Key Takeaways
1. Progressive Education: A century-old approach still relevant today
Progressive Education prepares students for active participation in a democratic society, in the context of a child-centered environment, and with an enduring commitment to social justice.
Origins and evolution. Progressive Education emerged in the early 20th century as a response to the rigid, industrialized model of schooling. Pioneers like John Dewey, Francis Parker, and Maria Montessori advocated for a more holistic, child-centered approach to learning. Their ideas, including hands-on experiences, project-based learning, and democratic classrooms, laid the foundation for modern progressive schools.
Continued relevance. Despite facing criticism and periods of decline, Progressive Education's core principles remain highly relevant in today's rapidly changing world. Its emphasis on critical thinking, creativity, and social responsibility aligns well with the skills needed for success in the 21st century. Progressive schools continue to innovate, adapting their methods to address contemporary challenges while staying true to their foundational values.
2. Child-centered learning: Engaging students' interests and emotions
I doubt that Dewey ever came close to considering that children should be able to choose whether or not they show up for class, and, for the record, neither have I.
Balancing structure and autonomy. Progressive educators recognize the importance of engaging students' natural curiosity and interests. This approach doesn't mean complete freedom, but rather a thoughtful balance between structure and autonomy. Teachers act as guides, helping students explore their interests within a framework that ensures they develop essential skills and knowledge.
Emotional engagement. Progressive schools prioritize students' emotional well-being, understanding that learning is deeply connected to how children feel. This includes:
- Creating safe, supportive classroom environments
- Encouraging self-expression and creativity
- Addressing social-emotional needs alongside academic goals
- Fostering strong relationships between teachers and students
3. Hands-on, experiential learning trumps rote memorization
When it comes to making school more like life, there's nothing to compare with giving students real-life jobs.
Learning by doing. Progressive schools emphasize hands-on, experiential learning over passive absorption of information. This approach includes:
- Project-based learning
- Field trips and community engagement
- Interdisciplinary studies that connect subjects to real-world applications
- Apprenticeships and internships
Deeper understanding. By engaging in real-world tasks and projects, students develop a deeper understanding of concepts and their practical applications. This approach not only enhances retention but also cultivates problem-solving skills, creativity, and the ability to apply knowledge in diverse contexts.
4. Building strong school communities fosters academic and personal growth
Progressive educators' belief in child-centered education certainly doesn't assume that children should never be frustrated or uncomfortable as they learn. They should, and so should their teachers.
Community as curriculum. Progressive schools view the school community itself as an essential part of the curriculum. This includes:
- Regular class meetings and school-wide assemblies
- Mixed-age learning groups and mentoring programs
- Collaborative projects that require teamwork and communication
- Involving students in school decision-making processes
Benefits of strong communities. Research shows that students who feel connected to their school community perform better academically, have fewer behavioral issues, and develop stronger social-emotional skills. These tight-knit communities also provide a safe space for students to take risks, make mistakes, and grow from their experiences.
5. Balancing freedom and structure in the classroom
Allowing children too much freedom, for instance, is a mistake shared by many well-meaning families and well-meaning schools.
Structured freedom. Progressive educators aim to create environments that offer students meaningful choices within a well-designed structure. This balance helps students develop:
- Self-regulation skills
- Intrinsic motivation
- Time management abilities
- Decision-making capabilities
Teacher as guide. In this model, teachers shift from being lecturers to facilitators. They create rich learning environments, offer guidance when needed, and help students reflect on their choices and experiences. This approach requires skilled educators who can adapt to individual student needs while maintaining overall classroom coherence.
6. Promoting social justice and civic engagement
At Park Day, as with everything we teach, we take care to engage students in social justice projects in ways that suit their evolving understanding.
Active citizenship. Progressive schools view education as a means to create engaged, socially responsible citizens. This involves:
- Incorporating current events and social issues into the curriculum
- Encouraging critical analysis of societal structures and inequalities
- Providing opportunities for community service and activism
- Fostering empathy and understanding for diverse perspectives
Age-appropriate engagement. Schools carefully tailor social justice education to students' developmental levels, starting with simple concepts of fairness in early grades and progressing to more complex discussions and actions as students mature.
7. Assessing students beyond standardized tests
Our thoughts, precisely.
Holistic assessment. Progressive schools reject the overreliance on standardized tests, instead opting for more comprehensive assessment methods:
- Project presentations and portfolios
- Self-assessments and peer evaluations
- Narrative reports from teachers
- Performance-based assessments
- Demonstrations of mastery through real-world applications
Continuous feedback. These assessment methods provide ongoing, detailed feedback to students and parents, focusing on individual growth and development rather than comparison to arbitrary standards. This approach helps cultivate a growth mindset and intrinsic motivation for learning.
8. The power of play and creativity in learning
Neuroscientists contend that for adults and children alike, play is a ramp to joyful learning: an exercise with the power to bolster social and cognitive skills, improving problem solving, creativity, abstract thinking, and collaboration.
Integrating play. Progressive schools recognize play as a crucial component of learning, not just for young children but for students of all ages. This includes:
- Unstructured playtime and recess
- Game-based learning activities
- Arts integration across subjects
- Imaginative projects and role-playing exercises
Creativity as a skill. By emphasizing creativity and play, these schools help students develop crucial skills for innovation and adaptability. This approach also makes learning more engaging and enjoyable, fostering a lifelong love of learning.
9. Integrating technology while preserving human connections
Progressive educators are often stereotyped as being automatically opposed to technology, like the nineteenth-century English Luddites who smashed textile machines to try to stall the Industrial Revolution from throwing artisans out of jobs. The image may have fit us, or some of us, in the past, but it was never entirely accurate.
Thoughtful tech integration. Progressive schools aim to incorporate technology in ways that enhance, rather than replace, human interaction and hands-on learning. This might include:
- Using digital tools for creative projects and presentations
- Leveraging technology for research and global connections
- Teaching digital literacy and responsible online behavior
- Balancing screen time with face-to-face interactions and physical activities
Critical approach. While embracing useful technologies, progressive educators also encourage critical thinking about the role of technology in society, its benefits, and its potential drawbacks.
10. Embracing failure as a pathway to learning and innovation
By honestly facing our inevitable mistakes and finding ways to learn from them, Park Day School and other progressive schools throughout America can join what is fast becoming an unusually healthy and productive national trend.
Reframing failure. Progressive schools work to create environments where failure is seen as a natural part of the learning process, not something to be feared or avoided. This includes:
- Encouraging risk-taking and experimentation
- Teaching reflection and analysis of mistakes
- Providing multiple opportunities to revise and improve work
- Celebrating effort and growth over perfection
Building resilience. By embracing failure as a learning opportunity, these schools help students develop resilience, perseverance, and adaptability – crucial skills for success in a rapidly changing world.
Last updated:
FAQ
What is "Loving Learning: How Progressive Education Can Save America's Schools" by Tom Little about?
- Explores Progressive Education: The book delves into the history, principles, and practices of Progressive Education in America, highlighting its potential to transform schools into joyful, child-centered environments.
- Critique of Standardized Schooling: Tom Little contrasts progressive methods with the dominant test-driven, rote-learning model, arguing that the latter stifles creativity, emotional well-being, and authentic learning.
- Personal and Professional Narrative: The author weaves his own experiences as a progressive educator and head of Park Day School into a broader call for educational reform.
- Vision for Change: The book advocates for reviving and expanding progressive strategies to prepare students for democracy, social justice, and lifelong learning.
Why should I read "Loving Learning" by Tom Little?
- Insight from Experience: Tom Little draws on nearly four decades as a progressive school leader and visits to over 40 progressive schools, offering practical, firsthand insights.
- Addresses Current Challenges: The book tackles issues like student anxiety, standardized testing pressures, and the decline of creativity and social engagement in schools.
- Hopeful and Solution-Oriented: Rather than just critique, Little presents inspiring examples and actionable solutions for reimagining education.
- Inspiration for Stakeholders: It’s a valuable resource for educators, parents, and policymakers seeking to restore joy, purpose, and equity in education.
What are the key takeaways from "Loving Learning" by Tom Little?
- Six Core Strategies: The book identifies six enduring strategies of Progressive Education: attention to emotions, reliance on student interests, reduced testing, real-world activities, interdisciplinary study, and social justice awareness.
- Child-Centered and Democratic: Progressive Education is defined by its focus on the whole child and its commitment to preparing students for active participation in a democratic society.
- Critique and Alternatives: Little critiques high-stakes testing and advocates for nuanced, individualized assessments and project-based learning.
- Call for Revival: The book urges educators to reclaim the progressive tradition and adapt it to meet 21st-century challenges.
How does Tom Little define Progressive Education in "Loving Learning"?
- Preparation for Democracy: Progressive Education prepares students for active participation in a democratic society within a child-centered environment.
- Commitment to Social Justice: The approach is rooted in an enduring commitment to social justice and equity.
- Joyful and Empathetic Learning: Education is seen as a joyful, empathetic process that values each child’s individuality and fosters community responsibility.
- Clear Identity: Little argues for a coherent, historically grounded definition to strengthen advocacy and adoption.
What are the core principles and strategies of Progressive Education according to Tom Little?
- Child-Centered Learning: Emphasizes teaching the whole child, balancing intellectual, emotional, and social development to nurture intrinsic motivation.
- Integrated, Project-Based Curriculum: Subjects are taught in interdisciplinary ways, often through real-world projects that engage students deeply.
- Community and Social Justice: Schools foster strong communities and emphasize social awareness, activism, and responsibility.
- Reduced Testing and Grading: Progressive schools curtail standardized testing in favor of qualitative, individualized assessments.
How does "Loving Learning" by Tom Little critique standardized testing and propose alternatives?
- Critique of Testing Mania: Little argues that excessive standardized testing narrows curricula, increases stress, and undermines creativity and joy in learning.
- No Improvement in Outcomes: He notes that high-stakes tests have not improved U.S. students’ international rankings or college readiness.
- Progressive Alternatives: The book highlights narrative reports, portfolios, student presentations, and self-assessments as richer forms of evaluation.
- Focus on Mastery and Growth: Progressive schools emphasize mastery learning and ongoing feedback, fostering responsibility and deeper understanding.
How does "Loving Learning" by Tom Little address the role of emotions and community in education?
- Teaching the Whole Child: Emotional well-being is considered as critical as intellectual growth, with classrooms designed to foster trust and empathy.
- Reducing Stress: The book explains how chronic stress impairs learning, advocating for environments that reduce anxiety and promote connectedness.
- Community Building Practices: Strategies like class meetings, buddy systems, and restorative justice cultivate supportive, democratic school cultures.
- Improved Outcomes: Strong communities are linked to reduced risky behaviors and better academic performance.
What is the role of play and sensory learning in Progressive Education according to Tom Little?
- Play as Essential: Play is vital for brain development, creativity, and motivation, and progressive schools protect unstructured playtime.
- Sensory and Experiential Learning: Activities that engage multiple senses, such as hands-on projects and ecosystem studies, help children learn deeply and joyfully.
- Balance of Structure and Freedom: While play is valued, educators provide enough structure to guide learning and skill development.
- Counter to Early Academics: The book critiques trends that reduce play in favor of early academics, emphasizing the importance of play for young children.
How does "Loving Learning" by Tom Little address social justice and activism in Progressive Education?
- Early Engagement: The book describes projects where students experience simulated oppression to develop empathy and social awareness.
- Curriculum Integration: Social justice themes are woven into studies, with students participating in community service and advocacy.
- Diversity and Inclusion: Progressive schools promote diversity through admissions, sliding scale tuition, and partnerships with public schools.
- Walking the Talk: Schools actively embody their social justice commitments in daily practices and policies.
What examples of successful progressive schools and networks does Tom Little provide in "Loving Learning"?
- Park Day School: The author’s own school exemplifies progressive education with detailed assessments, small classes, and a social justice focus.
- Mission Hill School: Known for resisting standardized testing and serving a diverse student body with high success rates.
- Casco Bay High School: Demonstrates progressive methods in a public school setting through standards-based grading and community service.
- Innovative Networks: Big Picture Learning and Expeditionary Learning networks emphasize student interests, mentorship, and real-world projects, showing strong outcomes for disadvantaged students.
How does technology fit into the progressive education model in "Loving Learning" by Tom Little?
- Tool, Not Panacea: Technology is embraced as a tool to enhance creativity and engagement, not as a replacement for hands-on or social learning.
- Student-Centered Use: Examples include students designing video games, using digital media for advocacy, and engaging in multimedia projects.
- Integration with Making: Progressive schools combine digital tools with crafts and maker activities to foster problem-solving and collaboration.
- Critical and Balanced Use: Little warns against overreliance on technology, emphasizing thoughtful, purposeful integration.
What are the best quotes from "Loving Learning" by Tom Little and what do they mean?
- “We must play the game of learning—not the game of school.” — Highlights the difference between authentic, joyful learning and rote, compliance-driven schooling.
- “If you see a problem, do something.” — Encourages students to take responsibility and act with empathy in their community.
- “Any school system in which one child may fail while another succeeds is unjust, undemocratic, uneducational.” — Captures Progressive Education’s commitment to equity and individualized support.
- “The test of a first-rate intelligence is the ability to hold two opposed ideas in the mind at the same time, and still retain the ability to function.” — Reflects the progressive goal of balancing institutional needs with individual development.
Review Summary
Loving Learning receives mixed reviews, with an average rating of 3.88 out of 5. Readers appreciate the book's insights into progressive education, its history, and real-world examples. Many find it inspirational and informative, praising its readability and passion for the subject. However, some critics argue it lacks practical implementation strategies, especially for public schools, and focuses too heavily on private institutions. Several reviewers note the book's relevance to current educational debates and its potential to spark discussions about alternative teaching methods.
Similar Books
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
