Key Takeaways
1. The United States Waged a Global Anticommunist Crusade
"Up to a million Indonesians, maybe more, were killed as part of Washington's global anticommunist crusade."
Global Intervention Strategy. The United States systematically targeted countries perceived as potentially communist, using a combination of covert operations, military intervention, and economic pressure. This was not simply a conflict between the US and Soviet Union, but a deliberate effort to reshape the global economic and political landscape.
Widespread Scope of Interventions:
- Overthrew governments in Iran, Guatemala, Brazil, Indonesia
- Supported military dictatorships across Latin America and Southeast Asia
- Utilized CIA operations to destabilize left-leaning governments
- Employed economic warfare and propaganda techniques
Ideological Motivation. The crusade was driven by a fundamental belief that any movement challenging American economic interests could be labeled communist and therefore eliminated. This approach went far beyond traditional geopolitical concerns, representing a comprehensive effort to prevent alternative developmental models.
2. Mass Murder Was a Deliberate Geopolitical Strategy
"The US government expended significant resources over years engineering the conditions for a violent clash, and then, when the violence broke out, assisted and guided its longtime partners to carry out the mass murder of civilians as a means of achieving US geopolitical goals."
Systematic Extermination. The anticommunist campaigns were not random violence but carefully orchestrated elimination of political opposition. The United States actively supported and often directly enabled mass killings in multiple countries.
Key Characteristics of Mass Murder Programs:
- Targeted unarmed civilians
- Used local military and paramilitary groups
- Provided intelligence, weapons, and diplomatic cover
- Eliminated entire political movements
- Created long-lasting societal trauma
Calculated Elimination. These operations were not simply about preventing communist expansion, but about destroying alternative political and economic imaginaries that could challenge US global economic dominance.
3. The Third World Movement Was Systematically Destroyed
"The Third World movement fell apart partly because of its own internal failures. But it was also crushed."
Crushing Revolutionary Potential. The anticommunist campaigns specifically targeted the most innovative and promising movements for independent development in the Global South. Leaders like Sukarno, Lumumba, and Allende represented alternative visions of national and global organization.
Destruction Mechanisms:
- Assassinating key leaders
- Supporting military coups
- Economic destabilization
- Propaganda campaigns
- Mass murder of political activists
Lost Possibilities. By eliminating these movements, the United States prevented potentially transformative approaches to economic development, social organization, and international cooperation that could have fundamentally reshaped global power structures.
4. Fanatical Anticommunism Shaped Modern Global Capitalism
"Almost all of us now live in the global economic system that Indonesia and Brazil entered in the mid-1960s, a worldwide capitalist order with the United States as its leading military power and center of cultural production."
Economic Restructuring. The anticommunist campaigns fundamentally reshaped global economic systems, creating a model of crony capitalism that persists today in many developing countries.
Characteristics of Imposed Economic Systems:
- Concentrated wealth in small elite groups
- Prioritized foreign investment
- Suppressed labor movements
- Limited democratic participation
- Maintained global economic hierarchies
Long-Term Consequences. The economic models installed through violent anticommunist interventions continue to define economic relationships between developed and developing nations.
5. Survivors Were Silenced and Traumatized
"Around 15 percent of the prisoners taken were women. They were subjected to especially cruel, gendered violence."
Systematic Suppression. Survivors of anticommunist violence were not only physically eliminated but also systematically silenced, with ongoing social and psychological trauma.
Ongoing Marginalization:
- Social stigmatization
- Economic exclusion
- Psychological trauma
- Denial of historical narrative
- Lack of reconciliation processes
Generational Impact. The violence created long-lasting societal wounds that continue to affect descendants of victims, preventing genuine healing and understanding.
6. Cold War Violence Continues to Haunt Developing Nations
"Fanatical anticommunism has never really left us, even in the First World."
Persistent Ideological Legacy. The anticommunist mentality continues to shape political discourse and action in many countries, particularly in the developing world.
Contemporary Manifestations:
- Ongoing political repression
- Persistent economic inequalities
- Continued stigmatization of left-wing movements
- Recurring political violence
- Unresolved historical traumas
Psychological Inheritance. The fear and paranoia generated during the Cold War continue to influence political behavior and institutional structures.
7. The Global Economic System Remains Fundamentally Unequal
"The gap between the First World and Third World is enormous. The US economy is not just a little bigger than Indonesia's. It is twenty times larger."
Persistent Global Hierarchy. Despite claims of progress, the fundamental economic inequalities established during the Cold War remain largely unchanged.
Inequality Indicators:
- Massive GDP disparities
- Continued economic dependency
- Limited social mobility
- Restricted developmental opportunities
- Maintained colonial-era economic structures
Systemic Limitations. The anticommunist interventions effectively locked many developing countries into subordinate economic positions.
8. Propaganda and Psychological Warfare Were Crucial Weapons
"The Western press repeated the narrative being peddled by the new Indonesian government, which Washington was enthusiastically welcoming onto the world stage."
Information Manipulation. Controlling narratives was as important as military intervention in maintaining global economic dominance.
Propaganda Techniques:
- Media manipulation
- Disinformation campaigns
- Cultural indoctrination
- Psychological terror
- Strategic narrative construction
Ideological Warfare. The battle was not just about physical control but about shaping understanding and perception of political possibilities.
9. Local Militaries Became Instruments of US Foreign Policy
"The Kennedy administration provided increasing levels of assistance to the Indonesian military, which was meant to serve as a counterweight to support that Sukarno was now receiving from the Soviets."
Military Transformation. Local military institutions were systematically reshaped to serve US geopolitical interests.
Militarization Strategies:
- Training programs
- Equipment provision
- Ideological indoctrination
- Creating "states within states"
- Developing counterinsurgency capabilities
Political Manipulation. Military institutions became primary instruments for maintaining US-aligned political systems.
10. The Victims Were Overwhelmingly Innocent Civilians
"Almost everyone killed and imprisoned was entirely innocent of any crime."
Indiscriminate Violence. The anticommunist campaigns targeted entire communities, killing people based on political association, ethnicity, or mere suspicion.
Victim Characteristics:
- Unarmed civilians
- Political activists
- Union members
- Ethnic minorities
- Intellectuals and artists
Humanitarian Catastrophe. The scale of violence went far beyond legitimate political conflict, representing a systematic effort to eliminate entire social and political movements.
Last updated:
FAQ
What's The Jakarta Method about?
- Focus on Anticommunism: The book examines the U.S. government's anticommunist efforts during the Cold War, focusing on Indonesia and Brazil as key battlegrounds.
- Historical Context: It provides a detailed narrative of the 1965 Indonesian coup and the mass killings that followed, linking these events to broader U.S. interventionism.
- Global Impact: The book argues that these events significantly influenced global politics, shaping U.S. foreign policy and Cold War dynamics.
Why should I read The Jakarta Method?
- Revealing Hidden Histories: Vincent Bevins uncovers lesser-known events that have profoundly impacted modern geopolitics, especially in Southeast Asia and Latin America.
- Critical Analysis: The book offers a critical examination of U.S. foreign policy, challenging the notion of American exceptionalism by highlighting its darker aspects.
- Engaging Narrative: Bevins combines personal stories, interviews, and research to create a compelling and accessible narrative.
What are the key takeaways of The Jakarta Method?
- Systematic Violence: The U.S. supported systematic violence against leftist movements, leading to mass deaths under the guise of fighting communism.
- Global Extermination Network: The events in Indonesia and Brazil contributed to a global network of extermination, with anticommunist regimes collaborating to eliminate threats.
- Power Dynamics: The book emphasizes understanding power dynamics between nations and serves as a cautionary tale about foreign intervention consequences.
What are the best quotes from The Jakarta Method and what do they mean?
- “The violence was effective...”: This quote highlights the calculated nature of the violence as a strategy to achieve political goals.
- “We are gathered here today...”: Sukarno’s speech emphasizes the collective struggle against imperialism and the importance of unity among newly independent nations.
- “Go to hell with your aid!”: Sukarno’s defiance symbolizes the resistance of Global South leaders against neocolonial pressures.
How does The Jakarta Method connect Indonesia and Brazil?
- Shared Strategies: Both countries experienced U.S.-backed coups leading to brutal military regimes, with similar methods used to suppress leftist movements.
- Mass Violence: The systematic extermination of communists in both nations illustrates the global nature of U.S. anticommunist efforts.
- Geopolitical Impact: The outcomes in both countries significantly influenced U.S. foreign policy and Cold War dynamics.
What is the Jakarta Axiom mentioned in The Jakarta Method?
- Definition: The Jakarta Axiom refers to the U.S. policy of tolerating neutral Third World nations as long as they kept communism in check.
- Policy Shift: After the 1958 civil war, the U.S. adopted a more aggressive stance against perceived threats, including Sukarno.
- Consequences: This policy shift contributed to the violent suppression of leftist movements in Indonesia.
How does The Jakarta Method address the role of the CIA?
- Covert Operations: The book details the CIA’s involvement in orchestrating coups and supporting anticommunist regimes in Indonesia and Brazil.
- Support for Extermination: The CIA provided lists of suspected communists, facilitating mass killings and raising ethical questions.
- Long-term Implications: These actions contributed to a legacy of distrust and resentment in the Global South.
What was the September 30th Movement in Indonesia?
- Overview: A failed coup attempt in Indonesia aimed at arresting military officials believed to be plotting against Sukarno.
- Consequences: The movement led to a violent military backlash, resulting in mass murders of communists and leftists.
- Significance: It set the stage for General Suharto's rise and the establishment of a military dictatorship.
How does The Jakarta Method depict the impact of the Cold War on Indonesia?
- Cold War Dynamics: The book shows how the Cold War shaped U.S. foreign policy in Indonesia, leading to interventionist strategies.
- Domestic Influence: The climate of fear justified extreme measures, including mass violence against suspected communists.
- Legacy: The violence left deep scars on Indonesian society, affecting its political landscape today.
What role did Sukarno play in the events described in The Jakarta Method?
- Leadership: Sukarno was Indonesia's first president and a key figure in its independence struggle.
- Balancing Act: He attempted to balance various political factions, crucial in the lead-up to the September 30th Movement.
- Legacy: His downfall came with the military's rise, leaving a complex legacy as both a founding father and an authoritarian.
How does The Jakarta Method explore the theme of imperialism?
- Neocolonialism: The book discusses U.S. neocolonial practices, exerting control over countries like Indonesia and Brazil.
- Local Impact: It highlights the devastating effects of imperialism, including mass violence and repression.
- Resistance: Despite overwhelming power, local movements and leaders fought for independence and justice.
How did the U.S. support the Indonesian military during the 1965 coup?
- Kill Lists: U.S. officials provided lists of suspected communists, facilitating targeted killings.
- Military Aid: The U.S. provided training and resources, enabling the military to carry out the coup.
- Propaganda: The U.S. spread propaganda demonizing leftists, justifying the military's actions.
Review Summary
The Jakarta Method receives high praise for exposing the US government's role in supporting mass killings of suspected communists during the Cold War, particularly in Indonesia. Readers find the book informative, infuriating, and eye-opening, as it challenges conventional Cold War narratives. Many appreciate Bevins' thorough research and human-centered approach, though some find the writing occasionally disjointed. The book is widely recommended for its exploration of forgotten history and its relevance to understanding modern geopolitics. Some readers express shock at learning about these events for the first time.
Similar Books
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub
digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.