Plot Summary
Plotting in the Garden
Leonie, Chrissy, and Myrna, three aging friends, gather in Leonie's backyard, sipping drinks and reminiscing about their college days. They discuss a plan to murder several men who wronged their friend Fern years ago. The conversation is light-hearted yet serious, as they debate methods of murder, from pushing out windows to poisoning. The women are driven by a desire to avenge Fern, who was deeply hurt by these men. Despite the grim topic, the scene is filled with humor and irony, highlighting their close bond and shared history.
Revenge Plans Unfold
The women continue to discuss their revenge and redemption plot, with Myrna expressing doubts about the feasibility of their plans. Leonie, however, is determined to proceed, suggesting they make the murders look like accidents. Chrissy, with her theatrical background, adds a touch of drama to the conversation. The friends are motivated by a sense of justice for Fern, who was ostracized by a group of male writers led by Humphrey Vacher. The chapter explores themes of loyalty, aging, and the desire for retribution.
Fern's Past Haunts
Fern, once a successful writer, was targeted by Humphrey and his followers after excluding him from an anthology. The relentless criticism damaged her reputation and confidence, leading to her physical and emotional decline. The friends feel guilty for not defending Fern earlier and are now driven to act on her behalf. This chapter delves into the impact of public shaming and the long-lasting effects of betrayal, as well as the complexities of friendship and guilt.
The Apology List
The friends compile a list of the men involved in Fern's downfall, noting which ones have apologized. Four have expressed regret, but the others remain unapologetic. This list becomes a guide for their revenge and redemption plot, as they decide to target the non-apologizers first. The chapter highlights the theme of accountability and the moral dilemmas faced by the women as they grapple with their desire for justice versus the reality of their actions.
Chrissy's Brownie Blunder
Chrissy takes the lead in executing their first revenge and redemption attempt by delivering Ex-Lax-laced brownies to one of the non-apologetic men, Stephen. However, she mistakenly targets the wrong Stephen, who has already apologized to Fern. The encounter is awkward, and Chrissy ends up consuming the brownies herself. This chapter adds a comedic element to the story, illustrating the challenges and absurdities of their revenge plot.
Humphrey's Decline
The friends learn that Humphrey, the instigator of Fern's public shaming, is suffering from Parkinson's disease. This revelation complicates their feelings of anger and revenge, as they grapple with the idea of targeting someone who is already facing his own decline. The chapter explores themes of empathy, justice, and the passage of time and change, as the women reconsider their plans in light of Humphrey's condition.
A Failed Scheme
The friends' attempts to sabotage Humphrey's reputation by turning his books around in bookstores prove futile, as they discover his works are no longer in stock. This anticlimactic realization forces them to confront the futility of their revenge plot and the passage of time and change that has rendered their grievances obsolete. The chapter underscores the themes of aging, change, and the fleeting nature of fame and influence.
Bookstore Revelations
Despite their failed attempts at revenge and redemption, the friends find solace in the fact that Fern's books are prominently displayed in bookstores, while Humphrey's are forgotten. This discovery brings a sense of closure and vindication, as they realize that Fern's legacy has outlasted her detractors. The chapter concludes with a reflection on the power of resilience and the enduring impact of genuine talent and kindness.
Characters
Leonie
Leonie is the driving force behind the revenge and redemption plot, motivated by a fierce loyalty to Fern. Her flamboyant personality and determination to see justice served contrast with her declining health, adding urgency to her actions. Leonie's character embodies themes of friendship, loyalty, and the complexities of aging, as she navigates her own mortality while seeking retribution for past wrongs.
Chrissy
Chrissy brings a touch of drama and humor and irony to the group, with her background in amateur theater influencing her approach to the revenge and redemption plot. Her impulsive nature leads to comedic mishaps, such as the brownie blunder, highlighting her well-meaning but often misguided attempts to help Fern. Chrissy's character explores themes of identity, aging, and the challenges of maintaining relevance in a changing world.
Myrna
Myrna is the voice of reason within the group, often questioning the feasibility and morality of their plans. Her analytical nature and academic background provide a counterbalance to Leonie's boldness and Chrissy's impulsiveness. Myrna's character delves into themes of guilt, responsibility, and the struggle to reconcile past inaction with present desires for justice.
Fern
Fern is the catalyst for the revenge and redemption plot, having suffered public humiliation and professional setbacks due to Humphrey's campaign against her. Despite her physical decline, Fern remains a symbol of resilience and grace, inspiring her friends to seek justice on her behalf. Her character explores themes of betrayal, forgiveness, and the enduring impact of genuine talent and kindness.
Humphrey Vacher
Humphrey is the mastermind behind Fern's public shaming, driven by jealousy and a sense of entitlement. His decline due to Parkinson's disease adds complexity to his character, as the friends grapple with their feelings of anger and empathy. Humphrey's character embodies themes of power, influence, and the consequences of unchecked ambition.
Plot Devices
Revenge and Redemption
The central plot device is the friends' quest for revenge on behalf of Fern, which serves as a catalyst for the story's events. This device explores themes of justice, loyalty, and the moral complexities of retribution, as the women navigate their own motivations and the consequences of their actions. The narrative structure is driven by their evolving plans and the challenges they face in executing them.
Humor and Irony
Humor and irony are woven throughout the story, providing a counterbalance to the darker themes of revenge and betrayal. The friends' comedic mishaps and witty banter add levity to the narrative, highlighting the absurdity of their situation and the challenges of aging. This device enhances the story's engagement and accessibility, making it both thought-provoking and entertaining.
Time and Change
The passage of time and change is a key plot device, influencing the characters' motivations and the story's resolution. As the friends confront their own mortality and the changing world around them, they grapple with the relevance of their grievances and the impact of their actions. This device underscores themes of aging, resilience, and the enduring power of genuine talent and kindness.
Analysis
"Cut and Thirst" delves into the complexities of friendship and loyalty, as three women navigate their desire for justice on behalf of their wronged friend, Fern. The narrative explores the moral dilemmas of revenge and redemption, highlighting the challenges of reconciling past inaction with present desires for retribution. Through humor and irony, the story examines the absurdities of aging and the fleeting nature of fame and influence. Ultimately, the book underscores the enduring power of resilience and genuine talent, as Fern's legacy outlasts her detractors. The story invites readers to reflect on the impact of betrayal, the passage of time and change, and the importance of forgiveness and empathy in the face of adversity.
Last updated:
Questions & Answers
What is Cut and Thirst about?
- Aging friends seek revenge: Three older women, Leonie, Chrissy, and Myrna, plot to avenge their friend Fern, who was publicly shamed by a group of male writers years ago.
- Humorous yet dark: The story blends dark humor and irony with serious themes of aging, betrayal, and the desire for justice, as the women comically plan and attempt their revenge and redemption.
- Focus on female friendship: The narrative explores the complexities of long-term female friendships, highlighting their loyalty, shared history, and individual quirks.
Why should I read Cut and Thirst?
- Unique blend of genres: The story combines elements of dark comedy, mystery, and social commentary, offering a fresh and engaging reading experience.
- Exploration of complex themes: It delves into themes of aging, revenge and redemption, justice, and the lasting impact of betrayal, prompting reflection on these issues.
- Compelling female characters: The story features well-developed, relatable female characters who challenge stereotypes about older women, making it a refreshing read.
What is the background of Cut and Thirst?
- Literary world setting: The story is set within the backdrop of the literary world, exploring the dynamics of writers, critics, and the publishing industry.
- Cultural context of academia: It touches upon the changing landscape of academia, including the challenges faced by professors and the impact of social media on public discourse.
- Contemporary urban setting: The story unfolds in a modern urban environment, with references to gentrification, technology, and contemporary social issues.
What are the most memorable quotes in Cut and Thirst?
- "Revenge is a dish best eaten cold": This quote, spoken by Myrna, encapsulates the central theme of the story and the women's long-held desire for retribution.
- "We want them to feel the hoofbeats of doom approaching": This line, also from Myrna, highlights the psychological aspect of their revenge and redemption, aiming to instill fear in their targets.
- "Cut and thirst!": Chrissy's misremembered line from a play, "cut and thrust," becomes a darkly humorous motif, symbolizing their violent intentions and the need for a drink afterwards.
What writing style, narrative choices, and literary techniques does Margaret Atwood use?
- Conversational and witty tone: Atwood employs a conversational and witty tone, making the story engaging and accessible, even when dealing with dark themes.
- Third-person limited perspective: The narrative primarily follows Myrna's perspective, providing insight into her thoughts and feelings while maintaining a degree of narrative distance.
- Use of literary allusions: Atwood incorporates literary allusions and references, enriching the text and adding layers of meaning, particularly through Myrna's character.
Hidden Details & Subtle Connections
What are some minor details that add significant meaning?
- The apple tree and umbrella: Leonie's apple tree and red umbrella symbolize her ongoing battle with mortality and her attempts to defend herself from the inevitable.
- Chrissy's pastel colors: Chrissy's preference for lavender and aqua, along with her dingly bracelets, highlight her attempts to maintain a youthful and innocent persona, despite her involvement in the revenge and redemption plot.
- Myrna's shrinking height and growing feet: Myrna's physical changes, such as shrinking height and growing feet, subtly reflect her feelings of aging and the changing nature of her body.
What are some subtle foreshadowing and callbacks?
- Macbeth references: The early discussion of the "Scottish play" and the cauldron scene foreshadows the women's own plotting and the potential for their plans to go awry.
- Chrissy's fencing experience: Chrissy's past fencing experience, initially a throwaway detail, becomes significant when she proposes using her foil as a murder weapon.
- The "cut and thirst" misquote: Chrissy's misremembered line, "cut and thirst," is a callback to her theatrical past and foreshadows the violent nature of their revenge and redemption plans.
What are some unexpected character connections?
- Chrissy and the wrong Stephen: Chrissy's past connection with both Stephens, and her mistaken targeting of the wrong one, reveals the complexities of memory and the passage of time and change.
- Rhoda's kindness: The unexpected kindness of Rhoda, the wrong Stephen's wife, highlights the potential for empathy and forgiveness, even in the face of past wrongs.
- The shared literary past: The shared literary past of the three friends and their connection to the men they are targeting reveals the interconnectedness of their lives and the literary world.
Who are the most significant supporting characters?
- Fern: Though largely absent, Fern is the catalyst for the entire plot, her past suffering and present vulnerability driving the women's actions.
- Gervais: Fern's deceased husband, Gervais, is a significant presence, his anger and desire for justice influencing the women's feelings and motivations.
- Nancy: Nancy, the owner of the cheese shop, is a minor but recurring character, representing a reliable and consistent presence in the women's lives.
Psychological, Emotional, & Relational Analysis
What are some unspoken motivations of the characters?
- Leonie's fear of death: Leonie's determination to carry out the revenge and redemption plot may be driven by her fear of death and a desire to leave a lasting impact.
- Chrissy's need for relevance: Chrissy's impulsive actions and desire to be involved in the plot may stem from a need to feel relevant and useful in her aging years.
- Myrna's guilt and responsibility: Myrna's skepticism and analytical approach may be a way of coping with her guilt over not acting sooner to defend Fern.
What psychological complexities do the characters exhibit?
- Leonie's denial of illness: Leonie's flippant attitude towards her health and her excessive drinking reveal a denial of her own mortality.
- Chrissy's performative nature: Chrissy's theatrical background and her tendency to play a role highlight her complex relationship with her own identity.
- Myrna's internal conflict: Myrna's internal conflict between her desire for justice and her skepticism about their plans reveals her struggle with moral ambiguity.
What are the major emotional turning points?
- The discovery of Humphrey's illness: The revelation of Humphrey's Parkinson's disease forces the women to confront their feelings of anger and empathy, leading to a shift in their plans.
- Chrissy's encounter with the wrong Stephen: Chrissy's awkward encounter with the wrong Stephen and his wife forces her to confront the absurdity of their revenge and redemption plot.
- The bookstore revelation: The discovery that Humphrey's books are out of print and that Fern's are prominently displayed brings a sense of closure and vindication.
How do relationship dynamics evolve?
- Shared history and loyalty: The women's long-term friendship is characterized by a deep sense of loyalty and shared history, which drives their desire to avenge Fern.
- Individual quirks and differences: Despite their shared goal, the women's individual quirks and differences in personality create tension and humor and irony within the group.
- Shifting power dynamics: The power dynamics within the group shift throughout the story, with Leonie initially taking the lead, but Chrissy and Myrna also asserting their influence.
Interpretation & Debate
Which parts of the story remain ambiguous or open-ended?
- The true extent of Fern's suffering: The story leaves open the question of how deeply Fern was affected by the attacks and whether she truly forgives her tormentors.
- The effectiveness of their actions: The story does not definitively state whether their actions had any real impact on the men they targeted, leaving the reader to question the nature of justice.
- The women's future: The story ends without revealing what the women will do next, leaving their future open to interpretation and speculation.
What are some debatable, controversial scenes or moments in Cut and Thirst?
- The morality of their revenge and redemption plot: The women's decision to seek revenge, even if it is not lethal, raises questions about the morality of their actions and the nature of justice.
- Chrissy's use of seduction: Chrissy's plan to use seduction to lure Stephen raises questions about the ethics of using her sexuality as a weapon.
- The comedic treatment of serious themes: The story's use of humor and irony to address serious themes like revenge and mortality may be seen as controversial or inappropriate by some readers.
Cut and Thirst Ending Explained: How It Ends & What It Means
- Anticlimactic revenge: The ending is anticlimactic, with the women's attempts at revenge and redemption ultimately failing, highlighting the futility of their actions.
- Fern's enduring legacy: The ending emphasizes Fern's enduring legacy, as her books are prominently displayed while Humphrey's are forgotten, suggesting that true talent and kindness prevail.
- Acceptance and moving on: The ending suggests that the women have come to terms with the passage of time and change and the changing nature of their lives, finding a sense of closure and acceptance.
Review Summary
Cut and Thirst received mixed reviews, with an average rating of 3.13 out of 5. Many readers appreciated Atwood's wit and humor, enjoying the dialogue between the elderly women plotting revenge. However, some found the short story format limiting, wanting more character development and a stronger ending. Critics praised Atwood's sharp writing and themes of aging and friendship but noted that some social commentary felt dated. Overall, readers found it a quick, entertaining read, though some desired more depth and a more satisfying conclusion.
Similar Books
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub
digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.