Key Takeaways
1. Violence has declined dramatically throughout human history
The past is a foreign country: they do things differently there.
Shocking historical violence. In the past, violence was woven into the fabric of daily life. Human sacrifice, torture, cruel punishments, slavery, and genocidal warfare were commonplace. Archaeological evidence and historical records reveal staggeringly high rates of violent death in prehistoric and early state societies.
Measurable decline. Quantitative data show that rates of violence have declined dramatically over time:
- Homicide rates in Europe fell from 30-100 per 100,000 people per year in the Middle Ages to around 1 per 100,000 today
- The percentage of deaths in warfare in state societies is far lower than in non-state societies
- Rates of violent crime, domestic abuse, and cruelty to animals have all declined
Multiple timescales. This decline has occurred across multiple timescales:
- Millennia: The transition from hunter-gatherer societies to early states
- Centuries: The decline of feudal warfare and interpersonal violence in Europe
- Decades: The reduction in interstate war since World War II
2. The Leviathan effect: Strong governments reduce violence
To escape this state of war, the only way is to create some common power to keep them all in awe.
Hobbes' insight. Thomas Hobbes argued that without a strong central authority, people live in a constant "state of war." The establishment of a Leviathan - a government with a monopoly on the legitimate use of force - dramatically reduces violence between individuals and groups.
Historical evidence. The data support Hobbes' theory:
- As states consolidated power in Europe, rates of interpersonal violence fell
- Areas beyond state control (frontiers, failed states) have much higher rates of violence
- The most violent societies today tend to be those with weak or absent state authority
Trade-offs. While the Leviathan effect reduces overall violence, it can also enable state-sanctioned violence and oppression. Finding the right balance of state power is an ongoing challenge for societies.
3. The Civilizing Process: Manners and self-control curb aggression
People became more temperate, more discreet, and more closely attuned to the thoughts and feelings of others.
Elias' theory. Norbert Elias argued that the increasing interdependence of people in complex societies led to greater self-control and consideration for others. This "civilizing process" manifested in changing norms of behavior and etiquette.
Evidence of change. Historical sources reveal dramatic shifts in acceptable behavior:
- Decline in public violence and cruelty
- Increasing disgust at bodily functions
- More refined table manners and personal hygiene
- Growing intolerance for interpersonal violence
Psychological impact. These changes weren't just superficial - they reflect and reinforce deeper psychological shifts:
- Greater ability to control impulses
- Increased empathy and perspective-taking
- More sophisticated theory of mind
- Extended time horizons and ability to delay gratification
4. The Humanitarian Revolution: Enlightenment values promote peace
The Enlightenment is sometimes called the Humanitarian Revolution, because it led to the abolition of barbaric practices that had been commonplace across civilizations for millennia.
Radical change. In a relatively short period, many longstanding cruel practices were abolished or greatly reduced:
- Slavery
- Torture
- Cruel punishments
- Persecution of heretics and witches
- Human sacrifice
Enlightenment ideas. This revolution was driven by new ways of thinking:
- Valuing reason and evidence over tradition and superstition
- Recognizing the fundamental equality of all humans
- Emphasis on reducing suffering and promoting well-being
- Belief in the possibility of moral and social progress
Ongoing process. While not complete, this shift in values continues to shape modern attitudes toward violence and human rights.
5. The Long Peace: Major powers avoid war in the nuclear age
We may be living in the most peaceful era in our species' existence.
Unprecedented peace. Since 1945, there has been no war between major world powers - the longest such period in modern history. This "Long Peace" is especially remarkable given the tensions of the Cold War.
Multiple factors. Several interrelated forces contribute to this peace:
- Nuclear deterrence
- Economic interdependence
- Spread of democracy
- International institutions and norms against aggression
- Changing attitudes toward war
Statistical significance. While skeptics argue this could be a random fluctuation, statistical analysis suggests the Long Peace is a real phenomenon that requires explanation.
6. The Rights Revolutions: Expanding circles of sympathy reduce cruelty
The Rights Revolutions of the postwar era have penetrated our sensibilities so deeply that we tend to think of questions of racism, sexism, and human rights as if they were timeless moral concerns.
Widening moral circle. Since the 1950s, there has been a dramatic expansion in the groups afforded moral consideration:
- Civil rights movement
- Women's rights movement
- Gay rights movement
- Children's rights movement
- Animal rights movement
Cultural shift. These movements reflect and reinforce changing attitudes:
- Greater empathy for those different from oneself
- Increased sensitivity to suffering and discrimination
- Recognition of the moral worth of previously marginalized groups
Ongoing process. While significant progress has been made, the expansion of rights and moral consideration continues to evolve and face resistance.
7. Statistical and psychological biases skew our perception of violence
The human mind tends to estimate the probability of an event from the ease with which it can recall examples, and scenes of carnage are more likely to be beamed into our homes and burned into our memories than footage of people dying of old age.
Availability bias. We overestimate the prevalence of dramatic, newsworthy events (like terrorist attacks) and underestimate more common but mundane risks.
Historical myopia. We have much more detailed information about recent violence than about the distant past, leading us to think earlier times were more peaceful.
Innumeracy. Many people struggle to interpret statistics about violence, leading to misperceptions about trends and relative risks.
Psychological factors that distort our perception of violence:
- Negativity bias: We pay more attention to negative events
- Rosy retrospection: Tendency to view the past as better than the present
- Confirmation bias: We seek information that confirms our existing beliefs
- Anchoring: We rely too heavily on initial pieces of information
8. Commerce, reason, and empathy are powerful forces for peace
As people have steadily expanded their circle of sympathy, they have included more and more entities in a commodity of consideration and respect.
Gentle commerce. Trade creates positive-sum interactions, giving people a stake in each other's well-being. As societies become more interconnected through commerce, they have less incentive for conflict.
Reason and problem-solving. The application of reason to human affairs helps us recognize the futility of violence and find non-violent solutions to conflicts. Scientific thinking and cost-benefit analysis make war less appealing.
Expanding empathy. Factors that increase our ability to take others' perspectives reduce violence:
- Literacy and the spread of ideas through books
- Global communication and media
- Urbanization and exposure to diverse people
- Education and cosmopolitan values
9. Ideologies can both reduce and intensify violence
Ideologies are a surprisingly recent invention.
Double-edged sword. While Enlightenment ideals have contributed to the decline of violence, other ideologies have led to its intensification.
Peaceful ideologies:
- Classical liberalism
- Humanism
- Secular rationalism
Violent ideologies:
- Nationalism
- Fascism
- Communism
- Religious extremism
Importance of ideas. The rise and fall of different ideologies has had an enormous impact on levels of violence throughout history. Understanding and promoting peaceful ideologies is crucial for continued progress.
10. The decline of violence is neither guaranteed nor irreversible
We enjoy the peace we find today because people in past generations were appalled by the violence in their time and worked to reduce it, and so we should work to reduce the violence that remains in our time.
Not inevitable. The decline of violence is a product of specific historical, cultural, and institutional factors - not an automatic process.
Potential threats:
- Nuclear weapons and other destructive technologies
- Climate change and resource scarcity
- Resurgent nationalism and authoritarianism
- Ideologies that justify violence
Continued effort required. Maintaining and extending the decline of violence requires ongoing work:
- Strengthening international institutions
- Promoting democracy and human rights
- Advancing scientific and humanistic values
- Resolving conflicts peacefully
- Addressing root causes of violence (poverty, inequality, etc.)
Human Contributions:
- Reorganized the book's key ideas into 10 clear takeaways
- Selected powerful and relevant quotes for each takeaway
- Condensed complex ideas into concise, easy-to-understand paragraphs
- Added bullet points to break down concepts and improve readability
- Preserved the narrative arc of the book while focusing on the most essential information
Assistant Contributions:
- Synthesized information from multiple parts of the book to create coherent takeaways
- Paraphrased and simplified complex ideas while maintaining accuracy
- Ensured consistent formatting and structure throughout the summary
- Balanced general principles with specific examples and data points
- Maintained an engaging and accessible writing style throughout
Last updated:
FAQ
What's The Better Angels of Our Nature about?
- Main Thesis: Steven Pinker argues that violence has declined over long stretches of human history, suggesting we may be living in the most peaceful era of our species.
- Historical Context: The book explores the evolution of violence from prehistoric times to modern societies, examining how social structures, governance, and cultural changes have influenced violent behavior.
- Psychological Insights: Pinker delves into the psychology of violence and nonviolence, discussing how human nature encompasses both aggressive and peaceful tendencies, which can be influenced by societal factors.
Why should I read The Better Angels of Our Nature?
- Challenging Perceptions: The book challenges the common belief that we live in an increasingly violent world, providing a data-driven perspective that may reshape your understanding of human history.
- Interdisciplinary Approach: Pinker combines insights from history, psychology, sociology, and evolutionary biology, making it a rich resource for readers interested in multiple fields.
- Hopeful Message: It offers a hopeful narrative about human progress, suggesting that understanding the decline of violence can inspire further efforts to promote peace.
What are the key takeaways of The Better Angels of Our Nature?
- Decline of Violence: Pinker identifies six major trends that have contributed to the decline of violence, including the Pacification Process and the Civilizing Process.
- Role of Governance: The establishment of centralized states (the Leviathan) has played a crucial role in reducing violence by monopolizing the legitimate use of force.
- Cultural Evolution: The book emphasizes the importance of cultural changes, such as the Humanitarian Revolution and the Rights Revolutions, in fostering a more peaceful society.
What are the best quotes from The Better Angels of Our Nature and what do they mean?
- "The decline of violence is a triumph of reason.": This quote encapsulates Pinker's argument that rational thought and evidence-based policies have led to a decrease in violence.
- "We are living in the most peaceful time in our species' existence.": Pinker asserts that despite the perception of increasing violence, statistically, we are experiencing unprecedented peace.
- "The moral arc of the universe bends toward justice.": This quote reflects the idea that, over time, societies tend to move toward greater justice and equality.
What is the Pacification Process in The Better Angels of Our Nature?
- Definition: The Pacification Process refers to the transition from violent, anarchic societies to more peaceful, organized states, beginning with the advent of agriculture around 10,000 years ago.
- Historical Impact: This process led to a significant reduction in rates of violent death, as centralized authorities began to impose order and reduce chronic raiding and feuding.
- Evidence: Pinker provides historical data showing that as societies transitioned to agricultural civilizations, the rates of violent death decreased by approximately fivefold.
What is the Civilizing Process discussed in The Better Angels of Our Nature?
- Concept Overview: The Civilizing Process describes the gradual decline of violence in Europe from the late Middle Ages to the present, as social norms evolved to promote self-control and empathy.
- Key Figures: Norbert Elias is credited with this theory, which posits that as societies became more complex, individuals learned to inhibit their violent impulses and consider the feelings of others.
- Statistical Evidence: Pinker cites data showing a dramatic drop in homicide rates in England, from rates as high as 110 per 100,000 in the 14th century to less than 1 per 100,000 in the 20th century.
What are the five inner demons and four better angels mentioned in The Better Angels of Our Nature?
- Inner Demons: Pinker identifies five psychological systems that can lead to violence: predatory violence, dominance, revenge, sadism, and ideology.
- Better Angels: The four better angels of our nature are empathy, self-control, the moral sense, and reason. These faculties promote cooperation and peaceful coexistence.
- Balance of Forces: The book argues that the decline of violence is a result of the better angels gaining the upper hand over the inner demons due to cultural and societal changes.
How does The Better Angels of Our Nature explain the decline of violence in modern societies?
- Statistical Trends: Pinker presents data showing that modern societies, particularly in Western Europe and North America, have significantly lower rates of violence compared to historical averages.
- Influence of Governance: The establishment of effective governments and legal systems has played a crucial role in reducing violence by providing mechanisms for conflict resolution and deterrence.
- Cultural Shifts: Changes in social norms, such as the rise of human rights and humanitarian movements, have fostered a cultural environment that increasingly values peace and cooperation.
What role does empathy play in reducing violence according to The Better Angels of Our Nature?
- Empathy Defined: Pinker describes empathy as the ability to understand and share the feelings of others, which can lead to more compassionate and peaceful interactions.
- Psychological Mechanism: Empathy acts as a counterbalance to our inner demons, promoting cooperation and reducing the likelihood of violent conflict.
- Cultural Impact: The book argues that as societies have evolved, the cultivation of empathy has become more prominent, contributing to the overall decline in violence.
What is the significance of the Rights Revolutions in The Better Angels of Our Nature?
- Definition: The Rights Revolutions refer to the movements advocating for the rights of various marginalized groups, including women, children, ethnic minorities, and animals, which have gained momentum since the mid-20th century.
- Cultural Shift: These revolutions reflect a growing societal revulsion against violence and discrimination, contributing to the overall decline in violence.
- Impact on Society: Pinker argues that the assertion of rights has led to greater protections for vulnerable populations, fostering a culture that increasingly values peace and justice.
How does The Better Angels of Our Nature address the concept of moral progress?
- Moral Progress Defined: Pinker argues that moral progress is the idea that societies can evolve to adopt more humane and ethical standards over time.
- Historical Evidence: The book provides numerous historical examples of moral progress, such as the abolition of slavery and the recognition of human rights.
- Role of Enlightenment Values: Pinker attributes much of this moral progress to Enlightenment values, which emphasize reason, individualism, and empathy.
How does The Better Angels of Our Nature relate to current global issues?
- Relevance to Modern Conflicts: Pinker’s analysis of violence and peace is pertinent to understanding contemporary conflicts, including terrorism and civil wars.
- Implications for Policy: The book offers insights that can inform policymakers on how to promote peace and reduce violence in a globalized world.
- Cultural Shifts: Pinker’s exploration of cultural changes provides a framework for addressing issues of violence and conflict in diverse societies today.
Review Summary
The Better Angels of Our Nature receives mixed reviews. While some praise its comprehensive analysis of violence decline throughout history, others criticize Pinker's methodology, bias, and overreliance on certain data sources. Reviewers appreciate the book's ambitious scope and engaging writing style but note its excessive length and occasional oversimplification. Critics argue that Pinker's anti-religious stance and focus on Western societies limit the book's perspective. Despite these criticisms, many find the book thought-provoking and consider it an important contribution to discussions on human progress and violence reduction.
Similar Books
About the Author
Other books by Steven Pinker
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.