Key Takeaways
1. Women's voices have been silenced throughout Western history
At which point young Telemachus intervenes: 'Mother,' he says, 'go back up into your quarters, and take up your own work, the loom and the distaff … speech will be the business of men, all men, and of me most of all; for mine is the power in this household.'
Silencing begins early. The Odyssey, one of the earliest works of Western literature, depicts a young man silencing his mother, establishing a pattern that persists to this day. This scene exemplifies how deeply ingrained the notion of women's silence is in our cultural heritage.
Perpetuation through literature. Throughout classical literature, women are repeatedly silenced or transformed in ways that remove their ability to speak. Examples include:
- Io turned into a cow, only able to moo
- Echo cursed to only repeat others' words
- Philomela's tongue cut out after being raped
Limited exceptions. Women in classical literature were allowed to speak publicly only in specific circumstances:
- As victims or martyrs, often before their death
- To defend their homes, children, or other women
- When acting as spokespersons for women's interests exclusively
2. Ancient Greek myths reinforce female exclusion from power
If you were ever doubtful about the extent to which the exclusion of women from power is culturally embedded or unsure of the continued strength of classical ways of formulating and justifying it – well, I give you Trump and Clinton, Perseus and Medusa, and rest my case.
Myths as cultural blueprints. Greek mythology provides powerful narratives that justify and reinforce the exclusion of women from power. These stories continue to shape our cultural understanding of gender roles and power dynamics.
Key mythological examples:
- Clytemnestra: Portrayed as masculine and destructive when in power
- Amazons: Depicted as a threat to civilization, needing to be conquered
- Medusa: Her decapitation symbolizes the violent reassertion of male dominance
- Athena: Though a female deity, she embodies male attributes and is born from Zeus's head
Modern echoes. These ancient myths continue to influence contemporary discourse:
- Female politicians compared to Medusa (e.g., Hillary Clinton, Angela Merkel)
- Use of classical imagery in political cartoons and merchandise
- Persistent cultural discomfort with women in positions of power
3. Cultural stereotypes perpetuate male dominance in public speaking
It is still the case that when listeners hear a female voice, they do not hear a voice that connotes authority; or rather they have not learned how to hear authority in it; they don't hear muthos.
Gendered perceptions of speech. Our culture has deeply ingrained associations between male voices and authority, making it difficult for women to be taken seriously in public speaking roles.
Manifestations of bias:
- Women's voices described as "shrill," "nagging," or "whining"
- Physical appearance scrutinized more than content of speech
- Interruptions and "mansplaining" in professional settings
- Disproportionate online abuse directed at women who speak out
Historical context. These biases have roots in classical rhetoric, where public speaking was seen as an exclusively male domain. The ideal orator was defined as "vir bonus dicendi peritus" - a good man, skilled in speaking.
4. Modern politics still echoes classical misogyny
Even I have been pedantically objecting to Lysistrata being played as if it were about girl power – though maybe that's exactly how we should now play it.
Persistent patterns. Despite progress in women's rights, many aspects of modern politics reflect ancient prejudices against women in power.
Examples of continued bias:
- Female politicians judged more harshly for mistakes (e.g., Diane Abbott vs. Boris Johnson)
- Women's issues marginalized or seen as separate from "main" political concerns
- Disproportionate focus on appearance and personal life of female leaders
- Use of classical imagery to attack women in politics (e.g., Medusa depictions)
Reinterpretation needed. To challenge these biases, we may need to actively reinterpret classical narratives, finding new meanings that empower rather than limit women.
5. Redefining power is crucial for women's inclusion
If women are not perceived to be fully within the structures of power, surely it is power that we need to redefine rather than women?
Challenging traditional notions. Our current understanding of power is deeply intertwined with masculine ideals and public prestige. To truly include women, we must reconsider what power means and how it operates.
Potential new definitions of power:
- Ability to effect change and make a difference
- Collaborative influence rather than individual dominance
- Right to be taken seriously and heard
- Power as an attribute or action, not a possession
Broader implications. Redefining power could lead to:
- More diverse leadership styles being valued
- Greater emphasis on collective action and grassroots movements
- Recognition of different forms of influence and effectiveness
6. Individual strategies can help women navigate male-dominated spaces
Margaret Thatcher seems to have done that with her handbags, so that eventually the most stereotypically female accessory became a verb of political power: as in 'to handbag'.
Tactical approaches. Some women have found success by strategically using or subverting stereotypically feminine traits or symbols.
Examples of individual strategies:
- Margaret Thatcher's handbag as a symbol of power
- Using traditionally "female" accessories to make a point (e.g., blue tights for "bluestocking")
- Theresa May's shoes as a refusal to conform to male templates
- Exploiting exclusion from "boys' clubs" to carve out independent territory
Limitations. While these individual tactics can be effective, they don't address the underlying systemic issues and may reinforce certain stereotypes.
7. Systemic change is needed to truly empower women
We have to be more reflective about what power is, what it is for, and how it is measured. To put it another way, if women are not perceived to be fully within the structures of power, surely it is power that we need to redefine rather than women?
Beyond individual success. While individual women have achieved positions of power, true equality requires fundamental changes to societal structures and cultural narratives.
Areas for systemic change:
- Challenging deep-seated cultural narratives about women and power
- Redefining leadership beyond traditionally masculine traits
- Addressing unconscious biases in hiring, promotion, and public perception
- Changing institutional structures to be more inclusive and collaborative
Long-term vision. True change will require:
- Ongoing critical examination of our cultural inheritance
- Active reinterpretation and creation of new narratives
- Collective effort to reshape societal norms and expectations
- Patience and persistence in the face of deeply ingrained biases
Last updated:
FAQ
What's "Women & Power: A Manifesto" about?
- Exploration of Women's Voices: The book examines the historical and cultural mechanisms that have silenced women in public and political spheres.
- Historical Context: Mary Beard uses examples from ancient Greek and Roman cultures to illustrate how these practices have deep roots in Western society.
- Contemporary Relevance: It connects these historical practices to modern-day issues, showing how women are still marginalized in public discourse.
- Call for Change: The book is a manifesto urging a reevaluation of power structures to include women's voices more equitably.
Why should I read "Women & Power: A Manifesto"?
- Insightful Analysis: The book provides a deep dive into the historical silencing of women, offering a perspective that is both scholarly and accessible.
- Cultural Reflection: It encourages readers to reflect on how ancient practices influence current societal norms and gender dynamics.
- Empowerment: Mary Beard's work is a call to action for both women and men to challenge and change the status quo.
- Relevance: The issues discussed are pertinent to ongoing conversations about gender equality and women's rights.
What are the key takeaways of "Women & Power: A Manifesto"?
- Historical Silencing: Women have been systematically excluded from public discourse for thousands of years, a practice rooted in ancient cultures.
- Cultural Inheritance: Modern Western societies have inherited these exclusionary practices, which continue to affect women's roles in power.
- Redefining Power: Beard argues for a redefinition of power that includes women's voices and perspectives, moving beyond traditional male-dominated structures.
- Actionable Change: The book suggests that real progress requires a fundamental shift in how society perceives authority and leadership.
How does Mary Beard use historical examples in "Women & Power: A Manifesto"?
- Greek and Roman Contexts: Beard draws on examples from ancient Greek and Roman literature and history to illustrate the long-standing silencing of women.
- Telemachus and Penelope: She discusses the story from Homer's "Odyssey" where Telemachus tells his mother Penelope to be silent, highlighting early examples of gendered speech.
- Classical Myths: Myths like those of Medusa and the Amazons are used to show how female power has been portrayed as dangerous and needing control.
- Cultural Continuity: These examples are linked to modern practices, showing how ancient ideologies persist today.
What does Mary Beard mean by "the public voice of women"?
- Exclusion from Public Discourse: The term refers to the historical and ongoing exclusion of women from public speaking and decision-making roles.
- Cultural Norms: Beard discusses how societal norms have traditionally dictated that authoritative speech is a male domain.
- Impact on Modern Society: The book explores how these norms continue to affect women's participation in politics and public life today.
- Need for Change: Beard advocates for a cultural shift that recognizes and values women's contributions to public discourse.
How does "Women & Power: A Manifesto" address modern issues of gender and power?
- Contemporary Examples: The book draws parallels between ancient practices and modern instances of gender discrimination and silencing.
- Online Harassment: Beard discusses the abuse women face online as a modern form of silencing, akin to historical practices.
- Political Representation: The book examines the underrepresentation of women in politics and the barriers they face.
- Cultural Shifts: Beard calls for a reevaluation of what constitutes power and authority, advocating for more inclusive definitions.
What are some of the best quotes from "Women & Power: A Manifesto" and what do they mean?
- "Women in the West have a lot to celebrate; let’s not forget." This quote acknowledges progress while emphasizing that much work remains.
- "When it comes to silencing women, Western culture has had thousands of years of practice." It highlights the deep-rooted nature of gender inequality.
- "We need to think more fundamentally about the rules of our rhetorical operations." Beard calls for a reevaluation of how society perceives authority and speech.
- "If women are not perceived to be fully within the structures of power, surely it is power that we need to redefine rather than women?" This challenges the reader to rethink traditional power dynamics.
How does Mary Beard propose we redefine power in "Women & Power: A Manifesto"?
- Beyond Traditional Structures: Beard suggests moving away from male-coded definitions of power that focus on individual prestige and authority.
- Collaborative Power: She advocates for a model of power that emphasizes collaboration and collective action.
- Inclusive Authority: The book calls for recognizing diverse voices and experiences as legitimate sources of authority.
- Cultural Change: Beard argues that redefining power requires a cultural shift in how society values different forms of leadership and influence.
What role do classical myths play in "Women & Power: A Manifesto"?
- Illustrative Examples: Myths like those of Medusa and the Amazons are used to show how female power has been historically portrayed as dangerous.
- Cultural Narratives: These myths serve as cultural narratives that have justified the exclusion of women from power.
- Modern Parallels: Beard draws parallels between these ancient stories and modern depictions of women in power, showing their lasting impact.
- Reclaiming Narratives: The book also discusses efforts to reclaim these myths for feminist purposes, though it notes the challenges in doing so.
How does "Women & Power: A Manifesto" address the concept of "mansplaining"?
- Cultural Phenomenon: Beard discusses "mansplaining" as a modern manifestation of historical practices that undermine women's authority.
- Impact on Women: It highlights how such behaviors contribute to the silencing and marginalization of women in public and professional settings.
- Need for Awareness: The book calls for greater awareness of these dynamics and encourages both men and women to challenge them.
- Cultural Change: Addressing "mansplaining" is part of the broader cultural shift needed to redefine power and authority inclusively.
What is the significance of the "Miss Triggs" cartoon in "Women & Power: A Manifesto"?
- Illustration of Gender Bias: The cartoon is used to illustrate how women's contributions are often overlooked or dismissed in professional settings.
- Cultural Commentary: It serves as a commentary on the persistent gender biases that exist in workplaces and other public spheres.
- Call to Action: Beard uses the cartoon to highlight the need for cultural change in how women's voices are perceived and valued.
- Broader Implications: The "Miss Triggs" scenario is emblematic of the broader issues of gender inequality that the book addresses.
How does Mary Beard suggest we address the challenges women face in public discourse?
- Cultural Awareness: Beard emphasizes the need for greater awareness of the historical and cultural factors that contribute to women's silencing.
- Redefining Authority: She advocates for redefining what constitutes authority and power to be more inclusive of women's voices.
- Challenging Norms: The book encourages challenging societal norms and practices that marginalize women in public and professional settings.
- Collective Action: Beard calls for collective efforts to create a more equitable environment where women's contributions are recognized and valued.
Review Summary
Women & Power is praised for its insightful analysis of women's historical exclusion from power, tracing misogyny to ancient Greece and Rome. Readers appreciate Beard's scholarly approach and engaging writing style. Many find the book thought-provoking and relevant, though some wish for more concrete solutions. The book's brevity is both a strength and weakness, offering a concise overview but leaving some wanting more depth. Overall, it's considered an important contribution to feminist discourse, challenging traditional notions of power and authority.
Similar Books
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.