Small Town, Big Dreams

Jesse Gibson, a flamboyant, makeup-loving gay man, flees his conservative rural upbringing for the vibrant, accepting city of Portland. Determined to live unapologetically, he pursues his dream of becoming a therapist while working as a dancer at the Playground, a popular gay bar. Jesse's life is a patchwork of color, performance, and resilience, but beneath his confidence lies the ache of family rejection and the pressure of making ends meet. His best friend and roommate, Seth, is his anchor, but Jesse's longing for acceptance and self-actualization is ever-present, especially as he navigates the city's opportunities and challenges.

Clash at the Playground

At the Playground, Jesse's path collides with Dane, the brooding bartender. Their personalities are oil and water: Jesse is all sparkle and sass, while Dane is gruff and guarded, still nursing wounds from a toxic ex. Their banter, laced with sexual tension, becomes a spectacle, and their boss capitalizes on it by making them dance together every Friday. The forced proximity and public performance stoke their mutual irritation—and attraction—setting the stage for a slow-burn, enemies-to-lovers dynamic that everyone in the bar can't help but notice.

Friday Night Fireworks

The Friday night bar dances become a ritual, with Jesse and Dane's chemistry electrifying the crowd. What starts as antagonistic play-acting soon blurs into genuine arousal. Both men are surprised by how much the physical closeness affects them, and the line between performance and reality begins to fade. Their bodies communicate what their words won't admit: beneath the snark and scowls, something real is simmering. The crowd's cheers only amplify the tension, and both men are left shaken by the intensity of their connection.

Enemies, Tension, and Tips

The friction between Jesse and Dane escalates, both on and off the bar. Their mutual annoyance masks a growing fascination, and their friends and coworkers start placing bets on when the two will finally give in to their obvious attraction. Jesse's playful provocations and Dane's grumpy retorts become a dance of their own, each pushing the other's buttons. The tension finally boils over, leading to a heated, impulsive hookup that neither can forget—nor easily repeat, as both are wary of the emotional fallout.

Hookups and Heartaches

After a steamy, clandestine encounter in the bar's storage room, Jesse and Dane are left reeling. The sex is explosive, but the aftermath is awkward and confusing. Both men are haunted by past hurts—Jesse by his family's lack of acceptance, Dane by betrayal and loss. They try to convince themselves it was a one-time thing, but the emotional and physical pull between them only intensifies. Their attempts to return to business as usual are thwarted by longing, jealousy, and the realization that their connection runs deeper than either expected.

Underground Vulnerabilities

When Jesse is offered a singing gig in the Playground's more intimate Underground lounge, he's forced to confront his own insecurities. Performing in a new way, he reveals a softer, more vulnerable side that surprises both himself and Dane. Dane, working the bar, is captivated by Jesse's talent and authenticity, seeing past the glitter to the person beneath. Their interactions in the Underground are less performative, more honest, and the walls between them begin to crumble as they glimpse each other's true selves.

Unexpected Connections

A chance meeting at the park, where Dane is caring for his niece Hailey, gives Jesse a window into Dane's private life. Jesse's natural rapport with Hailey and his genuine kindness catch Dane off guard, challenging his assumptions about Jesse. The three share a playful afternoon, and Jesse's nurturing side shines. For the first time, Dane sees Jesse as more than a flirtatious performer—he's someone who could fit into Dane's world, and perhaps even his heart.

Ice Cream and Gummy Bears

After the park, Jesse joins Dane and Hailey for ice cream, a simple outing that becomes unexpectedly meaningful. Jesse's playful influence leads Dane to try new things (like gummy bears in his ice cream), and the trio's dynamic feels almost familial. The outing softens Dane's defenses, and Jesse glimpses the tenderness beneath his gruff exterior. The ride home is filled with awkward honesty and tentative flirtation, marking a turning point in their relationship as both begin to consider the possibility of more.

Rides, Rifts, and Realness

As Jesse and Dane spend more time together, misunderstandings and insecurities bubble up. Dane's past trauma makes him wary of trusting Jesse, especially when he overhears Jesse downplaying their connection to a friend. Hurt, Dane withdraws, and Jesse is left frustrated and confused. Their communication falters, but when they finally confront each other, they share their histories and fears. This raw honesty lays the groundwork for real intimacy, as both realize they want to try—despite the risks.

Dancing on the Bar

Their Friday night dances take on new meaning as Jesse and Dane allow themselves to be more vulnerable on stage. The crowd senses the shift, and their chemistry is no longer just for show. The dances become a metaphor for their relationship: a blend of performance and authenticity, tension and trust. Offstage, they begin to support each other in small but significant ways, and their friends and coworkers rally around their budding romance.

Storage Room Confessions

Another passionate encounter in the storage room leads to deeper confessions. Jesse and Dane admit their fears and desires, acknowledging that what's happening between them is more than just sex. They agree to exclusivity—not out of obligation, but because neither wants anyone else. Their physical connection is matched by growing emotional intimacy, and they begin to envision a future together, even as old wounds and doubts linger.

Family, Fears, and Facades

Jesse's complicated relationship with his parents looms large, especially as the holidays approach. He dreads returning home, knowing he'll have to hide parts of himself. Dane, meanwhile, is haunted by memories of his mother and the pain of past relationships. Both men struggle with the tension between chosen family and blood ties, and the fear that loving each other might mean losing something else. Their support for each other becomes a lifeline as they navigate these emotional minefields.

Singing in the Underground

Jesse's singing in the Underground becomes a symbol of his growth and self-acceptance. Dane is moved by Jesse's vulnerability and talent, and the two share moments of quiet support and affection. Their relationship becomes public knowledge among their friends and coworkers, and the bar community embraces them as a couple. The Underground, once a place of nerves and uncertainty, becomes a stage for Jesse's confidence and for their love.

Makeup, Mall, and Meaning

A mundane trip to the mall with Dane and Hailey becomes a microcosm of their relationship: playful, supportive, and full of small acts of care. Dane buys Jesse his favorite lip gloss, a gesture that means more than words. These everyday moments—shopping, babysitting, sharing meals—build a foundation of trust and affection. Jesse realizes that love isn't just about grand gestures, but about being seen, accepted, and cherished in the ordinary rhythms of life.

Babysitting and Boundaries

When Jesse babysits Hailey, he's welcomed into Dane's family circle. He bonds with Dane's sister Bree, helps with makeovers, and becomes a fixture in their home. The experience is healing for both men: Jesse finds the acceptance he craved, and Dane learns to let someone in. Their relationship shifts from secretive hookups to something open and integrated, and both begin to imagine a shared future.

Trust, Trauma, and Truces

Old insecurities resurface as Dane's fear of betrayal clashes with Jesse's need for reassurance. A misunderstanding about Jesse's intentions leads to a painful rift, but honest conversation and vulnerability help them find their way back. They confront their pasts—Dane's toxic ex, Jesse's family rejection—and make a conscious choice to trust each other. Their truce is hard-won, but it marks a new chapter of mutual respect and commitment.

Cuddles, Crushes, and Confessions

Jesse and Dane settle into a rhythm of affection, exclusivity, and domesticity. They navigate the quirks of living with Seth, the challenges of balancing work and school, and the joys of simply being together. Their friends tease them about being boyfriends, and both men finally admit—to themselves and each other—that they're in love. The relationship, once fraught with tension, becomes a source of comfort and joy.

Thanksgiving with the Found Family

Jesse is invited to Dane's family Thanksgiving, a milestone that cements his place in Dane's life. The holiday is filled with warmth, laughter, and acceptance, a stark contrast to Jesse's strained relationship with his own parents. The found family—Dane, Bree, Hailey, Mark, and even Seth—becomes a haven for both men. The experience underscores the power of chosen family and the importance of being loved for who you are.

Homecomings and Heart Attacks

When Jesse returns home for Christmas, he faces the full weight of his family's expectations and his own longing for acceptance. A heart-to-heart with his father is interrupted by a medical emergency—a heart attack that forces everyone to confront what truly matters. In the aftermath, Jesse's parents begin to accept him, and Jesse realizes he can't sacrifice his happiness for their approval. The crisis becomes a catalyst for healing, honesty, and a renewed commitment to living authentically.

Love, Loss, and Letting Go

Jesse rushes back to Portland, where Dane welcomes him with open arms. Both men confess their love, acknowledging the journey they've taken from enemies to partners. They move in together, blending their lives and their families. The story ends with Jesse singing in the Underground, surrounded by friends and loved ones, and Dane by his side. Their relationship, once fraught with conflict and uncertainty, is now a source of strength, joy, and belonging—a testament to the power of being seen, loved, and accepted, just as you are.

Characters

Jesse Gibson

Jesse is a young, queer man who escaped a stifling small town to live authentically in Portland. Outgoing, flamboyant, and fiercely independent, he uses makeup and performance as both armor and self-expression. Beneath his confidence lies vulnerability: the pain of family rejection, financial insecurity, and a deep longing for acceptance. Jesse's journey is one of self-discovery, as he learns to balance his need for attention with the desire for genuine connection. His relationship with Dane challenges him to trust, to be vulnerable, and to believe he is worthy of love.

Dane

Dane is a bartender with a tough exterior and a wounded heart. Burned by a manipulative ex, he's wary of charm and reluctant to trust. His world revolves around his sister Bree and niece Hailey, for whom he'd do anything. Dane's gruffness masks a deep capacity for care and tenderness, which emerges as he lets Jesse in. His journey is about overcoming fear, learning to trust again, and allowing himself to be loved. With Jesse, he finds not just passion, but the family and acceptance he's always craved.

Seth

Jesse's best friend and roommate, Seth is shy, sensitive, and a bit of an enigma. He provides a safe haven for Jesse, offering unconditional support and a listening ear. Seth's own struggles with intimacy and self-expression mirror Jesse's, and their friendship is a source of mutual healing. As the story unfolds, Seth's quiet strength and loyalty become increasingly important, especially as Jesse navigates the ups and downs of love and family.

Bree

Dane's sister Bree is a single mother juggling work, parenting, and the challenges of an absent partner. She is the emotional center of Dane's family, offering wisdom, humor, and unwavering support. Bree's acceptance of Jesse is immediate and genuine, and her home becomes a sanctuary for both men. Her relationship with Dane is marked by mutual reliance and deep affection, and her encouragement helps both men grow.

Hailey

Dane's four-year-old niece, Hailey, is a source of light and laughter. Her unconditional acceptance of Jesse and her playful spirit help bridge the gap between Jesse and Dane. Hailey's presence brings out the best in both men, reminding them of the importance of family, fun, and being true to oneself.

Mark

Bree's husband and Hailey's father, Mark is a truck driver whose long absences strain the family. Despite his flaws, he cares deeply for Bree and Hailey, and his eventual efforts to be more present help stabilize the family dynamic. Mark's acceptance of Jesse is quiet but meaningful, contributing to the sense of found family.

Chet

The owner of the Playground, Chet is quick to spot the chemistry between Jesse and Dane and isn't above exploiting it for business. He's a savvy manager who cares about his staff, and his encouragement helps Jesse step into new roles. Chet's playful meddling is a catalyst for many of the story's pivotal moments.

Skylar

A fellow dancer at the Playground, Skylar is Jesse's friendly rival and confidant. His teasing and support help Jesse navigate the complexities of work, love, and self-image. Skylar's presence adds levity and camaraderie, and his own journey mirrors Jesse's in many ways.

Jesse's Parents

Jesse's mother and father are products of their small-town, religious environment. Their love for Jesse is real but tangled in fear, guilt, and misunderstanding. Their journey toward acceptance is slow and painful, but ultimately hopeful, as they begin to reconcile their beliefs with their love for their son.

Dane's Ex (Steve)

Though never present, Steve's shadow looms large over Dane's psyche. His betrayal and emotional abuse left Dane wary of trust and intimacy. Overcoming the trauma of this relationship is central to Dane's growth and his ability to love Jesse fully.

Plot Devices

Enemies-to-Lovers Dynamic

The story's central device is the classic enemies-to-lovers arc, with Jesse and Dane's initial antagonism masking deep attraction. Their banter, public performances, and mutual provocations create a slow-burn romance that is both entertaining and emotionally resonant. The device allows for organic character development, as both men are forced to confront their assumptions, fears, and desires.

Forced Proximity and Public Performance

The requirement to dance together every Friday night serves as both a literal and metaphorical stage for Jesse and Dane's evolving relationship. The public nature of their interactions heightens the stakes, forcing them to navigate authenticity versus performance, and to reckon with how they are seen by others—and by each other.

Dual Narration and Alternating Perspectives

The narrative alternates between Jesse and Dane's points of view, providing insight into their internal struggles and emotional landscapes. This structure deepens the reader's understanding of both characters, highlighting the ways their experiences and perceptions both clash and complement each other.

Found Family and Chosen Community

The theme of found family is woven throughout, with Jesse and Dane building a support network of friends, coworkers, and each other's relatives. The contrast between Jesse's biological family and his chosen family in Portland underscores the importance of acceptance, belonging, and unconditional love.

Symbolism of Makeup and Performance

Makeup is more than cosmetic for Jesse—it's a symbol of self-acceptance, strength, and defiance. His performances, both on stage and in life, are acts of survival and celebration. The gradual removal of makeup in private moments with Dane mirrors Jesse's journey toward vulnerability and authenticity.

Foreshadowing and Emotional Payoff

Early references to family, trauma, and longing foreshadow the emotional arcs to come. The story pays off these threads with moments of catharsis—Jesse's confrontation with his parents, Dane's confession of love, and their eventual public acknowledgment as a couple.

Analysis

Pretty Perfect is a heartfelt, modern queer romance that explores the transformative power of authenticity, vulnerability, and chosen family. Through the lens of Jesse and Dane's journey—from antagonists to lovers to partners—the novel interrogates the ways we perform for others and for ourselves, and the courage it takes to be truly seen. The story is as much about healing from past wounds as it is about falling in love: Jesse's struggle for acceptance, both from his family and himself, mirrors Dane's battle with trust and self-worth. The narrative celebrates the messy, beautiful process of building a life—and a love—that is unapologetically one's own. In a world that often demands conformity, Pretty Perfect insists that happiness lies in embracing our imperfections, loving boldly, and finding home in those who see us, glitter and all.

Last updated: May 19, 2025