Read Write Own

1. The Internet's Evolution: From Open Protocols to Corporate Control

Today's dominant core internet services—the web (HTTP), email (SMTP), and subscription messaging (RSS)—are open protocols that are distributed across millions of institutions.

The early internet was built on open, decentralized protocols like HTTP and SMTP, which allowed for permissionless innovation and democratic governance. However, as the internet matured, corporate networks emerged, offering advanced features and ease of use but at the cost of centralized control.

The shift to corporate dominance led to high take rates, capricious rule changes, and the stifling of innovation at the network edges. Companies like Facebook, Google, and Amazon now control vast swathes of the internet, creating "walled gardens" that limit user choice and developer freedom. This centralization has resulted in:

• High fees for developers and creators (up to 30% on app stores)
• Limited data portability and interoperability
• Increased user surveillance and data exploitation
• Reduced innovation due to platform risk for startups

2. Blockchain Networks: A New Era of Digital Ownership and Community Governance

Blockchains are the only credible, known architecture for building networks with the societal benefits of protocol networks and the competitive advantages of corporate networks.

Blockchain networks combine the best aspects of protocol and corporate networks, offering open access, community governance, and the ability to attract capital for growth. They enable true digital ownership through tokens, which represent assets, access rights, or governance power.

Key features of blockchain networks include:

• Immutable rules encoded in software
• Low take rates (typically 1-2.5%)
• Community-driven governance
• Interoperability and composability
• Transparent and auditable transactions

These features create a more level playing field for developers, creators, and users, fostering innovation and fair economic distribution. By decentralizing control, blockchain networks aim to restore the original promise of the internet as an open, democratic space.

3. Token Economics: Incentivizing Network Growth and User Participation

Tokens are general-purpose containers for representing ownership.

Token incentives are a powerful tool for building and growing blockchain networks. They solve the "bootstrap problem" by rewarding early adopters and contributors, creating a virtuous cycle of network growth.

Tokenomics, the study of token economies, involves balancing supply (faucets) and demand (sinks) to create sustainable growth. Key concepts include:

• Faucets: Methods of distributing tokens (e.g., airdrops, mining rewards)
• Sinks: Ways to create token demand (e.g., transaction fees, staking)
• Governance tokens: Allowing token holders to vote on network decisions
• Utility tokens: Providing access to network services or features

Well-designed token economies can drive network adoption, fund ongoing development, and align incentives between network participants. This creates a more equitable distribution of value compared to traditional corporate models.

4. The Power of Composability in Software Development

Composability unlocks the best humanity has to offer.

Composability in software allows developers to build on existing components, creating a compounding effect of innovation. This principle is at the heart of open-source development and is now being extended to blockchain networks.

Benefits of composability include:

• Rapid innovation through reusable components
• Lower barriers to entry for developers
• Increased interoperability between applications
• Community-driven improvement of shared resources

Blockchain networks take composability further by making not just code, but also economic and governance systems composable. This allows for the creation of complex, interoperable financial and social systems that can be built and improved upon by a global community of developers.

5. Decentralized Social Networks: Empowering Creators and Users

Blockchain networks are like cities, built from the bottom up by the people who inhabit them.

Decentralized social networks built on blockchain technology aim to address the shortcomings of current corporate-controlled platforms. They offer:

• Lower take rates, allowing creators to earn more
• User ownership of data and social graphs
• Community governance of platform rules and algorithms
• Interoperability between different social applications

By redistributing the value captured by social networks, these platforms could potentially support millions of profitable niches, rather than concentrating wealth in a few large corporations. This model promises to revive the original vision of the internet as a space for diverse, independent voices and communities.

6. The Metaverse and Digital Economies: Redefining Virtual Ownership

The strongest form of an open metaverse would be a collection of composable blockchain networks, each of which meets one of the needs Sweeney describes, and which themselves interoperate, forming a meta-network.

The metaverse, a concept of interconnected virtual worlds, is poised to become a major part of our digital lives. Blockchain technology offers a way to build this metaverse as an open, user-owned system rather than a corporate-controlled one.

Key aspects of a blockchain-based metaverse include:

• True ownership of virtual assets through NFTs
• Interoperable virtual economies
• User-generated content with fair revenue sharing
• Decentralized governance of virtual spaces

This model contrasts with current corporate-owned virtual worlds and games, where users have limited rights and ownership. By enabling real digital ownership and economies, blockchain networks could unleash unprecedented creativity and economic opportunity in virtual spaces.

7. Artificial Intelligence and Content Creation: A New Economic Covenant

AI puts human creators at the beginning of the creative pipeline instead of the end of it.

The rise of AI in content creation presents both challenges and opportunities for creators. While AI can generate content at scale, it relies on human-created training data. Blockchain networks offer a way to create a new economic covenant between AI systems and content creators.

Potential solutions include:

• Token-based compensation for creators whose work is used in AI training
• Blockchain-verified attribution and licensing of AI-generated content
• Decentralized AI models owned and governed by creator communities

This approach could ensure that as AI becomes more prevalent in content creation, human creators remain valued and compensated participants in the creative process.

8. Regulatory Challenges and the Future of Blockchain Innovation

Ideally, policymakers and regulators would clarify the criteria that distinguish securities and commodities and provide a path for new projects to become sufficiently decentralized such that they are regulated as commodities.

Regulatory uncertainty is a significant challenge for blockchain innovation, particularly in the United States. Clear, thoughtful regulation is needed to protect consumers while allowing for innovation.

Key regulatory considerations include:

• Clarifying the distinction between securities and commodities in the context of digital assets
• Creating a pathway for blockchain projects to achieve "sufficient decentralization"
• Balancing consumer protection with the need for permissionless innovation
• Addressing the global nature of blockchain networks in a world of national regulations

The future of blockchain innovation depends on finding a regulatory balance that fosters growth while mitigating risks. By drawing lessons from the early internet era, policymakers have an opportunity to position their countries at the forefront of this transformative technology.

Last updated: September 11, 2024