Key Takeaways
1. The importance of awareness: Recognizing the "water" we swim in
The most obvious, ubiquitous, important realities are often the ones that are hardest to see and talk about.
Invisible realities. Our surroundings and societal norms often go unnoticed, much like water to fish. These ubiquitous elements shape our experiences and perceptions without our conscious awareness. Recognizing these hidden influences is crucial for personal growth and understanding.
Critical thinking. A liberal arts education aims to develop this awareness, teaching us not just how to think, but what to think about. This skill allows us to question our assumptions, challenge societal norms, and gain a deeper understanding of the world around us.
Key aspects of awareness:
- Recognizing societal norms and expectations
- Identifying personal biases and assumptions
- Understanding the impact of cultural context on our perceptions
2. Challenging our default self-centered perspective
Everything in my own immediate experience supports my deep belief that I am the absolute center of the universe, the realest, most vivid and important person in existence.
Natural egocentrism. Humans are hardwired to perceive the world from a self-centered perspective. This default setting places our own needs, desires, and experiences at the forefront of our consciousness, often at the expense of considering others.
Conscious effort required. Overcoming this innate self-centeredness requires deliberate effort and awareness. By recognizing our tendency towards egocentrism, we can actively work to broaden our perspective and consider the experiences and viewpoints of others.
Strategies to challenge self-centeredness:
- Practice empathy and perspective-taking
- Engage in active listening
- Reflect on personal biases and assumptions
- Seek out diverse experiences and viewpoints
3. The power of choice in how we think and perceive
"Learning how to think" really means learning how to exercise some control over how and what you think.
Cognitive control. The ability to choose how we interpret and respond to our experiences is a fundamental aspect of human consciousness. This power of choice allows us to shape our perceptions, attitudes, and ultimately, our lives.
Mindful decision-making. By consciously selecting what we focus on and how we construct meaning from our experiences, we can significantly impact our mental well-being and interactions with others. This skill is particularly crucial in navigating the challenges and frustrations of everyday life.
Areas where we can exercise cognitive choice:
- Interpretation of events and experiences
- Emotional responses to situations
- Focus of attention in daily life
- Attitudes towards others and ourselves
4. Overcoming the dangers of over-intellectualization
Probably the most dangerous thing about an academic education, at least in my own case, is that it enables my tendency to over-intellectualize stuff, to get lost in abstract thinking instead of simply paying attention to what's going on in front of me.
Balancing intellect and presence. While intellectual analysis is valuable, it can sometimes hinder our ability to fully engage with the present moment. Over-reliance on abstract thinking can disconnect us from the immediate reality of our experiences and relationships.
Mindful awareness. Cultivating the ability to be present and attentive to our surroundings and internal states is crucial for personal growth and well-being. This skill complements intellectual understanding, allowing for a more holistic approach to life.
Strategies to overcome over-intellectualization:
- Practice mindfulness and meditation
- Engage in physical activities that ground you in the present
- Deliberately focus on sensory experiences
- Balance analytical thinking with emotional intelligence
5. Navigating the mundane challenges of adult life
There happen to be whole large parts of adult American life that nobody talks about in commencement speeches. One such part involves boredom, routine, and petty frustration.
Everyday struggles. Adult life is often filled with mundane tasks, frustrating routines, and seemingly trivial challenges. These aspects of daily existence can be draining and demoralizing if not approached with the right mindset.
Finding meaning in the mundane. The ability to find purpose and significance in everyday experiences is a crucial skill for maintaining mental well-being and personal growth. This involves reframing our perspective on routine tasks and choosing to see them as opportunities for mindfulness and growth.
Common mundane challenges:
- Traffic and commuting
- Grocery shopping and errands
- Workplace frustrations
- Household chores and maintenance
Strategies for navigating mundane challenges:
- Practice gratitude for small conveniences
- Use routine tasks as opportunities for mindfulness
- Find ways to inject creativity or learning into daily activities
- Cultivate a sense of purpose in seemingly trivial tasks
6. Cultivating empathy and alternative interpretations
You can choose to look differently at this fat, dead-eyed, over-made-up lady who just screamed at her kid in the checkout line – maybe she's not usually like this; maybe she's been up three straight nights holding the hand of her husband, who's dying of bone cancer.
Expanding perspective. Developing the ability to consider alternative interpretations of situations and people's behaviors can greatly enhance our empathy and understanding. This skill allows us to move beyond our initial judgments and assumptions.
Compassionate imagination. By actively imagining potential circumstances or motivations behind others' actions, we can cultivate a more compassionate and understanding approach to interpersonal interactions. This practice can reduce conflict and increase our sense of connection with others.
Benefits of cultivating empathy:
- Reduced judgment and conflict
- Improved relationships and communication
- Increased emotional intelligence
- Greater sense of social connection
Techniques for developing empathy:
- Practice perspective-taking exercises
- Engage in active listening
- Read diverse literature and personal stories
- Volunteer or engage with different communities
7. The inevitability of worship and choosing what to value
Everybody worships. The only choice we get is what to worship.
Universal reverence. The concept of worship extends beyond religious contexts to encompass the fundamental values and priorities that guide our lives. Everyone, regardless of belief system, places supreme importance on certain ideals or pursuits.
Conscious value selection. Recognizing that we inevitably worship something allows us to make conscious choices about what we truly value. This awareness empowers us to align our actions and priorities with meaningful and fulfilling pursuits, rather than defaulting to societal expectations or fleeting desires.
Common objects of worship in modern society:
- Money and material success
- Physical appearance and youth
- Intellectual prowess and academic achievements
- Social status and popularity
- Career and professional accomplishments
Criteria for choosing what to worship:
- Long-term fulfillment and meaning
- Alignment with personal values and ethics
- Contribution to personal growth and well-being
- Positive impact on others and society
8. Breaking free from unconscious default settings
The insidious thing about these forms of worship is not that they're evil or sinful; it is that they are unconscious. They are default settings.
Automatic patterns. Our minds naturally fall into default patterns of thinking and behaving, often shaped by societal norms, personal experiences, and biological predispositions. These unconscious settings can significantly influence our choices and perceptions without our awareness.
Conscious living. Breaking free from these default settings requires active effort and ongoing awareness. By regularly examining our thoughts, reactions, and values, we can make more intentional choices about how we live and what we prioritize.
Signs of operating on default settings:
- Repetitive negative thought patterns
- Automatic emotional reactions
- Unexamined beliefs and prejudices
- Habitual behaviors that don't serve our goals
Steps to break free from default settings:
- Practice regular self-reflection and introspection
- Seek out diverse perspectives and experiences
- Challenge assumptions and question societal norms
- Develop mindfulness and present-moment awareness
- Continuously reassess personal values and priorities
Last updated:
Questions & Answers
What's "This Is Water" about?
- Commencement Speech: "This Is Water" is a commencement speech delivered by David Foster Wallace at Kenyon College in 2005. It explores themes of awareness, choice, and the importance of a liberal arts education.
- Everyday Realities: The speech uses everyday scenarios to highlight how the most obvious and important realities are often the hardest to see and talk about.
- Self-Centeredness: Wallace discusses the natural human tendency towards self-centeredness and the importance of consciously choosing how to think and perceive the world.
- Meaning and Worship: The speech delves into the concept of worship and how what we choose to worship can shape our lives and happiness.
Why should I read "This Is Water"?
- Practical Wisdom: The speech offers practical wisdom on how to live a more conscious and meaningful life, making it relevant for anyone seeking personal growth.
- Insightful Perspective: Wallace provides an insightful perspective on the value of education beyond academic achievements, focusing on critical thinking and awareness.
- Relatable Examples: Through relatable examples, the speech encourages readers to reflect on their own lives and the choices they make daily.
- Universal Themes: The themes of awareness, choice, and self-centeredness are universal, making the speech applicable to a wide audience.
What are the key takeaways of "This Is Water"?
- Awareness and Choice: The importance of being aware of our default settings and consciously choosing how to think and perceive the world.
- Self-Centeredness: Recognizing and overcoming our natural self-centeredness to live a more compassionate and meaningful life.
- Value of Education: Understanding that the true value of a liberal arts education lies in learning how to think critically and choose what to focus on.
- Worship and Meaning: The idea that everyone worships something, and the choice of what to worship can significantly impact our lives.
What are the best quotes from "This Is Water" and what do they mean?
- "This is water": This phrase emphasizes the importance of recognizing the obvious realities around us that we often overlook.
- "Learning how to think": This quote highlights the essence of education as the ability to choose what to think about, rather than just acquiring knowledge.
- "Everybody worships": Wallace suggests that everyone has something they prioritize or value, and this choice can shape their life experience.
- "The freedom of real education": This quote underscores the idea that true education provides the freedom to decide what has meaning and what doesn't.
How does David Foster Wallace use parables in "This Is Water"?
- Fish Story: Wallace begins with a parable about fish to illustrate how the most obvious realities are often the hardest to see.
- Bar Story: He uses a story about two men in a bar to demonstrate how different belief systems can lead to different interpretations of the same experience.
- Purpose of Parables: These parables serve to make complex ideas more relatable and understandable for the audience.
- Engagement Tool: Parables engage the audience by presenting philosophical concepts in a narrative form that is easy to digest.
What is the significance of the title "This Is Water"?
- Metaphor for Awareness: The title serves as a metaphor for the awareness of the everyday realities that surround us but often go unnoticed.
- Central Theme: It encapsulates the central theme of the speech, which is about recognizing and understanding the obvious yet overlooked aspects of life.
- Call to Consciousness: The phrase is a call to live consciously and to question the default settings of our perceptions and thoughts.
- Repetition for Emphasis: Wallace repeats the phrase to emphasize the importance of this awareness in leading a meaningful life.
How does "This Is Water" address the concept of self-centeredness?
- Default Setting: Wallace describes self-centeredness as a natural default setting that everyone has, which places oneself at the center of the universe.
- Awareness and Choice: He argues that being aware of this tendency allows us to choose to think differently and consider others' perspectives.
- Impact on Perception: Self-centeredness affects how we perceive everyday situations, often leading to frustration and unhappiness.
- Overcoming Self-Centeredness: The speech suggests that overcoming this default setting requires conscious effort and is key to living a compassionate life.
What does David Foster Wallace mean by "teaching you how to think"?
- Beyond Knowledge: Wallace suggests that education is not just about acquiring knowledge but about learning how to think critically and make conscious choices.
- Choice of Focus: It involves choosing what to pay attention to and how to construct meaning from experiences.
- Critical Awareness: The phrase implies developing a critical awareness of one's own thoughts and certainties.
- Lifelong Process: Wallace views this as a lifelong process that begins with education but continues throughout adult life.
How does "This Is Water" explore the theme of worship?
- Inevitable Worship: Wallace argues that everyone worships something, whether it's money, power, beauty, or a higher power.
- Consequences of Worship: The choice of what to worship can have profound effects on one's happiness and fulfillment.
- Unconscious Worship: Many forms of worship are unconscious default settings that people slip into without realizing.
- Conscious Choice: The speech encourages making a conscious choice about what to worship to avoid being consumed by it.
What role does liberal arts education play in "This Is Water"?
- Critical Thinking: Wallace emphasizes that a liberal arts education teaches critical thinking and the ability to choose what to think about.
- Value Beyond Material: He argues that the value of such an education lies in its human value, not just material payoff.
- Awareness and Freedom: The education provides the freedom to decide what has meaning and to live a more conscious life.
- Lifelong Learning: Wallace suggests that the lessons of a liberal arts education are applicable throughout one's life, beyond academic settings.
How does "This Is Water" address the challenges of adult life?
- Routine and Frustration: Wallace discusses the mundane routines and petty frustrations that characterize much of adult life.
- Choice in Perception: He emphasizes the importance of choosing how to perceive these challenges to avoid misery and frustration.
- Awareness of Others: The speech encourages considering others' perspectives and experiences to foster empathy and understanding.
- Living Consciously: Wallace argues that living consciously and making intentional choices can transform the experience of adult life.
What is the "real freedom" according to "This Is Water"?
- Attention and Awareness: Real freedom involves the ability to pay attention and be aware of one's thoughts and surroundings.
- Discipline and Effort: It requires discipline and effort to care about others and make sacrifices in everyday situations.
- Beyond Default Settings: Real freedom is about breaking free from unconscious default settings and living a more intentional life.
- Meaningful Life: Wallace suggests that this kind of freedom leads to a more meaningful and fulfilling life, as opposed to being trapped in the "rat race."
Review Summary
This Is Water is a highly praised speech by David Foster Wallace, later published as a book. Readers find it profound, inspiring, and thought-provoking, praising its insights on empathy, awareness, and the importance of choosing how to think. Many consider it a must-read for its life-affirming message. The book's format, with one sentence per page, receives mixed reactions. Some reviewers also discuss Wallace's other works and his struggle with depression, adding depth to their appreciation of the speech.
Similar Books
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub
digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.