Key Takeaways
1. Racism in children's literature persists through subtle means
"Racism is resilient, sneaky, and endlessly adaptable."
Hidden in plain sight. Racism in children's literature often operates covertly, embedded in seemingly innocuous characters and storylines. The Cat in the Hat, for instance, draws on blackface minstrelsy traditions, while other beloved characters like Bugs Bunny and Mickey Mouse have roots in racist caricatures. These subtle forms of racism persist because they are normalized and difficult to recognize without critical examination.
Nostalgic erasure. Adults often fail to acknowledge racism in cherished childhood books due to nostalgia. This emotional attachment can lead to dismissing or excusing problematic elements, perpetuating racist ideologies. Even well-intentioned revisions of classic texts, such as censoring racial slurs in Huckleberry Finn, can inadvertently mask the underlying racist structures without addressing them.
Color-blind racism. Publishers and creators often justify the lack of diversity in children's literature through "color-blind" arguments, claiming that race doesn't matter or that focusing on it is divisive. This approach ignores the reality of systemic racism and fails to address the need for genuine representation in children's books.
2. Whitewashing book covers erases diverse representation
"Whitewashing shows how putatively economic arguments sustain systemic inequalities."
Marketing misconceptions. Publishers often justify whitewashing book covers - replacing characters of color with white or ambiguous figures - as a marketing strategy. They claim that books with non-white characters on the cover won't sell as well, despite little evidence to support this assertion. This practice perpetuates a cycle where diverse books are seen as less marketable, leading to fewer being published or promoted.
Identity erasure. Whitewashed covers deny readers of color the opportunity to see themselves represented in literature. This erasure can have profound psychological effects, reinforcing feelings of otherness and exclusion. For white readers, it reinforces the false notion that only stories about white characters are universal or worth reading.
Visual impact. Book covers create powerful first impressions that shape readers' perceptions of characters and stories. When a cover misrepresents a character's race, it can fundamentally alter the reader's understanding of the narrative and its themes, potentially undermining the author's intentions and the book's cultural significance.
3. Genre restrictions limit storytelling for authors of color
"Genre is the new Jim Crow—a 'post-racial' way of regulating the literary experiences of people of color."
Pigeonholing authors. Publishers often expect authors of color to write only certain types of stories, primarily focusing on historical fiction, realism, or "issue" books addressing racism. This restricts creative freedom and perpetuates stereotypes about what stories people of color can or should tell.
Fantasy and sci-fi barriers. Genres like fantasy, science fiction, and speculative fiction remain largely dominated by white authors and characters. When authors of color attempt to write in these genres, they often face additional scrutiny or rejection, with publishers claiming there's no market for such stories from diverse voices.
Limited representation. The genre restrictions imposed on authors of color result in a narrower range of stories available to young readers. This not only limits the imaginative possibilities for children of color but also reinforces the idea that certain types of stories are only for white characters and readers.
4. The publishing industry's whiteness perpetuates systemic racism
"Publishing's whiteness either prevents it from seeing or, when it does see, from correcting its institutional biases."
Homogeneous workforce. The publishing industry remains overwhelmingly white, with estimates ranging from 79% to 89% of employees identifying as white. This lack of diversity at all levels of the industry - from interns to executives - creates a self-perpetuating cycle where the perspectives and experiences of people of color are undervalued or misunderstood.
Unconscious bias. Even well-intentioned white publishing professionals may harbor unconscious biases that affect their decision-making. These biases can influence which manuscripts are acquired, how they are edited and marketed, and ultimately, which stories reach young readers.
Systemic barriers. The publishing industry's structure creates obstacles for aspiring professionals of color:
- Low entry-level salaries favor those with independent financial support
- Prestigious unpaid internships are often inaccessible to candidates from less privileged backgrounds
- Networking and advancement often depend on connections within predominantly white social circles
5. Diverse books are essential for all children's development
"Children's literature is one of the most important arenas in which to combat prejudice."
Mirror and windows. Diverse books serve dual purposes:
- They provide "mirrors" for children of color to see themselves represented positively in literature
- They offer "windows" for all children to learn about and empathize with experiences different from their own
Combating stereotypes. Exposure to diverse literature helps children challenge stereotypes and develop a more nuanced understanding of race and culture. This is crucial for both children of color, who may internalize negative stereotypes, and white children, who may develop biased views without exposure to diverse perspectives.
Fostering empathy. Reading about characters from different backgrounds helps children develop empathy and cultural competence. This emotional intelligence is increasingly important in our diverse, globalized world and can help reduce prejudice and discrimination in future generations.
6. Critical reading skills help confront racism in literature
"Reading the un-bowdlerized classics of children's literature can help young people understand that racism is not anomalous."
Contextual understanding. Teaching children to read critically allows them to recognize and analyze racist elements in literature, both historical and contemporary. This skill helps them understand how racism operates in society and how it has evolved over time.
Engaging with discomfort. Rather than censoring or avoiding problematic texts, teaching children to confront and discuss racism in literature can be a powerful learning experience. This approach:
- Develops critical thinking skills
- Encourages open dialogue about race and prejudice
- Prepares children to recognize and challenge racism in real-life situations
Balancing preservation and criticism. While it's important to preserve historical texts, including their problematic elements, it's equally crucial to teach children how to engage with these works critically. This balance allows for an understanding of both literary and cultural history while promoting anti-racist values.
7. Activism is crucial to diversify children's literature
"We Need Diverse Books and Black Lives Matter are not just slogans. They are directives."
Grassroots movements. Initiatives like We Need Diverse Books have been instrumental in raising awareness about the lack of diversity in children's literature. These movements:
- Pressure publishers to increase representation
- Support authors and illustrators of color
- Educate readers and industry professionals about the importance of diverse books
Consumer power. Readers, parents, educators, and librarians can drive change by:
- Purchasing and promoting diverse books
- Demanding more inclusive offerings from publishers and bookstores
- Supporting independent presses and self-published authors who prioritize diversity
Institutional change. Activism has led to the creation of diversity-focused imprints, awards for diverse books, and changes in publishing practices. Continued pressure is needed to ensure these changes are sustained and expanded.
8. Acknowledging white privilege is key to dismantling racism
"White people: recognize your complicity in White supremacy and use your privilege to fight it."
Unconscious bias. White individuals must recognize that growing up in a racist society inevitably shapes their perceptions and behaviors, even if they don't consider themselves racist. Acknowledging this unconscious bias is the first step in addressing it.
Responsibility to act. As beneficiaries of systemic racism, white people have a moral obligation to work towards dismantling it. This includes:
- Educating themselves about racism and its effects
- Amplifying voices of color in literature and other fields
- Using their privilege to challenge racist structures and practices
Continuous self-reflection. Combating racism requires ongoing self-examination and willingness to confront uncomfortable truths. White individuals must be open to criticism and feedback, and commit to lifelong learning and growth in anti-racist practices.
9. Self-publishing empowers marginalized voices in literature
"When publishing gatekeepers exclude so many talented writers of color, self-publishing is often our only recourse."
Bypassing traditional barriers. Self-publishing allows authors of color to circumvent the often biased traditional publishing industry. This enables them to:
- Tell stories that might be rejected by mainstream publishers
- Maintain creative control over their work
- Reach readers directly without compromising their vision
Diverse genres and stories. Through self-publishing, authors of color can explore genres and themes that traditional publishers might deem "unmarketable" for diverse voices. This expands the range of stories available to young readers of all backgrounds.
Building community. Self-publishing has fostered networks of support among diverse authors and readers. These communities:
- Share resources and knowledge
- Promote each other's work
- Create alternative spaces for diverse literature to thrive
10. Anti-racist education is vital to combat societal prejudice
"Support a US Anti-Racist Education Act because racism is a national emergency that threatens our democracy."
Comprehensive approach. Anti-racist education should be integrated into all levels of schooling, from early childhood through higher education. This includes:
- Diverse literature in curricula
- Training for educators on recognizing and addressing racism
- Open discussions about race and its impact on society
Critical thinking skills. Anti-racist education equips students with the tools to:
- Recognize and challenge racist ideologies
- Understand the historical context of racism
- Develop empathy and cross-cultural understanding
Societal impact. By fostering a generation of anti-racist thinkers, this education can lead to:
- More inclusive policies and practices across all sectors of society
- Reduced racial bias and discrimination
- A more equitable and just democracy
Last updated:
FAQ
What is Was the Cat in the Hat Black?: The Hidden Racism of Children's Literature, and the Need for Diverse Books by Philip Nel about?
- Exploration of hidden racism: The book investigates how racism, both overt and subtle, is embedded in classic and contemporary children's literature, often going unnoticed by readers.
- Focus on structural and cultural racism: Nel argues that racism is structural, deeply rooted in publishing, culture, and institutions, with children's books serving as a key site where these ideologies persist and can be challenged.
- Case studies and analysis: Through examples like Dr. Seuss’s The Cat in the Hat, whitewashed book covers, and genre segregation, Nel illustrates how racial ideologies shape literature for young people.
- Call for change: The book advocates for increased diversity, anti-racist activism, and systemic reform in the publishing industry and beyond.
Why should I read Was the Cat in the Hat Black? by Philip Nel?
- Unveils persistent racism: The book helps readers recognize how racism endures in children’s literature and culture, even after decades of civil rights activism.
- Critical engagement with beloved texts: Nel encourages readers to confront the complexities of classic children’s books, fostering critical reading skills and emotional reflection.
- Actionable insights: The book offers concrete steps for readers, educators, and publishers to recognize, resist, and dismantle racism in children’s literature.
- Broader cultural understanding: It situates children’s books within larger social and historical contexts, deepening readers’ understanding of systemic racial bias.
What are the key takeaways from Was the Cat in the Hat Black? by Philip Nel?
- Racism is structural and systemic: Racism in children’s literature is not just about individual prejudice but is embedded in publishing practices, cultural norms, and institutional structures.
- Whiteness as the unmarked norm: The book reveals how Whiteness is often treated as invisible and universal, marginalizing people of color in both stories and the industry.
- Whitewashing and genre segregation: Practices like whitewashing book covers and limiting authors/characters of color to certain genres perpetuate racial hierarchies.
- Need for diverse books and activism: Nel calls for more diverse representation, critical reading, and active efforts to reform the industry and challenge racism.
How does Philip Nel define and critique “whitewashing” in children’s and young adult literature?
- Definition of whitewashing: Whitewashing is the practice of altering book covers or illustrations to depict characters of color as White or racially ambiguous, erasing authentic representation.
- Market-driven justification: Publishers often claim whitewashing is necessary for sales, but Nel argues this perpetuates structural racism and normalizes Whiteness as the default.
- Impact on readers: Whitewashing denies children of color the chance to see themselves in stories, reinforcing the idea that only White characters are relatable or important.
- Historical and ideological context: Nel connects whitewashing to earlier practices that positioned Whiteness as authoritative, showing its deep roots in publishing.
What is “color-blind racism” in children’s literature according to Philip Nel?
- Subtle denial of race: Color-blind racism refers to the ideology that claims race no longer matters, while actually preserving systemic inequalities through non-racial justifications.
- Publishing examples: Publishers use color-blind rhetoric to exclude or marginalize authors and characters of color, often citing market concerns or supposed genre fit.
- Sustaining racial hierarchies: This approach makes Whiteness invisible and normative, while people of color remain marginalized or stereotyped in children’s books.
- Risks of erasure: Color-blindness can make racism less obvious but more insidious, removing opportunities for critical engagement and reflection.
How does Was the Cat in the Hat Black? analyze the racial complexity of Dr. Seuss’s The Cat in the Hat?
- Origins in blackface minstrelsy: Nel reveals that the Cat was inspired by blackface minstrelsy, African American culture, and real Black individuals, such as elevator operator Annie Williams.
- Challenging literary segregation: Recognizing the Cat’s mixed racial ancestry disrupts the segregated history of American literature and highlights the “mixed bloodlines” of canonical children’s books.
- Symbolic ambiguity: The Cat embodies both oppressive racial caricatures and subversive, transgressive qualities, reflecting the contradictions of race and identity in 1950s America.
- Critical reflection: Nel encourages readers to confront the uncomfortable racial history behind beloved characters.
What are some notable examples of whitewashing in children’s and YA literature discussed by Philip Nel?
- Justine Larbalestier’s Liar: The US advance copy featured a White model on the cover, misrepresenting the mixed-race protagonist and undermining the novel’s themes.
- Rae Carson’s The Girl of Fire and Thorns: The cover depicted the dark-skinned protagonist as White, distorting the story’s racial politics and critique of colonialism.
- Cindy Pon’s Silver Phoenix: The hardcover exoticized the Asian protagonist, while the paperback lightened her skin and obscured her ethnicity, sending mixed messages about authenticity.
- Effects on readers: These cases alter perceptions, erase racial identities, and reinforce White supremacy in literature.
How does genre function as a mechanism of racial segregation in children’s literature, according to Philip Nel?
- Genre as the new Jim Crow: Nel argues that genre acts as a color-blind mechanism, segregating authors and characters of color into realism, historical fiction, and nonfiction, while fantasy and science fiction remain predominantly White.
- Statistical evidence: Data shows that books by and about African American and Native American characters are disproportionately concentrated in a few genres, with few in speculative fiction.
- Limits on imagination: This segregation restricts the diversity of stories available to children of color, limiting their imaginative possibilities.
- Reinforcing stereotypes: Genre boundaries reinforce ideas about which stories “belong” to which racial groups, perpetuating exclusion.
How does Philip Nel critique the argument that whitewashing or concealing a character’s race increases empathy in readers?
- Criticism of “judicious whitewashing”: Nel challenges the idea that hiding a character’s race fosters empathy, arguing that it treats race as a superficial trait rather than an integral identity.
- Risks of denying difference: Concealing race suggests that difference is an obstacle to identification, rather than an opportunity for learning and connection.
- Authentic identification: Nel asserts that readers can identify with characters of different races without erasing those differences, and that White children should have opportunities to identify with characters of color.
- Personal experience: He cites his own reading experiences to show that authentic representation does not hinder empathy.
What role does the publishing industry play in perpetuating racism in children’s literature, according to Philip Nel?
- Predominantly White workforce: The industry is overwhelmingly White, influencing which stories are published, how they are marketed, and who gets opportunities.
- Structural barriers: Unpaid internships, networking biases, and market assumptions disproportionately exclude people of color from publishing careers.
- Impact on diversity: These barriers limit the range of stories and voices in children’s literature, reinforcing systemic inequalities.
- Alternative avenues: Many authors of color turn to self-publishing or independent presses to share authentic stories.
What solutions and actions does Philip Nel propose in Was the Cat in the Hat Black? to combat racism in children’s literature?
- Multi-part remedy: Nel offers nineteen concrete suggestions for publishing, teaching, funding, and writing to dismantle racism in children’s books.
- Increasing diversity: He calls for more editors and creators of color, more books featuring diverse characters, and broader representation of lived experiences.
- Critical engagement: Teaching children to read “uncomfortably” and confront racist content with guidance fosters critical thinking and anti-racist awareness.
- Industry reforms: Nel advocates for hiring diverse staff, paid internships, and anti-racist education policies.
What is Philip Nel’s “manifesto for anti-racist children’s literature” and how can readers and the industry enact it?
- Recognize systemic racism: Nel urges readers, especially Whites, to understand that racism is often unconscious and shapes judgments in publishing and reading.
- Listen and act: He emphasizes listening to people of color, diversifying media consumption, and supporting diverse books and authors.
- Be accomplices, not just allies: Nel calls for active participation in anti-racist work, using privilege to challenge White supremacy and advocate for systemic change.
- Reader and industry activism: Readers can pressure publishers, support independent presses, and join campaigns like We Need Diverse Books to promote authentic diversity.
Review Summary
Was the Cat in the Hat Black? examines hidden racism in children's literature, exploring how classic books perpetuate racial stereotypes. Nel argues for more diverse representation and analyzes whitewashing in publishing. Readers appreciate the book's academic approach and call for change, though some find it repetitive or overreaching. Many praise Nel's insights on structural racism in children's books and publishing. The final chapter's actionable steps for promoting diversity are highlighted as particularly valuable. Overall, reviewers consider it an important, thought-provoking work for those involved with children's literature.
Similar Books
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
