Key Takeaways
1. Babies Possess an Innate Moral Sense
The moral sense, or conscience, is as much a part of man as his leg or arm.
Early moral understanding. Research indicates that babies as young as three months old exhibit a rudimentary moral sense, demonstrating a preference for helpful individuals over those who hinder others. This suggests that certain moral foundations are not solely acquired through learning but are, to some extent, products of biological evolution. These foundations include the capacity to distinguish between kind and cruel actions.
Helper/hinderer studies. Experiments involving puppet shows where geometrical figures either help or hinder each other reveal that infants consistently prefer the "helper" puppet. This preference is not merely a response to the shapes or colors of the puppets but to the social interactions they portray. Babies look longer at the "nice" puppet and often reach for it.
Implications for moral development. These findings challenge the traditional view that morality is solely a product of socialization. Instead, they suggest that humans are born with a basic moral toolkit that is then shaped and refined by experience and culture. This innate moral sense provides a foundation for the development of more complex moral reasoning and behavior later in life.
2. Empathy and Compassion Are Distinct but Intertwined
How selfish soever man may be supposed, there are evidently some principles in his nature, which interest him in the fortune of others, and render their happiness necessary to him, though he derives nothing from it except the pleasure of seeing it.
Defining empathy and compassion. Empathy involves vicariously experiencing another person's feelings, while compassion entails feeling concern for their well-being and a desire to alleviate their suffering. While empathy can be a powerful motivator for compassion, it is not always necessary or sufficient. One can feel empathy without acting compassionately, and vice versa.
The role of mirror neurons. Mirror neurons, which fire both when we perform an action and when we observe someone else performing that action, are often cited as the neural basis for empathy. However, the relationship between mirror neurons and empathy is complex and not fully understood. Empathy is also influenced by what one thinks of the other person.
Compassion in action. Even very young children exhibit compassionate behaviors, such as soothing others in distress and spontaneously helping adults with tasks. These actions suggest that compassion is not solely a learned behavior but has roots in our innate social nature.
3. Fairness and Equality Are Instinctive, but Self-Interest Persists
Robin Hood had it right. Humanity’s deepest wish is to spread the wealth.
Early sense of fairness. Studies show that even infants have a rudimentary sense of fairness, preferring equal distributions of resources and reacting negatively to unequal outcomes. This suggests that a concern for fairness is an innate human tendency. However, this concern for fairness is not always altruistic.
The Ultimatum Game. The Ultimatum Game, where one player proposes how to split a sum of money and the other player can accept or reject the offer, demonstrates that people are willing to forgo personal gain to punish unfair behavior. This suggests that a sense of fairness can override self-interest.
Self-interest and spite. While people may strive for equality in some situations, self-interest often prevails. Children, in particular, are more likely to object to unfairness when they are the ones receiving less. In some cases, they may even prefer to destroy resources rather than allow someone else to have more.
4. Our Moral Circle Is Limited by Nature
The soul selects its own society / Then shuts the door.
In-group preference. Humans naturally favor those who are similar to them, whether based on kinship, language, or arbitrary group membership. This in-group preference can lead to biases and discrimination against those who are perceived as "other." Babies prefer to look at faces of their own race.
The coalition theory. The coalition theory suggests that race is not inherently meaningful but becomes salient as a cue for identifying group membership. People are more likely to favor those who belong to the same coalition, regardless of their race or other physical characteristics.
Overcoming limitations. While our moral circle may be limited by nature, it is not fixed. Through education, exposure to diverse perspectives, and conscious effort, we can expand our circle of concern to include those who are different from us.
5. Disgust Can Corrupt Our Moral Judgments
These are not Menschen, human beings, but animals, it’s as clear as day.
The power of disgust. Disgust is a powerful emotion that can lead to dehumanization and cruelty. By associating certain groups with filth, disease, or other repulsive qualities, it becomes easier to justify violence and discrimination against them.
Core disgust. Core disgust is triggered by substances such as feces, vomit, and rotten flesh. This evolved as a protective mechanism to prevent us from consuming harmful substances. However, disgust can also be triggered by people, particularly those who are seen as violating social norms or threatening our sense of purity.
Moral implications. Disgust can corrupt our moral judgments, leading us to view certain behaviors or groups as inherently immoral. This can have devastating consequences, as seen in the rhetoric used to justify genocide and other atrocities.
6. Family Bonds Hold a Unique Moral Status
Every man is, no doubt, by nature, first and principally recommended to his own care; and as he is fitter to take care of himself than of any other person, it is fit and right that it should be so.
Kinship altruism. Family bonds are a fundamental aspect of human morality. We are naturally inclined to care for our close relatives, and this inclination has deep evolutionary roots. This is because relatives share genes, so kindness to kin is, in a very real way, kindness to oneself.
Moral obligations to family. Our moral obligations to family members often outweigh our obligations to strangers. We are expected to prioritize the well-being of our children, parents, and siblings, even at a cost to ourselves.
The limits of kinship. While family bonds are important, they can also be a source of conflict and injustice. Overly strong loyalty to family can lead to nepotism, corruption, and the exclusion of others.
7. Reason and Culture Can Expand Our Moral Horizons
As you would that men should do to you, do ye also to them likewise.
The role of reason. Reason plays a crucial role in expanding our moral horizons. By engaging in moral deliberation, we can identify inconsistencies in our beliefs, challenge our biases, and develop more inclusive and impartial moral principles.
The power of culture. Culture shapes our moral values and norms. Through stories, traditions, and social institutions, we learn to care about those who are outside our immediate circle of concern.
The importance of impartiality. Impartiality, the principle that everyone should be treated equally, is a cornerstone of many ethical systems. By striving for impartiality, we can overcome our natural biases and create a more just and equitable society.
Last updated:
FAQ
What is Just Babies: The Origins of Good and Evil by Paul Bloom about?
- Exploration of morality’s roots: The book investigates how morality develops from infancy, arguing that some moral capacities are innate rather than solely learned from culture.
- Interdisciplinary approach: Paul Bloom combines developmental psychology, evolutionary biology, and philosophy to explain the origins of good and evil in humans.
- Key themes: Topics include empathy, fairness, disgust, family bonds, and the role of reason in moral development, showing how both kindness and cruelty emerge from our nature.
Why should I read Just Babies by Paul Bloom?
- Insight into human nature: The book offers a compelling account of why people can be both wonderful and horrible, shedding light on the origins of good and evil.
- Scientific and philosophical integration: Bloom makes complex ideas accessible, blending cutting-edge research with philosophical reflection for a broad audience.
- Practical relevance: Understanding the moral life of babies can inform parenting, education, and social policy, helping readers appreciate and nurture the foundations of morality.
What are the key takeaways from Just Babies by Paul Bloom?
- Morality is partly innate: Humans are born with foundational moral capacities, including a sense of right and wrong, empathy, fairness, and justice.
- Morality is complex: Our natural moral sense includes both kindness and cruelty, shaped by evolutionary, developmental, and cultural factors.
- Moral progress requires reason: While babies have moral sentiments, adults use intelligence and deliberation to transcend innate biases and achieve moral insight and progress.
What are the main moral capacities that babies possess according to Just Babies?
- Innate empathy and compassion: Babies show early signs of empathy, such as distress at others’ pain and spontaneous helping behaviors.
- Sense of fairness: Even infants react to unequal distributions of resources, showing expectations of fairness and negativity toward unfairness.
- Moral evaluation: Babies can distinguish between prosocial and antisocial behaviors, preferring helpers over hinderers, indicating a rudimentary moral sense.
How does Paul Bloom define the "moral sense" in Just Babies?
- Capacity for moral judgment: The moral sense is the ability to distinguish between good and bad, kindness and cruelty, similar to an external sense like hearing or seeing.
- Beyond mere behavior: It involves making disinterested judgments about right and wrong, not just an impulse to do good.
- Philosophical roots: This concept echoes Enlightenment thinkers who believed morality is an innate part of human nature.
How does Just Babies explain babies’ understanding of good and evil?
- Experimental evidence: Studies using looking-time and reaching measures show that babies as young as three months prefer helpful characters over hinderers.
- Social evaluation: Babies expect individuals to approach helpers and avoid hinderers, indicating early social reasoning about others’ behavior.
- Negativity bias: Younger babies are more sensitive to badness (hindering) than goodness (helping), a pattern also seen in adults.
What role do empathy and compassion play in morality according to Just Babies by Paul Bloom?
- Empathy vs. compassion: Empathy is feeling what another feels, while compassion is caring about another and wanting to alleviate their suffering.
- Empathy is not sufficient: Psychopaths may understand right and wrong but lack empathy and compassion, leading to immoral behavior despite cognitive knowledge.
- Complex relationship: Compassion motivates moral actions, but empathy can be chosen or avoided, and sometimes empathy exists without compassion or vice versa.
How does Just Babies address fairness, status, and punishment in moral development?
- Innate fairness bias: Babies and young children show a preference for equal distribution of resources and expect fairness in rewards.
- Status and hierarchy: Human societies balance egalitarianism with status concerns, often through social mechanisms like ridicule or coalition-building.
- Punishment and revenge: Moral psychology includes desires for revenge and third-party punishment, which help enforce cooperation but can also lead to cycles of retaliation.
How does Paul Bloom explain the role of disgust in morality in Just Babies?
- Disgust as adaptation: Disgust likely evolved to protect humans from harmful foods and pathogens, with heightened sensitivity in certain contexts like pregnancy.
- Moral judgments: Disgust extends to moral domains, especially sexual morality, influencing judgments about behaviors like incest and homosexuality.
- Moral implications: Inducing disgust makes people judge moral transgressions more harshly, but Bloom warns that disgust is an unreliable moral guide and can fuel prejudice.
What is the significance of family and kinship in moral psychology according to Just Babies?
- Family as moral foundation: Morality originally evolved to regulate relationships within small groups, especially kin, where cooperation and altruism have evolutionary benefits.
- Prioritizing kin: People naturally prioritize family and in-group members over strangers, reflecting evolved biases in moral concern.
- Fictive kinship: Humans also create “fictive kin” relationships, such as chosen families, showing the flexibility and importance of close bonds in moral life.
How does Just Babies by Paul Bloom address the expansion of the moral circle and moral progress?
- Moral circle concept: The “moral circle” describes how humans have gradually extended moral concern from family to strangers, other races, and even animals.
- Drivers of expansion: Personal contact, stories, and cultural exposure help broaden empathy and reduce prejudice, facilitating inclusion of more individuals.
- Limits and challenges: Expanding the moral circle is complex and can create new conflicts; reason and deliberation are crucial for navigating these dilemmas.
What role does reason play in morality according to Just Babies by Paul Bloom?
- Reason complements emotion: While moral intuitions and emotions are foundational, reason allows humans to reflect, justify, and refine moral principles.
- Developmental evidence: Children engage in moral deliberation, debating fairness and justice with peers, showing that reasoning emerges alongside innate moral sentiments.
- Moral progress: Bloom argues that reason is essential for overcoming biases and achieving moral progress, challenging the idea that morality is only about gut feelings.
Review Summary
Just Babies explores the origins of morality in infants and young children through psychological experiments. While some reviewers found the book insightful and thought-provoking, others felt it strayed from its premise and lacked depth. The book examines concepts like empathy, fairness, and disgust, and how they relate to moral development. Bloom argues that humans have innate moral tendencies from birth, but reason and experience shape our ethical frameworks as we grow. Despite mixed opinions on its execution, many readers found the topic intriguing and the writing accessible.
Similar Books







Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub
digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.