Plot Summary
Letter Sparks a Journey
In 2010, Vivian Morris receives a letter from Angela, prompting her to reflect on her past, starting with her arrival in New York City in 1940. At nineteen, Vivian was sent to live with her Aunt Peg after being expelled from Vassar College. This move marked the beginning of a transformative journey, filled with glamour, chaos, and self-discovery, as she navigates the vibrant world of theater and the complexities of adult life.
Vivian's New York Adventure Begins
Arriving in New York City, Vivian is captivated by the endless possibilities and excitement. She moves into the Lily Playhouse, a theater owned by her Aunt Peg, and is immediately drawn into the vibrant world of showgirls and actors. Vivian quickly becomes immersed in this new life, finding herself surrounded by colorful characters and a newfound sense of freedom, which leads her on a path of self-discovery and independence.
The Lily Playhouse's Colorful World
The Lily Playhouse is a hub of creativity and disorder, where performers and staff live and work in a whirlwind of activity. Vivian is drawn into this world, where the lines between work and play are blurred. She finds her niche as a costume designer, using her sewing skills to create outfits for the performers, and discovers a sense of belonging and purpose within the theater community.
Celia: The Showgirl's Influence
Vivian quickly befriends Celia Ray, a stunning showgirl who embodies the glamour and excitement of New York City. Celia introduces Vivian to a world of nightlife, parties, and romance, and the two become inseparable. Under Celia's influence, Vivian sheds her innocence and embraces a life of adventure and indulgence, learning about love, sex, and the complexities of adult relationships.
Edna and Arthur's Arrival
The arrival of Edna Parker Watson, a renowned British actress, and her husband Arthur, brings a new dynamic to the Lily Playhouse. Displaced by the war in Europe, Edna and Arthur find refuge at the theater. Edna's presence inspires Vivian, who is captivated by her elegance and sophistication. The theater community rallies to create a new show that will showcase Edna's talents, bringing a sense of purpose and excitement to the group.
Crafting a New Show
With Edna's arrival, Aunt Peg decides to create a new show, "City of Girls," to feature Edna's talents. The theater's staff, including Vivian, work tirelessly to bring the production to life. Vivian is tasked with designing costumes, drawing on her creativity and resourcefulness. The process of creating the show brings the theater community together, highlighting their resilience and passion for the arts.
Billy's Return and New Show
Billy Buell, Peg's estranged husband, returns to the Lily Playhouse with a promise to write a new show featuring Edna. Despite his charm and talent, Billy's presence stirs tension, especially with Olive, Peg's pragmatic secretary. His charisma and creative energy invigorate the theater, but his history of unreliability looms large. The theater community rallies to bring the production to life, with Vivian designing costumes and the cast preparing for a potential hit.
Vivian's Scandalous Night Out
Feeling neglected and insecure, Vivian joins Celia and Arthur for a night out. Their public display of affection is captured by photographers, leading to a scandalous exposé. Vivian's actions threaten the theater's reputation and her relationships with Edna and Anthony. The night marks a turning point for Vivian, as she grapples with the consequences of her reckless behavior and the impact on those around her.
The Aftermath of Public Exposure
The scandal erupts, with Vivian's name nearly exposed in the press. Olive intervenes, convincing Walter Winchell to omit Vivian's identity from his column. Despite this, the damage is done. Vivian's relationships with Edna and Anthony are shattered, and Celia is fired from the theater. Vivian is left to confront her actions and the fallout, realizing the depth of her betrayal and the fragility of her place in the theater community.
Edna's Unyielding Performance
Despite the scandal, Edna delivers a powerful performance, maintaining her dignity and professionalism. Her resilience inspires the cast, even as they struggle with the tension and whispers from the audience. Edna's ability to rise above the chaos highlights her strength and dedication to her craft, serving as a stark contrast to Vivian's immaturity and impulsiveness.
Vivian's Return to Clinton
Overwhelmed by shame and guilt, Vivian returns to her parents' home in Clinton. Her brother, Walter, helps her escape the city, but not without expressing his disappointment. Back in her childhood environment, Vivian struggles with the monotony and smallness of her life, haunted by her past actions and the loss of her vibrant New York existence. She attempts to rebuild her life, but the shadow of her scandal lingers.
A New Life and Old Habits
In Clinton, Vivian becomes engaged to Jim Larsen, a respectable local man. However, the engagement is short-lived, as Jim enlists in the military following the attack on Pearl Harbor. The broken engagement serves as a catalyst for Vivian's self-reflection and growth. She begins to rediscover her passion for sewing and contemplates her future, realizing that she must forge her own path and find her true identity beyond societal expectations.
Vivian's Return to New York
Vivian is invited back to New York by her Aunt Peg, who needs help with a wartime theater project. Despite her father's disapproval, Vivian seizes the opportunity to escape her mundane life in Clinton. The city, vibrant and full of potential, offers her a chance to redefine herself. Vivian is eager to contribute to the war effort and reconnect with the theater world, which she had left behind after a scandalous incident. Her return marks the beginning of a new chapter, filled with both challenges and opportunities for growth.
Wartime Work and New Beginnings
Vivian joins Peg in producing shows for the Brooklyn Navy Yard workers, using her costume design skills to boost morale. The work is demanding but fulfilling, providing Vivian with a sense of purpose and community. She navigates the complexities of wartime life, adapting to shortages and the constant pressure to entertain and inspire. Through her work, Vivian discovers resilience and creativity, forming bonds with her colleagues and finding a place where she truly belongs.
Reflections on Love and Loss
As Vivian ages, she reflects on the relationships that have shaped her life, particularly her bond with Frank. Despite never marrying or having children of her own, Vivian finds fulfillment in her friendships and work. The loss of loved ones, including Frank, brings sorrow but also a deeper appreciation for the connections that endure. Vivian's story is a testament to the power of love in its many forms and the resilience of the human spirit.
Characters
Vivian Morris
Vivian is a woman who defies societal norms, choosing a life of independence and creativity. Her journey is marked by personal growth, as she learns from past mistakes and embraces her unique path. Vivian's relationships, particularly with Frank and Marjorie, highlight her capacity for deep connection and loyalty. Her story is one of self-discovery and the pursuit of authenticity.
Aunt Peg
Peg is Vivian's aunt and a key figure in her life. She provides Vivian with opportunities for growth and self-discovery, encouraging her to embrace her talents and independence. Peg's theater projects during the war offer Vivian a chance to contribute to the war effort and find her place in the world.
Celia Ray
Celia is a stunning showgirl whose influence on Vivian is profound. Her adventurous spirit and glamorous lifestyle introduce Vivian to the excitement of New York City, but her involvement in the scandal leads to her dismissal from the theater. Celia's friendship with Vivian is marked by both camaraderie and competition, highlighting the complexities of their relationship.
Edna Parker Watson
Edna is a renowned British actress whose grace and professionalism shine through even in the face of personal turmoil. Her ability to maintain her dignity and deliver a powerful performance despite the scandal surrounding her husband highlights her strength and dedication to her craft. Edna's presence at the theater elevates the production and inspires those around her.
Arthur Watson
Arthur is Edna's handsome husband, known for his roles in British films. While he is charming and good-looking, he lacks the depth and talent of his wife. Arthur's presence at the Lily Playhouse adds a touch of glamour, but he is often overshadowed by Edna's charisma and talent.
Olive Thompson
Olive is Peg's efficient secretary, whose no-nonsense attitude and loyalty are essential to the theater's survival. Her intervention in Vivian's scandal demonstrates her protective nature and commitment to the theater community. Olive's pragmatic approach often serves as a counterbalance to the chaos and drama surrounding the Lily Playhouse.
Billy Buell
Billy is Peg's estranged husband, whose return to the Lily Playhouse brings both excitement and tension. His charisma and talent are undeniable, but his history of unreliability and self-indulgence complicates his relationships with Peg and Olive. Billy's presence is a catalyst for the theater's creative energy, but his personal flaws create challenges for those around him.
Frank Grecco
Frank is a war veteran who struggles with the trauma of his past. His relationship with Vivian is based on mutual understanding and respect, providing both with a sense of belonging. Frank's journey is one of healing and redemption, as he learns to forgive himself and embrace the love and friendship that Vivian offers.
Marjorie Lowtsky
Marjorie is Vivian's business partner and closest friend. Together, they build a successful fashion business and raise Marjorie's son, Nathan. Marjorie's creativity and resilience complement Vivian's talents, and their partnership is a testament to the power of chosen family and friendship.
Nathan Lowtsky
Nathan is Marjorie's son, whom Vivian helps raise. He is a sensitive and kind-hearted child, cherished by both women. Nathan's presence in Vivian's life brings joy and purpose, highlighting the importance of family and unconditional love.
Plot Devices
Letters and Reflections
The narrative is framed by letters and reflections, allowing Vivian to recount her life story and the relationships that shaped her. This device provides a structure for the novel, connecting past and present and revealing the impact of Vivian's choices.
The Lily Playhouse
The Lily Playhouse serves as a central setting, representing a world of creativity and community. It is a place where characters from diverse backgrounds come together, each bringing their own stories and talents. The theater symbolizes resilience and passion, highlighting the transformative power of art.
Costumes and Fashion
Vivian's talent for sewing and costume design is a key plot device, allowing her to find her place in the theater world. Costumes serve as a form of expression and transformation, reflecting the characters' identities and aspirations. Through her work, Vivian gains confidence and independence, using her skills to contribute to the theater's success and her own personal growth.
Analysis
"City of Girls" by Elizabeth Gilbert is a vibrant exploration of a woman's journey to self-discovery and independence. Through Vivian's experiences, the novel delves into themes of love, friendship, and the pursuit of authenticity. The story highlights the transformative power of art and the importance of chosen family, as Vivian navigates the complexities of life and relationships. The novel's rich characters and vivid setting create a tapestry of resilience and creativity, offering readers a celebration of unconventional choices and the enduring power of love in its many forms.
Last updated:
Questions & Answers
What is City of Girls about?
- A woman's life story: City of Girls is a coming-of-age story told through the eyes of Vivian Morris, who recounts her experiences in the vibrant and chaotic world of 1940s New York City theater.
- Self-discovery and freedom: The novel explores themes of self-discovery, female sexuality, and the pursuit of personal freedom, as Vivian navigates her new life and relationships.
- A world of theater and glamour: The story is set against the backdrop of a small, run-down theater, filled with colorful characters, showgirls, and actors, creating a world of both glamour and grit.
Why should I read City of Girls?
- Vivid characters and setting: The novel offers a rich cast of characters and a detailed portrayal of 1940s New York City, immersing the reader in a world of theater, glamour, and social change.
- Exploration of female sexuality: City of Girls provides a frank and honest exploration of female sexuality and desire, challenging traditional notions of women's roles and experiences.
- Themes of love and friendship: The story delves into the complexities of love, friendship, and chosen family, highlighting the importance of human connection and support in navigating life's challenges.
What is the background of City of Girls?
- 1940s New York City: The novel is set in the vibrant and chaotic world of 1940s New York City, a time of social change and cultural transformation, with the looming presence of World War II.
- Theater world: The story is deeply rooted in the world of theater, exploring the lives of performers, playwrights, and backstage staff, and the challenges and triumphs of putting on a show.
- Social and cultural context: The novel touches on themes of class, sexuality, and gender roles, reflecting the social and cultural norms of the time, while also challenging them through the characters' actions and choices.
What are the most memorable quotes in City of Girls?
- "You will do foolish things, but do them with enthusiasm.": This quote, attributed to Colette, sets the tone for the novel, emphasizing the importance of embracing life's experiences, even the messy ones.
- "Sometimes people just need to think about something else.": This quote, reflecting Aunt Peg's philosophy, highlights the power of entertainment and distraction in providing solace and joy during difficult times.
- "A girl must create her own opportunities.": This quote, spoken by Celia Ray, encapsulates the novel's theme of female agency and the pursuit of personal freedom, even in the face of societal constraints.
What writing style, narrative choices, and literary techniques does Elizabeth Gilbert use?
- First-person narrative: The story is told from Vivian's perspective, creating an intimate and engaging reading experience, allowing readers to connect with her thoughts, feelings, and experiences.
- Conversational tone: Gilbert employs a conversational and witty tone, making the story feel like a personal memoir, and drawing the reader into Vivian's world.
- Vivid descriptions and imagery: The novel is rich in vivid descriptions and imagery, bringing the characters and settings to life, and immersing the reader in the sights, sounds, and smells of 1940s New York City.
Hidden Details & Subtle Connections
What are some minor details that add significant meaning?
- The sewing machine: Vivian's sewing machine, a gift from her grandmother, is a recurring symbol of her creativity, independence, and connection to her family history. It represents her ability to create beauty and find purpose in a chaotic world.
- The color blue: The color blue appears in various forms throughout the novel, from Vivian's blue rayon dress to the blue knee socks worn by Aunt Peg, symbolizing different aspects of their personalities and experiences.
- The use of slang: The characters' use of slang and colloquial language adds to the authenticity of the setting and reveals their social backgrounds and personalities, creating a sense of time and place.
What are some subtle foreshadowing and callbacks?
- The mention of a "small fire": Early in the novel, Olive mentions a "small fire" at the theater, which foreshadows the later chaos and destruction that will come to the Lily Playhouse.
- The description of Billy Buell: The early descriptions of Billy Buell as a "myth" and a "playboy" foreshadow his later unreliability and the impact he will have on the lives of those around him.
- The recurring phrase "Let's go!": Aunt Peg's frequent use of the phrase "Let's go!" foreshadows her impulsive nature and her tendency to draw others into her chaotic world.
What are some unexpected character connections?
- Peg and Olive's shared history: The revelation that Peg and Olive met as nurses during World War I adds depth to their relationship, highlighting their shared experiences and the bond that has sustained them over the years.
- Vivian and Celia's physical resemblance: The observation that Vivian and Celia look alike, though they are very different, creates a subtle connection between them, suggesting a shared sense of beauty and allure.
- Frank and Walter's shared history: The revelation that Frank served with Walter on the USS Franklin adds a layer of complexity to their relationship, highlighting the shared trauma and loss that connects them.
Who are the most significant supporting characters?
- Olive Thompson: As Aunt Peg's secretary, Olive is a constant presence in Vivian's life, providing a sense of stability and order amidst the chaos of the Lily Playhouse. Her loyalty and pragmatism make her a crucial figure in the story.
- Mr. Herbert: The Lily's playwright and stage manager, Mr. Herbert, adds a layer of humor and pathos to the story. His dry wit and dark humor provide a counterpoint to the more flamboyant characters.
- Benjamin Wilson: The Lily's songwriter and composer, Benjamin, is a talented and refined figure who brings a sense of artistry and sophistication to the theater. His quiet presence and musical talent add depth to the story.
Psychological, Emotional, & Relational Analysis
What are some unspoken motivations of the characters?
- Peg's need for chaos: Aunt Peg's attraction to chaos and disorder stems from a desire to escape the constraints of her privileged upbringing and to create a world where she can be free and independent.
- Olive's need for control: Olive's rigid adherence to rules and order stems from a need to maintain control in a world that she perceives as chaotic and unpredictable, a result of her experiences in the war.
- Billy's need for attention: Billy's constant pursuit of glamour and excitement stems from a deep-seated need for attention and validation, a result of his privileged but emotionally distant upbringing.
What psychological complexities do the characters exhibit?
- Vivian's internal conflict: Vivian struggles with her desire for freedom and her need for belonging, often torn between her own desires and the expectations of others. She grapples with her sexuality and her identity, seeking validation through her relationships.
- Celia's vulnerability: Despite her outward confidence and glamour, Celia is deeply vulnerable, using her beauty and sexuality as a means of survival and protection. Her past experiences have left her with a deep-seated fear of abandonment and a need for control.
- Frank's trauma: Frank's experiences in the war have left him with deep psychological scars, manifesting in his inability to be touched and his constant need to be in motion. He struggles with feelings of guilt and shame, and his inability to reconcile his past with his present.
What are the major emotional turning points?
- Vivian's loss of virginity: Vivian's decision to lose her virginity is a major turning point, marking her transition into adulthood and her embrace of sexual freedom.
- The scandal at the Biltmore: The scandal at the Biltmore Hotel is a major emotional turning point, forcing Vivian to confront the consequences of her actions and the fragility of her relationships.
- Walter's death: Walter's death is a major emotional turning point, forcing Vivian to confront her grief and her complicated relationship with her brother.
How do relationship dynamics evolve?
- Vivian and Celia's friendship: Vivian and Celia's friendship evolves from a shared sense of adventure and glamour to a more complex relationship marked by competition and betrayal.
- Vivian and Peg's mentorship: Vivian and Peg's relationship evolves from a familial connection to a mentorship, as Peg guides Vivian through the challenges of life and the theater world.
- Vivian and Frank's connection: Vivian and Frank's relationship evolves from a shared history to a deep and abiding love, based on mutual understanding and acceptance.
Interpretation & Debate
Which parts of the story remain ambiguous or open-ended?
- The nature of Peg and Olive's relationship: The novel leaves the nature of Peg and Olive's relationship ambiguous, suggesting a deep bond that transcends traditional definitions of friendship or romance.
- The long-term impact of the war: The novel does not fully explore the long-term impact of the war on the characters, leaving the reader to imagine how their experiences will shape their futures.
- The meaning of "City of Girls": The title itself remains somewhat ambiguous, open to interpretation as a reference to the theater, to New York City, or to the complex relationships between women.
What are some debatable, controversial scenes or moments in City of Girls?
- Vivian's sexual encounters: Vivian's numerous sexual encounters may be seen as either empowering or reckless, depending on the reader's perspective, sparking debate about female agency and sexual freedom.
- The portrayal of male characters: The novel's portrayal of male characters, particularly Arthur and Billy, may be seen as either critical or sympathetic, depending on the reader's interpretation of their actions and motivations.
- The ending of the novel: The novel's ending, which sees Vivian living a solitary life, may be seen as either empowering or tragic, depending on the reader's perspective on the importance of romantic love and family.
City of Girls Ending Explained: How It Ends & What It Means
- Vivian's solitary life: The novel ends with Vivian living a solitary life, having never married or had children. This ending can be interpreted as a testament to her independence and self-sufficiency, or as a reflection of her inability to form lasting relationships.
- The enduring power of chosen family: Despite her solitary life, Vivian is surrounded by a chosen family of friends and colleagues, highlighting the importance of human connection and support in navigating life's challenges.
- The acceptance of life's complexities: The ending suggests that life is not always neat or tidy, and that it is important to embrace the messiness and contradictions of human experience, rather than seeking a perfect or idealized outcome.
Review Summary
City of Girls received mixed reviews. Many praised the vivid 1940s New York setting and Gilbert's writing style. Readers enjoyed the strong female characters and exploration of sexuality. However, some found the narrative structure confusing and the protagonist self-absorbed. The book's length and pacing were criticized by some. Overall, it was seen as an entertaining but flawed historical fiction novel, with comparisons drawn to "The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo."
Similar Books
About the Author
Other books by Elizabeth Gilbert
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.