Key Takeaways
1. Fear of Man: A Universal Struggle
Fear of man is such a part of our human fabric that we should check for a pulse if someone denies it.
Defining the Fear. The fear of man is not merely being afraid of someone; it's about replacing God with people, seeking their approval, and being controlled by their opinions. This manifests in various ways, from peer pressure and people-pleasing to codependency and the pursuit of self-esteem. It's a deeply ingrained human tendency, affecting both the shy and the assertive.
Biblical Examples. The Bible is filled with examples of individuals who succumbed to the fear of man, including King Saul, who disobeyed God because he feared the people, and the Pharisees, who loved praise from men more than praise from God. Even Peter, despite his boldness, denied Christ out of fear of a servant girl. These stories highlight the pervasive nature of this struggle.
Modern Manifestations. In today's world, the fear of man is evident in our obsession with self-esteem, our over-commitment to please others, and our anxieties about being exposed as impostors. It drives our jealousy, our lies, and even our diets, revealing how deeply we crave the approval of others. Recognizing this universal struggle is the first step toward overcoming it.
2. Shame: The Root of Hiding and Fear
At the moment of Adam’s sin, shame — that is, “What will they think of me?” and “What will God think of me?” — became a cornerstone of human experience.
Shame's Origins. Shame, the feeling of being exposed and vulnerable, emerged immediately after Adam and Eve's sin. This shame-consciousness led them to hide from God and each other, marking the beginning of a desperate need for covering and protection. Shame stems from both our own sin and the sins committed against us.
Shame in Culture. In today's culture, shame often surfaces as low self-esteem, a secularized version of the biblical concept. Despite the prevalence of pornography and nudity, the taboo on nakedness persists, symbolizing our need for spiritual covering. We experience embarrassment when caught singing alone or when someone stares too long, revealing our underlying fear of exposure.
Hiding and Spying. Shame drives us to hide behind walls of self-protection, built with money, fame, or busyness. Yet, we also spy on others, seeking to normalize our own disgrace or find heroes to admire. This cycle of hiding and spying perpetuates the fear of man, keeping us trapped in a masquerade.
3. Rejection: The Idol of Approval
Sometimes we would prefer to die for Jesus than to live for him.
Craving Acceptance. Closely tied to shame is the fear of rejection, the desire for acceptance, love, and significance from others. This fear can lead us to compromise our values, as seen in King Saul's disobedience and the Pharisees' denial of Jesus. We often prioritize being liked, appreciated, or respected over standing for truth.
Peer Pressure. "Peer pressure" is simply a euphemism for the fear of man. It drives unwise decisions in teenagers and adults alike. We wait for others to take initiatives of love, worry about others' opinions of our appearance, and avoid opportunities to share our faith, all out of fear of rejection.
The Praise of God. Jesus, in contrast, did not seek praise from men but spoke truth with authority. The apostle Paul also prioritized the praise of God over the approval of others. Overcoming the fear of rejection requires a shift in focus from seeking human approval to seeking God's approval.
4. Threat: The Illusion of Power
What or who you need will control you.
Physical Vulnerability. The fear of physical harm is a potent driver of the fear of man. Abraham lied about his wife's identity out of fear for his life, demonstrating how easily we can prioritize self-preservation over trusting God. The Israelites' fear of the Canaanites led to a generation wandering in the wilderness.
Fear Run Amok. While fear in the face of genuine threat is natural, the fear of man is an exaggerated, sinful response. It's fear that forgets God, leading us to trust in others for salvation. This is seen in Janet, a victim of violence, whose abusers continued to control her life long after the abuse ended.
Faith in the Face of Threat. David, in contrast, consistently turned to God in his fear, declaring, "The Lord is the stronghold of my life—of whom shall I be afraid?" Overcoming the fear of threat requires a constant reminder of God's power and protection.
5. The World's Influence: A Culture of Self
Individualism, at first, only saps the virtues of public life; but, in the long run, it attacks and destroys all others, and is at length absorbed in downright selfishness.
Sub-Biblical Assumptions. The world, with its sub-biblical assumptions, intensifies our natural tendency to fear man. This includes a culture of victimization, where blame is shifted to others, and an overemphasis on self-esteem, which leaves us dependent on external validation. These assumptions affect our interpretations of the Bible.
The Cult of Self. Since the 1800s, Western culture has increasingly valued individual growth, personal identity, and the possibilities of the person without linking it to a submission to divine authority. This has led to a focus on feelings, a watered-down version of spirituality, and a diminished view of God's holiness and sovereignty.
Psychological Needs. American psychology has become the caretaker of these modern assumptions, promoting the idea that we are morally good, that emotions are the way to truth, and that all people are spiritual. It has also popularized the concept of psychological needs, which, when unmet, lead to personal pathology. This emphasis on self-focus and neediness further fuels the fear of man.
6. The Fear of the Lord: The Antidote to All Fears
He will be the sure foundation for your times, a rich store of salvation and wisdom and knowledge; the fear of the Lord is the key to this treasure.
Defining the Fear of the Lord. The fear of the Lord is not simply terror but a spectrum of attitudes, ranging from dread to reverent submission. It includes a knowledge of our sinfulness and God's moral purity, as well as a clear-eyed understanding of his justice and love. This worship-fear draws us closer to God, leading to obedience and delight.
Holiness of God. The key to understanding the fear of the Lord is grasping the holiness of God, his "otherness," his transcendence. He is different from us, and none of his attributes can be understood by comparison to his creatures. Yet, this transcendent God has also come close to us, revealing himself and becoming like us.
Learning the Fear of the Lord. The fear of the Lord can be learned through consistent Bible reading, meditation, and prayer. It requires recognizing God's mighty acts, both his holy love and justice. By focusing on God's glory and his character, we can displace the people-idols in our lives and become less prone to self-centeredness.
7. True Needs: Beyond Psychological Desires
Fear the LORD, you his saints, for those who fear him lack nothing.
Questioning Psychological Needs. The popular view of the person as a receptacle for psychological needs is challenged. While we all desire love and significance, elevating these desires to God-given needs can lead to self-centeredness and a distorted view of the gospel. It is essential to distinguish between biological, spiritual, and psychological needs.
The Image of God. The image of God in man is not about fulfilling psychological needs but about reflecting God's glory. We are to delight in God, make his name famous, and live for his purposes, not our own. This requires a shift in focus from self-improvement to the glory of the Holy God.
The "I Want" Problem. Psychological yearnings often stem from our refusal to love God and receive his love. They are expressions of our sinful nature, our "I want," which prioritizes self over God. The biblical response is to confess our self-centered desires and seek to love others out of the love and security we enjoy in Christ.
8. God's Love: Covering Shame and Filling Emptiness
O LORD, you have searched me and you know me.
The Welcoming God. After repenting of our self-centered desires, we encounter a God who welcomes us with open arms. He promises to remember our offenses no more, offering forgiveness and cleansing. This is a time to be controlled by the truth of God, not our fluctuating feelings.
Filling the Emptiness. God fills us with his love, pouring it out into our hearts by the Holy Spirit. This is not about satisfying our selfish desires but about meeting our spiritual need for forgiveness, covering from shame, protection from oppressors, and acceptance into God's family. It's about being deluged with God himself.
Hosea's Love Story. The book of Hosea provides a powerful illustration of God's love for his people. Hosea's marriage to Gomer, an adulterous wife, mirrors God's unwavering love for Israel, despite their unfaithfulness. This story reveals the depth of God's compassion and his commitment to redeeming his people.
9. Love in Action: Serving Others, Not Ourselves
To really understand the roots of the fear of man, we must begin to ask the right questions.
The Shape of Others. Having understood God's love and our own sinfulness, we must now consider other people. Are they gas pumps to fill our emptiness, tickets to acceptance, or priests to make us feel okay? Or are they something more?
Love Your Enemies. Jesus commands us to love our enemies, treating them as we have been treated by God. This requires a radical shift in perspective, seeing them not as threats but as individuals in need of God's grace. It means praying for them, serving them, and seeking their repentance.
Love Your Neighbor. We are also called to love our neighbors, those outside the body of Christ. This involves showing grace and mercy, treating them with the same compassion that God has shown us. It means being salt and light in our generation, pointing others to the love of Jesus.
10. The Church: A Community of Grace and Truth
We need to go further in searching the Scripture so that we can truly understand the nearly universal experience of the fear of man.
The Body of Christ. Those within the body of Christ are our family in a unique way. We are to love and be united with them, recognizing that we need each other to represent Christ fully. This requires actively participating in the church, seeking counsel, and using our gifts to serve others.
Corporate vs. Individual. The Bible emphasizes the corporate nature of faith. We are not meant to be isolated individuals but members of a community, working together to fulfill God's purposes. This requires a shift from "I" to "we," recognizing that we need each other to grow in grace and reflect God's glory.
Unity in Diversity. True biblical community does not mean sameness but unity in diversity. As we pursue oneness in the body of Christ, we become more unique, expressing our individual gifts and talents for the sake of the whole. This creates a vibrant, dynamic community that reflects the multifaceted glory of God.
Last updated:
FAQ
1. What is "When People Are Big and God Is Small" by Edward T. Welch about?
- Core Theme: The book explores the pervasive problem of the "fear of man"—being controlled by what others think, peer pressure, codependency, and people-pleasing—and contrasts it with the biblical call to fear God.
- Spiritual Diagnosis: Welch argues that many psychological struggles, such as low self-esteem and codependency, are rooted in making people "big" and God "small" in our lives.
- Biblical Solution: The book offers a scriptural path to freedom, emphasizing the need to grow in the fear of the Lord, repent of self-centered desires, and learn to love others more than needing them.
- Practical Application: Through personal stories, biblical examples, and practical steps, Welch guides readers to recognize, confront, and overcome the fear of man.
2. Why should I read "When People Are Big and God Is Small" by Edward T. Welch?
- Universal Relevance: Welch demonstrates that the fear of man is a near-universal human struggle, affecting everyone from the shy to the bold, and impacting relationships, self-image, and spiritual growth.
- Biblical Depth: The book provides a thorough biblical analysis of why we fear others and how this fear manifests in modern life, offering a perspective often missing in secular self-help literature.
- Practical Guidance: Readers receive concrete steps for identifying and addressing the fear of man, including self-examination, repentance, and cultivating a greater fear of God.
- Transformative Potential: By shifting focus from self and others to God, the book promises not just symptom relief but deep, lasting change in how we relate to God and people.
3. What are the key takeaways from "When People Are Big and God Is Small"?
- People as Idols: The fear of man is essentially idolatry—making people and their opinions more significant than God.
- Root of Many Problems: Issues like peer pressure, codependency, low self-esteem, and people-pleasing are all expressions of the fear of man.
- Fear of the Lord as Antidote: The most radical and effective treatment is to grow in the fear of the Lord, making God "big" in our hearts and lives.
- Need Less, Love More: True freedom comes when we need people less (for our own sake) and love them more (for God’s glory), shifting from self-centeredness to Christ-centered service.
4. How does Edward T. Welch define the "fear of man" in "When People Are Big and God Is Small"?
- Broad Biblical Definition: The fear of man includes being afraid of others, needing their approval, being controlled or mastered by them, and putting trust in people over God.
- Manifestations: It appears as peer pressure, people-pleasing, codependency, over-commitment, difficulty saying no, and even shyness or social anxiety.
- Idolatry at Heart: Welch frames the fear of man as replacing God with people, making their opinions and power central to our identity and decisions.
- Universal Struggle: He argues that everyone, regardless of personality or status, is susceptible to this fear in various forms.
5. What is the "fear of the Lord" and why is it central in "When People Are Big and God Is Small"?
- Definition: The fear of the Lord is a reverent awe and submission to God that leads to obedience, trust, and worship, rather than terror or avoidance.
- Contrast with Fear of Man: When God is "big" in our lives, the opinions and threats of people lose their controlling power.
- Path to Freedom: Growing in the fear of the Lord is presented as the primary antidote to the fear of man, shifting our focus from self and others to God’s holiness and love.
- Learned and Nurtured: Welch emphasizes that the fear of the Lord can be learned through Scripture, prayer, and community, and is a lifelong pursuit.
6. How does "When People Are Big and God Is Small" address self-esteem, codependency, and psychological needs?
- Critique of Modern Psychology: Welch challenges the popular notion that we are psychologically needy "love cups" who require affirmation from others to be whole.
- Root Problem: He argues that what we often call "needs" are actually desires or lusts that have become demands, leading to bondage to others’ opinions.
- Biblical Needs: The book distinguishes between true needs (for God, forgiveness, and community) and self-centered cravings for significance or love from people.
- Repentance and Redefinition: Freedom comes not from having our "needs" met by others, but from repentance, finding our identity in Christ, and learning to love others selflessly.
7. What practical steps does Edward T. Welch recommend for overcoming the fear of man in "When People Are Big and God Is Small"?
- Recognize the Problem: Identify where the fear of man is active in your life, including its roots in past experiences and cultural influences.
- Grow in the Fear of the Lord: Regularly meditate on God’s holiness, justice, and love through Scripture, prayer, and worship.
- Repent of Self-Centered Desires: Examine and confess where your desires for approval, acceptance, or control have become idols.
- Need People Less, Love More: Shift from needing people for your own sake to loving them for God’s sake, seeking to serve rather than be served.
8. How does "When People Are Big and God Is Small" use biblical stories and characters to illustrate its points?
- Examples of Fear of Man: Welch examines figures like Abraham (lying out of fear), King Saul (disobeying God to please people), Peter (denying Christ), and the Israelites (fearing Canaanites).
- Positive Models: He highlights those who feared God above people, such as Daniel and his friends, and the apostle Paul.
- Jesus as Ultimate Example: Jesus is portrayed as the one who perfectly feared God, not man, and who empowers believers to do the same.
- Lessons from Their Lives: These stories are used to show both the dangers of fearing people and the blessings of fearing God.
9. What does "When People Are Big and God Is Small" say about shame, victimization, and being sinned against?
- Two Types of Shame: Welch distinguishes between shame from our own sin and shame from being sinned against (victimization).
- Biblical Response: Both types of shame are addressed by God’s covering through Christ—confession and faith for our own sin, and receiving God’s compassion and new identity for victimization.
- Not Defined by the Past: The book warns against letting past abuse or rejection define us, instead urging us to find our worth and healing in God’s love and promises.
- Moving Forward: Healing involves both honest lament and a shift from self-focus to God-focus, learning to trust and obey even in the aftermath of deep wounds.
10. How does "When People Are Big and God Is Small" address relationships, community, and the church?
- Church as Family: Welch emphasizes that Christians are called into a corporate identity, not just individual faith, and that unity and love in the church reflect God’s glory.
- Need for Community: True spiritual growth and freedom from the fear of man require participation in the body of Christ, where mutual encouragement, accountability, and service occur.
- Loving Others Well: The book calls for loving enemies, neighbors, and especially fellow believers, moving beyond self-protection and isolation.
- Practical Unity: Unity is achieved through confession, forgiveness, honoring others, and using spiritual gifts for the good of the whole body.
11. What are the most important quotes from "When People Are Big and God Is Small" and what do they mean?
- "What or who you need will control you." This highlights the central thesis that our perceived needs dictate our actions and allegiances, often leading to bondage.
- "The most radical treatment for the fear of man is the fear of the Lord. God must be bigger to you than people are." This encapsulates the book’s solution: making God central displaces the controlling power of others.
- "Regarding other people, our problem is that we need them (for ourselves) more than we love them (for the glory of God)." Welch points out the shift needed from self-centered neediness to God-centered love.
- "Jesus did not die to increase our self-esteem. Rather, Jesus died to bring glory to the Father by redeeming people from the curse of sin." This challenges the therapeutic gospel and re-centers the message on God’s purposes.
12. What is the ultimate goal and conclusion of "When People Are Big and God Is Small" by Edward T. Welch?
- Fear God and Keep His Commandments: The book concludes that the whole duty of man is to fear God and obey Him, not to be ruled by the opinions or approval of others.
- Transformation of Identity: True freedom and joy come from finding our identity in Christ, not in what others think or how they treat us.
- Lifelong Process: Overcoming the fear of man is a lifelong journey of growing in the fear of the Lord, repentance, and love.
- Blessing for Others: As we are liberated from the fear of man, we become better equipped to love, serve, and build up others for God’s glory.
Review Summary
When People Are Big and God is Small receives mostly positive reviews, praised for its biblical approach to overcoming fear of man and focusing on God. Many readers find it convicting and life-changing. Some criticize it as overly simplistic or harsh regarding psychological needs. The book challenges modern psychology's emphasis on self-esteem, arguing for a God-centered perspective. Readers appreciate its practical advice and insights on loving others more while needing them less. Overall, it's considered a thought-provoking read that encourages spiritual growth and a deeper understanding of God's sovereignty.
Similar Books
About the Author
Other books by Edward T. Welch
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
