重点摘要
1. 奥巴马的胜利并不意味着美国种族主义的终结
“尽管巴拉克·奥巴马的政治成功可能会让白人对有效的黑人领导能力持更开放的态度,但也有可能会加深许多白人公众长期以来的否认。”
象征性变化与系统性变化。 奥巴马的当选虽然具有历史意义,但并不能自动消除数百年的制度性种族主义。他的个人成功并不能否定在教育、就业、医疗和刑事司法等方面影响数百万有色人种的持续种族不平等。
自满的危险。 奥巴马的胜利可能会导致一种虚假的种族进步感,使白人美国人认为种族主义不再是一个重要问题。这种自满可能会阻碍进一步解决系统性种族差距和歧视的努力。
- 需要区分个人成就与广泛的社会变革
- 持续的种族不平等需要持续关注和行动
- 选举成功不一定转化为更广泛的社会变革
2. 种族主义2.0:一种新的开明例外主义形式的出现
“如果白人喜欢、尊重甚至投票给像巴拉克·奥巴马这样的人,但只是因为他们认为这些人以某种方式‘超越’了他们的黑人身份,那么声称这些候选人的成功证明了种族主义的终结是毫无意义的。”
种族偏见的演变。 种族主义2.0代表了一种更微妙的偏见形式,人们可能会接受甚至庆祝有色人种中的杰出人物,同时仍然对更广泛的种族群体持负面看法。这种种族主义的新表现形式允许那些被视为“不同”或“与众不同”的个人取得成功。
象征性人物的危险。 通过提升少数几个有色人种作为成功的例子,这种新的种族主义形式可以强化对更大群体的负面刻板印象。它在“超越”种族的“可接受”少数族裔和仍然被种族刻板印象看待的人之间制造了一个虚假的二分法。
- 种族主义2.0可以与对有色人种个人在权力位置上的支持共存
- 它可能会为不符合“杰出”模式的大多数非裔美国人设置更高的障碍
- 这种形式的种族主义比公开的偏见更难识别和对抗
3. 持续的种族不平等与后种族社会的主张相矛盾
“在一个平均黑人家庭的净资产不到平均白人家庭的十分之一,平均拉丁裔家庭的净资产约为八分之一的国家,很难将奥巴马的数学进步与事实相提并论。”
经济差距依然存在。 尽管声称种族进步,但白人家庭和有色人种家庭之间的巨大财富差距依然存在。这些差距不仅仅是收入问题,而是受历史政策和持续歧视影响的代际财富积累问题。
各个领域的系统性不平等。 美国社会的各个方面都存在种族差距:
- 教育:有色人种学生往往就读于资金不足的学校,并面临更严厉的纪律措施
- 就业:黑人大学毕业生的失业率高于白人高中辍学生
- 刑事司法:有色人种被不成比例地针对、逮捕和监禁
- 医疗:健康结果和获得优质护理方面的种族差距依然显著
这些持续的不平等表明,个人成功故事并不能否定需要系统性变革来解决种族不公的问题。
4. 白人的否认和忽视持续种族差距的危险
“鉴于奥巴马的广泛吸引力和他升任总统,白人可能会宣称种族主义斗争已经结束,这一点不足为奇。”
历史上的否认模式。 在美国历史上,白人美国人一贯低估或否认种族主义的存在和影响。这种否认即使在面对明显的种族歧视和不平等证据时也持续存在。
否认的后果。 忽视或最小化种族差距有严重后果:
- 允许系统性种族主义继续不受挑战
- 否定有色人种的经历和斗争
- 阻碍实现真正种族平等和正义的进程
- 延续美国功绩主义和色盲的虚假叙述
克服这种否认对于解决持续的种族问题和实现真正的平等至关重要。
5. 倾听有色人种对种族主义经历的重要性
“白人必须学会倾听(并相信)有色人种关于种族主义的说法,尤其是在他们自己的生活中。”
重视亲身经历。 要真正理解和对抗种族主义,白人美国人必须倾听并相信有色人种分享的经历。这些第一手的叙述提供了对种族主义现实的关键见解,这些见解可能对那些没有直接经历过的人来说并不明显。
克服怀疑和防御。 许多白人美国人难以接受种族主义的叙述,常常将其视为夸大或孤立事件。这种怀疑源于:
- 缺乏个人经历种族歧视
- 对承认系统性种族主义的抵触
- 对美国功绩主义和色盲的信仰
通过积极倾听和相信这些经历,白人美国人可以对种族主义的普遍性和影响有更准确的理解。
6. 面对美国历史的不舒服真相
“在消除种族主义的对话和行动的主要障碍中,白人无法以除最爱国和不自我批评的方式来构想我们的国家是其中最大的障碍之一。”
挑战主流叙述。 许多白人美国人坚持对美国历史的净化版本,淡化或忽视了国家的种族主义、奴隶制和种族灭绝的遗产。面对这些不舒服的真相对于理解当代种族问题的根源至关重要。
面对历史的不公正。 更诚实地审视美国历史揭示了:
- 奴隶制的残酷现实及其持久的经济影响
- 对土著人民的种族灭绝和流离失所
- 住房、教育和就业中的系统性歧视
- 政府对有色人种社区的医学实验
- 美国对全球有色人种的外交政策行动
承认这段历史对于解决持续的种族不平等和实现真正的和解与进步至关重要。
7. 个人责任:白人美国人必须积极对抗种族主义
“白人必须对解决种族主义和白人特权承担个人责任。”
超越被动的非种族主义。 白人美国人仅仅避免公开的种族主义行为是不够的。积极对抗种族主义需要:
- 自我教育种族问题和历史
- 反对种族主义言论、笑话和行为
- 检查和挑战自己的偏见和假设
- 支持反种族主义政策和倡议
- 利用自己的特权放大有色人种的声音
需要持续的努力。 消除种族主义是一个需要持续承诺和行动的过程。白人美国人必须愿意:
- 参与关于种族的不舒服对话
- 接受批评和反馈而不变得防御
- 认识到意图不能否定影响
- 理解成为盟友是一个动词,而不是一个静态身份
8. 建立跨种族联盟和理解共同利益
“废除种族主义需要重新定义当前白人对自身利益的种族认知为经济认知。”
寻找共同点。 许多工薪阶层的白人美国人由于种族偏见而投票反对他们的经济利益。认识到跨种族的共同经济挑战可以促进更有效的变革联盟。
克服种族分歧。 建立跨种族联盟需要:
- 承认种族主义如何被用来分裂工人阶级
- 强调跨种族群体的共同斗争和目标
- 强调种族主义最终对所有社会成员的伤害
- 推动解决种族和经济不平等的政策
通过将自身利益重新定义为经济福祉而非种族身份,可以建立更强大的社会和经济正义运动。
9. 选举政治之外的持续斗争的必要性
“变革不会自动到来,而是通过持续的斗争实现的。”
选举政治作为起点。 虽然奥巴马的当选具有历史意义,但必须认识到,仅靠投票不能解决根深蒂固的种族问题。实现有意义的变革需要持续的激进主义和组织工作。
将能量转化为持续的运动。 为了在奥巴马竞选的势头上继续前进:
- 参与地方社区组织和草根运动
- 支持解决系统性种族不平等的政策倡议
- 让民选官员对他们的承诺和行动负责
- 在必要时参与直接行动和公民抗命
- 教育他人关于种族问题和持续斗争的必要性
争取种族正义的斗争需要在选票箱之外的持续承诺和行动,重点是消除系统性种族主义,建立一个对所有人更公平的社会。
最后更新日期:
FAQ
What's "Between Barack and a Hard Place" about?
- Exploration of Racism: The book examines the persistence of racism and white denial in the United States, particularly in the context of Barack Obama's presidency.
- Racism 2.0 Concept: Tim Wise introduces the idea of "Racism 2.0," a more subtle form of racism that allows for the success of individual people of color while maintaining systemic racial inequities.
- White Denial: It delves into how white Americans often deny or downplay the existence and impact of racism, even in the face of evidence.
- Call for Responsibility: The book calls for white Americans to take responsibility for addressing racism and dismantling white privilege.
Why should I read "Between Barack and a Hard Place"?
- Insightful Analysis: The book provides a deep analysis of race relations in the U.S., offering a perspective that challenges common narratives.
- Understanding Racism: It helps readers understand the complexities of modern racism and the ways it manifests in society.
- Call to Action: Tim Wise encourages readers, especially white Americans, to actively participate in the fight against racism.
- Timely and Relevant: Although published in 2009, the themes remain relevant in today's discussions about race and equality.
What are the key takeaways of "Between Barack and a Hard Place"?
- Racism's Persistence: Despite Obama's presidency, systemic racism and white privilege remain deeply entrenched in American society.
- White Denial: Many white Americans continue to deny the existence of racism, which hinders progress toward racial equality.
- Racism 2.0: This new form of racism celebrates individual successes of people of color while ignoring broader systemic issues.
- Responsibility and Action: The book emphasizes the need for white Americans to take responsibility and actively work to dismantle racism.
What is "Racism 2.0" as described by Tim Wise?
- Enlightened Exceptionalism: Racism 2.0 allows for the success of individual people of color, like Barack Obama, while maintaining negative stereotypes about the larger community.
- Subtle Racism: It is less overt than traditional racism but still perpetuates racial inequities by setting unrealistic standards for people of color.
- White Comfort: This form of racism makes white people feel comfortable by allowing them to support certain individuals without addressing systemic issues.
- Reinforcement of Stereotypes: It reinforces the idea that only those who "transcend" their racial identity are acceptable, which can increase pressure and anxiety for people of color.
How does Tim Wise address white denial in "Between Barack and a Hard Place"?
- Historical Context: Wise provides historical examples of white denial, showing how it has persisted over time despite clear evidence of racial injustice.
- Current Examples: He uses contemporary examples, including reactions to Obama's presidency, to illustrate ongoing denial.
- Impact on Progress: The book discusses how white denial impedes progress toward racial equality by preventing honest dialogue and action.
- Call for Awareness: Wise urges white Americans to acknowledge and confront their denial to effectively address racism.
What are the best quotes from "Between Barack and a Hard Place" and what do they mean?
- "Racism 2.0": This term encapsulates the idea of a more subtle, insidious form of racism that celebrates individual success while ignoring systemic issues.
- "White Denial": Wise frequently discusses how white Americans deny the existence and impact of racism, which is a significant barrier to progress.
- "Personal Responsibility": The book emphasizes the need for white individuals to take responsibility for their role in perpetuating racism and work towards change.
- "The Audacity of Truth": This phrase highlights the importance of confronting uncomfortable truths about race and privilege in America.
How does "Between Barack and a Hard Place" suggest white Americans can address racism?
- Acknowledge Privilege: Recognize and understand the privileges that come with being white in America.
- Listen and Believe: Actively listen to and believe the experiences of people of color regarding racism.
- Educate and Advocate: Educate oneself about racial issues and advocate for policies and practices that promote racial equity.
- Challenge Racism: Speak out against racism in all its forms, whether overt or subtle, in personal and institutional settings.
What role does Barack Obama's presidency play in "Between Barack and a Hard Place"?
- Symbol of Progress: Obama's presidency is seen as a symbol of racial progress but not a solution to systemic racism.
- Racism 2.0 Example: His success is used to illustrate Racism 2.0, where individual achievements are celebrated while ignoring broader racial issues.
- White Perception: The book discusses how Obama's presidency affected white Americans' perceptions of race and racism.
- Call for Action: Wise uses Obama's presidency to call for continued action and responsibility in addressing racial inequities.
What is the significance of the title "Between Barack and a Hard Place"?
- Play on Words: The title is a play on the phrase "between a rock and a hard place," suggesting a difficult situation.
- Obama's Presidency: It reflects the complex position of Obama's presidency in the context of ongoing racial issues.
- Racial Challenges: The title highlights the challenges faced by people of color in navigating a society that celebrates individual success but maintains systemic barriers.
- White Denial: It also points to the difficulty of addressing white denial and the persistence of racism despite apparent progress.
How does Tim Wise propose to dismantle systemic racism in "Between Barack and a Hard Place"?
- White Responsibility: Emphasizes the need for white Americans to take responsibility for their role in perpetuating racism.
- Active Engagement: Encourages active engagement in antiracist work, including education, advocacy, and challenging racist practices.
- Cross-Racial Alliances: Advocates for building alliances across racial lines to work collectively toward racial justice.
- Institutional Change: Calls for systemic changes in policies and practices that perpetuate racial inequities.
What historical context does "Between Barack and a Hard Place" provide about racism in America?
- Legacy of Slavery: Discusses the long-lasting impact of slavery and segregation on current racial dynamics.
- Civil Rights Movement: References the civil rights movement and its achievements, as well as its limitations in eradicating racism.
- White Supremacy: Explores the historical roots of white supremacy and its influence on American institutions and culture.
- Ongoing Struggles: Highlights the ongoing struggles for racial equality and the resistance faced by movements for change.
What impact does "Between Barack and a Hard Place" aim to have on its readers?
- Awareness and Understanding: Aims to increase awareness and understanding of modern racism and white privilege.
- Motivation for Action: Seeks to motivate readers, especially white Americans, to take action against racism in their communities.
- Challenge Denial: Encourages readers to challenge their own denial and biases regarding race and privilege.
- Inspire Dialogue: Hopes to inspire honest and productive dialogue about race and racism in America.
评论
《在巴拉克与困境之间》探讨了奥巴马当选后美国的种族主义问题。怀斯认为,尽管取得了一些进展,但一种更为隐蔽的“种族主义2.0”依然存在。他质疑后种族社会的概念,并呼吁白人承担起解决系统性种族主义的责任。读者认为这本书见解深刻,尽管有些人觉得内容重复或某些结论缺乏支持。许多人赞赏怀斯对种族问题的分析以及他在黑人总统历史性当选后,继续为平等而努力的呼吁。