Searching...
English
English
Español
简体中文
Français
Deutsch
日本語
Português
Italiano
한국어
Русский
Nederlands
العربية
Polski
हिन्दी
Tiếng Việt
Svenska
Ελληνικά
Türkçe
ไทย
Čeština
Română
Magyar
Українська
Bahasa Indonesia
Dansk
Suomi
Български
עברית
Norsk
Hrvatski
Català
Slovenčina
Lietuvių
Slovenščina
Српски
Eesti
Latviešu
فارسی
മലയാളം
தமிழ்
اردو
Bad Men Do what Good Men Dream

Bad Men Do what Good Men Dream

A Forensic Psychiatrist Illuminates the Darker Side of Human Behavior
by Robert I. Simon 2008 339 pages
Psychology
Psychiatry
Philosophy
Listen
11 minutes

Key Takeaways

1. The dark side of human nature exists in everyone

Bad men do what good men dream.

Universal dark side. All humans harbor antisocial impulses and dark fantasies to varying degrees. The key difference between "good" and "bad" people is not the presence of these thoughts, but the ability to resist acting on them. Most people are able to channel their darker impulses into socially acceptable outlets or keep them confined to fantasy.

Psychological defenses. Common defense mechanisms like projection and denial allow people to distance themselves from their own dark side by attributing negative traits to others. This can lead to scapegoating and dehumanization of certain groups. Recognizing our own capacity for evil is crucial for developing empathy and resisting the urge to demonize others.

Societal implications. Understanding the universality of the human dark side has important implications for criminal justice, mental health treatment, and conflict resolution. Rather than viewing "evil" as something inherent only in certain individuals, we must recognize it as a potential in all of us that can be mitigated through proper socialization, mental health support, and ethical frameworks.

2. Child abuse and neglect often contribute to future violent behavior

The wind is sown with abuse of children, and the whirlwind is reaped when those former children abuse the next generation.

Cycle of abuse. Many violent offenders, including serial killers, experienced severe physical, sexual, or emotional abuse as children. This early trauma can lead to stunted emotional development, lack of empathy, and a propensity for violence. However, it's important to note that most abuse victims do not become abusers themselves.

Neurological impacts. Childhood abuse and neglect can have lasting effects on brain development, particularly in areas related to emotional regulation, impulse control, and empathy. This neurological damage can predispose individuals to violent or antisocial behavior later in life.

Breaking the cycle. Early intervention and support for at-risk children and families is crucial for preventing future violence. Therapy, positive role models, and stable environments can help mitigate the effects of childhood trauma and teach healthier coping mechanisms.

3. Serial killers are driven by deviant fantasies and a lack of empathy

Serial sexual killers torture their victims for one reason only: to obtain a maximal orgasm that they are unable to achieve in any other way.

Fantasy-driven violence. Serial killers, particularly sexual predators, are often motivated by elaborate sadistic fantasies that fuse violence with sexual gratification. These fantasies typically develop in adolescence and become increasingly detailed and compelling over time.

Lack of empathy. A defining characteristic of serial killers is their inability to empathize with their victims. They view people as objects to be used for their own gratification rather than as human beings with inherent worth. This allows them to commit horrific acts without remorse.

Common traits:

  • History of childhood abuse or neglect
  • Animal cruelty and fire-setting in youth
  • Inability to form meaningful relationships
  • Grandiose sense of self-importance
  • Fascination with law enforcement
  • Escalating pattern of violence over time

4. Cults exploit psychological vulnerabilities for control and manipulation

For people in the midst of a personal crisis, joining a cult has led some to experience a significant diminishing of their personal psychological suffering—at least, for a time.

Psychological appeal. Cults attract followers by offering a sense of belonging, purpose, and certainty in an uncertain world. They often target vulnerable individuals who are experiencing personal crises or feelings of alienation from mainstream society.

Mind control techniques:

  • Love bombing: Overwhelming new members with affection and attention
  • Isolation from outside influences
  • Us vs. them mentality
  • Guilt and shame manipulation
  • Sleep deprivation and dietary restrictions
  • Constant indoctrination

Destructive potential. While not all cults are violent, some can evolve into dangerous organizations under charismatic, mentally unstable leaders. The combination of absolute devotion from followers and unchecked power can lead to tragic outcomes, as seen in cases like Jonestown and Heaven's Gate.

5. Workplace violence often stems from unaddressed mental health issues

It's never a normal person who snaps. It's always an abnormal person, often in a pressure situation.

Warning signs. Many perpetrators of workplace violence exhibit clear warning signs before committing violent acts. These can include:

  • Increased irritability and mood swings
  • Social isolation
  • Paranoid or threatening statements
  • Substance abuse
  • Decreased job performance
  • Fascination with weapons or violence

Organizational factors. Certain workplace conditions can increase the risk of violence, such as high-stress environments, poor management practices, lack of job security, and inadequate mental health support for employees.

Prevention strategies. Organizations can reduce the risk of workplace violence by:

  • Implementing comprehensive threat assessment protocols
  • Providing mental health resources and support for employees
  • Training managers to recognize warning signs and respond appropriately
  • Fostering a culture of respect and open communication
  • Establishing clear policies and procedures for addressing potential threats

6. Sexual misconduct by professionals is a betrayal of trust and power

To give patients sexual intimacy in lieu of treatment is to rob them of treatment and abandon them to their illness.

Abuse of power. Sexual misconduct by professionals such as therapists, doctors, and clergy is particularly damaging due to the inherent power imbalance and violation of trust in these relationships. Victims often experience long-lasting psychological trauma and difficulty forming future trusting relationships.

Contributing factors:

  • Lack of proper boundaries in professional relationships
  • Unresolved personal issues of the professional
  • Inadequate oversight and accountability measures
  • Mishandling of transference and countertransference in therapy

Prevention and accountability. Preventing professional sexual misconduct requires:

  • Rigorous ethical training and ongoing education
  • Clear professional guidelines and codes of conduct
  • Effective reporting mechanisms and investigations
  • Appropriate disciplinary actions for offenders
  • Support and protection for whistleblowers and victims

7. Suicide intent is complex and often misunderstood

Suicide intent is frequently an issue in criminal cases in which it must be determined if the victim was murdered or committed suicide.

Multifaceted motivations. Suicide is rarely the result of a single factor, but rather a complex interplay of psychological, social, and biological influences. Common contributing factors include:

  • Mental illness, particularly depression
  • Substance abuse
  • Chronic pain or illness
  • Social isolation
  • Financial stress
  • Trauma or loss

Psychological autopsy. In cases of equivocal death, forensic psychiatrists may conduct a psychological autopsy to determine the likelihood of suicide. This involves a thorough examination of the deceased's mental state, life circumstances, and behavior leading up to their death.

Prevention strategies. Effective suicide prevention requires a multifaceted approach:

  • Improving access to mental health care
  • Public education to reduce stigma
  • Crisis intervention services
  • Restricting access to lethal means
  • Supporting those bereaved by suicide
  • Responsible media reporting of suicide

8. Terrorism and extremism arise from a combination of factors

Throughout history, ordinary, good men and women of many faiths, have committed terrible crimes against humanity while acting in the name of God.

Root causes. Terrorism and extremism are often fueled by a complex mix of:

  • Political grievances
  • Economic inequality
  • Religious or ideological indoctrination
  • Social marginalization
  • Personal psychological factors

Radicalization process. Individuals typically become radicalized through a gradual process that involves:

  1. Exposure to extremist ideology
  2. Adoption of a black-and-white worldview
  3. Isolation from moderating influences
  4. Dehumanization of perceived enemies
  5. Justification of violence for the cause

Countering extremism. Effective strategies to combat terrorism and extremism include:

  • Addressing underlying socioeconomic grievances
  • Promoting education and critical thinking skills
  • Supporting moderate voices within communities
  • Providing deradicalization programs
  • International cooperation in intelligence and law enforcement

9. Good character and mental health are key to resisting dark impulses

Character is destiny.

Foundations of character. Good character is built on:

  • Strong moral values and ethical principles
  • Empathy and compassion for others
  • Self-awareness and emotional intelligence
  • Resilience in the face of adversity
  • Personal responsibility and integrity

Mental health factors. Psychological well-being contributes to resisting destructive impulses through:

  • Healthy self-esteem and self-acceptance
  • Ability to regulate emotions
  • Strong support systems and relationships
  • Effective coping mechanisms for stress
  • Sense of purpose and meaning in life

Nurturing goodness. Society can promote good character and mental health by:

  • Emphasizing character education in schools
  • Providing accessible mental health resources
  • Fostering supportive communities
  • Promoting positive role models
  • Encouraging self-reflection and personal growth

Human nature contains both light and darkness. By understanding the psychological factors that contribute to destructive behavior, we can work to cultivate the positive aspects of human potential and create a more compassionate, just society.

Last updated:

Review Summary

3.82 out of 5
Average of 100+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

Bad Men Do what Good Men Dream receives mixed reviews. Some find it insightful for beginners but oversimplified and outdated for experts. Readers appreciate the exploration of criminal psychology and the idea that everyone has dark impulses. However, critics point out factual errors, repetitive content, and an overly American focus. The book's strengths lie in its accessible language and case studies, while weaknesses include religious references and a lack of nuance. Overall, it's considered a decent introduction to the subject, but not a definitive work.

About the Author

Robert I. Simon is a forensic psychiatrist and author known for his work in criminal psychology. He has extensive experience in the field, having worked with various criminal cases and mental health issues. Simon's approach in Bad Men Do what Good Men Dream combines his clinical expertise with accessible writing for a general audience. He explores the psychological continuum between normal behavior and criminal acts, emphasizing that all individuals possess both good and bad impulses. Simon's work aims to provide insights into the criminal mind while highlighting the importance of mental health and understanding human nature.

0:00
-0:00
1x
Create a free account to unlock:
Bookmarks – save your favorite books
History – revisit books later
Ratings – rate books & see your ratings
Listening – audio summariesListen to the first takeaway of every book for free, upgrade to Pro for unlimited listening.
🎧 Upgrade to continue listening...
Get lifetime access to SoBrief
Listen to full summaries of 73,530 books
Save unlimited bookmarks & history
More pro features coming soon!
How your free trial works
Create an account
You successfully signed up.
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 73,530 books.
Day 4: Trial Reminder
We'll send you an email reminder.
Cancel anytime in just 15 seconds.
Day 7: Trial Ends
Your subscription will start on Sep 26.
Monthly$4.99
Yearly$44.99
Lifetime$79.99