Key Takeaways
1. The Battlefield Demands Constant Vigilance and Adaptability
Facing the enemy, the commander of a reconnaissance patrol should be conscious of the great responsibility which rests on him.
Reconnaissance is paramount. The ever-changing nature of war necessitates continuous reconnaissance to gather accurate intelligence about the enemy's disposition, strength, and intentions. A failure to adapt to new information can lead to disastrous consequences.
Adaptability is crucial. A rigid adherence to pre-set plans can be a recipe for disaster. Commanders must be prepared to modify their strategies and tactics based on the realities on the ground, even if it means deviating from orders. Examples include:
- Changing attack routes based on enemy fire
- Adjusting defensive positions to exploit terrain
- Modifying tactics based on enemy behavior
Exploit opportunities. A keen eye for observation and a willingness to seize fleeting opportunities can turn the tide of battle. This might involve exploiting a gap in the enemy's lines, capitalizing on their mistakes, or adapting to unforeseen circumstances.
2. Leadership Requires Leading from the Front and Sharing Hardships
To win the confidence of his men, the officer must first make severe demands on himself; he must be circumspect, look after his men, share their hardships, and, above all, set them a good example.
Lead by example. A commander's willingness to share the hardships and dangers faced by his troops is essential for building trust and inspiring loyalty. Soldiers are more likely to follow an officer who leads from the front and demonstrates courage under fire.
Empathy and care. A good leader is not only concerned with achieving objectives but also with the well-being of his men. This involves:
- Ensuring adequate supplies and rest
- Providing medical care and support
- Recognizing and rewarding bravery
Discipline and respect. While empathy is important, a leader must also maintain discipline and enforce standards. This requires a balance of firmness and fairness, ensuring that orders are followed while treating subordinates with respect.
3. Terrain and Environment Dictate Tactics and Strategy
In war, the terrain is a critical factor that must be carefully considered.
Terrain awareness. A thorough understanding of the terrain is essential for planning and executing successful military operations. Factors such as elevation, vegetation, and obstacles can significantly impact troop movement, visibility, and firepower.
Adapt to the environment. Different environments require different tactics and strategies. For example:
- Jungle warfare necessitates close-quarters combat and ambushes
- Mountain warfare requires specialized equipment and climbing skills
- Trench warfare demands fortifications and siege tactics
Utilize terrain to advantage. Commanders should seek to exploit the terrain to their advantage, using natural features to provide cover, concealment, and defensible positions. This might involve:
- Positioning troops on high ground for better visibility
- Using forests or hills to mask troop movements
- Creating chokepoints to funnel enemy forces
4. Maintaining Morale is Paramount, Even in Dire Circumstances
High morale springs from the ability to accomplish difficult tasks.
Morale is a force multiplier. A unit's morale can significantly impact its combat effectiveness. High morale can enable troops to overcome seemingly insurmountable obstacles, while low morale can lead to defeat even in the face of superior numbers or equipment.
Factors influencing morale:
- Strong leadership and clear communication
- A sense of purpose and belief in the mission
- Adequate supplies and rest
- Recognition and rewards for achievements
Maintaining morale under pressure:
- Emphasize small victories and positive developments
- Provide opportunities for rest and recreation
- Foster camaraderie and a sense of shared purpose
- Address concerns and rumors promptly
5. Effective Communication and Coordination are Essential for Success
Good communications between infantry and artillery are essential.
Clear communication is vital. In the chaos of battle, clear and concise communication is essential for coordinating troop movements, calling in artillery support, and responding to changing circumstances.
Methods of communication:
- Telephone lines (though vulnerable to disruption)
- Runners and messengers
- Signal flares and visual signals
- Radio (though still in its early stages)
Coordination between arms:
- Infantry and artillery must work together to suppress enemy defenses
- Engineers must clear obstacles and construct fortifications
- Air support can provide reconnaissance and strike capabilities
Decentralized command. In situations where communication is disrupted, subordinate commanders must be empowered to make decisions on their own initiative, based on their understanding of the overall mission.
6. Logistical Support is the Lifeline of Any Military Operation
The lack of supplies can cripple even the most determined fighting force.
Supplies are essential. A steady flow of supplies, including food, ammunition, and medical equipment, is crucial for sustaining military operations. A failure to provide adequate logistical support can quickly cripple even the most determined fighting force.
Challenges of logistical support:
- Difficult terrain and weather conditions
- Enemy attacks on supply lines
- Limited transportation resources
Strategies for effective logistics:
- Establish secure supply routes
- Stockpile supplies in forward areas
- Utilize local resources when possible
- Prioritize essential supplies
Adaptability in logistics. Logistical plans must be flexible enough to adapt to changing circumstances. This might involve finding alternative routes, improvising transportation methods, or adjusting supply priorities.
7. Exploiting Enemy Weaknesses and Maintaining Momentum are Key to Victory
A sudden attack on the flanks and rear of the enemy positions made their previously constructed fortifications useless.
Identify vulnerabilities. Success in warfare often depends on identifying and exploiting the enemy's weaknesses. This might involve targeting their flanks, exploiting gaps in their defenses, or disrupting their supply lines.
Maintain momentum. Once a breakthrough has been achieved, it is crucial to maintain momentum and prevent the enemy from regrouping. This requires aggressive pursuit, rapid exploitation of gains, and a willingness to take risks.
Seize the initiative. A proactive approach to warfare is often more effective than a reactive one. By seizing the initiative and dictating the terms of engagement, a commander can force the enemy to respond to his actions, rather than the other way around.
8. Fortifications and Preparedness Can Mitigate Losses
The heavy casualties suffered by the 3rd Battalion were due to the fact that the ground was too close to the woods and that the troops had not been able to dig in properly.
Defense in depth. A well-designed defensive system should incorporate multiple layers of fortifications, obstacles, and fire support. This creates a "defense in depth" that can absorb enemy attacks and prevent a breakthrough.
Importance of entrenchment. Even in offensive operations, troops should take the time to dig in and create defensive positions whenever possible. This can provide crucial protection against enemy fire and allow them to consolidate their gains.
Utilize natural defenses. Commanders should seek to incorporate natural features, such as hills, forests, and rivers, into their defensive plans. These features can provide additional protection and make it more difficult for the enemy to attack.
9. War is a Brutal Test of Physical and Mental Endurance
War is the most severe test of a soldier's physical and mental endurance.
Physical demands. Warfare places immense physical demands on soldiers, requiring them to endure long marches, harsh weather conditions, and constant exposure to danger.
Mental strain. The psychological toll of war can be even greater than the physical one. Soldiers must cope with fear, stress, grief, and the constant threat of death.
Importance of resilience. The ability to withstand these physical and mental challenges is essential for survival and success in combat. This requires:
- Physical fitness and stamina
- Mental toughness and discipline
- Strong camaraderie and support networks
10. The Human Element is the Decisive Factor in Warfare
In the final analysis, it is the human element that is the decisive factor in warfare.
Technology is secondary. While technology plays an increasingly important role in modern warfare, it is ultimately the human element that determines the outcome of battles.
Importance of leadership. Competent and courageous officers can inspire their troops to overcome seemingly insurmountable obstacles. Conversely, poor leadership can lead to defeat even in the face of superior equipment.
The will to fight. The will to fight, driven by factors such as patriotism, loyalty, and a desire for survival, is a crucial determinant of combat effectiveness. Soldiers who are motivated and committed to their cause are more likely to persevere in the face of adversity.
Last updated:
FAQ
1. What is "Infantry Attacks" by Erwin Rommel about?
- Firsthand WWI Combat Memoir: "Infantry Attacks" is Erwin Rommel’s detailed memoir of his experiences as a junior officer in the German Army during World War I, covering campaigns in France, Romania, and Italy.
- Tactical and Leadership Insights: The book is both a narrative of battles and a practical manual, offering Rommel’s observations on small-unit tactics, leadership, reconnaissance, and decision-making under fire.
- Focus on Infantry Warfare: Rommel emphasizes the challenges and solutions of infantry combat, including movement, attack, defense, and adaptation to rapidly changing battlefield conditions.
- Lessons and Reflections: Each chapter concludes with "battlefield observations," where Rommel distills lessons learned and offers advice for future officers and soldiers.
2. Why should I read "Infantry Attacks" by Erwin Rommel?
- Classic Military Literature: The book is considered a foundational text in military tactics and leadership, influencing generations of officers, including WWII leaders like Patton.
- Unique Perspective: Rommel’s firsthand, ground-level view provides rare insight into the realities of WWI combat and the mindset of a future legendary general.
- Practical Lessons: The book is filled with actionable advice on leadership, initiative, and adaptability, relevant not only to military professionals but also to anyone interested in decision-making under pressure.
- Historical Significance: "Infantry Attacks" offers a German perspective on WWI, covering lesser-known campaigns and providing context for the evolution of modern warfare.
3. What are the key takeaways from "Infantry Attacks" by Erwin Rommel?
- Initiative and Decisiveness: Success in battle often depends on junior leaders taking initiative and making rapid decisions, even in the absence of clear orders.
- Importance of Reconnaissance: Accurate, timely reconnaissance is critical; Rommel repeatedly stresses the need for personal observation and detailed terrain analysis.
- Adaptability and Flexibility: The ability to adapt tactics to changing situations, terrain, and enemy actions is a recurring theme throughout the book.
- Leadership by Example: Rommel advocates for officers to lead from the front, share hardships with their men, and inspire confidence through personal courage and competence.
- Preparation and Training: Rigorous training, attention to detail, and preparation in peacetime are essential for survival and effectiveness in war.
4. How does Erwin Rommel describe effective infantry tactics in "Infantry Attacks"?
- Use of Terrain and Cover: Rommel emphasizes exploiting terrain for movement and protection, avoiding open ground, and using natural features for concealment.
- Fire and Maneuver: He advocates for coordinated fire and movement, with units providing mutual support and suppressing the enemy during advances.
- Surprise and Speed: Achieving surprise through stealth, rapid movement, and unexpected attacks is a key element in his tactical approach.
- Decentralized Command: Rommel supports empowering small-unit leaders to make decisions on the spot, adapting to the immediate situation rather than waiting for higher orders.
5. What leadership principles does Erwin Rommel advocate in "Infantry Attacks"?
- Lead from the Front: Rommel insists that officers should share the dangers and hardships of their men, setting an example in courage and discipline.
- Know Your Men: He stresses the importance of understanding the strengths and weaknesses of subordinates, building trust and morale.
- Clear Communication: Orders should be concise, clear, and adapted to the situation; confusion and ambiguity can be fatal in combat.
- Responsibility and Initiative: Leaders must take responsibility for their actions and be willing to act decisively, even in uncertain or chaotic conditions.
6. How does "Infantry Attacks" by Erwin Rommel address the challenges of reconnaissance and intelligence?
- Personal Involvement: Rommel often conducts reconnaissance himself, highlighting the value of firsthand observation over secondhand reports.
- Use of Small Patrols: He describes sending out small, stealthy patrols to gather information, emphasizing caution and the use of cover.
- Reporting and Communication: Timely and accurate reporting of reconnaissance findings is crucial; delays or omissions can lead to disaster.
- Terrain Familiarity: Rommel advocates for officers to study maps, use compasses, and practice night navigation to maintain orientation and avoid surprises.
7. What are some of the most important "battlefield observations" or lessons learned in "Infantry Attacks"?
- Dispersal Under Fire: Dense formations are vulnerable to artillery and machine-gun fire; Rommel recommends dispersed, flexible formations.
- Rapid Entrenchment: Digging in quickly, even under fire, greatly reduces casualties and increases staying power.
- Coordination with Artillery: Close cooperation with supporting artillery is essential for both attack and defense.
- Avoiding Friendly Fire: Clear identification and communication are necessary to prevent tragic incidents of friendly fire, which Rommel experienced firsthand.
8. How does Erwin Rommel describe the psychological aspects of combat in "Infantry Attacks"?
- Morale and Endurance: High morale, fostered by competent leadership and shared hardship, is vital for withstanding the stresses of battle.
- Fear and Fatigue: Rommel acknowledges the effects of fear, exhaustion, and uncertainty, and discusses ways to mitigate them through discipline and rest.
- Shock and Surprise: The psychological impact of sudden attacks, artillery barrages, and night actions can break enemy resistance or cause panic.
- Leadership Influence: The presence and actions of leaders directly affect the psychological state of their troops, for better or worse.
9. What are some notable battles or campaigns covered in "Infantry Attacks" by Erwin Rommel?
- Western Front (France/Belgium): Rommel details actions in the Argonne, Meuse, and Verdun regions, including trench warfare and night attacks.
- Eastern Front (Romania): He describes mountain warfare, harsh weather, and the challenges of supply and movement in the Carpathians.
- Italian Front (Caporetto): The book covers the famous breakthrough at Caporetto, including infiltration tactics and the rapid exploitation of enemy weaknesses.
- Defensive and Offensive Operations: Rommel provides accounts of both holding ground under intense attack and leading aggressive assaults against fortified positions.
10. How did "Infantry Attacks" by Erwin Rommel influence later military leaders and doctrine?
- Influence on WWII Commanders: The book was widely read by WWII leaders, including George S. Patton, who reportedly memorized it.
- Development of Blitzkrieg: Rommel’s emphasis on speed, initiative, and decentralized command contributed to the development of German blitzkrieg tactics.
- Training Manual: "Infantry Attacks" became a standard text in military academies, valued for its practical, experience-based lessons.
- Enduring Relevance: The principles outlined by Rommel continue to inform modern military doctrine, especially regarding small-unit leadership and adaptability.
11. What are some of the best quotes from "Infantry Attacks" by Erwin Rommel, and what do they mean?
- "Sweat saves blood, blood saves lives, and brains save both." – Emphasizes the value of preparation, training, and intelligent planning in reducing casualties.
- "The art of war is simple enough. Find out where your enemy is. Get at him as soon as you can. Strike him as hard as you can, and keep moving on." – Highlights Rommel’s philosophy of aggressive, decisive action.
- "In the absence of orders, go find something and kill it." – Stresses the importance of initiative and offensive spirit at all levels.
- "The best form of welfare for the troops is first-class training, for this saves unnecessary casualties." – Underlines Rommel’s belief in rigorous training as the foundation of combat effectiveness.
12. What are the limitations or criticisms of "Infantry Attacks" by Erwin Rommel?
- Focus on German Perspective: The book presents only the German side of the conflict, with limited insight into the enemy’s experience or broader strategic context.
- Heroic Narrative: Some critics note Rommel’s tendency to highlight his own actions and successes, potentially downplaying the contributions of others or the role of luck.
- WWI Context: The tactics and technology described are specific to World War I and may not fully translate to later conflicts, though many principles remain relevant.
- Limited Strategic Analysis: "Infantry Attacks" is primarily a tactical and operational memoir, with less emphasis on grand strategy or political factors influencing the war.
Review Summary
Infantry Attacks receives high praise for its detailed account of WWI tactics and Rommel's leadership. Readers appreciate the insights into small-unit combat and Rommel's analytical approach. Many find it valuable for military leaders, though some criticize its repetitive nature and lack of broader context. The book is noted for its clear writing, hand-drawn maps, and lessons on infantry warfare. Rommel's courage, tactical brilliance, and care for his men are frequently highlighted. Some readers find it dry or overly technical, while others consider it a fascinating look into Rommel's early military career.
Similar Books
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
