Key Takeaways
1. Post-truth: Emotions trump facts in shaping beliefs
Post-truth is when one thinks that the crowd's reaction actually does change the facts about a lie.
Defining post-truth. The Oxford Dictionaries define post-truth as circumstances where objective facts are less influential in shaping public opinion than appeals to emotion and personal belief. This represents a fundamental shift in how truth is perceived and valued in society.
Origins and implications. The concept rocketed to prominence during the 2016 US presidential election and Brexit vote, reflecting a growing willingness to embrace "alternative facts" that align with one's views. Post-truth goes beyond mere lying or spin – it represents a more profound challenge to the very notion of shared objective reality. In a post-truth world, feelings and ideology can override evidence, with dangerous consequences for democracy, policy-making, and social cohesion.
2. Science denial paved the way for post-truth politics
Do we want to live in a world where policy is made based on how it makes us feel rather than how well it will work in reality?
Tobacco strategy blueprint. The tobacco industry's efforts to cast doubt on the link between smoking and cancer in the 1950s-90s created a template for science denial:
- Fund your own experts
- Suggest there are "two sides" to settled science
- Emphasize uncertainty and demand impossible levels of proof
- Use public relations and lobbying to push your message
Climate change denial. These tactics were later adopted by climate change deniers, evolution skeptics, and other groups seeking to undermine inconvenient scientific findings. By sowing doubt about established facts, science denial laid the groundwork for the broader rejection of objective truth in politics and culture.
3. Cognitive biases make us vulnerable to misinformation
The problem here was not any so-called political bias. It was instead what the researchers call "information bias," which is when the news gathering and reporting routines of journalists result in coverage that is distorted from the truth.
Hardwired for bias. Humans have several innate cognitive biases that can lead us astray:
- Confirmation bias: Seeking information that confirms existing beliefs
- Backfire effect: Strengthening beliefs when presented with contradictory evidence
- Dunning-Kruger effect: Overestimating one's knowledge/abilities
Motivated reasoning. These biases are often driven by motivated reasoning – our tendency to find ways to believe what we want to be true. This makes us susceptible to misinformation that aligns with our existing views and identities, especially on emotionally charged topics.
4. Traditional media's decline created space for partisan news
If you make a recipe with just one rotten ingredient, the whole dish will taste rotten.
Financial pressures. The rise of the internet devastated traditional media business models, leading to staff cuts and reduced investigative reporting. This created a vacuum in quality journalism.
False balance trap. In an effort to appear unbiased, many outlets embraced a misguided notion of "balance" that gave equal weight to fringe views alongside established facts. This false equivalence, especially on issues like climate change, confused the public and eroded trust in media institutions.
Partisan alternatives. Cable news networks and talk radio rushed to fill the void with opinion-driven coverage catering to partisan audiences. This fragmentation of the media landscape made it easier for people to consume only information that confirmed their existing beliefs.
5. Social media and fake news accelerated the post-truth era
Fake news is not simply news that is false; it is deliberately false. It has been created for a purpose.
Echo chambers. Social media algorithms tend to show users content that aligns with their existing views, creating "filter bubbles" that reinforce biases and limit exposure to diverse perspectives.
Viral misinformation. The ease of sharing on social platforms allows fake news to spread rapidly, often outpacing fact-checks or corrections. During the 2016 US election:
- Top 20 fake news stories on Facebook: 8.7 million engagements
- Top 20 real news stories: 7.3 million engagements
Blurred lines. With traditional gatekeepers weakened, it became harder for many to distinguish between reliable and unreliable sources online. This confusion benefited those seeking to spread disinformation for political or financial gain.
6. Postmodernism inadvertently provided tools for science denial
If everything is a narrative, then we need alternatives to the dominant narrative. I don't look like a guy who reads Lacan, do I?
Questioning objectivity. Postmodern thinkers challenged the idea of objective truth, arguing that all knowledge claims are shaped by power structures and cultural context. While intended as a critique of oppressive systems, these ideas were later co-opted by science deniers.
Intelligent Design example. Some proponents of Intelligent Design explicitly cited postmodern thinkers in their attempts to undermine the authority of evolutionary science. By framing scientific consensus as just another "narrative," they sought to elevate religious views to equal standing in education.
Unintended consequences. Many postmodernist scholars have expressed regret at how their ideas have been misused to attack scientific expertise and factual reality. The notion that all perspectives are equally valid has proven dangerous when applied to empirical questions with real-world consequences.
7. Fighting post-truth requires vigilance and critical thinking
Truth still matters, as it always has. Whether we realize this in time is up to us.
Challenge falsehoods. It's crucial to confront lies and misinformation promptly, as silence can be seen as tacit acceptance. While it may not convince the most ardent believers, pushback can sway those who haven't yet made up their minds.
Support quality journalism. Funding investigative reporting and fact-checking organizations is essential to maintain a shared basis of factual reality. Diversifying news sources and being willing to critically examine one's own beliefs are also important.
Teach media literacy. Education on how to evaluate sources, spot fake news, and understand cognitive biases is vital. Some key skills:
- Check for multiple reliable sources
- Be wary of emotional manipulation
- Look for original data/evidence
- Consider alternative explanations
Long-term view. While post-truth politics can seem overwhelming, research shows that repeated exposure to accurate information can eventually overcome even strongly held misconceptions. Persistence in defending truth and reason is essential for the health of democracy and society.
Last updated:
FAQ
What's "Post-Truth" by Lee McIntyre about?
- Exploration of Post-Truth: The book delves into the concept of "post-truth," where objective facts are less influential in shaping public opinion than appeals to emotion and personal belief.
- Historical Context: McIntyre traces the roots of post-truth back to various historical, cultural, and political developments, including the rise of social media and the decline of traditional media.
- Impact on Society: It examines how post-truth affects political discourse, scientific understanding, and public trust in institutions.
- Call to Action: The book encourages readers to recognize and combat the spread of misinformation and the erosion of truth in public life.
Why should I read "Post-Truth" by Lee McIntyre?
- Understanding Modern Challenges: The book provides insights into the current challenges of misinformation and the manipulation of truth in politics and media.
- Critical Thinking Skills: It offers tools and strategies to critically assess information and resist cognitive biases.
- Historical Perspective: McIntyre provides a historical perspective on how post-truth has evolved, helping readers understand its deep-rooted causes.
- Empowerment: By understanding the mechanisms of post-truth, readers can become more informed and active participants in democratic processes.
What are the key takeaways of "Post-Truth" by Lee McIntyre?
- Definition of Post-Truth: Post-truth is characterized by the subordination of facts to emotions and personal beliefs, often for political gain.
- Role of Cognitive Bias: Cognitive biases, such as confirmation bias and the backfire effect, play a significant role in the persistence of post-truth.
- Media's Influence: The decline of traditional media and the rise of social media have facilitated the spread of misinformation.
- Fighting Post-Truth: Combating post-truth requires critical thinking, media literacy, and a commitment to evidence-based reasoning.
How does Lee McIntyre define "post-truth"?
- Emotional Over Facts: McIntyre defines post-truth as a situation where objective facts are less influential than appeals to emotion and personal belief.
- Political Strategy: It is often used as a strategy for political dominance, where truth is manipulated to fit ideological narratives.
- Historical Precedents: The book discusses historical precedents of post-truth, such as propaganda and misinformation campaigns.
- Normative Concern: Post-truth is presented as a normative concern, highlighting the importance of truth in maintaining democratic societies.
What role does cognitive bias play in "Post-Truth" by Lee McIntyre?
- Confirmation Bias: Cognitive biases like confirmation bias lead individuals to favor information that confirms their preexisting beliefs.
- Backfire Effect: The backfire effect occurs when people hold onto their beliefs more strongly when presented with contradictory evidence.
- Motivated Reasoning: People often engage in motivated reasoning, where they process information in a way that aligns with their desires and emotions.
- Implications for Truth: These biases contribute to the persistence of misinformation and the challenge of correcting false beliefs.
How does "Post-Truth" by Lee McIntyre address the decline of traditional media?
- Loss of Trust: The book discusses how the decline of traditional media has led to a loss of trust in established news sources.
- Rise of Partisan Media: It highlights the rise of partisan media outlets that prioritize opinion over fact-based reporting.
- Impact of Social Media: Social media platforms have blurred the lines between news and opinion, contributing to the spread of misinformation.
- Need for Media Literacy: McIntyre emphasizes the importance of media literacy in discerning credible sources from unreliable ones.
What is the relationship between postmodernism and post-truth in McIntyre's book?
- Philosophical Roots: McIntyre explores how postmodernist ideas, which question objective truth, have influenced the post-truth era.
- Critique of Science: Postmodernism's critique of science and objectivity has been co-opted by some to undermine factual discourse.
- Right-Wing Appropriation: The book discusses how right-wing movements have used postmodernist skepticism to challenge scientific consensus.
- Consequences for Truth: This philosophical shift has contributed to the erosion of trust in facts and expertise.
How does "Post-Truth" by Lee McIntyre suggest we combat misinformation?
- Critical Thinking: The book advocates for developing critical thinking skills to evaluate information and resist cognitive biases.
- Support for Journalism: It encourages supporting investigative journalism and fact-based reporting to counter misinformation.
- Media Literacy Education: McIntyre suggests promoting media literacy education to help individuals discern credible sources.
- Active Engagement: Readers are urged to actively challenge falsehoods and engage in informed discussions to uphold truth.
What are the best quotes from "Post-Truth" by Lee McIntyre and what do they mean?
- "The very concept of objective truth is fading out of the world. Lies will pass into history." This quote underscores the book's central theme of the diminishing role of truth in public discourse.
- "In times of universal deceit, telling the truth will be a revolutionary act." It highlights the courage required to uphold truth in an era dominated by misinformation.
- "Post-truth amounts to a form of ideological supremacy." This quote emphasizes how post-truth is used as a tool for political dominance, where truth is manipulated to fit narratives.
- "We are not post-truth any more than we are pre-truth, unless we allow ourselves to be." It serves as a call to action, urging readers to resist the erosion of truth and actively engage in defending it.
How does "Post-Truth" by Lee McIntyre relate to current events?
- Political Climate: The book's exploration of post-truth is highly relevant to the current political climate, where misinformation is prevalent.
- Media Landscape: It addresses the challenges posed by the modern media landscape, including the rise of social media and partisan news.
- Public Discourse: McIntyre's insights into cognitive bias and motivated reasoning are applicable to understanding public discourse and polarization.
- Call to Action: The book's call to action for critical thinking and media literacy is timely in addressing the spread of misinformation.
What historical examples does "Post-Truth" by Lee McIntyre use to illustrate its points?
- Tobacco Industry: The book discusses the tobacco industry's campaign to create doubt about the link between smoking and cancer.
- Climate Change Denial: It examines the tactics used by climate change deniers to undermine scientific consensus.
- Swift Boat Veterans for Truth: McIntyre uses the Swift Boat campaign against John Kerry as an example of early post-truth tactics in politics.
- Yellow Journalism: Historical instances of yellow journalism are used to illustrate the long-standing presence of misinformation in media.
What is the significance of the title "Post-Truth"?
- Era of Misinformation: The title signifies an era where misinformation and emotional appeals overshadow objective facts.
- Challenge to Truth: It highlights the challenge to truth and the need to defend it in public discourse.
- Cultural Shift: The title reflects a cultural shift towards valuing personal beliefs over empirical evidence.
- Call for Awareness: It serves as a call for awareness and action to address the erosion of truth in society.
Review Summary
Post-Truth by Lee McIntyre receives mixed reviews. Many praise it as an informative, accessible introduction to the concept of post-truth, particularly in relation to American politics and Trump's presidency. Readers appreciate McIntyre's exploration of cognitive biases, media influence, and postmodernism's role. However, some criticize the book for being US-centric, lacking rigorous academic standards, and offering insufficient solutions. Despite these critiques, most reviewers find the book thought-provoking and relevant to understanding contemporary challenges to truth and facts in society.
Similar Books
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.