Plot Summary
New York's Unexpected Encounter
Arthur, a hopeful teenager from Georgia, finds himself in the bustling chaos of New York City for a summer internship. Feeling out of place, he stumbles into a post office where he meets Ben, a charming local boy mailing a breakup box to his ex. Their brief, humorous interaction leaves Arthur captivated by Ben's smile and the serendipity of their meeting. This chance encounter sparks Arthur's belief in fate and the universe's mysterious ways, setting the stage for a summer of unexpected possibilities.
Fate's Flash Mob Intervention
Just as Arthur and Ben begin to connect, a flash mob erupts in the post office, creating chaos and causing them to lose sight of each other. Arthur is left with a sense of longing and a belief that their meeting was orchestrated by the universe. Despite the vastness of New York, Arthur is determined to find Ben again, clinging to the hope that fate will bring them back together. This moment underscores the theme of destiny and the power of chance encounters.
The Search for Hudson
Obsessed with finding Ben, whom he only knows as "Box Boy," Arthur enlists the help of friends and colleagues, scouring social media and considering a Craigslist missed connection post. Meanwhile, Ben is dealing with the emotional aftermath of his breakup. Both boys navigate their uncertainties, with Arthur's determination growing stronger as he uncovers clues about Ben's identity and past relationship. This chapter highlights the challenges of finding connection in a city as vast as New York.
Missed Connections and Misunderstandings
Arthur's persistence pays off when he discovers a flyer with his face on it, posted by Ben in an attempt to reconnect. This revelation reignites Arthur's hope and belief in the universe's plan. They exchange emails and confirm their mutual interest, despite initial awkwardness and misunderstandings. Agreeing to meet for a proper first date, they set the stage for a new beginning, emphasizing the importance of perseverance and the willingness to try again.
A Do-Over Date Dilemma
Arthur and Ben's first official date is filled with nervous energy and high expectations. They struggle to find common ground, with Arthur's overthinking and Ben's financial concerns creating tension. Despite the challenges, they share moments of genuine connection and humor, leading to a mutual decision to have a "do-over" date. This agreement symbolizes their willingness to give each other a second chance and explore the potential of their relationship.
Karaoke and Confessions
Arthur joins Ben and his friends for a karaoke night, where the group dynamic adds both pressure and excitement. As they navigate the evening's challenges, Arthur and Ben confront their insecurities and past relationship baggage. Through music and laughter, they begin to understand each other better, leading to heartfelt confessions and a deeper bond. The night ends with a sense of hope and the promise of a fresh start, as they embrace the chaos and beauty of their unfolding story.
Honest Conversations and First Kisses
As their relationship progresses, Arthur and Ben face insecurities and engage in honest conversations. Arthur worries about living up to Ben's past, while Ben fears ruining Arthur's first romantic experiences. Despite these fears, they share a tender first kiss, leading to a series of "do-over" kisses. This moment solidifies their connection, highlighting the beauty of vulnerability and the power of honest communication in building a meaningful relationship.
Navigating New York's Emotional Maze
As they continue to explore their relationship, Ben and Arthur encounter emotional hurdles. Ben struggles with self-worth and the pressure of meeting Arthur's expectations, while Arthur grapples with his own insecurities and the impending end of his summer in New York. Their journey is marked by moments of joy and tension, as they learn to navigate the complexities of love and friendship in a city that never sleeps. Through heartfelt conversations and shared experiences, they begin to understand the importance of being present and cherishing the time they have together.
Unexpected Visitors and Revelations
Arthur's birthday brings unexpected surprises as his best friends, Jessie and Ethan, visit from Georgia. Their arrival prompts a series of revelations, including their own relationship status, which initially shocks Arthur. Meanwhile, Ben orchestrates a heartfelt treasure hunt for Arthur, leading to a deeper understanding of their connection. These events highlight the importance of friendship and the impact of unexpected moments in shaping relationships. As secrets are unveiled and truths are shared, Arthur and Ben's bond is tested, ultimately strengthening their commitment to each other.
The Final Goodbye and New Beginnings
As Arthur's departure from New York looms, he and Ben confront the reality of their situation. They share a bittersweet farewell, acknowledging the challenges of a long-distance relationship. Despite their love for each other, they decide to part ways, understanding that their paths may lead them back together in the future. This poignant moment underscores the theme of letting go and the hope that true connections can withstand the test of time. Their goodbye is not an end, but a new beginning, filled with the promise of future possibilities.
Reflections on Love and Friendship
In the aftermath of their summer together, Arthur and Ben reflect on their experiences and the lessons learned. They cherish the memories and the growth they achieved, both individually and as a couple. Their story is a testament to the power of love, friendship, and the courage to embrace the unknown. As they move forward with their lives, they remain connected through shared memories and the hope of reuniting one day. This chapter highlights the enduring impact of meaningful relationships and the belief that love can transcend distance and time.
Characters
Arthur Seuss
Arthur is a dreamer who believes in the power of the universe to bring people together. His summer in New York is transformative, as he navigates the complexities of first love and self-discovery. Arthur's journey is marked by vulnerability and growth, as he learns to embrace imperfections and cherish the moments that matter. His relationship with Ben challenges him to confront his insecurities and trust in the strength of their connection.
Ben Alejo
Ben is a New Yorker grappling with self-doubt and the aftermath of a past relationship. His connection with Arthur forces him to confront his fears and open up to the possibility of love. Ben's journey is one of self-acceptance and growth, as he learns to trust in his own worth and the power of vulnerability. His relationship with Arthur is a catalyst for change, pushing him to embrace the unknown and cherish the present.
Dylan
Dylan is Ben's best friend, known for his humor and unwavering support. He provides a sense of stability and comic relief in Ben's life, often acting as a sounding board for Ben's concerns. Dylan's own romantic endeavors add depth to his character, showcasing his capacity for love and friendship. His presence is a reminder of the importance of having a strong support system in times of uncertainty.
Samantha
Samantha is Dylan's love interest and a key player in helping Ben find Arthur. Her resourcefulness and genuine interest in others make her a valuable friend. She navigates her own relationship challenges with grace, offering insight and support to those around her.
Hudson
Hudson is Ben's ex-boyfriend, whose actions indirectly lead to Ben and Arthur's meeting. His presence looms over Ben's life, representing past heartbreak and unresolved feelings. Hudson's character serves as a reminder of the complexities of love and the importance of moving forward.
Jessie and Ethan
Jessie and Ethan are Arthur's best friends from Georgia, whose surprise visit to New York brings unexpected revelations. Their relationship challenges Arthur's perception of love and friendship, prompting him to reflect on his own connections. Jessie and Ethan's journey is one of self-discovery and growth, as they navigate the complexities of their new relationship while supporting Arthur through his own challenges.
Plot Devices
Missed Connections
The concept of missed connections is central to Arthur and Ben's story, highlighting the role of chance encounters in shaping their relationship. This plot device underscores the theme of destiny and the belief that certain people are meant to cross paths, despite the odds.
Do-Over Dates
The idea of a "do-over" date reflects Arthur and Ben's desire to start fresh and overcome past mistakes. This plot device emphasizes the importance of perseverance and the willingness to try again, even when things don't go as planned. It serves as a reminder that relationships require effort and understanding to flourish.
Treasure Hunt
The treasure hunt orchestrated by Ben for Arthur's birthday is a pivotal plot device that underscores the theme of grand gestures and the effort required to maintain meaningful relationships. This device highlights Ben's willingness to go the extra mile for Arthur, showcasing the depth of his feelings and the importance of creating memorable experiences. The treasure hunt serves as a metaphor for the journey of love, filled with unexpected twists and turns that ultimately lead to deeper understanding and connection.
Do-Over Kisses
The concept of "do-over" kisses is a recurring plot device that symbolizes Arthur and Ben's willingness to embrace imperfections and grow together. This device emphasizes the importance of second chances and the power of vulnerability in building a meaningful relationship. It serves as a reminder that love is not about perfection, but about the willingness to try again and cherish the moments that matter.
Analysis
"What If It's Us" is a heartfelt exploration of love, destiny, and the complexities of human connection. Through the lens of Arthur and Ben's summer romance, the book delves into themes of fate, vulnerability, and the courage to embrace the unknown. The narrative highlights the importance of honest communication, the power of second chances, and the enduring impact of meaningful relationships. By weaving together elements of humor, serendipity, and emotional depth, the story captures the essence of young love and the belief that true connections can transcend time and distance. Ultimately, the book serves as a reminder that love is a journey filled with unexpected twists and turns, and that the moments we cherish are often the ones that shape us the most.
Last updated:
Questions & Answers
What is What If It's Us about?
- Chance Meeting, Summer Romance: The story follows Arthur, a summer intern in New York, and Ben, a local, after a chance encounter at a post office.
- Exploring Fate and Connection: It delves into their relationship as they navigate the complexities of first love, identity, and the belief in destiny.
- Navigating Uncertainty: The novel explores their journey through dates, misunderstandings, and personal growth, questioning if their connection is meant to be.
Why should I read What If It's Us?
- Heartfelt and Relatable: The novel offers a genuine portrayal of first love, capturing the excitement, insecurities, and emotional rollercoaster of young relationships.
- Diverse Characters and Perspectives: It features diverse characters with unique backgrounds and experiences, providing a fresh and inclusive perspective on love and friendship.
- Exploration of Fate vs. Choice: The story prompts readers to consider the role of destiny and free will in shaping our lives, making it a thought-provoking and engaging read.
What is the background of What If It's Us?
- Contemporary New York City: The story is set in modern-day New York City, capturing the vibrant and diverse atmosphere of the city.
- Summer Romance: The narrative unfolds during the summer, adding a sense of fleeting time and urgency to the characters' relationship.
- Cultural and Personal Identity: The novel explores themes of cultural identity, particularly through Ben's Puerto Rican heritage and Arthur's Jewish background, adding depth to their personal journeys.
What are the most memorable quotes in What If It's Us?
- "I believe in love at first sight. Fate, the universe, all of it. But not how you're thinking. I just think you're meant to meet some people. I think the universe nudges them into your path.": This quote encapsulates Arthur's core belief in destiny and the universe's role in bringing people together.
- "Maybe the whole reason you're here is because the universe wanted you to meet me, so I could tell you to throw the box away.": This line highlights the characters' playful banter and their shared belief in the universe's influence on their lives.
- "I'm not going to lie: it's the crappiest feeling ever.": This quote captures the raw emotion and vulnerability of the characters as they navigate the complexities of relationships and personal growth.
What writing style, narrative choices, and literary techniques does Becky Albertalli use?
- Dual First-Person Perspective: The story is told from the alternating viewpoints of Arthur and Ben, providing intimate access to their thoughts and feelings.
- Conversational and Humorous Tone: The writing style is engaging and relatable, using witty dialogue and humorous observations to capture the characters' personalities.
- Use of Metaphor and Symbolism: The authors employ recurring symbols and metaphors, such as the post office, the box, and the do-over dates, to enhance the story's themes and emotional depth.
Hidden Details & Subtle Connections
What are some minor details that add significant meaning?
- The Hot Dog Tie: Arthur's hot dog tie, initially a source of embarrassment, becomes a symbol of their first meeting and a recurring motif throughout the story.
- The Dream & Bean Shirt: Ben's Dream & Bean shirt, given to him by Dylan, connects him to the coffee shop where he meets Samantha and later becomes a clue for Arthur.
- The Post Office Setting: The post office, a seemingly mundane location, becomes a symbol of chance encounters and the universe's mysterious ways, highlighting the significance of their meeting.
What are some subtle foreshadowing and callbacks?
- The "What If" Theme: The recurring phrase "what if" throughout the book foreshadows the characters' constant questioning of their relationship and its potential outcomes.
- The Flash Mob: The flash mob proposal in the post office foreshadows the grand gestures and romantic expectations that Arthur brings to the relationship.
- The Box: The breakup box, initially a symbol of Ben's past, becomes a recurring motif, representing the emotional baggage and unresolved feelings that both characters carry.
What are some unexpected character connections?
- Samantha and Patrick: Samantha's friendship with Patrick, her "Nancy Drew" of social media, highlights her resourcefulness and her ability to connect with people, which ultimately helps Ben find Arthur.
- Hudson and Harriett: The close friendship between Hudson and Harriett, initially a source of tension for Ben, reveals the complexities of their shared history and their individual struggles with relationships.
- Arthur and Morrie: The doorman, Morrie, who calls Arthur "doctor," is a recurring minor character who adds a touch of humor and warmth to Arthur's experience in New York.
Who are the most significant supporting characters?
- Dylan: Ben's best friend, Dylan, provides comic relief and unwavering support, acting as a sounding board for Ben's insecurities and relationship challenges.
- Namrata and Juliet: Arthur's colleagues, Namrata and Juliet, offer a sense of camaraderie and support, helping him navigate his feelings and providing a sense of community in New York.
- Jessie and Ethan: Arthur's best friends from Georgia, Jessie and Ethan, serve as a reminder of his past and provide a contrasting perspective on relationships, highlighting the complexities of love and friendship.
Psychological, Emotional, & Relational Analysis
What are some unspoken motivations of the characters?
- Arthur's Need for Connection: Arthur's eagerness to find Ben stems from a deep-seated desire for connection and a belief in the universe's plan, reflecting his longing for a meaningful relationship.
- Ben's Fear of Vulnerability: Ben's initial reluctance to fully commit to Arthur stems from his fear of vulnerability and his past heartbreak, highlighting his struggle with self-worth and trust.
- Dylan's Fear of Abandonment: Dylan's over-the-top behavior and constant need for validation from Samantha reveal his underlying fear of abandonment and his struggle with past relationship failures.
What psychological complexities do the characters exhibit?
- Arthur's Overthinking: Arthur's tendency to overthink and analyze every situation reflects his anxiety and his desire for control, often leading to self-doubt and insecurity.
- Ben's Self-Sabotage: Ben's self-sabotaging behavior, such as being late and downplaying his feelings, stems from his fear of vulnerability and his struggle with self-worth.
- Dylan's Insecurity: Dylan's comedic persona masks his deep-seated insecurities and his fear of losing his best friend, highlighting his struggle with commitment and change.
What are the major emotional turning points?
- The Post Office Flash Mob: The flash mob proposal in the post office serves as a catalyst for Arthur's belief in fate and his determination to find Ben, marking a turning point in his emotional journey.
- The First Kiss: Arthur and Ben's first kiss, and subsequent do-over kisses, represent a significant emotional turning point, solidifying their connection and deepening their feelings for each other.
- The Karaoke Confessions: The karaoke night, where Arthur and Ben share heartfelt confessions, marks a turning point in their relationship, as they begin to understand each other's vulnerabilities and insecurities.
How do relationship dynamics evolve?
- From Chance Encounter to Connection: Arthur and Ben's relationship evolves from a chance encounter to a deep emotional connection, marked by shared experiences, honest conversations, and mutual vulnerability.
- Navigating Insecurities and Past Baggage: Both characters navigate their insecurities and past relationship baggage, learning to trust each other and embrace the complexities of love and friendship.
- The Importance of Communication: The relationship dynamics highlight the importance of open communication, vulnerability, and the willingness to work through misunderstandings to build a meaningful connection.
Interpretation & Debate
Which parts of the story remain ambiguous or open-ended?
- The Future of Arthur and Ben: The ending leaves the future of Arthur and Ben's relationship open-ended, prompting readers to consider the possibilities of long-distance love and the challenges of maintaining a connection across time and distance.
- The Role of Fate: The novel leaves the question of fate versus free will unanswered, allowing readers to interpret the characters' journey and the role of chance encounters in their lives.
- The Meaning of "Us": The title, "What If It's Us," remains open to interpretation, prompting readers to consider the different meanings of "us" and the various forms of connection that the characters experience.
What are some debatable, controversial scenes or moments in What If It's Us?
- Ben's Relationship with Hudson: Ben's continued connection with his ex-boyfriend, Hudson, is a source of tension and debate, prompting readers to question the boundaries of friendship and the complexities of moving on from past relationships.
- Arthur's Expectations: Arthur's high expectations and romantic ideals, while endearing, can be seen as unrealistic and potentially problematic, prompting readers to consider the challenges of navigating real-life relationships.
- The "Do-Over" Concept: The recurring theme of "do-overs" can be interpreted as both a positive and negative aspect of the relationship, highlighting the characters' desire for perfection while also acknowledging the importance of embracing imperfections.
What If It's Us Ending Explained: How It Ends & What It Means
- Open-Ended Future: The ending of "What If It's Us" is intentionally open-ended, leaving the future of Arthur and Ben's relationship uncertain, but hopeful.
- Focus on Growth and Connection: The ending emphasizes the characters' personal growth and the enduring impact of their connection, suggesting that love can transcend time and distance.
- Emphasis on the Journey: The ending highlights the importance of the journey itself, rather than a definitive outcome, encouraging readers to embrace the uncertainties of life and the power of meaningful relationships.
Review Summary
What If It's Us received mixed reviews, with some praising its realistic portrayal of teenage romance and diverse representation, while others criticized its slow pacing and overuse of pop culture references. Many readers enjoyed the characters and their development, particularly the friendship dynamics. The ending was divisive, with some appreciating its realism and others disappointed by the lack of a traditional happy ending. Overall, the collaboration between Albertalli and Silvera was well-received, though some felt the book didn't fully live up to expectations.
What If It's Us Series
Similar Books
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.