Key Takeaways
1. Faith Requires a Teleological Suspension of the Ethical
In his action he overstepped the ethical altogether, and had a higher telos outside it, in relation to which he suspended it.
Ethical Duty vs. Divine Command. Kierkegaard introduces the concept of a "teleological suspension of the ethical," where faith necessitates setting aside conventional moral obligations to fulfill a higher, divine purpose. This is exemplified by Abraham's willingness to sacrifice Isaac, an act that defies ethical norms but is undertaken in obedience to God.
Ethical as Universal. The ethical, in Kierkegaard's view, represents the universal moral code that applies to all individuals at all times. It is a system of duties and obligations that govern social interactions and maintain order. However, faith, as demonstrated by Abraham, transcends this universal ethical framework.
Paradoxical Nature of Faith. The teleological suspension of the ethical creates a paradox, as it requires the individual to act against what is considered morally right in the eyes of society. This paradox is central to Kierkegaard's understanding of faith, highlighting its inherent tension and difficulty.
2. The Individual Stands Above the Universal Through Faith
For faith is just this paradox, that the single individual is higher than the universal.
Individual vs. Collective. Kierkegaard posits that faith elevates the individual above the universal, challenging the Hegelian notion that the individual finds fulfillment only through integration into the collective. Abraham's willingness to sacrifice Isaac demonstrates a commitment to a personal relationship with God that supersedes societal expectations.
Absolute Relation to the Absolute. This elevation of the individual is not arbitrary but stems from a direct, unmediated relationship with the divine. The individual, through faith, enters into an "absolute relation to the absolute," bypassing the need for ethical justification or social approval.
Ethical Duty as Relative. This absolute duty to God renders ethical duties relative. The ethical is not abolished, but it is given a paradoxical expression. Love of God can cause the knight of faith to give his love of his neighbor the opposite expression to that which is his duty ethically speaking.
3. Abraham's Silence Highlights Faith's Inexpressible Nature
Abraham cannot be mediated, which can also be put by saying he cannot speak.
Inability to Articulate Faith. Abraham's inability to explain his actions to Sarah, Eleazar, or Isaac underscores the inexpressible nature of faith. Faith, in Kierkegaard's view, transcends rational understanding and cannot be adequately conveyed through language.
Universal vs. Particular. Speech, by its nature, operates within the realm of the universal, seeking to establish common ground and shared understanding. However, faith, as a deeply personal and subjective experience, defies such universalization.
Distress and Anguish. Abraham's silence is not a sign of weakness or evasion but a reflection of the profound distress and anguish that accompany genuine faith. He cannot communicate the reasons for his actions because they are rooted in a realm beyond human comprehension.
4. Anguish is Intrinsic to the Paradox of Faith
What is left out of the Abraham story is the anguish.
Sleepless Nights. Kierkegaard emphasizes that the story of Abraham is not just about obedience but about the immense anguish involved in the decision to suspend the ethical. This anguish is not merely emotional distress but a deep existential struggle.
Ethical Contradiction. The anguish arises from the inherent contradiction between Abraham's ethical duty as a father and his religious duty to God. He is torn between his love for Isaac and his unwavering faith, creating a profound inner conflict.
The Test of Faith. This anguish is not a sign of weakness but a crucial component of the test of faith. It is through grappling with this inner turmoil that Abraham demonstrates the depth and sincerity of his commitment to God.
5. Resignation Precedes and Underpins Faith
In infinite resignation there is peace and repose; anyone who wants it, who has not debased himself by – what is still worse than being too proud – belittling himself, can discipline himself into making this movement.
Renunciation of the Finite. Before one can attain faith, one must first undergo a process of infinite resignation, relinquishing all claims to worldly possessions, desires, and expectations. This involves a conscious and deliberate renunciation of the finite in favor of the infinite.
Eternal Consciousness. Through resignation, the individual gains an eternal consciousness, a sense of connection to something beyond the temporal realm. This provides a foundation for faith, allowing the individual to transcend the limitations of earthly existence.
Discipline and Effort. Resignation is not a passive acceptance of fate but an active and disciplined process that requires strength of will and a willingness to confront the pain of loss. It is a necessary prerequisite for the leap of faith.
6. The Absurd is the Realm Where Faith Operates
He believed on the strength of the absurd, for there could be no question of human calculation, and it was indeed absurd that God who demanded this of him should in the next instant withdraw the demand.
Beyond Reason and Logic. Faith, according to Kierkegaard, operates in the realm of the absurd, where reason and logic cease to apply. It is a belief in something that defies human understanding and cannot be justified through rational means.
Double Movement of Faith. Abraham's faith is characterized by a "double movement": first, the infinite resignation of Isaac, and second, the belief that he will receive Isaac back despite the impossibility of such an event. This second movement is made "on the strength of the absurd."
Human Impossibility. The absurd is not merely improbable or unlikely but humanly impossible. It is a situation where all rational calculations and expectations are suspended, and the individual relies solely on faith in the divine.
7. The Knight of Faith Embodies Finitude and Infinity
The knights of infinite resignation are readily recognizable, their gait is gliding, bold. But those who wear the jewel of faith can easily disappoint, for their exterior bears a remarkable similarity to what infinite resignation itself as much as faith scorns, namely the bourgeois philistine.
Ordinary Appearance. The "knight of faith," the individual who has successfully made the leap into the absurd, often appears outwardly ordinary, indistinguishable from the "bourgeois philistine." This is because they have fully embraced both the infinite and the finite.
Mastery of Both Realms. The knight of faith has mastered the art of navigating both the spiritual and the earthly realms. They have experienced the pain of renunciation and the bliss of faith, yet they remain grounded in the everyday realities of life.
The Dance of Faith. Kierkegaard uses the metaphor of a dancer to illustrate the knight of faith's ability to seamlessly transition between the infinite and the finite. They can "leap straight into a definite position" without wavering or losing their balance.
8. Hegelian Ethics Cannot Accommodate Abraham's Faith
Where Hegel goes wrong, on the other hand, is in talking about faith, in not protesting loudly and clearly against the honor and glory enjoyed by Abraham as the father of faith when he should really be remitted to some lower court for trial and exposed as a murderer.
Clash of Worldviews. Kierkegaard critiques Hegelian ethics for its inability to account for the phenomenon of faith. Hegel's emphasis on reason, universality, and the integration of the individual into the state clashes with the paradoxical and subjective nature of faith.
Ethical vs. Religious. Hegelian ethics, according to Kierkegaard, prioritizes the ethical life, where individuals find fulfillment through contributing to the well-being of society. However, faith, as exemplified by Abraham, transcends this ethical framework, placing the individual in a direct relationship with the divine.
Abraham as a Murderer. From a Hegelian perspective, Abraham's willingness to sacrifice Isaac would be considered a moral outrage, an act of irrationality and barbarism. Kierkegaard argues that if Hegelian ethics is the ultimate standard, then Abraham should be condemned as a murderer.
9. The Demonic Mirrors the Divine, Yet Remains Distinct
The demonic has that same property as the divine, that the individual can enter into an absolute relationship to it.
Counterfeit Faith. Kierkegaard explores the concept of the "demonic" as a distorted reflection of the divine. The demonic, like faith, involves a direct, unmediated relationship with an absolute, but this absolute is not God but a destructive force.
Isolation and Concealment. The demonic individual, like the knight of faith, is often isolated and concealed, operating outside the bounds of conventional morality. However, their actions are driven by self-serving motives rather than a genuine commitment to the divine.
The Merman and Agnete. The legend of Agnete and the Merman serves as an example of the demonic. The merman, a seducer from the depths, represents the allure of the demonic, while Agnete's innocence and faith offer a path to redemption.
10. The Task of Each Generation is to Grasp Faith Anew
In this respect every generation begins afresh, has no task other than that of any previous generation, and comes no further, provided the latter didn't shirk its task and deceive itself.
No Progress in Faith. Kierkegaard emphasizes that faith is not something that can be inherited or accumulated over time. Each generation must grapple with the paradox of faith anew, without relying on the experiences or insights of previous generations.
Authenticity and Passion. The key to genuine faith is authenticity and passion. Each individual must confront the challenges and uncertainties of existence with honesty and a willingness to embrace the absurd.
Avoiding Self-Deception. The greatest danger lies in self-deception, in pretending to have faith without truly understanding its demands and complexities. Each generation must guard against complacency and strive to grasp the essence of faith for themselves.
Last updated:
FAQ
1. What is "Fear and Trembling" by Søren Kierkegaard about?
- Central focus on Abraham: The book centers on the biblical story of Abraham’s willingness to sacrifice his son Isaac, using it as a lens to explore the nature of faith.
- Exploration of faith and ethics: Kierkegaard, writing under the pseudonym Johannes de silentio, investigates the paradoxes and challenges of true faith, especially when it conflicts with ethical norms.
- Critique of modern attitudes: The text critiques how faith has become “cheapened” in modern times, arguing that true faith is a lifelong, difficult task, not a simple starting point.
- Philosophical and literary approach: The book blends philosophical argument, literary narrative, and personal reflection to probe the limits of human understanding and the meaning of religious experience.
2. Why should I read "Fear and Trembling" by Søren Kierkegaard?
- Foundational existentialist work: The book is a cornerstone of existentialist philosophy and has deeply influenced modern theology and philosophy.
- Profound exploration of faith: It offers a unique, challenging perspective on what it means to have faith, going beyond conventional religious or ethical interpretations.
- Engages with universal dilemmas: The text addresses timeless questions about duty, ethics, individuality, and the relationship between humans and the divine.
- Rich literary style: Kierkegaard’s use of pseudonyms, narrative retellings, and rhetorical flourishes make the book both intellectually stimulating and artistically engaging.
3. What are the key takeaways from "Fear and Trembling" by Søren Kierkegaard?
- Faith as paradox: True faith involves a “teleological suspension of the ethical,” where the individual’s relationship with God can override universal moral laws.
- The “knight of faith”: Kierkegaard distinguishes between the “knight of infinite resignation” and the “knight of faith,” emphasizing that faith requires both renunciation and the belief in the impossible.
- The isolation of faith: Genuine faith is deeply personal and often cannot be explained or justified to others, leading to existential loneliness.
- Critique of Hegelian ethics: The book challenges Hegel’s view that the ethical (the universal) is the highest human calling, arguing instead for the primacy of the individual’s absolute relation to God.
4. How does Kierkegaard retell the story of Abraham and Isaac in "Fear and Trembling"?
- Multiple retellings: Kierkegaard presents four different versions of the Abraham and Isaac story, each highlighting different emotional and ethical dimensions.
- Focus on Abraham’s suffering: The retellings emphasize Abraham’s anguish, isolation, and the incomprehensibility of his faith-driven actions.
- Contrast with traditional readings: Unlike traditional interpretations that celebrate Abraham’s obedience, Kierkegaard’s versions stress the paradox and horror of his situation.
- Illustrates the limits of understanding: The variations show that no retelling can fully capture the “fear and trembling” at the heart of Abraham’s faith.
5. What is the "teleological suspension of the ethical" in "Fear and Trembling" by Søren Kierkegaard?
- Definition of the concept: The “teleological suspension of the ethical” means that the ethical (universal moral law) can be suspended for a higher purpose (telos), namely, the individual’s absolute duty to God.
- Abraham as the example: Abraham’s willingness to sacrifice Isaac is seen as an act that suspends ethical duty (not to kill) for a divine command.
- Paradox of faith: This concept creates a paradox where the individual is “higher than the universal,” justified not by ethics but by faith.
- Critique of universalism: Kierkegaard uses this idea to challenge the Hegelian notion that the ethical is always supreme.
6. How does Kierkegaard distinguish between the "knight of infinite resignation" and the "knight of faith" in "Fear and Trembling"?
- Knight of infinite resignation: This figure renounces their deepest desire, accepting loss and finding peace in resignation, but does not expect to regain what is lost.
- Knight of faith: Goes beyond resignation by believing, “on the strength of the absurd,” that the lost object (e.g., Isaac, the beloved) will be restored in this life.
- Example of Abraham: Abraham is the knight of faith because he both gives up Isaac and believes he will receive him back, despite all human logic.
- Everyday illustration: Kierkegaard uses the example of a shopman or a young lover to show how the knight of faith lives fully in the world while holding onto the absurd hope.
7. What is Kierkegaard’s critique of Hegelian philosophy in "Fear and Trembling"?
- Ethical as the universal: Hegel claims that morality is realized in the individual’s identification with the universal (society, state, ethical norms).
- Faith as a higher category: Kierkegaard argues that faith cannot be subsumed under the ethical; it is a higher, paradoxical relationship between the individual and the absolute (God).
- Incommensurability of faith: For Kierkegaard, faith is not something that can be mediated or explained by philosophical systems—it is a leap beyond reason.
- Abraham as a challenge: The story of Abraham exposes the limits of Hegelian ethics, as Abraham’s act cannot be justified by universal moral standards.
8. How does "Fear and Trembling" by Søren Kierkegaard address the problem of communication and silence in faith?
- Faith is incommunicable: Kierkegaard argues that true faith cannot be fully explained or justified to others; it is a private, inward experience.
- Abraham’s silence: Abraham cannot explain his actions to Sarah, Isaac, or his servant, highlighting the isolation and unintelligibility of faith.
- Language and the universal: Speaking translates experience into the universal, but faith exists outside the universal, making it unspeakable.
- The risk of misunderstanding: Attempts to communicate faith often lead to misunderstanding, suspicion, or accusations of madness or immorality.
9. What is the significance of "anguish" and "paradox" in "Fear and Trembling" by Søren Kierkegaard?
- Anguish as essential: Kierkegaard insists that the true experience of faith involves deep anguish, not just obedience or resignation.
- Paradox at the core: Faith is defined by the paradox that the individual is higher than the universal, and that one can believe the impossible (“on the strength of the absurd”).
- No rational resolution: The paradox and anguish cannot be resolved by reason or ethics; they must be lived and endured.
- Faith as a lifelong task: The book argues that faith is not a simple or easy state, but a continual, passionate struggle with paradox and anxiety.
10. How does "Fear and Trembling" by Søren Kierkegaard use pseudonyms and literary style to convey its message?
- Use of Johannes de silentio: Kierkegaard writes under a pseudonym to distance himself from the text and to highlight the subjective, limited perspective of the narrator.
- Dialectical lyric: The book blends philosophical argument with literary narrative, parables, and rhetorical flourishes, creating a unique “dialectical lyric.”
- Irony and indirection: The pseudonymous approach allows Kierkegaard to explore ideas without directly asserting them as his own, inviting readers to wrestle with the text.
- Emphasis on subjectivity: The style reinforces the book’s central theme that faith is a subjective, inward passion that cannot be systematized or universally communicated.
11. What are the best quotes from "Fear and Trembling" by Søren Kierkegaard and what do they mean?
- “Faith begins precisely where thinking leaves off.”: This highlights the idea that faith is not a product of rational thought, but a leap beyond it.
- “The ethical expression for what Abraham did is that he was willing to murder Isaac; the religious expression is that he was willing to sacrifice Isaac; but in this contradiction lies the very anguish that can indeed make one sleepless.”: This quote encapsulates the central paradox and the existential anxiety at the heart of faith.
- “Only one who works gets bread, and only one who knows anguish finds rest, only one who descends to the underworld saves the loved one, only one who draws the knife gets Isaac.”: This emphasizes that spiritual achievement requires personal struggle and suffering.
- “Faith is the highest passion in a human being. Many in every generation may not come that far, but none comes further.”: This underscores Kierkegaard’s view that faith is the ultimate human achievement, but also the most difficult.
12. How does "Fear and Trembling" by Søren Kierkegaard relate to Kierkegaard’s own life and the broader context of existentialism?
- Biographical parallels: Kierkegaard’s own experiences—his broken engagement, his sense of isolation, and his struggle with faith—inform the book’s themes of sacrifice and inwardness.
- Existentialist foundations: The book lays the groundwork for existentialist thought by emphasizing individual choice, subjective truth, and the limits of rational systems.
- Influence on theology and philosophy: "Fear and Trembling" has inspired both modern Protestant theology and existentialist philosophers like Jean-Paul Sartre and Martin Heidegger.
- Enduring relevance: The book continues to challenge readers to confront the demands of authentic faith, individuality, and the meaning of ethical and religious life.
Review Summary
Fear and Trembling is a challenging philosophical work exploring faith through the story of Abraham and Isaac. Kierkegaard examines the paradox of faith, arguing it transcends ethics and reason. Many readers find the book profound yet difficult, praising its insights into religious belief and human existence. Some struggle with its dense prose and complex ideas. The work is seen as a seminal text in existentialism and Christian philosophy, though its glorification of blind faith troubles some. Overall, readers appreciate Kierkegaard's unique perspective on faith, ethics, and the human condition.
Similar Books
About the Author
Other books by Søren Kierkegaard
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
