The Science Delusion

1. Science's Dogmas: Challenging the Materialist Worldview

The biggest scientific delusion of all is that science already knows the answers. The details still need working out but, in principle, the fundamental questions are settled.

Materialism's limitations. The materialist philosophy that dominates modern science is based on several unexamined assumptions:

• Everything is essentially mechanical
• Matter is unconscious
• The laws of nature are fixed
• Nature is purposeless
• Biological inheritance is purely material
• Memories are stored as material traces in brains
• The mind is confined to the brain
• Psychic phenomena are illusory

These dogmas have become so entrenched that they are rarely questioned. However, recent scientific discoveries and philosophical inquiries suggest that these assumptions may be limiting our understanding of reality.

Expanding scientific inquiry. By challenging these dogmas, we can open up new avenues of research and potentially revolutionize our understanding of consciousness, life, and the universe. This approach does not reject the achievements of science but seeks to expand its scope and deepen its insights.

2. Matter and Energy: Rethinking Conservation Laws

Materialism provided a seemingly simple, straightforward worldview in the late nineteenth century, but twenty-first-century science has left it behind.

Dark matter and energy. Modern cosmology has revealed that:

• Only about 4% of the universe consists of familiar matter and energy
• 23% is made up of dark matter
• 73% is dark energy

These discoveries challenge our understanding of matter and energy conservation. The nature of dark matter and energy remains largely unknown, suggesting that our current laws of physics may be incomplete.

Quantum vacuum. The concept of the quantum vacuum or zero-point field further complicates our understanding of energy conservation. This field, permeating all of space, contains fluctuations of energy that appear and disappear, potentially offering new sources of energy if harnessed.

3. Nature's Laws: Evolving Habits, Not Fixed Rules

People make the mistake of talking about 'natural laws'. There are no natural laws. There are only temporary habits of nature.

Habits vs. laws. The idea that the laws of nature are fixed and eternal is being challenged by:

• Evidence of evolving constants in physics
• The concept of morphic resonance, suggesting that nature has an inherent memory
• The recognition that the universe itself is evolving

This perspective sees the regularities in nature as habits that have developed over time, rather than immutable laws imposed from the outset.

Implications for science. Viewing nature's regularities as habits opens up new possibilities for scientific inquiry:

• It allows for the evolution of natural phenomena
• It suggests that the future may not be entirely predictable based on past patterns
• It encourages a more dynamic and open-ended approach to scientific research

4. Consciousness: Beyond Brain Activity

You, your joys and your sorrows, your memories and your ambitions, your sense of personal identity and free will, are in fact no more than the behavior of a vast assembly of nerve cells and their associated molecules.

Limitations of materialism. The materialist view that consciousness is merely a byproduct of brain activity faces several challenges:

• It fails to explain subjective experience (the "hard problem" of consciousness)
• It struggles to account for phenomena like near-death experiences and memories of past lives
• It contradicts our direct experience of consciousness as more than just brain activity

Alternative perspectives. Emerging theories propose that:

• Consciousness may be a fundamental aspect of reality, not just an emergent property of complex brains
• The brain may act more like a receiver of consciousness rather than its generator
• Consciousness might extend beyond individual brains, connecting us to a broader field of awareness

5. Purposeful Universe: Challenging Mechanistic Views

If evolutionary biology has taught us anything over the last century, it is that there is no need to invoke a divine creator to explain the emergence of complex functional organization in nature.

Inherent purpose. The mechanistic view of nature as purposeless is being challenged by:

• The apparent fine-tuning of the universe for life
• The goal-directed behavior observed in living organisms
• The emergence of complex, self-organizing systems at all levels of nature

Implications. Recognizing purpose in nature:

• Bridges the gap between scientific and spiritual worldviews
• Encourages a more holistic approach to understanding life and the universe
• Suggests that evolution may have inherent directionality, rather than being purely random

6. Inheritance: More Than Just Genes

Genes are overrated in the sense that they do not 'code for' or 'program' the form and behavior of organisms.

Beyond genetic determinism. Recent research reveals that inheritance involves more than just genes:

• Epigenetic factors can modify gene expression without changing DNA sequences
• Cultural inheritance plays a significant role in human behavior and development
• The concept of morphic resonance suggests a form of collective memory influencing inheritance

Implications for biology. This expanded view of inheritance:

• Challenges the central dogma of molecular biology
• Explains phenomena that genetic determinism struggles to account for
• Offers new approaches to understanding evolution and development

7. Memory: Not Stored in Material Traces

The trace theory of memory is very questionable indeed. It raises appalling logical problems.

Problems with trace theory. The idea that memories are stored as material traces in the brain faces several issues:

• Decades of research have failed to locate specific memory traces
• It doesn't explain how memories persist despite the turnover of brain molecules
• It struggles to account for phenomena like past-life memories and savant syndrome

Alternative models. New theories propose that:

• Memory may be a resonance phenomenon, connecting us to past experiences across time
• The brain may act more like a tuning system than a storage device
• Memories might be stored in a field that extends beyond the physical brain

8. Extended Minds: Consciousness Beyond the Brain

Our conscious experiences are not confined to our brains, or even to our bodies. Our minds extend far beyond our skins.

Mind beyond the brain. Evidence suggesting that consciousness extends beyond the brain includes:

• Telepathy and other psi phenomena
• Near-death and out-of-body experiences
• The sense of being stared at

Field theories of mind. These phenomena can be better explained by theories that view consciousness as a field:

• Extending beyond the physical brain
• Connecting us to others and our environment
• Potentially accessing information beyond the limitations of our senses

9. Psychic Phenomena: Evidence and Implications

Most people have had seemingly telepathic experiences. Most have felt they were being looked at from behind, and have turned round, or they have made others turn by staring at them.

Evidence for psi. Despite skepticism, there is substantial evidence for psychic phenomena:

• Statistically significant results in controlled experiments on telepathy and precognition
• Widespread anecdotal reports of psychic experiences
• Animal behavior suggesting forms of telepathy and precognition

Implications. Taking psychic phenomena seriously could:

• Revolutionize our understanding of consciousness and its relationship to space and time
• Lead to practical applications in fields like disaster prediction and mental health
• Bridge the gap between scientific and spiritual worldviews

10. Holistic Medicine: Integrating Mind and Body

Mechanistic medicine is at its best when dealing with mechanical aspects of the body, like defective joints, decayed teeth, faulty heart valves and blocked arteries, or infections curable with antibiotics.

Limitations of mechanistic medicine. While highly successful in many areas, the mechanistic approach to medicine has limitations:

• It often ignores the role of the mind in health and healing
• It struggles to address chronic conditions and mental health issues
• It tends to treat symptoms rather than underlying causes

Integrative approach. A more holistic view of health incorporates:

• The role of beliefs, emotions, and social connections in healing
• Alternative and complementary therapies that consider the whole person
• Preventive approaches that address lifestyle and environmental factors

This integrative approach has the potential to improve health outcomes, reduce healthcare costs, and enhance overall well-being.

Last updated: April 3, 2025