Key Takeaways
1. The Rule of Seven: Catastrophes Don't Just Happen
No crash happens in isolation or as the result of a single event. It requires a minimum of 7 things to go wrong in order for an airplane to crash. And one of those 7 is always human error.
Sh!t doesn't just happen. Catastrophes are not random, meaningless events that we're helpless against. They are the result of a series of cascade events, with at least one involving human error. By understanding this, we can predict and prevent many disasters.
- The Rule of 7: A minimum of 7 things must go wrong for a catastrophe to occur
- At least one of these factors always involves human error
- Cascade events: A series of smaller issues that lead to the final catastrophic event
- Delusion events: Near-misses that reinforce complacency
By recognizing these patterns and addressing potential cascade events, we can significantly reduce the risk of catastrophes occurring.
2. Preparation Is Key: Adopt a Catastrophe Mindset
Often, many of the victims were innocent and not responsible, but we must focus on those who are responsible and in charge and made the key decisions. Or didn't make a key decision.
Expect the unexpected. A catastrophe mindset involves anticipating potential problems and preparing for them before they occur. This approach is not about being pessimistic, but rather being proactive and realistic.
- Anticipate potential problems
- Prepare for various scenarios
- Train and equip yourself and your team
- Develop contingency plans
By adopting this mindset, you can reduce anxiety about potential disasters and increase your chances of successfully navigating a crisis if one does occur.
3. Leadership and Courage Are Essential in Crisis
Often, in order to deal with a cascade event, leadership and courage are needed to go against a culture of complacency and fear.
Be the voice of reason. In times of crisis, strong leadership and courage are crucial to overcome complacency and fear. Leaders must be willing to make difficult decisions and go against the grain when necessary.
- Recognize and address potential problems early
- Communicate clearly and effectively
- Make tough decisions when required
- Lead by example
Effective leadership during a crisis can mean the difference between a near-miss and a full-blown catastrophe.
4. Focus on Both Big Picture and Details
We generally think in one of two different ways: a big picture thinker or a detail thinker. Both types are needed. Understand yourself and those in your organization.
Balance is crucial. To effectively prevent and manage catastrophes, it's essential to consider both the big picture and the small details. Organizations need both types of thinkers to identify potential issues and develop comprehensive solutions.
Big picture thinkers:
- Identify patterns and trends
- See connections between seemingly unrelated events
- Develop overarching strategies
Detail thinkers:
- Spot specific problems or inconsistencies
- Implement precise solutions
- Ensure thorough execution of plans
By combining these perspectives, organizations can create more robust catastrophe prevention and management strategies.
5. Conduct Thorough Area Studies
You must conduct an Area Study of your Catastrophe Area of Operations (AO). Your home, your work, and any other locales where you spend a significant amount of time.
Know your environment. Conducting thorough area studies of your key locations helps you identify potential risks and develop appropriate prevention and response strategies.
Key aspects of an area study:
- Identify potential threats and hazards
- Locate critical resources (hospitals, police stations, etc.)
- Determine evacuation routes
- Assess environmental factors
By understanding your environment in detail, you can better prepare for and respond to potential catastrophes.
6. Use the CARVER Formula for Vulnerability Assessment
CARVER is a formula we use in Special Forces to assess targets for specific missions. It is the way we find critical nodes and the places where catastrophe is most likely to happen; or be made to happen.
Identify vulnerabilities systematically. The CARVER formula provides a structured approach to assessing potential vulnerabilities in your organization or environment.
CARVER stands for:
- Criticality: How important is the target?
- Accessibility: Can the target be reached?
- Recognizability: Can the target be identified?
- Vulnerability: How susceptible is the target to attack or failure?
- Effect: What would be the impact of an attack or failure?
- Recuperability: How quickly can the target recover?
By applying this formula, you can identify and prioritize potential weaknesses and develop targeted strategies to address them.
7. Implement the 10th Man Strategy
If 9 people agree, then the 10th man must disagree regardless of how crazy it sounds.
Challenge assumptions. The 10th Man strategy encourages organizations to actively seek out and consider contrarian viewpoints, even when there seems to be a consensus.
Key aspects of the 10th Man strategy:
- Designate someone to play devil's advocate
- Encourage open-minded consideration of alternative perspectives
- Require the 10th Man to provide supporting evidence for their position
- Use this process to uncover potential blind spots or overlooked issues
By implementing this strategy, organizations can avoid groupthink and identify potential problems that might otherwise be missed.
8. Learn from Past Mistakes: Conduct After Action Reviews
The hardest AARs to conduct are when things go well. To incorporate catastrophe thinking into a successful event.
Continuous improvement is vital. After Action Reviews (AARs) are essential for learning from both successes and failures. They help organizations identify areas for improvement and prevent future catastrophes.
Key elements of an effective AAR:
- Honesty and openness
- Focus on both successes and failures
- Identify lessons learned
- Develop actionable improvements
By consistently conducting thorough AARs, organizations can continuously improve their catastrophe prevention and management capabilities.
9. Perseverance Triumphs Over Tragedy
The human spirit can overcome the most difficult terrain and weather.
Never give up. The story of the survivors of Uruguayan Air Force Flight 571 demonstrates the incredible power of human perseverance in the face of seemingly insurmountable odds.
Lessons from the survivors:
- Maintain hope even in dire circumstances
- Work together as a team
- Be willing to make difficult decisions
- Adapt to changing situations
By cultivating a spirit of perseverance, individuals and organizations can increase their chances of surviving and overcoming catastrophic events.
10. Human Error Is Always a Factor in Catastrophes
If we plan and prepare adequately, we can delete the human error cascade event from the situation, thus avoiding the final event.
Acknowledge human fallibility. Recognizing that human error is always a factor in catastrophes allows us to develop strategies to mitigate its impact.
Ways to reduce human error:
- Implement robust training programs
- Develop and follow standard operating procedures
- Encourage open communication about mistakes
- Use technology to support human decision-making
By acknowledging and addressing the potential for human error, we can significantly reduce the risk of catastrophes occurring.
Last updated:
FAQ
What is "Sh!t Doesn’t Just Happen II: The Gift of Failure" by Bob Mayer about?
- Explores Seven Catastrophes: The book analyzes seven major historical catastrophes, breaking down the events that led to each disaster.
- Focus on Human Error: Mayer emphasizes that disasters rarely result from a single cause; instead, they are the culmination of multiple "cascade events," with human error always playing a role.
- Learning from Failure: The central theme is the "gift of failure"—how examining past catastrophes can help individuals and organizations prevent or mitigate future disasters.
- Practical Mindset and Tools: The book provides frameworks, definitions, and actionable advice for developing a "catastrophe mindset" to anticipate, plan for, and respond to potential crises.
Why should I read "Sh!t Doesn’t Just Happen II: The Gift of Failure" by Bob Mayer?
- Real-World Lessons: The book uses real catastrophes to illustrate how preventable most disasters are, making the lessons highly applicable to personal and professional life.
- Actionable Frameworks: Mayer offers practical tools like the Rule of 7, CARVER formula, and the concept of cascade events, which can be used to improve decision-making and risk management.
- Unique Perspective: Drawing on his experience as a Green Beret and West Point graduate, Mayer brings a military and systems-thinking approach to catastrophe prevention.
- Mindset Shift: The book encourages readers to move beyond complacency and delusional thinking, fostering a proactive attitude toward safety and preparedness.
What are the key takeaways from "Sh!t Doesn’t Just Happen II: The Gift of Failure"?
- Disasters Are Predictable: Most catastrophes are not random; they result from a series of identifiable and preventable events.
- The Rule of 7: At least seven things must go wrong for a disaster to occur, and human error is always one of them.
- Cascade and Delusion Events: Recognizing and addressing small failures (cascade events) and near-misses (delusion events) is crucial to preventing larger disasters.
- Preparation and Mindset: Adopting a catastrophe mindset, conducting area studies, and using structured planning tools can significantly reduce risk.
What is the "Rule of 7" in Bob Mayer's "Sh!t Doesn’t Just Happen II: The Gift of Failure"?
- Definition: The Rule of 7 states that rarely does a disaster happen in isolation or as the result of a single event; it usually requires a minimum of seven things to go wrong.
- Human Error Included: One of these seven events is always human error, whether in decision-making, oversight, or action.
- Application: By identifying and addressing these cascade events early, individuals and organizations can prevent the final catastrophic event.
- Framework for Analysis: The Rule of 7 is used throughout the book to dissect each catastrophe, showing how multiple failures combined to cause disaster.
What are "cascade events" and "delusion events" in "Sh!t Doesn’t Just Happen II: The Gift of Failure"?
- Cascade Events: These are events prior to a catastrophe that contribute to the actual disaster but are not catastrophic by themselves.
- Delusion Events: A cascade event that does not lead to a final event (disaster) is called a delusion event; it reinforces complacency and the dangerous belief that "dodging the bullet" is normal.
- Normalization of Risk: Repeated delusion events can lead to the normalization of unacceptable risk, making organizations more vulnerable to catastrophe.
- Importance of Recognition: Recognizing and correcting cascade and delusion events is essential to breaking the chain that leads to disaster.
How does Bob Mayer define and use the "catastrophe mindset" in "Sh!t Doesn’t Just Happen II: The Gift of Failure"?
- Expecting Failure: The catastrophe mindset is the expectation that what can go wrong, will go wrong, prompting proactive planning and vigilance.
- Contrasts with Positive Thinking: Mayer argues that many people are part of a "cult of positive thinking" that ignores reality and risk, whereas a catastrophe mindset embraces preparation for failure.
- Practical Application: This mindset involves conducting area studies, using structured planning tools, and constantly questioning assumptions and procedures.
- Leadership and Culture: Mayer stresses that leadership, not just management, is required to foster a catastrophe mindset within organizations.
What are the seven catastrophes analyzed in "Sh!t Doesn’t Just Happen II: The Gift of Failure," and what types of failure do they represent?
- The Challenger Explosion: Organizational failure and normalization of deviance at NASA.
- The Fall of the Last Czar (Nicholas II): Leadership failure and lack of decisive action.
- The Sultana Explosion: Greed, regulatory failure, and neglect of safety.
- Mulholland & The St. Francis Dam: Engineering failure, hubris, and lack of oversight.
- The Sinking of the Kursk: Poor training, maintenance, and systemic denial.
- Pearl Harbor: Strategic and tactical miscalculations, and failure to heed warnings.
- Alive! (Uruguayan Air Force Flight 571): Survival against the odds, perseverance, and improvisation.
What practical methods and tools does Bob Mayer recommend in "Sh!t Doesn’t Just Happen II: The Gift of Failure" for preventing catastrophes?
- Preparation Mindset: Always assume things can go wrong and plan accordingly.
- Focus and Area Studies: Pay attention to both big-picture trends and small details; conduct thorough studies of your environment and operations.
- CARVER Formula: Analyze critical nodes for vulnerability using Criticality, Accessibility, Recognizability, Vulnerability, Effect, and Recuperability.
- 10th Man Principle: Designate someone to challenge groupthink and consider alternative scenarios, even if they seem unlikely.
- After Action Reviews (AARs): Honestly review successes and failures to identify near-misses and areas for improvement.
- Standing Operating Procedures (SOPs): Develop, document, and regularly update procedures to standardize best practices and responses.
How does "Sh!t Doesn’t Just Happen II: The Gift of Failure" by Bob Mayer connect military and survival principles to catastrophe prevention?
- Special Forces Experience: Mayer draws on his background as a Green Beret, emphasizing the importance of preparation, adaptability, and leadership under stress.
- Lose-Lose Scenarios: Military training often involves scenarios with no right answer, teaching flexibility and creative problem-solving.
- HALO Effect: Approaching problems from an outsider’s perspective (High Altitude Low Opening) can reveal hidden risks and solutions.
- Teamwork and Leadership: The book highlights the need for honest communication, shared responsibility, and involving operators in decision-making.
What are some of the most important definitions and concepts introduced in "Sh!t Doesn’t Just Happen II: The Gift of Failure"?
- Catastrophe: The final event causing great and sudden damage or suffering; utter failure.
- Cascade Event: A contributing event prior to a catastrophe, not catastrophic by itself.
- Delusion Event: A cascade event that does not result in disaster, reinforcing complacency.
- Sunk Cost: Past costs that should not influence current decision-making.
- Red and White Flag of Danger: Noting a problem without taking action, often through memos or task forces.
- Redline Protocols: Written rules allowing experts to overrule management when a critical threshold is about to be crossed.
What are the "Three Benefits of Catastrophe Thinking, Planning & Preparing" according to Bob Mayer?
- Avoiding Catastrophe: Proper planning and preparation can eliminate human error and prevent disasters from occurring.
- Preparedness for Crisis: Having plans, equipment, and training in place ensures a better response if catastrophe strikes.
- Peace of Mind: Being prepared reduces anxiety and allows individuals and organizations to focus on other priorities, knowing they have mitigated potential risks.
What are the best quotes from "Sh!t Doesn’t Just Happen II: The Gift of Failure" by Bob Mayer, and what do they mean?
- “Sh!t doesn’t just happen.” – Emphasizes that most disasters are preventable and result from a series of failures, not random chance.
- “The Rule of 7: no crash happens in isolation or as the result of a single event. It requires a minimum of 7 things to go wrong in order for an airplane to crash. And one of those 7 is always human error.” – Highlights the complexity of disasters and the inevitability of human involvement.
- “For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for nature cannot be fooled.” (Richard Feynman, quoted in the Challenger section) – Stresses the importance of facing facts and not letting image or wishful thinking override safety and truth.
- “Nothing is impossible to the man who doesn’t have to do it.” – Points out the disconnect between decision-makers and those who bear the consequences, advocating for involving operators in critical decisions.
- “Perseverance needs to actually be more tenacious in the face of repeated setbacks.” – From the Alive! section, underlining the importance of resilience and determination in survival situations.
Review Summary
The Challenger Launch Decision is a meticulously researched book that offers a revisionist explanation for the 1986 disaster. Vaughan argues that the launch decision resulted from NASA's organizational culture rather than individual negligence. While praised for its thorough analysis and insights into bureaucratic decision-making, some readers found it overly academic and repetitive. The book introduces the concept of "normalization of deviance" and challenges conventional wisdom about the disaster. Despite its density, many reviewers consider it an important work for understanding organizational failures and safety culture.
Similar Books
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
