Key Takeaways
1. Collaboration is essential, but not always beneficial
Too often a business leader asks, How can we get people to collaborate more? That's the wrong question. It should be, Will collaboration on this project create or destroy value?
Collaboration isn't always positive. While internal collaboration is often viewed as universally good, it can sometimes undermine performance. Companies need to be strategic about when and how they encourage collaboration. The key is to determine whether working together will produce better results than working independently.
Potential benefits and drawbacks:
- Benefits: innovative cross-unit product development, increased sales through cross-selling, transfer of best practices
- Drawbacks: wasted time, damaged relationships, delays in getting to market, budget overruns, lower quality
Evaluate carefully: Before launching collaborative initiatives, assess whether the potential benefits outweigh the costs and risks. Consider factors like the complexity of the project, the expertise required, and the existing relationships between units.
2. Evaluate collaboration using the collaboration premium framework
A collaboration premium is the difference between the projected financial return on a project and two often overlooked factors—opportunity cost and collaboration costs.
Use the collaboration premium framework. This approach helps determine if a collaborative project will create or destroy value. It involves estimating three key factors:
- Projected return: The expected cash flow generated by the project
- Opportunity cost: The potential value of alternative projects that won't be pursued
- Collaboration costs: Expenses arising from working across organizational boundaries
Formula: Collaboration Premium = Projected Return - (Opportunity Cost + Collaboration Costs)
If the calculation yields a positive number, the project is likely to create value. If it's negative, the collaboration may destroy value and should be reconsidered.
3. Avoid common errors in assessing collaborative projects
Never forget that the goal of collaboration is not collaboration but, rather, business results that would be impossible without it.
Be wary of common pitfalls. When evaluating collaborative projects, managers often make three key mistakes:
- Overestimating financial returns: Don't let enthusiasm for collaboration lead to overly optimistic projections.
- Ignoring opportunity costs: Consider what other valuable projects might be sacrificed.
- Underestimating collaboration costs: Account for challenges like coordination, travel, and potential conflicts.
Real-world example: DNV's food safety initiative failed partly because managers didn't properly assess opportunity costs and collaboration costs. They overlooked a potentially more lucrative IT opportunity and underestimated the difficulties of getting different units to work together effectively.
4. Implement strategies for managing conflict at the point of disagreement
Without a structured method for dealing with these issues, people get bogged down not only in what the right result should be but also in how to arrive at it.
Equip employees to resolve conflicts. To manage disagreements effectively at the point of conflict, implement these strategies:
- Devise a common method for resolving conflicts: Establish a clear, step-by-step process for parties to follow.
- Provide criteria for making trade-offs: Give people guidelines for balancing competing priorities.
- Use escalation as a coaching opportunity: Help employees develop conflict resolution skills.
Benefits of this approach:
- Reduces wasted time and ill will
- Encourages innovative solutions
- Integrates conflict resolution into day-to-day processes
Example: Intel trains new employees in a common method and language for decision-making and conflict resolution, providing a shared framework that expedites problem-solving.
5. Develop methods for resolving escalated conflicts
The solution to these problems is a commitment by managers—a commitment codified in a formal policy—to deal with escalated conflict directly with their counterparts.
Create a system for handling escalated conflicts. When disagreements can't be resolved at lower levels, use these strategies:
- Establish joint escalation requirements: Require conflicting parties to present issues together.
- Ensure managers resolve conflicts directly with counterparts: Avoid passing problems up the chain.
- Make the resolution process transparent: Explain decision-making rationales to provide guidance for future conflicts.
Benefits:
- Reduces unproductive escalations
- Ensures decision-makers have comprehensive information
- Provides valuable lessons for the organization
Example: IBM's Market Growth Workshops and Cross-Team Workouts provide structured forums for resolving escalated conflicts, with clear processes for moving issues up the management chain when necessary.
6. Choose the right collaboration mode for your organization
Different modes of collaboration involve different strategic trade-offs. Companies that choose the wrong mode risk falling behind in the relentless race to develop new technologies, designs, products, and services.
Understand the four collaboration modes. Choose the most appropriate based on two key dimensions:
- Openness: Is participation open to anyone or limited to select players?
- Hierarchy: Who makes key decisions - one "kingpin" or all participants?
The four modes:
- Open, hierarchical (Innovation Mall): Anyone can offer ideas, but your company defines problems and chooses solutions.
- Open, flat (Innovation Community): Anyone can offer and solicit ideas; no single participant has decision-making authority.
- Closed, hierarchical (Elite Circle): Your company selects participants and decides which ideas to develop.
- Closed, flat (Consortium): A select group is invited to participate, with shared decision-making.
Consider your organization's capabilities, structure, and assets when selecting the most suitable mode for each innovation initiative.
7. Foster a culture of productive collaboration
When a company begins to see conflict as a valuable resource that should be managed and exploited, it is likely to gain insight into problems that senior managers may not have known existed.
Create an environment that supports effective collaboration. To maximize the benefits of working together while minimizing drawbacks:
- Train employees in conflict resolution and collaboration skills
- Establish clear processes for initiating and managing collaborative projects
- Recognize and reward successful collaborative efforts
- Encourage open communication and constructive disagreement
- Regularly assess and refine collaborative initiatives
Benefits of a collaborative culture:
- Increased innovation and problem-solving
- Better knowledge sharing across the organization
- Improved employee engagement and satisfaction
- Enhanced adaptability to market changes
Remember: The goal is not simply more collaboration, but the right collaboration that creates value for the organization.
Last updated:
FAQ
What's "HBR's 10 Must Reads on Collaboration" about?
- Definitive Collection: This book is part of the HBR’s 10 Must Reads series, which compiles essential articles on collaboration from the Harvard Business Review.
- Focus on Collaboration: It explores the importance of collaboration in business, offering insights and best practices for leaders to foster effective teamwork.
- Diverse Topics: The book covers various aspects of collaboration, including leadership, conflict management, and the use of technology to enhance teamwork.
- Expert Contributions: It features articles by renowned authors and experts in the field, providing a comprehensive view of collaboration in modern organizations.
Why should I read "HBR's 10 Must Reads on Collaboration"?
- Comprehensive Insights: The book provides a thorough understanding of collaboration, making it valuable for both aspiring and experienced leaders.
- Practical Advice: It offers actionable strategies and real-world examples to improve collaboration within organizations.
- Expert Perspectives: Readers gain insights from leading thinkers and practitioners in the field of business collaboration.
- Critical for Success: Understanding collaboration is crucial for navigating today’s interconnected business environment and achieving organizational goals.
What are the key takeaways of "HBR's 10 Must Reads on Collaboration"?
- Leadership Role: Effective collaboration requires leaders to connect people and ideas, model collaborative behavior, and manage conflict.
- Conflict Management: Embracing and managing conflict is essential for fostering collaboration and innovation.
- Technology's Role: Digital tools and social media can enhance collaboration but require careful implementation and management.
- Strategic Collaboration: Organizations must choose the right type of collaboration based on their strategic goals and capabilities.
How does "HBR's 10 Must Reads on Collaboration" define a collaborative leader?
- Connector Role: Collaborative leaders connect people and ideas both inside and outside the organization.
- Modeling Behavior: They demonstrate collaborative behavior at the top, setting an example for others.
- Managing Conflict: Effective leaders manage conflict to prevent it from hindering collaboration.
- Leveraging Talent: They attract and leverage diverse talent to enhance team performance and innovation.
What strategies does "HBR's 10 Must Reads on Collaboration" suggest for managing conflict?
- Common Method: Implement a common method for resolving conflicts to streamline the process.
- Trade-off Criteria: Provide clear criteria for making trade-offs to guide decision-making.
- Coaching Opportunities: Use conflict escalation as an opportunity for coaching and development.
- Joint Escalation: Require joint escalation of conflicts to ensure accountability and comprehensive understanding.
How does "HBR's 10 Must Reads on Collaboration" address the use of technology in collaboration?
- ESSPs Definition: The book discusses emergent social software platforms (ESSPs) that facilitate collaboration without predefined workflows.
- Benefits of ESSPs: These platforms help in finding information quickly, harnessing collective intelligence, and building social networks.
- Risk Management: It emphasizes that while there are risks, they are often outweighed by the benefits when managed properly.
- Encouraging Participation: Successful implementation requires top-down support and active participation from leaders.
What are the myths about Enterprise 2.0 according to "HBR's 10 Must Reads on Collaboration"?
- Risk Overestimation: The book dispels the myth that the risks of using ESSPs outweigh the rewards.
- ROI Misconception: It argues against the need for a monetary ROI calculation for E2.0 initiatives.
- Automatic Adoption: The belief that employees will automatically use collaboration platforms is challenged.
- Limited Value Perception: It refutes the idea that E2.0 only helps close colleagues work better together.
- Information Focus: The book clarifies that E2.0's value lies in connecting people, not just generating information.
How does "HBR's 10 Must Reads on Collaboration" suggest organizations choose the right type of collaboration?
- Strategic Alignment: Organizations should align collaboration modes with their strategic goals and capabilities.
- Open vs. Closed Networks: Decide whether to use open or closed networks based on the need for diverse ideas or specialized expertise.
- Flat vs. Hierarchical Governance: Choose between flat or hierarchical governance depending on the need for control or shared decision-making.
- Combination of Modes: Organizations can use a combination of collaboration modes to support different strategic objectives.
What role does social intelligence play in leadership according to "HBR's 10 Must Reads on Collaboration"?
- Empathy and Attunement: Leaders with high social intelligence exhibit empathy and are attuned to others' moods.
- Neural Connections: Social intelligence involves leveraging neural connections to inspire and motivate others.
- Behavioral Impact: Leaders' behaviors can energize or deflate their teams, affecting overall performance.
- Development Focus: The book emphasizes developing social intelligence skills to enhance leadership effectiveness.
What are the challenges of building collaborative communities as discussed in "HBR's 10 Must Reads on Collaboration"?
- Shared Purpose: Establishing a shared purpose that guides efforts at all levels is crucial.
- Ethic of Contribution: Encouraging an ethic of contribution where members prioritize the common good over individual gain.
- Interdependent Processes: Developing processes that enable flexible yet disciplined collaboration.
- Collaborative Infrastructure: Creating an infrastructure that values and rewards collaboration.
How does "HBR's 10 Must Reads on Collaboration" differentiate between good and bad collaboration?
- Collaboration Premium: Good collaboration creates a premium where the benefits outweigh the costs and opportunity costs.
- Overestimation Risks: Avoid overestimating the financial return of collaboration without considering potential downsides.
- Opportunity Costs: Consider what other opportunities are being forgone by focusing on a particular collaborative effort.
- Collaboration Costs: Account for the costs associated with coordinating and managing cross-unit collaboration.
What are the best quotes from "HBR's 10 Must Reads on Collaboration" and what do they mean?
- "Collaboration Does Not Equal Consensus": This quote emphasizes that collaboration involves diverse perspectives and constructive conflict, not just agreement.
- "Loosening Control Without Losing Control": It highlights the balance leaders must strike between allowing autonomy and maintaining direction.
- "The Heart of Collaborative Leadership": This phrase underscores the importance of leveraging differences to create value through collaboration.
- "Harnessing Ideas, People, and Resources": It reflects the essence of collaboration in tapping into collective intelligence for organizational success.
Review Summary
HBR's 10 Must Reads on Collaboration receives mixed reviews. Readers appreciate its comprehensive coverage of collaboration topics, including building relationships, supporting teamwork, and addressing organizational silos. Some find the articles insightful and practical, with valuable examples and strategies for effective collaboration. However, others criticize the book for focusing primarily on large corporations and containing outdated content. The translation quality and font size in some editions are also criticized. Overall, the book is recommended for those interested in team development, business management, and improving workplace collaboration, despite its limitations.
Similar Books
About the Author
Other books by Harvard Business Publishing
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
