Key Takeaways
1. Our planet is an animal farm, not a factory
We have misunderstood what our planet is, and therefore misunderstood how to save it.
Reframing our perspective. The common visual representations of climate change – smokestacks and polar bears – have given us the impression that our planet is a factory, and that the animals most relevant to climate change are wild and far away. This misunderstanding has led to a counterproductive approach to addressing the crisis.
The reality of our planet:
- 60% of all mammals on Earth are animals raised for food
- There are approximately 30 farmed animals for every human
- 59% of all land capable of growing crops is used to grow food for livestock
- One-third of all fresh water humans use goes to livestock
By recognizing our planet as an animal farm rather than a factory, we can better understand the true nature of the climate crisis and the actions needed to address it.
2. Individual actions matter in addressing climate change
If we cannot address climate change, never save our home, until we acknowledge that our planet is an animal farm.
The power of personal choices. While it's easy to feel powerless in the face of climate change, individual actions can have a significant impact. The idea that only large-scale structural changes matter is a form of denial that allows us to avoid personal responsibility.
Impact of individual choices:
- Eating a plant-based diet
- Avoiding air travel
- Living car-free
- Having fewer children
These four actions have been identified as the highest-impact things an individual can do to tackle climate change. Of these, plant-based eating is the most immediately accessible and addresses the most urgent greenhouse gases: methane and nitrous oxide.
3. Animal agriculture is a leading cause of greenhouse gas emissions
According to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, if cows were a country, they would rank third in greenhouse gas emissions, after China and the United States.
The hidden culprit. Animal agriculture's contribution to climate change is often underestimated or overlooked. However, it is responsible for a significant portion of global greenhouse gas emissions, deforestation, and resource consumption.
Animal agriculture's impact:
- Responsible for 14.5% to 51% of global greenhouse gas emissions (estimates vary)
- Leading source of methane emissions
- Primary cause of deforestation, especially in the Amazon
- Major consumer of water and land resources
Addressing animal agriculture is crucial for effectively combating climate change, as it affects multiple aspects of the environment and resource use.
4. Reducing animal product consumption is crucial for climate mitigation
Not eating animal products for breakfast and lunch saves 1.3 metric tons per year.
A simple yet powerful change. Shifting towards a plant-based diet is one of the most effective ways individuals can contribute to climate change mitigation. This doesn't require a complete lifestyle overhaul, but rather a manageable adjustment to daily habits.
Benefits of reducing animal product consumption:
- Lowers personal carbon footprint
- Reduces demand for resource-intensive animal agriculture
- Encourages development of more sustainable food systems
- Improves personal health and reduces healthcare costs
By making this change, individuals can have a tangible impact on greenhouse gas emissions while also potentially improving their own health and wellbeing.
5. Climate change requires both structural and personal changes
We need structural change, yes—we need a global shift away from fossil fuels and toward renewable energy. We need to enforce something akin to a carbon tax, mandate environmental-impact labels for products, replace plastic with sustainable solutions, and build walkable cities. We need structures to nudge us toward choices we already want to make.
A comprehensive approach. Addressing climate change effectively requires action at both the systemic and individual levels. While large-scale policy changes are crucial, they must be complemented by personal choices and lifestyle adjustments.
Key areas for change:
- Energy: Shift to renewable sources
- Policy: Implement carbon taxes and environmental regulations
- Infrastructure: Develop sustainable cities and transportation systems
- Personal: Make conscious choices in diet, travel, and consumption
Recognizing the interconnectedness of these areas can help us understand that every action, from voting for climate-conscious policies to choosing plant-based meals, contributes to the overall solution.
6. Confronting our mortality can inspire environmental action
If we don't overcome our agnosticism and alter our behavior in the ways that we know are necessary, how will our descendants judge us? Will they know that they inherited a battlefield because we were unwilling to turn off our lights?
Legacy and responsibility. Contemplating our own mortality and the future we leave behind can be a powerful motivator for environmental action. By considering how future generations will judge our choices, we can gain perspective on the long-term consequences of our actions.
Reflecting on our impact:
- Consider the world we're leaving for future generations
- Acknowledge our role in shaping the planet's future
- Recognize the urgency of the climate crisis
- Use the prospect of judgment as motivation for change
This perspective can help transform abstract environmental concerns into personal, emotionally resonant motivations for action.
7. Collective action and belief are key to solving the climate crisis
We are the flood, and we are the ark.
The power of unity. Addressing climate change requires not only individual actions but also collective belief and effort. Like the story of Noah's Ark, we must work together to build a metaphorical vessel that can carry us through the environmental crisis.
Elements of collective action:
- Shared belief in the urgency of the crisis
- Coordinated efforts across communities and nations
- Support for climate-conscious policies and leaders
- Cultural shifts towards sustainable lifestyles
By recognizing our collective power and responsibility, we can overcome the feeling of individual helplessness and create meaningful change. Just as no one person built the ark, no single individual can solve climate change – but together, we have the power to shape our planet's future.
Last updated:
FAQ
What's "We Are the Weather: Saving the Planet Begins at Breakfast" about?
- Focus on Climate Change: The book explores the impact of human activities, particularly animal agriculture, on climate change and the environment.
- Personal Responsibility: It emphasizes the role of individual choices, especially dietary habits, in combating climate change.
- Historical Context: The author draws parallels between past collective actions, like those during World War II, and the current need for collective environmental action.
- Narrative Style: Jonathan Safran Foer uses a mix of personal anecdotes, historical references, and scientific data to make his case.
Why should I read "We Are the Weather"?
- Urgent Issue: The book addresses the pressing issue of climate change and offers practical solutions that individuals can implement.
- Unique Perspective: Foer combines personal narrative with scientific research, making the topic accessible and engaging.
- Actionable Advice: It provides specific actions, like dietary changes, that readers can take to make a difference.
- Thought-Provoking: The book challenges readers to reconsider their daily habits and their impact on the planet.
What are the key takeaways of "We Are the Weather"?
- Dietary Impact: Reducing consumption of animal products is crucial for mitigating climate change.
- Collective Action: Individual actions, when multiplied across society, can lead to significant environmental benefits.
- Historical Lessons: Past collective efforts, such as those during wartime, can inspire current environmental action.
- Personal Reflection: The book encourages readers to reflect on their own contributions to climate change and consider changes.
How does Jonathan Safran Foer suggest we combat climate change?
- Dietary Changes: Foer advocates for eating no animal products before dinner as a manageable way to reduce one's carbon footprint.
- Collective Effort: He emphasizes the importance of collective action, drawing parallels to historical events where society came together for a common cause.
- Awareness and Belief: The book stresses the need for awareness and belief in the science of climate change to drive action.
- Incremental Steps: Foer suggests starting with small, manageable changes that can lead to larger shifts in behavior over time.
What role does animal agriculture play in climate change according to the book?
- Significant Contributor: Animal agriculture is identified as a major contributor to greenhouse gas emissions, potentially more than the entire transportation sector.
- Deforestation and Methane: The industry is responsible for deforestation and significant methane emissions, both of which exacerbate climate change.
- Resource Intensive: Raising animals for food requires vast amounts of land, water, and feed, leading to environmental degradation.
- Need for Reduction: Foer argues that reducing animal product consumption is essential for addressing climate change effectively.
What historical parallels does Foer draw in "We Are the Weather"?
- World War II Efforts: He compares the collective efforts during WWII, such as rationing and blackouts, to the current need for collective environmental action.
- Civil Rights Movement: The book references the strategic actions of the civil rights movement as a model for how organized efforts can lead to significant change.
- Past Environmental Successes: Foer highlights past environmental successes, like the Montreal Protocol, to show that global cooperation is possible.
How does Foer address the concept of belief in climate change?
- Belief vs. Knowledge: He distinguishes between knowing about climate change and truly believing it, which is necessary for action.
- Emotional Connection: The book discusses the importance of connecting emotionally to the issue to drive meaningful change.
- Cognitive Dissonance: Foer explores the cognitive dissonance many feel between their knowledge of climate change and their daily actions.
- Cultural Shifts: He suggests that cultural shifts in belief are necessary to inspire widespread behavioral changes.
What are some of the best quotes from "We Are the Weather" and what do they mean?
- "We are the flood, and we are the ark." This quote encapsulates the dual role humans play in both causing and potentially solving the climate crisis.
- "The most hopeless conditions can inspire the most hopeful actions." It suggests that dire situations can motivate people to take significant, positive actions.
- "We will rise to meet the planetary crisis, or we won’t." This quote emphasizes the urgency and binary nature of the climate challenge.
- "Life is not always indispensable in the abstract, but it is always indispensable in the particular." It highlights the importance of individual lives and actions in the broader context of environmental issues.
How does Foer suggest individuals can make a difference?
- Dietary Shifts: He advocates for reducing animal product consumption, particularly by avoiding them before dinner.
- Incremental Changes: Foer encourages starting with small, manageable changes that can lead to larger shifts in behavior.
- Collective Impact: He emphasizes that individual actions, when multiplied across society, can lead to significant environmental benefits.
- Awareness and Advocacy: The book encourages readers to become more aware of their impact and to advocate for broader societal changes.
What is the significance of the book's title, "We Are the Weather"?
- Metaphor for Impact: The title suggests that human actions collectively create the "weather" or conditions of the planet.
- Emphasis on Agency: It highlights the power and responsibility individuals have in shaping the future of the environment.
- Call to Action: The title serves as a reminder that change begins with individual and collective actions, much like weather patterns are formed by various contributing factors.
- Interconnectedness: It underscores the interconnectedness of human actions and their impact on the global climate.
How does Foer use personal anecdotes in the book?
- Relatable Narratives: Foer shares personal stories to make the complex issue of climate change more relatable and engaging.
- Illustrating Points: His anecdotes serve to illustrate broader points about human behavior and the environment.
- Emotional Connection: By sharing his own experiences, Foer creates an emotional connection with readers, encouraging them to reflect on their own lives.
- Bridging Gaps: Personal stories help bridge the gap between abstract scientific concepts and everyday life, making the book accessible to a wider audience.
What challenges does Foer acknowledge in changing dietary habits?
- Cultural Significance: He recognizes the cultural and emotional significance of food, which can make dietary changes difficult.
- Habitual Nature: Foer acknowledges that eating habits are deeply ingrained and can be challenging to alter.
- Social Dynamics: The book discusses the social dynamics of eating and how they can complicate efforts to change one's diet.
- Incremental Approach: Despite these challenges, Foer advocates for an incremental approach, starting with small changes that can lead to larger shifts over time.
Review Summary
We Are the Weather receives mixed reviews. Some praise its urgent message on climate change and personal responsibility, particularly regarding diet. Others criticize its meandering structure, repetitiveness, and lack of focus. Many readers appreciate Foer's personal anecdotes and historical analogies, while some find them distracting. The book's central argument—that reducing animal product consumption is crucial for combating climate change—resonates with many, but some question its effectiveness. Overall, readers acknowledge the importance of the topic but are divided on the book's execution and impact.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.