreneurs leave the “walled city” of known solutions and venture into the unknown, risking failure to create something new.
- Businesspeople as Copiers: Businesspeople operate within established markets, succeeding by copying proven formulas and making incremental improvements.
- Rarity of Entrepreneurs: True entrepreneurs are rare, as most people and companies prefer the safety of copying.
- Mindset Difference: Entrepreneurs are driven by audacity and a willingness to solve perfect problems, while businesspeople focus on efficiency and optimization.
9. What advice does Jim McKelvey give for building an Innovation Stack in your own business?
- Start with a Perfect Problem: Choose a problem that hasn’t been solved and that you care deeply about.
- Invent When You Must: Copy existing solutions when possible, but be ready to invent when copying won’t work.
- Iterate Rapidly: Expect that each solution will create new problems, requiring further innovation.
- Embrace Discomfort: Be prepared for fear, uncertainty, and lack of feedback—these are signs you’re doing something new.
- Focus on Customers: Build for the needs of new or excluded customers, not for disrupting competitors.
10. How does pricing strategy fit into the Innovation Stack, according to "The Innovation Stack" by Jim McKelvey?
- Low, Not Lowest: The goal is to offer a consistently low price that reflects the efficiencies of your Innovation Stack, not to undercut competitors at all costs.
- Builds Trust: A low, transparent price fosters customer trust and loyalty, which is more valuable than short-term profit maximization.
- Competitive Barrier: Keeping prices low leaves little room for competitors to enter the market, as they would need to replicate your entire stack to match your price.
- Corporate Alignment: Low pricing signals to employees and customers that the company values long-term relationships over short-term gains.
11. What are the most important qualities or mindsets for entrepreneurs, according to Jim McKelvey in "The Innovation Stack"?
- Audacity and Humility: The courage to try something new, combined with the humility to admit you don’t have all the answers.
- Perseverance/Stubbornness: The willingness to keep going despite setbacks, fear, and lack of external validation.
- Comfort with Discomfort: Accepting fear and uncertainty as natural parts of the entrepreneurial journey.
- Focus on the Problem: Deep care for the problem you’re solving is the best motivator and source of energy.
12. What are the best quotes from "The Innovation Stack" by Jim McKelvey and what do they mean?
- “You don’t plan to innovate, you don’t want to innovate, you don’t aspire to innovate, you have to innovate.” – Innovation is a necessity when facing unsolved problems, not a goal in itself.
- “Copy when you can; invent when you must.” – Use existing solutions when possible, but don’t be afraid to create new ones when needed.
- “Humility and audacity are allies.” – Being open to not knowing, while still having the courage to act, is key to entrepreneurship.
- “If the innovation feels right, it probably feels right to a hundred other people with the same idea. If it feels too early, in my experience, that’s a good time to leave the walled city.” – Acting before something feels comfortable is often necessary for true innovation.
- “Qualification matters only in the world of copying, not in the world of entrepreneurship.” – You don’t need to be an expert to start; expertise is built through the process of solving new problems.
Review Summary
The Innovation Stack receives mostly positive reviews for its insights on entrepreneurship and innovation. Readers appreciate McKelvey's humility, storytelling, and practical advice. The book explains how companies build unique "innovation stacks" to solve problems and compete. Many found the Square story and case studies of other innovative companies interesting. Some criticize the book for being repetitive or lacking depth. Overall, reviewers recommend it as an inspiring and informative read for entrepreneurs and business leaders, though a few felt it could have been more concise.
Similar Books
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
