重点摘要
1. 医生也会犯错:质疑医疗建议,寻求证据支持
医生毕竟是人,和所有人一样,他们会犯错,存在偏见,甚至掌握过时的信息。许多医学误区的存在,源于多种原因:
- 缺乏时间跟进最新研究
- 药企的影响
- 对长期信念的抗拒
- 遵循既定医疗规范的压力
做一个有知识的患者,主动掌控自己的健康:
- 研究相关健康问题
- 询问治疗方案及替代选择
- 必要时寻求第二意见
- 理解医学知识的局限性
记住,健康最终是你自己的责任。医生能提供专业建议,但你必须积极参与医疗决策。
2. 脂肪误区:吃脂肪不会让你发胖或引发心脏病
“吃脂肪不会让我发胖,糖和淀粉才会。”
长期以来,低脂饮食被奉为减肥和预防心脏病的法宝,但最新研究推翻了这一观点:
- 饱和脂肪并不增加心脏病风险
- 高脂饮食有助于减重和改善健康指标
- 糖和精制碳水化合物才是肥胖和代谢疾病的罪魁祸首
拥抱健康脂肪,饮食中应包含:
- 牛油果
- 坚果和种子
- 橄榄油
- 富含脂肪的鱼类
- 草饲肉类
通过增加健康脂肪摄入,减少糖和精制碳水,你能改善整体健康,维持理想体重,降低慢性病风险。
3. 小麦与谷物:并非我们想象的那么健康
“无论全麦与否,面包的血糖生成指数都高于白糖。”
重新审视谷物摄入。美国农业部食物金字塔及许多营养指南推崇全谷物为健康饮食基石,但证据显示谷物,尤其是小麦,对许多人可能有害:
- 高血糖生成指数,导致血糖和胰岛素骤升
- 含有抗营养素,妨碍营养吸收
- 可能引发炎症和消化问题
- 现代小麦经过大量改良,已与古代品种大相径庭
考虑替代选择,减少谷物依赖,重点摄入:
- 蔬菜和水果
- 优质蛋白质
- 健康脂肪
- 坚果和种子
许多人减少谷物后,能感受到精力提升、体重下降和炎症减轻。
4. 运动为健康而非减重:饮食才是关键
“运动能让你更健康、更快乐(前提是你喜欢所做的运动),但它并不能帮你减肥。”
运动益处多多,但单靠运动减重效果有限,原因包括:
- 运动会增加食欲,导致摄入更多热量
- 运动消耗的热量常被高估
- 身体会适应运动,降低整体热量消耗
减重应聚焦饮食:
- 减少糖和精制碳水摄入
- 增加蛋白质和健康脂肪
- 控制食量
- 可尝试间歇性禁食
运动虽非减重关键,却对整体健康至关重要。选择让你愉悦的运动,提升力量、柔韧性和心肺功能。
5. 阳光照射:合理晒太阳利大于弊
“在人类99.99%的历史中,我们都保持着苗条、健康且无糖尿病的体态。”
阳光对健康不可或缺。尽管有皮肤癌警告,适度晒太阳带来诸多益处:
- 促进维生素D合成
- 改善情绪和认知功能
- 调节生物钟
- 可能降低某些癌症风险
安全晒太阳的方法:
- 逐步增加日晒时间
- 避免晒伤
- 短时间内暴露较大面积皮肤
- 根据肤质和当地紫外线指数调整
值得注意的是,防晒霜使用增加的同时,皮肤癌发病率也上升,提示饮食和环境毒素等因素同样重要。
6. 抗生素:滥用伤肠道,需谨慎使用
“每次你为感冒或其他病毒感染服用抗生素,都会发生两件事:一是抗生素对病因无效,也不会缩短病程;二是杀死肠道及身体其他部位数十亿有益细菌。”
抗生素非万能良药。虽在某些情况下救命,但滥用带来问题:
- 破坏肠道有益菌群
- 增加抗药性细菌风险
- 可能引发长期健康问题
合理用药原则:
- 仅在细菌感染时服用抗生素
- 按医嘱完成疗程
- 服药期间及之后考虑补充益生菌
- 通过饮食和生活方式增强免疫力
记住,大多数感冒和流感是病毒感染,抗生素无效。
7. 激素优化:男女老化皆需关注
“你的激素,比身体任何其他因素更决定你是谁。激素平衡,你就健康。”
激素对健康至关重要。随着年龄增长,激素水平自然下降,带来多种症状和健康问题。优化激素可改善:
- 精力
- 情绪和认知
- 肌肉量和骨密度
- 性欲和性功能
建议进行激素检测和调节,配合专业医生:
- 评估激素水平
- 讨论激素疗法的利弊
- 探索自然支持激素的方法
- 持续监测并调整治疗
激素优化不仅是女性的雌激素或男性的睾酮,而是实现内分泌系统整体平衡。
8. 维生素D:现代医学常被忽视的重要营养素
“维生素D不仅是维生素,更是前激素,参与体内数千种生化反应。”
维生素D缺乏已成流行病。它对骨骼健康、免疫功能和情绪调节至关重要,还可能预防癌症和自身免疫病。饮食难以满足需求。
优化维生素D水平的方法:
- 适度晒太阳(避免晒伤)
- 冬季考虑补充剂
- 定期检测血液维生素D浓度
- 目标水平为50-80 ng/mL,而非仅仅“正常范围”
维生素D与维生素K2、镁、钙等协同作用,需全面营养支持。
9. 甲状腺健康:单靠TSH检测不足以诊断
“只需检测TSH(促甲状腺激素)即可判断甲状腺功能是否正常。TSH正常,甲状腺无恙,症状全是心理作用。”
甲状腺功能复杂。许多医生仅依赖TSH检测,容易漏诊:
- TSH受多种非甲状腺因素影响
- 游离T3和游离T4水平对评估更关键
- 甲状腺抗体可提示自身免疫性疾病
倡导全面甲状腺检测:
- 请求完整甲状腺面板(TSH、游离T3、游离T4、逆T3、甲状腺过氧化物酶抗体)
- 结合症状和化验结果综合判断
- 寻找懂甲状腺复杂性的医生
- 关注饮食、压力和环境毒素对甲状腺的影响
甲状腺功能最佳化对整体健康至关重要。
10. 钙与骨骼健康:牛奶并非灵丹妙药
“乳制品消费最高的国家,骨质疏松率反而最高。”
重新审视乳制品与骨骼健康的关系。高乳制品摄入并不必然强化骨骼:
- 乳钙吸收率低于植物钙源
- 维生素D、维生素K2、镁等营养素对骨骼更关键
- 乳制品高蛋白可能增加钙流失
维护骨骼健康应:
- 多样化钙源(绿叶蔬菜、沙丁鱼、芝麻)
- 保持充足维生素D水平
- 进行负重运动
- 补充维生素K2、镁、硼等骨骼支持营养素
骨骼健康是营养、激素和生活方式多重因素的综合体现。
最后更新日期:
FAQ
What's "Lies My Doctor Told Me" about?
- Challenging Medical Myths: The book by Ken D. Berry, MD, aims to debunk common medical myths that can negatively impact health.
- Encouraging Critical Thinking: It encourages readers to question the medical advice they receive and to become more informed about their health.
- Doctor-Patient Relationship: The book discusses the importance of having a collaborative relationship with your doctor, rather than a dictatorial one.
- Empowerment Through Knowledge: It provides tools and resources for readers to research and understand their health better.
Why should I read "Lies My Doctor Told Me"?
- Informed Decisions: It helps you make informed decisions about your health by questioning outdated or incorrect medical advice.
- Health Optimization: The book offers insights into optimizing your health through diet, lifestyle, and questioning conventional wisdom.
- Awareness of Medical Practices: It raises awareness about how some medical practices may be influenced by outdated research or pharmaceutical interests.
- Empowerment: Reading it empowers you to take control of your health and engage in meaningful discussions with your healthcare provider.
What are the key takeaways of "Lies My Doctor Told Me"?
- Question Medical Advice: Always question the medical advice you receive and do your own research.
- Diet and Lifestyle: Focus on a diet and lifestyle that aligns with human DNA and ancestral eating habits.
- Doctor-Patient Partnership: Cultivate a partnership with your doctor where both parties are engaged in your health journey.
- Avoid Blind Trust: Do not blindly trust medical guidelines or pharmaceutical recommendations without understanding the research behind them.
What are the best quotes from "Lies My Doctor Told Me" and what do they mean?
- "The doctor is more to be feared than the disease." This French proverb suggests that sometimes medical advice can be more harmful than the condition itself.
- "You can lead a doctor to knowledge, but you can’t make him think." This highlights the importance of doctors being open-minded and continuously learning.
- "Eating fat won’t make you fat, but eating sugars and starches will." This challenges the conventional belief that dietary fat is the primary cause of obesity.
- "Your health is both robust and fragile, at the same time." It emphasizes the importance of maintaining a balanced lifestyle to protect your health.
How does Ken D. Berry, MD, suggest we approach our relationship with doctors?
- Partnership Approach: Treat the doctor-patient relationship as a partnership where both parties contribute to health decisions.
- Respectful Dialogue: Engage in respectful dialogue with your doctor, bringing your own research and questions to appointments.
- Seek Lifelong Learners: Find doctors who are eager learners and open to new treatments and ideas.
- Trust Your Instincts: Trust your own health intuitions and research, and don't be afraid to seek a second opinion if necessary.
What myths about diet does "Lies My Doctor Told Me" address?
- Fat Consumption: The book debunks the myth that eating fat, especially saturated fat, leads to obesity and heart disease.
- Milk and Bones: It challenges the belief that drinking milk is essential for strong bones.
- Whole Wheat: The book questions the health benefits of whole wheat, suggesting it may not be as beneficial as commonly believed.
- Calorie Counting: It argues against the idea that all calories are equal and that calorie counting is the best way to lose weight.
What does "Lies My Doctor Told Me" say about cholesterol?
- Cholesterol Myths: The book argues that high cholesterol levels are not necessarily dangerous and do not directly increase heart attack risk.
- Statin Medications: It questions the widespread use of statin medications for lowering cholesterol, suggesting they may not be as beneficial as claimed.
- Dietary Cholesterol: The book states that dietary cholesterol has little impact on blood cholesterol levels.
- Research Flaws: It highlights flaws in the research that led to the demonization of cholesterol.
How does "Lies My Doctor Told Me" suggest we approach nutrition?
- Ancestral Diets: Follow a diet that mimics what our ancestors ate, focusing on whole foods and avoiding processed grains and sugars.
- Fat as Fuel: Embrace healthy fats as a primary energy source rather than fearing them.
- Question Guidelines: Be skeptical of government dietary guidelines, which may be influenced by corporate interests.
- Individual Research: Use resources like PubMed to research nutrition topics and make informed dietary choices.
What does "Lies My Doctor Told Me" say about the use of antibiotics?
- Over-Prescription: The book warns against the over-prescription of antibiotics for viral infections, which do not respond to these medications.
- Gut Health: It emphasizes the importance of maintaining gut health and the negative impact of unnecessary antibiotics on beneficial bacteria.
- Antibiotic Resistance: Overuse of antibiotics can lead to resistant bacteria, making future infections harder to treat.
- Probiotics: Suggests using probiotics to maintain a healthy balance of gut bacteria.
How does "Lies My Doctor Told Me" address the topic of sunlight and skin cancer?
- Sunlight Benefits: The book argues that sunlight is not inherently dangerous and is essential for vitamin D production.
- Sunscreen Use: It questions the widespread use of sunscreen and suggests that diet may play a more significant role in skin health.
- Research Gaps: Highlights the lack of conclusive research linking sunlight exposure directly to skin cancer.
- Natural Exposure: Encourages natural sun exposure while avoiding sunburns, rather than complete avoidance.
What does "Lies My Doctor Told Me" say about thyroid health?
- TSH Test Limitations: The book criticizes the reliance on the TSH test alone for diagnosing thyroid issues, advocating for a full thyroid panel.
- Symptom Consideration: Emphasizes the importance of considering symptoms and not just lab results in thyroid diagnosis.
- Holistic Approach: Suggests a more holistic approach to thyroid health, including diet and lifestyle changes.
- Patient Advocacy: Encourages patients to advocate for comprehensive testing if they suspect thyroid issues.
How does "Lies My Doctor Told Me" suggest we handle vitamin D intake?
- Supplementation Needs: The book argues that most people need more vitamin D than they get from diet and limited sun exposure.
- Breastfeeding and Vitamin D: It challenges the notion that breast milk is deficient in vitamin D, suggesting that mothers need adequate vitamin D intake.
- Health Benefits: Highlights the wide-ranging health benefits of maintaining optimal vitamin D levels.
- Testing and Monitoring: Recommends regular testing of vitamin D levels to ensure they are within the optimal range.
评论
《医生骗我的那些谎言》一书评价不一。许多读者赞赏贝瑞医生对传统医学观念的挑战,以及他强调患者自我掌控健康的理念。他们认为本书内容丰富,颇具启发性,尤其是在营养与健康误区方面。然而,也有批评指出书中缺乏科学引用,且对某些饮食方式存在偏颇。一些读者觉得文风过于简单重复。关于胆固醇、他汀类药物和激素替代疗法等话题,读者的反应既有认同,也有质疑。
Similar Books








