This Changes Everything

1. Climate change demands a fundamental shift in our economic system

"Climate change challenges not only capitalism, but also the building blocks of materialism that preceded modern capitalism, a mentality some call 'extractivism.'"

Systemic change required. The climate crisis exposes the fundamental flaws in our current economic model, which prioritizes endless growth and profit over environmental sustainability. This system, rooted in the belief that nature is an inexhaustible resource to be exploited, has led to unprecedented levels of greenhouse gas emissions and environmental degradation.

Rethinking prosperity. Addressing climate change requires us to reimagine our notion of progress and well-being. This involves:

• Shifting from GDP growth to more holistic measures of societal health
• Prioritizing renewable energy and circular economy principles
• Valuing ecosystem services and natural capital
• Implementing policies that promote long-term sustainability over short-term gains

Overcoming resistance. Powerful interests, particularly in the fossil fuel industry, resist these necessary changes. However, the mounting evidence of climate impacts and the growing public awareness create opportunities for transformative action.

2. The fossil fuel industry actively undermines climate action

"The fossil fuel companies have known for decades that their core product was warming the planet, and yet they have not only failed to adapt to that reality, they have actively blocked progress at every turn."

Deliberate obstruction. Despite early awareness of climate change, fossil fuel companies have:

• Funded climate denial campaigns
• Lobbied against environmental regulations
• Misled the public about the severity of the climate crisis
• Continued to expand fossil fuel extraction and infrastructure

Financial influence. The industry's vast financial resources allow it to:

• Dominate political discourse through campaign contributions
• Fund think tanks and research institutions that promote climate skepticism
• Influence media coverage and public opinion
• Delay or water down climate policies

Greenwashing tactics. Many companies engage in superficial environmental initiatives while continuing business as usual, creating a false impression of progress and distracting from the need for systemic change.

3. Big Green groups often compromise with polluters, hindering progress

"Large parts of the movement aren't actually fighting those interests—they have merged with them."

Co-opted environmentalism. Many prominent environmental organizations have:

• Accepted funding from fossil fuel companies and other polluters
• Promoted market-based solutions that benefit corporate interests
• Endorsed "green" initiatives that amount to greenwashing
• Avoided confrontational tactics in favor of "collaboration" with industry

Watered-down policies. This compromised approach has led to:

• Weak emission reduction targets
• Over-reliance on voluntary corporate commitments
• Promotion of false solutions like carbon offsets
• Neglect of more radical, systemic changes needed to address the crisis

Grassroots alternatives. In contrast, smaller, more radical environmental groups and Indigenous-led movements often take stronger stances against polluters and advocate for more transformative solutions.

4. Extractivism mentality fuels environmental destruction

"Extractivism is a nonreciprocal, dominance-based relationship with the earth, one purely of taking. It is the opposite of stewardship, which involves taking but also taking care that regeneration and future life continue."

Cultural roots. The extractivist mindset has deep historical and cultural origins:

• Colonial legacy of resource exploitation
• Enlightenment ideas of nature as a machine to be controlled
• Capitalist emphasis on maximizing short-term profits

Broader impacts. Extractivism affects more than just natural resources:

• Exploits human labor and communities
• Disregards long-term consequences and sustainability
• Perpetuates global inequalities and injustices

Shifting paradigms. Overcoming extractivism requires:

• Recognizing the interconnectedness of all life
• Adopting Indigenous and traditional knowledge systems
• Prioritizing regenerative practices in agriculture, energy, and industry
• Redefining progress to include ecological and social well-being

5. Market-based solutions have failed to address climate crisis

"The carbon market has attracted a truly impressive array of grifters and hustlers who scour biologically rich but economically poor nations like Papua New Guinea, Ecuador, and Congo, often preying on the isolation of Indigenous people whose forests can be classified as offsets."

False promises. Market mechanisms like carbon trading and offsets have:

• Failed to significantly reduce emissions
• Created opportunities for fraud and exploitation
• Allowed polluters to continue business as usual
• Diverted attention from more effective regulatory approaches

Perverse incentives. These systems often:

• Reward financial speculation rather than genuine emissions reductions
• Disadvantage poorer countries and communities
• Commodify nature in ways that ignore its intrinsic value
• Perpetuate the myth that economic growth can be decoupled from environmental impact

Alternative approaches. More effective solutions include:

• Direct regulation of emissions
• Public investment in renewable energy and green infrastructure
• Just transition policies for affected workers and communities
• International climate finance that prioritizes equity and local control

6. Billionaire saviors and technological fixes are not the answer

"We've tried it Branson's way. (And Buffett's, Bloomberg's, Gates's, and Pickens's way.) The soaring emissions speak for themselves."

Misplaced faith. Relying on billionaire philanthropists and high-tech solutions to solve the climate crisis is problematic because:

• It reinforces the same power structures that created the problem
• It often prioritizes profit-driven approaches over public interest
• It can lead to neglect of proven, low-tech solutions
• It diverts attention from the need for collective action and policy change

Technological limitations. Many proposed technological fixes, such as geoengineering, carry significant risks:

• Unpredictable environmental consequences
• Potential for unilateral action by powerful actors
• Moral hazard of reducing pressure for emissions reductions
• Exacerbation of global inequalities

Democratic alternatives. Instead of relying on billionaires and tech fixes, we should focus on:

• Strengthening democratic decision-making around climate solutions
• Empowering communities to implement local, context-appropriate measures
• Investing in public research and development of sustainable technologies
• Addressing the root causes of climate change through systemic changes

7. Indigenous and local communities offer sustainable alternatives

"These movements have truly heard the message of climate change and are winning battles to keep significant amounts of carbon in the ground."

Traditional wisdom. Indigenous peoples and local communities often possess:

• Generations of knowledge about sustainable resource management
• Holistic worldviews that recognize the interconnectedness of humans and nature
• Practices that prioritize long-term ecological health over short-term gain

Frontline resistance. These communities are:

• Leading protests against fossil fuel extraction and infrastructure projects
• Defending forests and biodiversity hotspots
• Implementing innovative sustainable development models
• Advocating for rights-based approaches to climate action

Scaling up solutions. To address the climate crisis, we must:

• Recognize and protect Indigenous land rights
• Incorporate traditional ecological knowledge into climate policies
• Support community-led conservation and restoration efforts
• Learn from and replicate successful local initiatives

8. Urgent collective action and policy changes are needed

"We are on a very tight deadline. We need to make dramatic changes in our energy and economic systems in less than a decade."

Time is running out. The latest climate science indicates that:

• We have a rapidly closing window to avoid catastrophic warming
• Incremental changes are no longer sufficient
• Bold, transformative action is required across all sectors of society

Policy priorities. Key areas for immediate action include:

• Rapid phase-out of fossil fuels and transition to renewable energy
• Massive investment in green infrastructure and public transportation
• Reforming agricultural practices to reduce emissions and enhance resilience
• Implementing strong regulations and pricing mechanisms for carbon pollution

Building a movement. Achieving these changes requires:

• Broad-based coalitions that unite environmental, labor, and social justice groups
• Mass mobilization and sustained civil disobedience
• Countering the influence of fossil fuel interests in politics
• Educating and empowering the public to demand climate action

9. Climate crisis intertwines with social and economic justice

"Climate change can be a catalyst for a new kind of politics, one based on the real-time protection of life on earth."

Intersectionality of issues. The climate crisis is deeply connected to:

• Economic inequality and poverty
• Racial and gender discrimination
• Indigenous rights and land dispossession
• Labor exploitation and workers' rights

Just transition. Addressing climate change offers opportunities to:

• Create millions of green jobs
• Revitalize communities affected by deindustrialization
• Reduce pollution in vulnerable neighborhoods
• Strengthen democratic control over energy and resources

Global equity. Climate solutions must prioritize:

• Historical responsibility of developed countries
• Support for adaptation and mitigation in vulnerable nations
• Technology transfer and capacity building
• Fair distribution of the costs and benefits of climate action

Transformative vision. The climate crisis calls us to:

• Reimagine our economic and social systems
• Build solidarity across borders and communities
• Create a more just, sustainable, and resilient world for all

Last updated: December 12, 2024