On the Origin of Time

1. Cosmology's Maturing: From Speculation to Observation

In cosmology we discover the past.

Cosmology's evolution. Once considered a realm of unrestrained speculation, cosmology has matured into a rigorous science, driven by spectacular observations from sophisticated satellites and Earth-based instruments. This transformation allows scientists to trace the universe's history of expansion and glean insights into its origin, evolution, and fate.

Telescopes as time machines. Cosmologists are time travelers, using telescopes to look back into deep time. The light from distant stars and galaxies has traveled millions or billions of years to reach us, providing a glimpse into the universe's past. This allows scientists to study the cosmic microwave background radiation (CMB), a relic of the hot big bang, and decipher patterns encoded within it.

Key observations:

• Expansion of space: Predicted by Lemaître in 1927 and confirmed by Hubble's observations.
• Cosmic microwave background radiation: A snapshot of the universe 380,000 years after the big bang.
• Accelerating expansion: Discovered in 1998, suggesting the presence of dark energy.

2. The Uncanny Biofriendliness of the Universe

It appears as if the universe has somehow been designed to make life possible.

Fine-tuning for life. The universe exhibits an extraordinary fitness for life, with its fundamental physical properties seemingly engineered to facilitate the emergence of living organisms. This "Goldilocks factor" is evident in the strength of gravity, the temperature variations in the CMB, the number of spatial dimensions, and the chemical properties of elements.

Examples of cosmic coincidences:

• Gravity: If stronger, stars would die too quickly for complex life to evolve.
• CMB temperature variations: If larger, giant black holes would dominate; if smaller, no galaxies would form.
• Neutron-to-proton mass ratio: A slight change would prevent the formation of atoms.
• Dark energy density: A larger value would have prevented galaxy formation.

The riddle of design. The fundamental laws of physics appear specifically engineered to facilitate the emergence of life. This raises profound questions about the deeper nature of the laws and our place within their scheme.

3. Relativity's Revolution: Spacetime and Gravity

Henceforth space as such and time as such shall recede completely to the shadows and only a kind of union of the two shall retain independence.

Einstein's spacetime. Einstein's theory of special relativity revolutionized our understanding of space and time, merging them into a single four-dimensional entity called spacetime. This framework introduced the concept of a cosmic speed limit (the speed of light) and redefined our relationship with the universe.

General relativity and gravity. Einstein's theory of general relativity describes gravity as a manifestation of the curving and bending of spacetime by mass and energy. This geometric interpretation of gravity explains phenomena such as the bending of light around massive objects and the existence of black holes.

Key concepts:

• Spacetime: A four-dimensional union of space and time.
• Light cones: Structures that define an observer's past and future.
• Event horizon: The boundary of a black hole, beyond which nothing can escape.
• Gravitational waves: Ripples in spacetime caused by accelerating masses.

4. The Big Bang's Paradox: A Beginning Beyond Understanding

We can compare spacetime to an open, conic cup.

Lemaître's primeval atom. Georges Lemaître proposed that the universe began with a primeval atom, a tiny speck of staggering density whose disintegration created matter, space, and time. This idea, initially met with skepticism, laid the foundation for the big bang theory.

The singularity problem. The big bang theory implies a singularity at the origin of time, where spacetime curvature becomes infinite and the laws of physics break down. This poses a paradox: how can the laws of physics determine the universe's origin if they don't apply at the singularity?

Quantum indeterminacy. Lemaître speculated that quantum indeterminacy could resolve the causality conundrum posed by the big bang. Random quantum jumps could have generated a complex universe from a simple primeval atom, making the idea of a beginning easier to accept.

5. Quantum Cosmology: A Blend of Gravity and Uncertainty

Clearly the initial quantum could not conceal in itself the whole course of evolution.

Merging relativity and quantum theory. Quantum cosmology seeks to reconcile general relativity and quantum theory to understand the universe's origin. This requires a new framework that goes beyond the traditional separation of laws and conditions.

Hawking's no-boundary proposal. Stephen Hawking and Jim Hartle proposed that the universe has no boundary in the past, replacing the initial singularity with a smooth, rounded quantum origin. This implies that time itself emerges from a deeper, timeless state.

The role of quantum fluctuations. Quantum fluctuations, amplified by inflation, are thought to have seeded the formation of galaxies and large-scale structures in the universe. These fluctuations also contribute to the temperature variations in the CMB.

6. The Multiverse and the Anthropic Principle: A Contentious Debate

The anthropic principle is a counsel of despair.

The multiverse concept. The multiverse theory suggests that our universe is just one of many, each with its own physical properties. This arises from inflationary theory, which tends to generate not one but many universes.

The anthropic principle. The anthropic principle states that we observe the universe the way it is because we exist. It suggests that selection effects play out across the multiverse, favoring universes suited for life.

Criticisms of the anthropic principle:

• Compromises the scientific process of prediction and falsification.
• Introduces a subjective element into physics.
• Fails to explain why the metalaws of the multiverse are what they are.

7. Hawking's Top-Down Cosmology: A New Perspective

The history of the universe depends on the question you ask.

A worm's-eye view. Hawking's top-down cosmology rejects the God's-eye view, emphasizing that we are within the universe, not outside it. This requires a new philosophy of physics that accounts for our inherent limitations as observers.

Rethinking the laws of physics. Top-down cosmology suggests that the laws of physics are not immutable, timeless truths but rather emergent properties of the universe, shaped by its evolution and our observations. This implies a retrospective element in cosmology, where the present influences our understanding of the past.

Key elements:

• Rejection of a global classical state.
• Emphasis on the interconnectedness of the universe.
• Recognition of the role of observership in shaping reality.

8. Holographic Universe: Information on the Surface

The fabric of existence weaves itself whole.

Holographic principle. The holographic principle suggests that the information content of a volume of space can be encoded on its boundary surface. This implies that the universe may be a hologram, with all its complexity projected from a lower-dimensional surface.

Black holes and holography. The entropy of a black hole is proportional to the area of its event horizon, suggesting that black holes store information on their surface. This led to the holographic duality, which relates gravity in a volume of space to a quantum field theory on its boundary.

Implications for cosmology. Holographic cosmology suggests that the universe's history and properties are encoded on a distant boundary, challenging our understanding of space, time, and causality.

9. The Arrow of Time: From Order to Disorder

I hardly move, yet far I seem to have come.

The entropic arrow. The arrow of time arises from the tendency of disorder to increase, as measured by entropy. The second law of thermodynamics states that entropy always increases in a closed system.

The mystery of low entropy. The universe began in an extremely ordered, low-entropy state. This raises the question of why the initial conditions were so special and how the arrow of time emerged.

Quantum indeterminism. Quantum indeterminism could have generated a complex universe from a simple primeval atom. If the complexity of today’s universe were the result of countless frozen accidents in its embryonic evolution rather than the necessary consequence of perfectly orchestrated initial conditions right at the start, wouldn’t the whole idea of a beginning be easier to swallow?

10. The Quest for a Unified Theory: String Theory and M-Theory

Mathematics “takes you by the hand,” he said, “to discover new physical theories.

The Standard Model. The Standard Model of particle physics describes all known matter particles and the three forces that govern their interactions (electromagnetic, weak, and strong). However, it doesn't include gravity or dark matter.

String theory and M-theory. String theory attempts to unify all forces, including gravity, by replacing point-like particles with tiny vibrating strings. M-theory is a web of interconnected string theories that offers a more complete picture of the universe.

The multiverse landscape. String theory predicts a vast landscape of possible universes, each with its own physical laws. This raises the question of why our universe has the specific properties that it does.

11. The Fate of Information in Black Holes: A Quantum Puzzle

I am dying…for…a…cup…of…tea.

Hawking radiation. Black holes emit a faint trickle of thermal radiation, known as Hawking radiation, due to quantum effects near their event horizon. This radiation causes black holes to slowly evaporate over time.

The information paradox. The evaporation of black holes raises a paradox: what happens to the information that falls into a black hole when it disappears? Quantum theory says information cannot be destroyed, but Hawking's calculations suggested it was lost forever.

Holographic resolution. The holographic principle offers a potential resolution to the information paradox. It suggests that the information content of a black hole is encoded on its event horizon, and that this information is preserved in the Hawking radiation.

12. The Humanistic Implications: Reclaiming Our Place in the Cosmos

We are together, the universe and us.

The limitations of a God's-eye view. Arendt argued that the pursuit of objective knowledge in science can lead to earth alienation, a loss of connection to our human condition. This is because it is as if we are looking down on the world and our activities as if we are outside it.

A worm's-eye perspective. Hawking's final theory embraces a worm's-eye perspective, recognizing that we are part of the universe we are trying to understand. This requires a new approach to cosmology that integrates observership and acknowledges the finitude of our knowledge.

Reclaiming our place. By embracing our human perspective, we can reclaim our sense of belonging to the cosmos and find meaning in our existence. This requires a shift from seeking a final theory to understanding the interconnectedness of all things.

Last updated: March 3, 2025