The Naive and the Sentimental Novelist

1. Novels are second lives that reveal the complexities of our existence

Novels are second lives. Like the dreams that the French poet Gérard de Nerval speaks of, novels reveal the colors and complexities of our lives and are full of people, faces, and objects we feel we recognize.

Immersive experience: Novels transport readers into alternative realities, allowing them to experience life through different perspectives. This immersion is so powerful that readers often feel the fictional world is more real than their own reality.

Paradoxical nature: Despite knowing that novels are fictional, readers willingly suspend their disbelief to engage with the story. This paradox is at the heart of the novel's appeal, as it allows readers to explore complex emotions and situations in a safe, imaginary space.

Universal appeal: Novels tap into shared human experiences, making them relatable across cultures and time periods. They provide insights into the human condition that can be both comforting and enlightening, helping readers better understand themselves and others.

2. The art of the novel relies on our ability to believe in contradictory states

This paradox stems from the nature of the novel. Let us begin by emphasizing that the art of the novel relies on our ability to believe simultaneously in contradictory states.

Cognitive dissonance: The novel's power lies in its ability to make readers hold conflicting ideas simultaneously. This cognitive dissonance creates a unique mental state where imagination and reality coexist.

Suspension of disbelief: Readers consciously choose to accept the fictional world as real, despite knowing it's imaginary. This willing suspension of disbelief is crucial for the novel's effectiveness.

Balancing act: Novelists must strike a delicate balance between creating a believable world and acknowledging its fictional nature. This tension between reality and fiction is what gives novels their depth and complexity.

3. Reading a novel is a collaborative and personal task of transforming words into images

Reading a novel means that, while committing the overall context to memory, we follow, one by one, the thoughts and actions of the protagonists and ascribe meaning to them within the general landscape.

Mental visualization: Readers actively engage in creating mental images based on the author's words. This process of visualization is unique to each reader, making the experience of reading a novel highly personal.

Collaborative creation: The novel comes to life through the combined efforts of the author and the reader. The author provides the framework, but the reader's imagination fills in the details, creating a unique interpretation of the story.

Cognitive engagement: Reading a novel involves multiple cognitive processes:

• Visualization of scenes and characters
• Emotional connection with the story
• Analysis of plot and themes
• Memory retention of overall context

4. The novel's center is a profound opinion or insight about life

The center of a novel is a profound opinion or insight about life, a deeply embedded point of mystery, whether real or imagined.

Hidden meaning: The center of a novel is not always explicitly stated but is gradually revealed through the narrative. It represents the core message or insight that the author wants to convey.

Evolution during writing: Often, the center emerges or evolves as the author writes the novel. This discovery process adds depth and authenticity to the work.

Reader's interpretation: The perceived center can vary among readers, depending on their personal experiences and interpretations. This multiplicity of meanings contributes to the novel's richness and longevity.

5. Literary characters are artificial constructs shaped by the novel's landscape

People do not actually have as much character as we find portrayed in novels, especially in nineteenth- and twentieth-century novels.

Exaggerated traits: Fictional characters often possess more defined and exaggerated traits than real people. This amplification serves to highlight specific aspects of human nature or to drive the plot forward.

Shaped by context: Characters in novels are deeply influenced by their surroundings, the events they experience, and the overall landscape of the story. Their development is intrinsically linked to the novel's plot and themes.

Artificial nature: While characters may seem real to readers, they are ultimately constructs created by the author. Understanding this artificiality can enhance appreciation of the author's craft and the novel's deeper meanings.

6. Objects and details in novels are extensions of characters' emotions

Tolstoy does not tell us what Anna's feelings are as she rides on the St. Petersburg train. Instead, he paints pictures that help us to feel these emotions: the snow visible from the window on the left, the activity in the compartment, the cold weather, and so on.

Emotional projections: Objects and details in novels often serve as extensions of characters' emotions, allowing readers to infer feelings without explicit description.

Sensory engagement: By focusing on sensory details, authors create a more immersive experience for readers, enabling them to feel as if they are present in the scene.

Subtle characterization: The way characters interact with their environment and perceive objects around them provides insight into their personalities and emotional states.

7. Museums and novels share the quality of preserving everyday life and language

Just as museums preserve objects, novels preserve the nuances, tones, and colors of language, expressing in colloquial terms people's ordinary thoughts and the haphazard way in which the mind skips from one topic to the next.

Cultural preservation: Both museums and novels act as repositories of cultural artifacts, preserving aspects of everyday life that might otherwise be lost to time.

Language archive: Novels capture the evolving nature of language, preserving colloquialisms, dialects, and speech patterns of specific times and places.

Snapshot of society: Through their detailed descriptions and dialogues, novels provide future generations with insights into the social norms, values, and daily life of past eras.

8. The politics of representation is a challenge for novelists in non-Western countries

Throughout the poorer, non-Western parts of the world (including my homeland, Turkey), the issue of whom and what to represent can be a nightmare for literature and for novelists.

Cultural dilemma: Non-Western novelists often struggle with the challenge of representing their culture authentically while also appealing to a global audience.

Class and identity: Many non-Western authors come from privileged backgrounds, creating a disconnect between their experiences and those of the majority they aim to represent.

Balancing act: These authors must navigate between:

• Authentic representation of their culture
• Meeting expectations of Western literary traditions
• Addressing social and political issues in their countries
• Appealing to both local and international readers

9. The search for a novel's center drives both writing and reading

The search for the novel's secret center with utmost attention. This is the most frequent operation our mind performs when we read a novel, whether naively unaware or sentimentally reflective.

Driving force: The quest to uncover a novel's central meaning motivates both the writing and reading processes.

Layers of meaning: The center of a novel is often not immediately apparent, requiring readers to engage deeply with the text and analyze its various elements.

Evolving interpretation: As readers progress through a novel, their understanding of its center may shift, creating a dynamic reading experience.

10. The form of a novel can be an enigma that reveals its deeper meaning

I believe that the highest achievement of a novelist, as a creator and an artist, is the ability to construct the form of a novel as an enigma—a puzzle whose solution reveals the novel's center.

Structural significance: The structure of a novel can be as important as its content in conveying meaning and revealing its central themes.

Reader engagement: Complex novel structures challenge readers to actively participate in decoding the text's significance, leading to a more rewarding reading experience.

Artistic innovation: Experimenting with novel forms allows authors to push the boundaries of storytelling and find new ways to express ideas and emotions.

Last updated: January 24, 2025