Key Takeaways
1. Bitcoin: A digital currency born from libertarian ideals
Bitcoin ideology bought into the entire Federal Reserve conspiracy package.
Libertarian roots. Bitcoin emerged from cyberlibertarian subculture, which combines anarcho-capitalism with distrust of government and central banks. Its creators and early adopters believed Bitcoin could replace fiat currencies, eliminate the need for financial intermediaries, and usher in a new era of financial freedom.
Ideological flaws. However, Bitcoin's underlying ideology is based on discredited economic theories and conspiracy thinking. It assumes inflation is solely caused by central banks printing money, ignores the complexities of monetary policy, and promotes a deflationary model that encourages hoarding rather than spending. This ideological baggage has led to numerous practical problems in Bitcoin's implementation and adoption.
2. The blockchain: A revolutionary but impractical technology
Bitcoin decentralises things that should not be decentralised, then centralises them anyway but wastefully.
Inefficient by design. The blockchain, Bitcoin's underlying technology, is touted as revolutionary but is fundamentally inefficient. It requires massive computational power and energy consumption to maintain a decentralized ledger, which could be more efficiently managed by centralized systems.
Limited scalability. Bitcoin's blockchain can only process about 7 transactions per second globally, far below the capacity needed for a global payment system. Attempts to increase capacity have led to community schisms and technological dead-ends.
- Transaction backlog is a persistent problem
- High fees and long confirmation times are common
- Proposed solutions like Lightning Network remain theoretical
3. Cryptocurrencies are prone to scams, hacks, and wild speculation
Everything to do with cryptocurrencies and blockchains is the domain of fast-talking conmen.
Rampant fraud. The cryptocurrency ecosystem is plagued by scams, from simple Ponzi schemes to elaborate ICO frauds. The lack of regulation and the complexity of the technology make it easy for bad actors to exploit uninformed investors.
Exchange vulnerabilities. Cryptocurrency exchanges, where most trading occurs, are frequent targets of hacks and internal fraud. Notable examples include:
- Mt. Gox: Lost $460 million in customer funds
- Bitfinex: Hacked for $72 million in 2016
- Countless smaller exchanges disappearing with user funds
Speculative bubbles. The cryptocurrency market is characterized by extreme price volatility and speculative manias. Two major Bitcoin bubbles (2013 and 2017) saw prices skyrocket then crash, with similar patterns in other cryptocurrencies and tokens.
4. Smart contracts: Promising concept, problematic execution
Smart contracts work on the wrong level: they run on facts and not on human intent – but legal contracts are a codification of human intent.
Fundamental flaws. Smart contracts, automated agreements on blockchain platforms like Ethereum, face several inherent problems:
- Cannot account for complex real-world situations and changing circumstances
- Require perfect, bug-free code, which is nearly impossible to achieve
- Difficult to fix errors or update once deployed
The DAO disaster. The most high-profile smart contract failure, The DAO, raised $150 million then lost $50 million to a hack due to a code vulnerability. This led to a controversial blockchain rollback, undermining the principle of immutability.
5. Business blockchain hype outpaces practical applications
Blockchains won't clean up your data for you.
Overblown promises. Many businesses and consultants promote blockchain as a cure-all for various industry problems, but most proposed use cases offer no advantage over traditional databases.
Reality check. Blockchain applications in business face significant hurdles:
- Scalability issues for large-scale data management
- Difficulty integrating with existing systems
- Privacy concerns with shared ledgers
- Need for industry-wide standards and cooperation
Hype cycle. Most "blockchain" projects in development are either vaporware or rebranded database solutions with little relation to actual blockchain technology.
6. The music industry's blockchain dreams face significant hurdles
No single blockchain can possibly scale to the whole music industry.
Unrealistic expectations. The music industry hopes blockchain can solve longstanding issues with rights management, royalty payments, and transparency. However, these hopes ignore several critical problems:
Technical limitations. Music industry blockchain proposals face significant technical challenges:
- Inability to scale to millions of songs and billions of plays
- Difficulty integrating with existing systems and databases
- Need for trusted oracles to input real-world data
Human factors. Many blockchain solutions ignore the human element in music rights management:
- Disputes over ownership and royalty splits
- Changing contractual relationships
- Need for flexibility in interpreting agreements
7. Cryptocurrency's future: More bubbles, scams, and unfulfilled promises
There will be more promises of free riches in the future, and more asset bubbles. All of this will happen again.
Continued volatility. The cryptocurrency market is likely to experience more dramatic price swings and speculative manias, driven by hype, manipulation, and the promise of quick riches.
Persistent problems. Fundamental issues with cryptocurrencies will remain unresolved:
- Scalability limitations
- High energy consumption
- Vulnerability to hacks and scams
- Lack of practical use cases beyond speculation
Regulatory challenges. As cryptocurrencies gain more mainstream attention, they will face increased scrutiny from regulators concerned about investor protection, money laundering, and financial stability. This may lead to crackdowns on exchanges and ICOs, potentially dampening enthusiasm in the short term but possibly leading to a more stable and legitimate ecosystem in the long run.
Last updated:
FAQ
What is "Attack of the 50 Foot Blockchain" by David Gerard about?
- Critical history of crypto: The book is a skeptical, often humorous, history and analysis of Bitcoin, blockchain technology, Ethereum, and smart contracts, focusing on their origins, promises, and real-world outcomes.
- Debunking the hype: Gerard systematically examines the claims made by cryptocurrency advocates, contrasting them with the actual technical, economic, and social realities.
- Scams and psychology: The book argues that the crypto world is less about technology and more about psychology, bubble thinking, and the prevalence of scams.
- Broader context: It also explores the ideological roots of crypto, its impact on business and society, and case studies like the music industry’s blockchain dreams.
Why should I read "Attack of the 50 Foot Blockchain" by David Gerard?
- Skeptical perspective: The book offers a much-needed critical viewpoint on a field often surrounded by hype and misinformation.
- Accessible explanations: Gerard breaks down complex technical concepts into understandable language, making it suitable for non-experts.
- Real-world caution: It provides practical warnings about the risks, scams, and failures in the crypto space, which is valuable for anyone considering involvement.
- Cultural insight: The book delves into the subcultures, ideologies, and psychological factors driving the cryptocurrency phenomenon.
What are the key takeaways from "Attack of the 50 Foot Blockchain"?
- Crypto is not magic: Bitcoin and blockchains are not revolutionary technologies but are often inefficient, impractical, and plagued by centralization and waste.
- Ideology over utility: Much of the crypto movement is driven by libertarian and conspiratorial ideologies rather than genuine technological need or benefit.
- Scams are rampant: The lack of regulation and oversight has made the crypto world a breeding ground for scams, Ponzi schemes, and incompetence.
- Promises vs. reality: Most of the grand claims about decentralization, anonymity, and financial revolution have not materialized in practice.
What are the most important concepts explained in "Attack of the 50 Foot Blockchain"?
- Bitcoin and blockchain basics: The book explains what Bitcoin is, how the blockchain works, and the concept of proof of work.
- Mining and centralization: It details how mining works, why it wastes energy, and how it has become centralized despite claims of decentralization.
- Smart contracts and ICOs: Gerard covers the idea of smart contracts, their limitations, and the rise (and problems) of Initial Coin Offerings (ICOs).
- The oracle problem and immutability: The book discusses why smart contracts struggle to interact with the real world and why immutability can be a curse.
How does David Gerard define and critique Bitcoin and blockchain technology?
- Bitcoin as digital cash: Gerard describes Bitcoin as an attempt at decentralized digital money, but notes it is unregulated, irreversible, and technically unforgiving.
- Blockchain as a ledger: The blockchain is explained as a public, tamper-evident ledger, but Gerard argues that its touted immutability and decentralization are overstated.
- Proof of work waste: He criticizes proof of work as an intentionally wasteful process, making Bitcoin ecologically damaging and economically inefficient.
- Centralization paradox: Despite claims, mining and exchanges have become highly centralized, undermining the original vision.
What is the ideological background of Bitcoin and blockchain, according to "Attack of the 50 Foot Blockchain"?
- Libertarian and anarcho-capitalist roots: The book traces crypto’s origins to libertarian, cyberlibertarian, and Austrian economics ideologies, often with anti-government and conspiratorial overtones.
- Gold standard nostalgia: Many crypto advocates are “gold bugs” who believe in a fixed money supply and distrust central banks.
- Conspiracy theory economics: Gerard highlights how Bitcoin discourse often borrows from fringe economic theories and conspiracy jargon.
- Ideology over practicality: The book argues that these ideological roots have led to many of the practical failures and unrealistic promises in crypto.
What are the main promises and myths of Bitcoin and blockchain debunked in "Attack of the 50 Foot Blockchain"?
- Decentralization myth: Mining and transaction processing have become centralized in a few large pools.
- Anonymity myth: Bitcoin is pseudonymous at best; law enforcement can and does trace transactions.
- No fees and instant payments: Transaction fees and delays are now common, making Bitcoin impractical for everyday use.
- Banking the unbanked and economic equality: The book shows that Bitcoin has failed to deliver on these social promises, often worsening inequality.
How does "Attack of the 50 Foot Blockchain" describe the history of Bitcoin bubbles and scams?
- Early bubbles: The book details the rise and fall of Bitcoin’s first major price bubbles, driven by speculation and media hype.
- Ponzi schemes and thefts: It covers notorious scams like Pirateat40’s Bitcoin Savings & Trust and the collapse of Mt. Gox, highlighting the lack of regulation.
- Exchange failures: Gerard documents the repeated hacks, incompetence, and outright fraud at crypto exchanges.
- Darknet and ransomware: The book explains how illicit uses like drug markets and ransomware have been the main real-world applications of Bitcoin.
What does David Gerard say about smart contracts, Ethereum, and ICOs in "Attack of the 50 Foot Blockchain"?
- Smart contracts are flawed: Gerard argues that smart contracts are brittle, hard to code correctly, and often fail in practice due to the “oracle problem” and immutability.
- Ethereum’s ambitions and failures: The book covers Ethereum’s promise as a “world computer,” but notes its technical and security issues, including the infamous DAO hack.
- ICO mania: Gerard critiques ICOs as largely unregulated, speculative fundraising schemes, often with little real substance or utility.
- Bubble and scam parallels: He draws parallels between ICOs and historical bubbles, emphasizing the lack of investor protection.
How does "Attack of the 50 Foot Blockchain" assess the business and enterprise blockchain hype?
- Buzzword over substance: Gerard argues that “blockchain” has become a meaningless buzzword in business, often used to sell vaporware or rebranded databases.
- No real adoption: Most claimed enterprise blockchain projects are trials or PR exercises, not real, working systems.
- Data and trust issues: The book points out that blockchains don’t solve the real problems of data quality, interoperability, or trust in business.
- Permissioned blockchains: Gerard is skeptical of “private” or “permissioned” blockchains, seeing them as inefficient versions of existing database technology.
What case studies does "Attack of the 50 Foot Blockchain" use to illustrate blockchain’s limitations, especially in the music industry?
- Music industry dreams: The book examines proposals to use blockchains for music rights and payments, showing why they are technically and practically unworkable.
- Imogen Heap’s experiment: Gerard details the “Tiny Human” blockchain release, which garnered more press than sales and was nearly impossible for fans to use.
- Rights management complexity: He explains that the real problems are messy, ever-changing rights and data, which blockchains can’t fix.
- Industry resistance: The book notes that incumbents resist change, and blockchain solutions often just recreate old problems in new forms.
What are the best quotes from "Attack of the 50 Foot Blockchain" by David Gerard, and what do they mean?
- “Bitcoin and blockchains are not a technology story, but a psychology story: bubble economy thinking and the art of the steal.” – This highlights the book’s thesis that crypto is driven more by human psychology and scams than by genuine innovation.
- “If it sounds too good to be true, it almost certainly is.” – Gerard’s recurring warning about the promises of crypto and blockchain.
- “Everything to do with cryptocurrencies and blockchains is the domain of fast-talking conmen. If anyone tries to sell you on either, kick them in the nuts and run.” – A blunt summary of the author’s skepticism and advice to readers.
- “The good bits of blockchain are not original, and the original bits of blockchain turn out not to be much good.” – Gerard’s assessment that the genuinely useful parts of blockchain technology predate Bitcoin, while its innovations are mostly problematic.
Review Summary
Attack of the 50 Foot Blockchain receives mixed reviews, with an overall rating of 3.97 out of 5. Many readers praise its informative and humorous take on cryptocurrencies, highlighting the author's critical perspective and well-researched content. Supporters appreciate the book's insights into the flaws and risks of Bitcoin and blockchain technology. However, some critics find it biased and poorly researched, arguing that it dismisses potential benefits. The book is noted for its accessible writing style, extensive citations, and ability to explain complex concepts to a general audience.
Similar Books
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
