Key Takeaways
1. Effective Classroom Management Hinges on Teacher Influence
The results of this study will document that the most important factor affecting student learning is the teacher.
Teacher's pivotal role. The book underscores the paramount importance of the teacher in shaping the learning environment and influencing student achievement. Effective teaching and learning are impossible in a poorly managed classroom, where disorder and disrespect prevail. The teacher's ability to create a well-managed classroom is the single most important factor in student success.
Creating a flourishing environment. A well-managed classroom provides an environment where teaching and learning can flourish. This doesn't happen by chance; it requires conscious effort and skill on the part of the teacher. The teacher is the architect of the classroom environment, setting the tone and establishing the conditions for student success.
Three major roles. Effective teachers perform three major roles:
- Making wise choices about instructional strategies
- Designing classroom curriculum to facilitate learning
- Making effective use of classroom management techniques
While all three roles are essential, effective classroom management serves as the foundation upon which the other two are built.
2. Rules and Procedures: The Bedrock of Order
Furthermore, inefficient procedures and the absence of routines for common aspects of classroom life, such as taking and reporting attendance, participating in discussions, turning in materials, or checking work, can waste large amounts of time and cause students’ attention and interest to wane.
Guiding student behavior. Rules and procedures are essential for creating a structured and predictable classroom environment. They provide clear expectations for student behavior, reducing ambiguity and promoting a sense of order. Rules define general expectations, while procedures outline specific behaviors.
Categories of rules and procedures. Rules and procedures typically fall into several categories:
- General expectations for behavior
- Beginning and ending the class day or period
- Transitions and interruptions
- Materials and equipment
- Group work
- Seatwork and teacher-led activities
Student involvement. The most effective classroom managers involve students in the design of rules and procedures. This fosters a sense of ownership and increases student buy-in. Rules and procedures should be viewed as a "contract" between teacher and students, negotiated and agreed upon by all.
3. Disciplinary Interventions: A Balanced Approach
Clearly, the results of these studies should permit schools to strike . . . a ‘healthy balance’ between rewards and punishments.
Addressing misbehavior. Disciplinary interventions are necessary to address student misbehavior and maintain order in the classroom. However, it's crucial to employ a balanced approach that combines positive and negative consequences. The categorical rejection of disciplinary techniques is not supported by research.
Categories of disciplinary interventions:
- Teacher reaction
- Tangible recognition
- Direct cost
- Group contingency
- Home contingency
Student and parent perspectives. It's important to consider the perspectives of both students and parents when implementing disciplinary interventions. Parents generally expect teachers to discipline their children, and students have a strong sense of "fairness" when it comes to behavioral expectations.
4. Teacher-Student Relationships: Building Bridges, Not Walls
Briefly, teachers should be effective instructors and lecturers, as well as friendly, helpful, and congenial.
Foundation of effective management. Teacher-student relationships are the keystone of effective classroom management. When students feel connected to their teacher, they are more likely to accept rules, procedures, and disciplinary actions. Without a good relationship, students may resist these elements.
Dominance and cooperation. An optimal teacher-student relationship involves a healthy balance between dominance and cooperation. High dominance is characterized by clarity of purpose and strong guidance, while high cooperation is characterized by a concern for the needs and opinions of others.
Addressing student needs. Effective managers tailor their approach to the unique needs of individual students. Some students need encouragement, while others need a gentle reprimand. Teachers should develop a set of "helping skills" to employ with different types of students.
5. Mental Set: The Teacher's Inner Compass
It was not whether she came in right away but whether she came in before something spread or became more serious.
Mindfulness and awareness. An appropriate mental set is essential for effective classroom management. This involves a heightened sense of situational awareness and a conscious control over one's thoughts and behavior. Teachers must cultivate a mindful stance relative to their "withitness" and "emotional objectivity."
Withitness and emotional objectivity. Withitness involves a keen awareness of disruptive behavior or potentially disruptive behavior and immediate attention to that behavior. Emotional objectivity allows the teacher to address disciplinary issues in an "unemotional, matter-of-fact" manner.
Developing withitness and objectivity. Teachers can enhance their withitness by:
- Reacting immediately to disruptive behavior
- Forecasting potential problems
- Observing master teachers
Teachers can maintain emotional objectivity by:
- Looking for reasons why students misbehave (reframing)
- Monitoring their own thoughts
- Taking care of their own emotional health
6. Student Responsibility: Cultivating Self-Governance
Self-discipline connotes internal motivation for one’s behavior, the internalization of democratic ideals, and is most evident when external regulations of behavior are absent.
Empowering students. Students should be given the message that they are responsible for their own behavior and provided with strategies and training to realize that control. This involves fostering self-discipline, self-management, self-regulation, and social skills.
Strategies for teaching responsibility:
- Classroom meetings
- Using a language of responsibility
- Written statements of belief
- Written self-analyses
Self-monitoring and control. Self-monitoring and control strategies involve teaching students to observe their own behavior, record it, compare it with a criterion, and reward their success. Cognitively based strategies involve examining one's thoughts, considering consequences, and selecting the most effective course of action.
7. Starting Strong: Setting the Tone from Day One
The beginning of the school year is an important time for classroom management because your students will learn behavior, attitudes, and work habits that will affect the rest of the year.
First impressions matter. The beginning of the school year is a critical time to set the tone for classroom management. What you do that first day sets a tone that can carry you through the rest of the year. This involves:
- Arranging and decorating the room to support effective management
- Beginning with a strong first day of class
- Emphasizing classroom management for the first few days
Room arrangement and decoration. The way you arrange and decorate your classroom communicates a great deal to students. The emphasis should be on functionality, creating a "learning" environment rather than a "pretty" environment.
First-day activities. On the first day of class, it's important to:
- Greet students warmly
- Present and discuss classroom rules and procedures
- Engage students in activities that convey a sense of the content and activities they will be engaged in
8. School-Level Management: A Unified Front
At all public school grade levels, effective classroom management has been recognized as a crucial element in effective teaching.
Beyond the classroom. Effective management extends beyond individual classrooms to encompass the entire school. School-level management provides the larger context in which classroom management takes place. This involves:
- Establishing rules and procedures for behavioral problems caused by the school's physical characteristics or routines
- Establishing clear schoolwide rules and procedures regarding specific types of misbehavior
- Establishing and enforcing appropriate consequences for specific types of misbehavior
- Establishing a system that allows for the early detection of students who have high potentials for violence and extreme behaviors
- Adopting a schoolwide management program
Ecological interventions. Ecological interventions are rules and procedures that counteract possible negative consequences of the school's physical characteristics or schedule. These interventions aim to prevent problems before they arise.
Schoolwide programs. Adopting a schoolwide management program communicates a strong sense of solidarity among school staff regarding management. This requires teachers to agree on a set of actions and strategies that all of them will use.
Last updated:
FAQ
1. What is Classroom Management That Works by Robert J. Marzano about?
- Research-based classroom management: The book synthesizes findings from over 100 studies to present effective, research-backed strategies for managing classrooms.
- Comprehensive framework: Marzano outlines a holistic approach, covering rules, procedures, disciplinary interventions, teacher-student relationships, mental set, student responsibility, and school-level management.
- Goal of the book: The primary aim is to help teachers create safe, orderly, and respectful learning environments that maximize student achievement and minimize disruptions.
2. Why should I read Classroom Management That Works by Robert J. Marzano?
- Evidence-based guidance: The book offers practical strategies grounded in extensive research and meta-analyses, ensuring recommendations are both effective and actionable.
- Addresses real classroom challenges: Marzano provides solutions for common issues like disruptive behavior, unclear rules, and teacher stress.
- Supports teacher well-being: Techniques for managing teacher stress and maintaining a positive mental set are included, promoting sustained classroom success.
3. What are the key takeaways from Classroom Management That Works by Robert J. Marzano?
- Teacher impact is critical: Effective classroom management is foundational to student learning and achievement, with the teacher being the most influential factor.
- Comprehensive management strategies: The book emphasizes the importance of clear rules, consistent procedures, positive relationships, and emotional objectivity.
- Student responsibility and schoolwide systems: Encourages student self-regulation and highlights the importance of school-level management for a cohesive environment.
4. What are the main components of effective classroom management according to Marzano?
- Rules and procedures: Clearly defined and consistently enforced rules and routines establish order and predictability.
- Disciplinary interventions: Balanced use of positive and negative consequences, including strategies like Think Time and group contingencies, effectively reduce disruptions.
- Teacher-student relationships and mental set: Building positive relationships and maintaining emotional objectivity are essential for managing behavior.
5. How does Robert J. Marzano define and emphasize the importance of "mental set" in classroom management?
- Definition of mental set: Mental set refers to a teacher’s mindfulness, situational awareness (“withitness”), and emotional objectivity in the classroom.
- Withitness: Being aware of all classroom happenings and intervening early to prevent disruptions is crucial for effective management.
- Emotional objectivity: Responding to misbehavior calmly and professionally, without personalizing student actions, helps maintain control and a positive environment.
6. What strategies does Classroom Management That Works recommend for establishing classroom rules and procedures?
- Early and explicit teaching: Introduce and practice rules and procedures from the first days of school to make them routine.
- Student involvement: Involving students in creating or discussing rules increases their ownership and compliance.
- Consistency and reinforcement: Enforce rules consistently and acknowledge positive behaviors to reinforce expectations.
7. What disciplinary interventions does Marzano recommend in Classroom Management That Works?
- Balanced approach: Use a mix of teacher reactions, tangible recognition, direct costs (like time out), group contingencies, and home contingencies.
- Think Time strategy: Have students reflect on their behavior in a separate space, followed by debriefing and self-analysis.
- Self-monitoring and cognitive strategies: Teach students to observe and record their own behavior, recognize emotions, and choose positive responses.
8. How does Classroom Management That Works by Marzano address the importance of teacher-student relationships?
- Critical for management: Positive, cooperative, and appropriately dominant relationships reduce disruptions and foster a supportive learning environment.
- Balance dominance and cooperation: Effective teachers combine clear leadership with genuine concern for students, avoiding extremes.
- Adapt to student needs: Tailor relationship-building strategies to different student types, such as passive, aggressive, or attention-challenged students.
9. What advice does Marzano give for handling high-need students in Classroom Management That Works?
- Identify student categories: Recognize high-need students, including passive, aggressive, attention-problem, perfectionist, and socially inept types.
- Tailored interventions: Use individualized strategies like private conversations, behavior charts, and positive reinforcement to address unique needs.
- Build trust and consistency: Establish empathetic, consistent interactions to foster trust and improve engagement.
10. How does Marzano recommend teachers develop and maintain "withitness" in classroom management?
- Definition and importance: Withitness is the teacher’s ability to be aware of everything happening in the classroom and to intervene early.
- Practical strategies: Regularly scan the room, make eye contact, move around, and respond immediately to potential issues.
- Impact on disruptions: Withitness has the largest effect size in reducing classroom disruptions, making it a vital skill.
11. What role does student responsibility play in classroom management according to Classroom Management That Works?
- Students as partners: Students should be responsible for their own behavior and be taught self-discipline and self-regulation strategies.
- Teaching social skills: Programs like the Child Development Project and I Can Problem Solve help students develop pro-social behaviors.
- Self-analysis and accountability: Tools such as classroom meetings and written self-reflections encourage students to take ownership of their actions.
12. What is the significance of school-level management and ecological interventions in Marzano’s approach?
- Schoolwide environment: School-level management sets the context for individual classrooms, influencing climate and behavior.
- Consistent rules and early intervention: Establishing and enforcing schoolwide rules and identifying at-risk students early promotes safety and order.
- Ecological interventions: Adjusting physical environments and schedules (e.g., traffic flow, recess times) helps prevent misbehavior and maintain a positive school climate.
Review Summary
Classroom Management That Works receives mixed reviews, with an average rating of 3.71/5. Some praise its research-based approach and practical strategies for new teachers, while others find it outdated and lacking fresh insights for experienced educators. Readers appreciate the clear organization and action steps but criticize the reliance on older data. Many suggest it's most useful for novice teachers or as a refresher. Some reviewers highlight its value in understanding classroom management fundamentals, while others recommend more current resources for professional development.
About the Author
Other books by Robert J. Marzano
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
