Plot Summary
Dark Family Secrets
Nora Davis, a successful surgeon, lives under the shadow of her father, Aaron Nierling, a serial killer known as the Handyman. He was arrested for murdering numerous women and severing their hands. Despite changing her last name and building a new life, Nora is haunted by her past, especially as the anniversary of her father's arrest approaches. She struggles with the fear that she might share his dark tendencies.
A Surgeon's Solitude
Nora leads a solitary life, avoiding relationships due to her fear of her genetic inheritance. She frequents a bar where she meets Brady, an old college acquaintance. Despite her attraction to him, she is wary of getting close. Her life is disrupted when she senses someone is watching her, and she becomes increasingly paranoid about her safety.
Shadows of the Past
Two of Nora's patients, Amber Swanson and Shelby Gillis, are found murdered with their hands severed, echoing her father's crimes. Detective Barber questions Nora, suspecting a connection due to her father's history. Nora is terrified that her past is catching up with her and that she might be implicated in the murders.
A Dangerous Inheritance
As the investigation intensifies, Nora grapples with her identity and fears that she might be like her father. She receives a letter from him, urging her to visit. Despite her reluctance, she decides to confront him, hoping to find answers about the murders and her own nature.
The Copycat Killer
Nora visits her father in prison, seeking answers. He taunts her, suggesting she might be responsible for the murders. Nora is horrified but determined to prove her innocence. She realizes someone is trying to frame her, using her father's methods to cast suspicion on her.
Unraveling the Mystery
Nora investigates the murders, suspecting someone close to her is involved. She discovers that her half-sister, Harper, is behind the killings. Harper, who shares their father's dark tendencies, seeks revenge on Nora for turning their father in years ago.
A Sister's Betrayal
Harper's plan to frame Nora is revealed. She has been manipulating events to make it appear that Nora is the killer. In a tense confrontation, Harper attempts to kill Nora, but Nora manages to overpower her with the help of Brady, who arrives just in time.
Confronting the Monster
In a final showdown, Nora confronts Harper in her basement, where Harper has tied up Philip, Nora's colleague. Despite being drugged, Nora fights back and subdues Harper with Brady's help. The police arrive, and Harper is arrested, confessing to the murders.
A New Beginning
With Harper in prison, Nora begins to heal from the trauma of her past. She realizes she is not like her father and can choose her own path. She rekindles her relationship with Brady, finding love and acceptance. Nora finally feels free to live her life without fear.
Characters
Nora Davis
Nora is a skilled surgeon living under the shadow of her father's crimes. She is isolated, fearing she might inherit his psychopathic tendencies. Throughout the story, she struggles with her identity and the fear of becoming like him. Her journey is one of self-discovery and redemption as she fights to clear her name and embrace her true self.
Aaron Nierling
Aaron is Nora's father, a notorious serial killer known as the Handyman. He is manipulative and narcissistic, showing no remorse for his crimes. Even from prison, he exerts a psychological hold over Nora, taunting her with the possibility that she might be like him.
Brady Mitchell
Brady is a former college acquaintance of Nora's who re-enters her life. He is charming and supportive, helping Nora in her time of need. Despite initial misunderstandings, he proves to be a loyal ally, assisting her in uncovering the truth and ultimately becoming her romantic partner.
Detective Ed Barber
Detective Barber is the lead investigator on the murder cases. He is initially suspicious of Nora due to her father's history but eventually realizes she is being framed. His persistence and dedication to finding the truth play a crucial role in solving the case.
Harper
Harper is Nora's half-sister, who shares their father's psychopathic traits. She harbors resentment towards Nora for turning their father in and seeks revenge by framing her for the murders. Harper's actions are driven by a desire to prove her loyalty to their father and to destroy Nora's life.
Philip Corey
Philip is Nora's colleague and partner in their surgical practice. He is charming and flirtatious but ultimately a good friend to Nora. He becomes an unwitting victim in Harper's plan, but his survival and testimony help exonerate Nora.
Plot Devices
Dual Identity
The story explores the theme of dual identity as Nora grapples with her father's legacy and her own fears of inheriting his traits. Her journey is one of self-discovery, as she learns to separate herself from her father's crimes and embrace her true self.
Red Herrings
The narrative uses red herrings to mislead both Nora and the reader, creating suspense and tension. Characters like Brady and Philip are initially suspected, but the true culprit is revealed to be Harper, adding a twist to the story.
Psychological Manipulation
Aaron's psychological manipulation of Nora is a key plot device. His letters and their prison meeting play on her fears and insecurities, making her question her own sanity and morality. This manipulation heightens the tension and drives Nora's actions.
Analysis
"The Locked Door" delves into the theme of nature versus nurture, questioning whether evil is inherited or a product of environment. Nora's journey is one of self-acceptance, as she learns that she is not defined by her father's actions. The story also examines the impact of family secrets and the struggle to break free from a dark legacy. Through Nora's character, the novel conveys a message of hope and redemption, emphasizing the power of choice in shaping one's identity.
Last updated:
Review Summary
The Locked Door receives mixed reviews, with praise for its gripping plot and unexpected twists, but criticism for predictable elements and an unlikable protagonist. Many readers found it a fast-paced, engaging thriller, while others felt it lacked depth and believability. The main character, Nora, a surgeon with a serial killer father, is central to the story's intrigue. Despite divided opinions, most agree McFadden's writing style keeps readers engaged throughout. The audiobook narration received negative feedback from several listeners.