Key Takeaways
1. Sondheim's Art: Mirrors to Our Lives
His works understand us as much as we understand them.
Beyond Clever Lyrics. Sondheim's genius transcends mere lyrical wit and musical complexity. His works possess a unique ability to resonate deeply with individual experiences, reflecting personal struggles and triumphs. This intimate connection transforms his musicals from entertainment into profound explorations of the human condition.
Deconstructing Life. Sondheim's art doesn't offer easy answers or neatly packaged solutions. Instead, it dismantles life's complexities, laying bare its inherent confusion and disarray. This deconstruction allows audiences to confront the raw, unfiltered realities of existence, fostering a deeper understanding of themselves and the world around them.
Rite of Passage. Sondheim's musicals are not mere escapism but rather a rite of passage, an induction into adulthood. His works confront the terrors and joys of life, its conflicts and concords, its mysteries and banalities. This unflinching honesty resonates with audiences seeking a deeper understanding of themselves and their place in the world.
2. The Audience Comes First: Sondheim's Hard-Learned Lesson
Musical theatre audiences are a forgiving bunch, but one thing they won’t forgive is “being made asses of.”
Anyone Can Whistle's Failure. Sondheim's early flop, "Anyone Can Whistle," taught him a crucial lesson about the importance of respecting the audience. The show's satirical and absurdist elements, while innovative, ultimately alienated viewers by mocking their expectations and intelligence.
The "Simple" Scene. The infamous "Simple" scene, which ended with the cast laughing at the audience, exemplified this misstep. While intended as a clever commentary on societal conformity, it backfired, leaving audiences feeling insulted and resentful.
Hammerstein's Influence. Sondheim's mentor, Oscar Hammerstein, emphasized the importance of connecting with the audience and delivering a meaningful message. "Anyone Can Whistle" served as a stark reminder that artistic vision must be balanced with audience consideration to achieve true impact.
3. Unmet Needs: The Ghosts Haunting "Gypsy"
The greatest burden placed on a child is the unlived life of the parent.
Rose's Frustrated Dreams. "Gypsy" explores the damaging effects of a parent's unfulfilled ambitions on their children. Madame Rose, driven by her own thwarted dreams of stardom, relentlessly pushes her daughters onto the vaudeville stage, sacrificing their well-being for her own vicarious gratification.
Louise's Sacrificial Lamb. Louise, initially overshadowed by her sister June, becomes the primary target of Rose's ambition after June's departure. Louise's identity is subsumed by her mother's desires, leaving her feeling invisible and unloved.
Breaking the Cycle. The musical culminates in Louise's transformation into Gypsy Rose Lee, a moment of self-discovery that allows her to break free from her mother's control and embrace her own identity. This act of self-actualization offers a glimmer of hope for transcending the cycle of unmet needs and familial trauma.
4. Intimacy's Terrors: "Company's" Urban Loneliness
Loneliness, then, is less the withdrawal of others than the withdrawal of the intimacy that others could offer, and that we could offer them.
Bobby's Detachment. "Company" delves into the complexities of modern relationships and the fear of commitment. Bobby, the perpetual bachelor, struggles to connect with others on a meaningful level, maintaining a detached and emotionally unavailable persona.
The Married Couples' Ambivalence. Bobby's married friends, while seemingly content, harbor their own anxieties and regrets about commitment. Their ambivalence towards marriage reflects the challenges of maintaining intimacy and navigating the complexities of long-term relationships.
Joanne's Provocation. Joanne, the cynical and world-weary observer, serves as a catalyst for Bobby's emotional growth. Her blunt honesty and unconventional approach force him to confront his own fears and desires, ultimately leading him towards a greater understanding of himself and the importance of genuine connection.
5. Reunions and Regrets: "Follies'" Haunting Pasts
Most people have one foot in the past and one foot in present.
The Weismann Follies Reunion. "Follies" explores the corrosive power of nostalgia and the difficulty of escaping the past. The reunion of former Weismann Girls serves as a catalyst for confronting long-buried regrets and unresolved conflicts.
Sally and Ben's Obsessions. Sally and Ben, two former lovers, are haunted by their past choices and the roads they didn't take. Their inability to move on from their youthful infatuation perpetuates their unhappiness and prevents them from finding fulfillment in the present.
Phyllis's Self-Discovery. Phyllis, trapped in a loveless marriage, undergoes a journey of self-discovery, confronting the sacrifices she made to conform to societal expectations. Her eventual embrace of her fragmented self offers a glimmer of hope for transcending the limitations of the past.
6. Regret and Redemption: "A Little Night Music's" Delicate Balance
The profoundest wish we can have for someone (ourselves included) is that they be that someone, naked in soul and spirit in the way that a stripper is naked in the flesh.
Desiree's "Send in the Clowns". "A Little Night Music" explores the complexities of love, loss, and regret. Desirée Armfeldt's poignant ballad, "Send in the Clowns," encapsulates the show's central theme of missed opportunities and the bittersweet acceptance of life's imperfections.
The Quintet's Commentary. The quintet of singers acts as a Greek chorus, offering cynical commentary on the characters' romantic entanglements. Their presence underscores the show's exploration of societal expectations and the illusion of perfect love.
Petra's Appetite for Life. Petra, the pragmatic serving maid, embodies a zest for life and a rejection of societal constraints. Her song, "The Miller's Son," celebrates the pursuit of pleasure and the acceptance of life's inherent imperfections.
7. History's Fragments: "Pacific Overtures'" Perspective
The people who truly own a musical theatre song are neither those who write it nor those who perform it.
Commodore Perry's Arrival. "Pacific Overtures" challenges traditional historical narratives by presenting the story of Commodore Perry's arrival in Japan from the Japanese perspective. This shift in viewpoint reveals the complexities of cultural exchange and the lasting impact of Western imperialism.
"Someone in a Tree's" Elusive Truth. The song "Someone in a Tree" encapsulates the show's exploration of historical interpretation. The song highlights the difficulty of obtaining a complete and unbiased account of the past, as individual perspectives are always limited and subjective.
The Reciter's Role. The Reciter serves as a guide through the complexities of Japanese history, offering commentary and challenging the audience to question their own assumptions about the past. His presence underscores the show's exploration of cultural identity and the power of storytelling.
8. The Allure and Peril of Revenge: "Sweeney Todd's" Dark Reflection
The greatest burden placed on a child is the unlived life of the parent.
Benjamin Barker's Transformation. "Sweeney Todd" explores the destructive nature of revenge and the corrosive effects of injustice. Benjamin Barker's transformation into Sweeney Todd, the Demon Barber of Fleet Street, is driven by a thirst for vengeance that consumes his humanity.
Mrs. Lovett's Complicity. Mrs. Lovett, Sweeney's accomplice, represents the banality of evil and the ease with which individuals can become complicit in acts of violence. Her pragmatic approach to Sweeney's murderous impulses underscores the show's exploration of societal corruption and moral decay.
The Cycle of Violence. The musical culminates in a bloodbath, highlighting the futility of revenge and the cyclical nature of violence. Sweeney's inability to escape his past leads to his ultimate destruction, serving as a cautionary tale about the dangers of unchecked rage and the pursuit of vengeance.
9. The Price of Lost Innocence: "Merrily We Roll Along's" Backward Glance
The heaviest burden for a child to bear is the psychological distress felt by a parent, because all that distress gets pushed onto them.
The Loss of Ideals. "Merrily We Roll Along" charts the disillusionment of three friends as they navigate the complexities of adulthood. Their youthful ideals and artistic aspirations are gradually eroded by ambition, compromise, and the pursuit of success.
The Corrosive Effects of Compromise. Frank, the talented composer, sacrifices his artistic integrity for commercial success, becoming a wealthy but unfulfilled Hollywood producer. His betrayal of his friends and his artistic vision underscores the show's exploration of the price of ambition.
The Power of Regret. The musical's backward narrative structure allows the audience to witness the characters' journey from cynicism to idealism, highlighting the poignant contrast between their youthful dreams and their adult realities. This structure emphasizes the enduring power of regret and the importance of staying true to one's values.
10. The Artist Within: "Sunday in the Park with George's" Creative Spark
The artist, to be an artist, must “give us more to see.”
Georges' Artistic Vision. "Sunday in the Park with George" explores the creative process and the sacrifices required to achieve artistic greatness. Georges, the meticulous painter, is consumed by his art, often at the expense of his personal relationships.
Dot's Inspiration. Dot, Georges' muse and lover, represents the human connection and emotional depth that Georges often struggles to express. Her presence challenges him to see beyond the technical aspects of his art and to embrace the complexities of human experience.
The Legacy of Art. The musical culminates in a celebration of artistic legacy, highlighting the enduring power of art to connect generations and to inspire new forms of creative expression. Georges's great-grandson, George, inherits his artistic spirit, carrying on his legacy in a new and innovative way.
11. Empathy for the Damned: "Assassins'" Troubled Souls
The formal tributes to Sondheim began within days of his passing.
The Assassins' Humanity. "Assassins" challenges audiences to confront the humanity of individuals who have committed heinous acts. By exploring the motivations and circumstances that led these figures to violence, the musical forces us to grapple with the complexities of human nature and the potential for darkness within us all.
The Balladeer's Perspective. The Balladeer serves as a voice of reason and historical context, offering a counterpoint to the assassins' distorted perspectives. His presence underscores the importance of critical thinking and the dangers of romanticizing violence.
The Power of Connection. The musical culminates in a plea for connection and understanding, urging audiences to recognize the shared humanity that binds us together, even in the face of unspeakable acts. This message of empathy and compassion offers a glimmer of hope for transcending the cycle of violence and division.
12. The Necessity of Love: "Passion's" Unconventional Wisdom
Sondheim’s theatrical worlds open our eyes to our own world.
Fosca's Unconventional Love. "Passion" challenges conventional notions of love and beauty, exploring the transformative power of obsession and the redemptive potential of human connection. Fosca, the sickly and unconventional heroine, embodies a fierce and unwavering love that defies societal expectations.
Giorgio's Transformation. Giorgio, initially repulsed by Fosca's intensity, undergoes a gradual transformation, learning to see beyond her physical appearance and to appreciate the depth of her emotional capacity. His journey highlights the importance of empathy and the potential for love to transcend superficiality.
The Power of Acceptance. The musical culminates in a celebration of love in its most unconventional and challenging forms, urging audiences to embrace the complexities of human relationships and to recognize the transformative power of acceptance and compassion.
Last updated:
Review Summary
How Sondheim Can Change Your Life explores Stephen Sondheim's musicals, analyzing their themes and life lessons. Many readers appreciated the deep dive into Sondheim's work, finding new insights and connections. Some felt the academic approach occasionally diminished the joy of the shows, while others found it enlightening. The book resonated strongly with Sondheim fans, though a few disagreed with certain interpretations. Overall, readers found it a thoughtful examination of Sondheim's genius, offering both theatrical analysis and personal reflections on how his work impacts audiences.