Key Takeaways
1. Smart Collaboration is Today's Strategic Imperative.
Collaboration has gone from a nice-to-have to a strategic imperative.
Complexity demands collaboration. Modern problems are increasingly volatile, uncertain, complex, and ambiguous (VUCA), requiring diverse expertise. No single expert, no matter how brilliant, can solve these multifaceted challenges alone. Professionals must integrate specialized knowledge across silos.
Specialization is increasing. Knowledge is expanding rapidly, forcing professionals and firms to specialize deeply. While this creates pockets of deep expertise, it also fragments knowledge, making it harder to bring the full force of the firm to bear on complex client issues without intentional collaboration. This trend is accelerating across all professional fields.
Opting out is not viable. The market is bifurcating into high-profit, customized work and lower-end, routine tasks. Firms aiming for the high-value segment must collaborate effectively. Even for standardized work, efficient collaboration, often technology-supported, is needed to differentiate and avoid being squeezed on productivity from individual stars alone.
2. Collaboration Unlocks Significant Financial Growth.
For a professional service firm, the financial benefits of multidisciplinary collaboration are unambiguous.
Revenue grows exponentially. Clients served by multiple practice groups generate significantly more revenue than those served by a single group. This nearly exponential growth continues as more disciplines become involved, creating additional value for both incumbent and new service providers on the account.
- Clients served by two practice groups generate multiple times more revenue than those served by one.
- This pattern holds across law, consulting, and accounting firms.
Profits increase over time. While initial fee pressure might slightly lower percentage margins on broader engagements, the increased revenue base leads to higher overall profits. Cross-practice work is also less susceptible to price-based competition compared to single-specialty services, which clients often view as commodities.
Cross-border work is lucrative. Projects involving multiple countries are typically more complex and demanding, leading to higher average revenues. Delivering seamless service across national boundaries is a key differentiator, although managing costs and quality across diverse locations requires refined collaboration skills.
3. Deep Collaboration Builds Enduring Client Loyalty.
The more partners serve a client, the longer that client remains with the firm, even when an important partner leaves.
Institutionalizing client relationships. When multiple partners and practice groups serve a client, the relationship becomes embedded within the firm rather than being tied to a single individual. This makes it significantly harder for clients to switch providers, especially when compared to clients served by a single partner.
- Clients served by multiple partners are far more likely to remain with the firm if their primary contact departs.
Reducing "lift out" risk. While groups of partners from the same unit might leave together and take clients, it is far less common for clients served by cross-practice, multi-office teams to be "stolen." Breadth of relationships across different service lines and geographies increases client stickiness.
Building deeper understanding. Larger, collaborative teams develop a more comprehensive understanding of the client's operations, personnel, technology, and strategic priorities over time. This deep institutional knowledge creates high barriers to entry for competitors and reinforces the firm's position as a trusted, indispensable adviser.
4. Collaborative Teams Drive Innovation and Better Solutions.
A growing body of research, including my own doctoral work, supports clients’ views that innovation is most likely to happen when specialists team up.
Teams outperform individuals. Studies across various fields, from science to law, show that teams are more productive and produce innovations with greater impact than individual experts working alone. Collaboration allows for the creative recombination of different people's information, perspectives, and expertise.
Innovation is often adaptation. For many clients, innovation means meticulously tailoring standard technical approaches to their very specific business needs and constraints. Collaborative teams are better equipped to adapt existing solutions by drawing on diverse experiences and knowledge bases from different sectors or disciplines.
Complexity requires diverse input. Clients facing complex, multifaceted problems explicitly seek advisers who can bring the "full force of the organization to bear." They believe collaborative teams are more likely to deliver novel, advanced, and applicable solutions that go beyond the obvious or standard.
5. Collaboration is Essential for Attracting and Retaining Talent.
Any lurking skepticism among the older generations in your firm notwithstanding, it’s true: people in this age cohort will eventually take over your firm.
Integrating lateral hires. Collaboration is critical for the success of lateral partners, who need to quickly integrate with incumbent partners and clients. Laterals who successfully collaborate on existing client work and entice colleagues onto their own matters are significantly more likely to remain productive and stay with the firm long-term.
- Laterals need two-way collaboration within 18 months to succeed.
- Failed lateral hires are costly in terms of money, time, and cultural disruption.
Attracting and retaining millennials. Younger professionals value involvement, challenge, empowerment, and flexibility. Collaborative work environments meet these needs by offering exposure to complex issues, opportunities to challenge superiors, and chances to work on diverse projects. Firms that fail to offer collaborative opportunities risk losing this crucial talent pool.
Boosting engagement and loyalty. Professionals who collaborate more develop stronger psychological attachments to their firms, feeling a greater sense of belonging and commitment. Collaborative experiences foster camaraderie, support, and a shared sense of purpose, leading to higher productivity and retention rates across all levels.
6. Solo Specialists Must Collaborate to Expand Their Business.
My research clearly shows that rainmakers who collaborate—that is, who share the work that they originate—end up with significantly bigger books of business than those who hoard work.
Sharing work generates more work. Counterintuitively, solo specialists who involve other partners in their client work significantly grow their own book of business in subsequent years. Referring work, especially across practice groups, increases their origination revenue more than hoarding work.
Collaboration builds capabilities. By working on cross-practice projects, solo specialists learn about other domains and gain the confidence to identify broader issues facing their own clients. This allows them to initiate conversations about complex problems and move up the client food chain.
Overcoming internal barriers. Solo specialists face hurdles like competence and interpersonal trust issues, lack of knowledge about firm offerings, and perceived inefficiency of collaboration. Building a trusted network, proactively learning about colleagues' expertise, and developing effective team leadership skills are crucial steps to overcome these barriers and unlock growth.
7. Contributors Gain Significant Career Benefits from Collaboration.
Simply stated, working as someone else’s grinder equips the contributor to become a finder—and to get increasingly good at that new role.
Service work fuels business development. Collaborating on others' projects provides contributors with invaluable experience in handling complex, cross-practice issues. This exposure builds their capabilities and confidence, enabling them to sell more sophisticated work to their own clients later.
Collaboration increases referrals. Working effectively on a colleague's project builds trust and demonstrates competence, making that colleague more likely to refer work in the future. The more partners a contributor collaborates with, the more referrals they receive, both from direct collaborators and through word-of-mouth reputation.
Reputation and rates rise. Collaboration enhances a professional's reputation for tackling complex problems, which increases demand for their services. Partners who work on more cross-disciplinary projects see their hourly rates increase faster than those who do not, reflecting their increased market value and strategic capability.
8. Seasoned Collaborators Face Unique Leadership Challenges.
So if collaboration is difficult, stressful, clash-inducing, and countercultural—a seemingly daunting list—why should the seasoned collaborator want to take it up a notch?
Leading peers is complex. Seasoned collaborators, while understanding the value of teamwork, face the challenge of leading highly autonomous peers who may prioritize their own clients or departments. Building a committed, accountable team requires navigating internal politics, overcoming resistance, and securing buy-in from colleagues with competing priorities.
Ensuring quality control. As account leaders, seasoned collaborators must ensure high service quality across diverse team members, often in different locations or disciplines. This requires clear communication of client expectations, effective project management, and proactive quality assurance without overburdening themselves or micromanaging.
Managing distributed teams. Leading multicultural, geographically dispersed teams adds layers of complexity, including time zone differences, cultural misunderstandings, and reliance on technology. Overcoming "us and them" thinking and the "mutual knowledge problem" requires intentional efforts to build trust, focus on commonalities, and ensure symmetrical information flow.
9. Leaders Must Measure and Incentivize Collaborative Behavior.
If you want to tie some portion of partners’ financial rewards to collaboration—that is, to the way they achieve their objectives, rather than just the outcomes themselves—then you need a credible, nonburdensome method of measuring their behaviors and holding them accountable.
Metrics drive behavior. Performance management systems, more than compensation alone, shape partners' actions. Leaders must design metrics that explicitly measure and reward collaborative behaviors and outcomes, ensuring alignment with the firm's strategic goals rather than inadvertently promoting individualistic or siloed approaches.
Compensation reinforces culture. While compensation is a "hygiene factor" that must be fair, it also signals what the firm values. Overemphasizing individual origination or using opaque systems can undermine collaboration. Rebalancing rewards to value contributions to others' clients and using transparent, outcomes-based metrics can foster a more collaborative culture.
Strategic planning is foundational. Leaders must set a clear firm strategy that necessitates collaboration, then guide groups and individuals in setting aligned objectives. Focusing on goals achievable only through cross-boundary teamwork ensures that collaboration is integral to the "how," not just a vague aspiration.
10. Technology Platforms Are Crucial Enablers of Collaboration.
By building a technology platform to help connect partners with the right opportunities and knowledge, you can mitigate many of the obstacles that stand in the way of contributors’ increased involvement in cross-practice or cross-geography collaboration.
Connecting experts and opportunities. Collaborative technology platforms (CTPs), mimicking social networking, help professionals quickly find the right experts and relevant knowledge within the firm. They increase transparency of expertise and ongoing projects, lowering the barriers related to finding trustworthy colleagues and understanding firm offerings.
Increasing efficiency and transparency. CTPs make team actions, decisions, and rationale more transparent and searchable, reducing duplicated efforts and improving coordination. They allow for targeted communication and reduce email overload, making collaborative work processes more efficient and less burdensome.
Democratizing knowledge and reputation. CTPs allow professionals at all levels to share insights, contribute to discussions, and build their reputation based on demonstrated expertise and helpfulness. This empowers contributors, makes hidden gems visible, and provides a valuable resource for learning and professional development across the firm.
11. Clients Actively Seek and Value Internal Collaboration.
Yes, clients want you, their professional service providers, to collaborate within your own firm.
Access to best expertise. Clients understand that complex problems require diverse specialists and expect their primary adviser to bring in colleagues with relevant expertise. They value providers who can bring the "full force of the organization" to bear on their issues, especially as their own businesses become more complex and global.
Deeper business understanding. Collaborative teams can provide clients with valuable insights into their own organization by sharing intelligence gathered from different departments or locations. They can also offer cross-sectoral benchmarks and innovative approaches learned from serving other clients, helping clients think about their business in new ways.
Consistency and risk mitigation. Clients value consistency in service quality across different offices and over time, and see internal collaboration as a mechanism to ensure this. More eyes on the work also reduces the risk of errors or rogue behavior, providing clients with greater assurance and peace of mind.
12. Lessons on Collaboration Emerge from Unexpected Places.
Sometimes the best way to explore a complex business question—or for that matter, almost any complex question—is to take a sideways look at it.
Parallels in knowledge work. Elite medical research institutions, like professional service firms, are filled with highly specialized, autonomous "stars" who historically operated in silos. However, the increasing complexity of research demands collaboration, presenting similar challenges in convincing powerful individuals to change their behavior for the collective good.
Change requires multiple levers. Transforming a competitive, star-driven culture into a collaborative one requires more than just financial incentives. Leaders must:
- Develop a compelling story for change.
- Model the desired collaborative behaviors.
- Reinforce collaboration through aligned systems (performance management, compensation, technology).
- Develop new collaborative capabilities and confidence in their people.
Persistence and prototyping are key. Collaboration initiatives start slowly and face resistance. Piloting small-scale changes and celebrating early wins can build momentum and demonstrate the value of collaboration. Leaders must be persistent and willing to redesign approaches when initial implementations fall short.
Last updated:
Review Summary
Smart Collaboration receives mixed reviews, with an average rating of 3.61/5. Positive reviews praise its insights on improving client service and profits through collaboration in professional services firms. Critics note its narrow focus on consulting and law firms. Readers appreciate the research-based findings and practical examples, but some find it less applicable to broader organizational contexts. The book is seen as valuable for managers and partners in professional services, offering strategies to overcome silos and enhance teamwork. Some readers found it informative but challenging to finish due to its research-heavy content.
Similar Books







Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub
digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.