Key Takeaways
1. Math is About Asking "Why," Not Just "What"
Too many people are being made to feel stupid for asking questions about maths that sound basic but are actually important and profound.
Beyond Rote Memorization. The essence of mathematics lies not in blindly accepting rules and formulas, but in questioning their origins and justifications. A true mathematical impulse is to immediately want to break all the rules, or find sneaky situations in which those rules don’t hold, to show that the supposed authority figure doesn’t have quite as much authority as they think. This spirit of inquiry is what drives mathematical understanding and innovation.
Challenging Assumptions. Instead of passively accepting mathematical "facts," we should actively seek to understand their underlying principles. This involves asking "why" at every step, even when the answers seem obvious. For example, questioning why 1 + 1 = 2 leads to a deeper exploration of numbers, arithmetic, and their applications in various contexts.
Cultivating Curiosity. By encouraging questions and validating the desire to understand more, we can foster a more engaging and meaningful relationship with mathematics. This approach transforms math from a rigid set of rules into a dynamic exploration of ideas and their connections to the world around us.
2. Abstraction: Simplifying the World to Understand It
The point is to encapsulate one aspect of the world around us so that we can be done with that part as fast as possible, leaving the more interesting part of our brain to deal with the more exciting parts of the world.
Ignoring the Hard Parts. Abstraction involves temporarily setting aside certain details of a situation to focus on the most relevant aspects. This simplification allows us to identify patterns, make connections, and develop a deeper understanding of the underlying principles at play.
Numbers as Abstractions. Numbers are a prime example of abstraction, representing a simplified way of quantifying the world around us. By ignoring the specific qualities of objects (e.g., applehood, banananess), we can focus on their quantity and develop a system of arithmetic that applies universally.
Abstraction's Purpose. The goal of abstraction is not to make things boring, but to free up our cognitive resources for more creative and imaginative pursuits. By simplifying the building blocks of our understanding, we can construct more complex and nuanced models of the world.
3. Math is a Cyclical Process of Discovery and Refinement
Mathematics is the logical study of how logical things work.
Beyond the Textbook. Mathematics is not a static body of knowledge, but a dynamic and evolving field. It involves a cyclical process of exploration, abstraction, and refinement, where new methods lead to new discoveries, which in turn lead to new methods.
The Spiral Staircase. This cyclical process can be visualized as a spiral staircase, where each step represents a new level of understanding. We begin with basic concepts like numbers, then move on to shapes, symmetry, and more abstract ideas, constantly building upon and refining our knowledge.
Logic and Abstraction. The cyclical nature of math is driven by the interplay between logic and abstraction. We use logic to study abstract concepts, and then use those concepts to develop new logical tools, creating a continuous feedback loop that propels mathematical progress.
4. Math is About Finding Connections and Relationships
Maths instead says: let’s work out what those contexts are and what they mean.
Beyond Formulas. Mathematics is not just about memorizing formulas and solving equations, but about identifying relationships between different concepts and situations. This involves looking for similarities, analogies, and connections that can help us understand the world more deeply.
Finding Sameness. Finding a sense in which things are the same is a starting point, a launch pad for us to be able to study different things at once, as when we first move into the world of numbers. This allows us to apply existing knowledge to new problems and develop more general solutions.
Finding Differences. It's equally important to identify the differences between things, so that we don't try and push analogies further than is appropriate. This nuanced approach helps us avoid oversimplification and develop a more accurate understanding of the world.
5. Logic is the Framework, Not the Limit
Maths is not about ‘getting the right answer’, it’s about building arguments backing up an answer.
The Framework of Truth. Logic serves as the foundation for mathematical reasoning, providing a framework for determining the validity of arguments and conclusions. However, logic is not the only aspect of mathematics.
Beyond Binary Logic. While mathematical logic is often binary (true or false), the application of logic in real-world situations is more nuanced. We must consider the context, assumptions, and limitations of our models, and be willing to adapt our thinking as new information emerges.
Justifications, Not Answers. The focus of mathematics should be on building strong justifications for our claims, rather than simply seeking the "right answer." This involves showing our working, explaining our reasoning, and being able to defend our conclusions against scrutiny.
6. Math is Driven by Curiosity and a Desire for Deeper Understanding
Maths comes from wanting to understand things better.
The Spark of Inquiry. Mathematics originates from a deep-seated human curiosity and a desire to understand the world around us. It's about asking "why" and "how," not just accepting things as they are.
Beyond Usefulness. While mathematics has many practical applications, its primary motivation is the pursuit of knowledge and understanding for its own sake. This intrinsic motivation is what drives mathematicians to explore new ideas, develop new theories, and push the boundaries of human knowledge.
Embracing Confusion. Confusion and uncertainty are not signs of failure, but rather opportunities for growth and discovery. By embracing these feelings and persisting in our efforts to understand, we can unlock new insights and develop a deeper appreciation for the beauty and complexity of mathematics.
7. Visual Representation is a Powerful Tool for Understanding
I love it when children wonder how many sides a circle has: is it none (because there are no straight edges), one (all the way round) or infinitely many little tiny ones?
Beyond Equations. Visual representations, such as diagrams, graphs, and geometric models, can provide valuable insights into mathematical concepts. These representations can help us see patterns, make connections, and develop a more intuitive understanding of abstract ideas.
Different Perspectives. Different visual representations can highlight different aspects of a mathematical concept. By exploring multiple representations, we can gain a more complete and nuanced understanding of the underlying structure.
Visuals in Research. Visual representations are not just for beginners, but are also used by advanced researchers to explore complex mathematical structures. In fields like category theory, diagrams are an essential tool for reasoning and communicating ideas.
8. Math is a Tool for Building and Progress, but Progress Must Be Questioned
I’m convinced that strengthening our connections is crucial if we want to loosen the grip that white patriarchy has over society.
Building Blocks. Mathematics provides a framework for building complex systems of thought, where each concept builds upon previous ones. This allows us to develop increasingly sophisticated models of the world and make progress in various fields.
The Colonialist Undertones. The pursuit of mathematical progress is not without its ethical considerations. We must be mindful of the potential for mathematics to be used for harmful purposes, such as developing weapons or perpetuating social inequalities.
Ethnomathematics. It's important to recognize and value different mathematical traditions, including those that have been marginalized or overlooked by mainstream academia. This involves challenging the dominant narrative of mathematical progress and acknowledging the contributions of diverse cultures.
9. Letters in Math: Succinctness, Generalization, and Relationships
I was fine with maths, until the numbers turned into letters …’
Succinctness. Using letters in math allows us to express complex relationships in a concise and efficient manner. This is especially useful when dealing with general principles that apply to a wide range of numbers or situations.
Generalization. Letters enable us to make statements that are true for all numbers, rather than just specific examples. This allows us to develop more powerful and versatile mathematical tools.
Relationships. Letters help us to express relationships between different quantities, even when we don't know their specific values. This is essential for solving equations, modeling real-world phenomena, and exploring abstract mathematical structures.
10. Formulas: Explanations, Not Just Equations
I want to help you see that the reasons people are put off maths are really unfortunate and not based in the true nature of maths.
Beyond Memorization. Formulas are not just arbitrary equations to be memorized, but rather concise explanations of underlying relationships. Understanding the origins and justifications for formulas allows us to use them more effectively and creatively.
Connecting Concepts. Formulas often connect seemingly disparate concepts, revealing hidden connections and providing new insights. For example, the formula for a straight line (y = mx + c) connects the geometric concept of a line with the algebraic concepts of slope and intercept.
Power and Understanding. By understanding the "why" behind formulas, we can unlock their full potential and use them to solve problems, make predictions, and gain a deeper appreciation for the beauty and power of mathematics.
Last updated:
Review Summary
Is Maths Real? receives mixed reviews. Many praise Cheng's explanations of mathematical concepts and her efforts to make math more accessible and engaging. Readers appreciate her focus on the "why" behind math rather than just memorization. However, some find the book's structure disjointed and the frequent political and social commentary distracting. The target audience is unclear, with some finding it too basic and others too complex. Overall, readers value Cheng's passion for math education but have varying opinions on her approach and execution.
