Key Takeaways
1. Leaders must master multiple perspectives to navigate complexity
The evidence is clear that the ability to use multiple frames is associated with greater effectiveness for managers and leaders.
Four key frames. Effective leaders view situations through four different lenses or frames: structural, human resource, political, and symbolic. Each frame offers a unique perspective on organizational dynamics:
- Structural frame: Focuses on roles, goals, policies, and formal relationships
- Human resource frame: Emphasizes needs, skills, and relationships of people
- Political frame: Views organizations as arenas of scarce resources and competing interests
- Symbolic frame: Focuses on culture, meaning, ritual, ceremony, and stories
Versatile thinking. By developing the ability to reframe - to look at the same situation from multiple perspectives - leaders can generate more creative solutions and avoid blind spots. This versatility allows them to diagnose problems more accurately and craft more comprehensive strategies.
Integrative approach. The most effective leaders don't rely on just one or two frames. They develop the capacity to integrate insights from all four perspectives, allowing them to see the full complexity of a situation and respond with nuance. This multi-frame thinking is especially critical in today's rapidly changing, interconnected world.
2. Structural leadership focuses on designing effective systems and processes
The right structure helps ensure that individuals know what they're supposed to do and how they're expected to work with others to get it done.
Clear architecture. Structural leaders focus on creating the right organizational design, policies, and processes to achieve goals efficiently. Key elements include:
- Clear roles and responsibilities
- Well-defined goals and performance standards
- Coordination mechanisms
- Information and control systems
Contextual fit. Effective structural leaders recognize there is no one-size-fits-all approach. They analyze key contextual factors to determine the optimal structure:
- Size and age of organization
- Core technology and processes
- Environment (stable vs. dynamic)
- Strategy and goals
- Workforce characteristics
Ongoing alignment. As circumstances change, structural leaders continuously realign the organization's architecture. They redesign roles, adjust coordination mechanisms, and implement new systems to maintain fit between structure and situation.
3. Human resource leadership emphasizes empowering and developing people
If people feel that the organization is responsive to their needs and supportive of their personal goals, they will respond with commitment and loyalty.
Talent investment. Human resource leaders view people as the organization's most valuable asset. They invest heavily in:
- Recruiting and selecting the right people
- Training and development
- Fair and motivating reward systems
- Work-life balance initiatives
Empowerment. These leaders create conditions that allow employees to perform at their best:
- Meaningful, challenging work
- Autonomy and decision-making authority
- Access to information and resources
- Opportunities for growth
Relationships. Human resource leaders excel at building strong connections with and among employees. They foster a family-like culture of caring, open communication, and mutual support.
4. Political leadership requires building coalitions and managing conflict
Politics is here to stay. Ignoring that reality sets you up for chronic frustration and failure.
Power dynamics. Political leaders recognize that organizations are arenas of competing interests vying for scarce resources. They map the political terrain to understand:
- Key stakeholders and their interests
- Sources of power and influence
- Potential allies and opponents
Coalition building. Effective political leaders create alliances to advance their agendas:
- Identify shared interests
- Negotiate mutually beneficial agreements
- Exchange favors and resources
- Frame issues to appeal to diverse groups
Conflict management. Rather than avoiding conflict, skilled political leaders:
- Surface hidden conflicts constructively
- Create arenas for negotiation
- Mediate disputes
- Find integrative solutions where possible
5. Symbolic leadership creates meaning through culture, rituals, and vision
Symbols cluster to form culture, the shared patterns that define "our way of doing things" for a group or organization.
Cultural shaping. Symbolic leaders recognize the power of organizational culture in shaping behavior. They actively cultivate shared values, beliefs, and norms through:
- Stories and myths
- Rituals and ceremonies
- Artifacts and symbols
- Language and slogans
Meaning making. These leaders help people find purpose and significance in their work by:
- Articulating an inspiring vision
- Connecting daily tasks to a larger mission
- Celebrating accomplishments and milestones
- Fostering a sense of belonging to something greater than oneself
Emotional connection. Symbolic leaders tap into people's emotions and imagination. They use vivid imagery, metaphors, and dramatic flair to energize and unite followers around shared ideals.
6. Reframing allows leaders to see situations from different angles
Reframing is examining the same situation from multiple vantage points. The effective leader changes lenses when things don't make sense or aren't working.
Cognitive flexibility. Reframing involves consciously shifting between different mental models or frames to gain new insights. This flexibility allows leaders to:
- Break out of habitual thinking patterns
- Generate creative solutions to stubborn problems
- Adapt more nimbly to changing circumstances
Multiple interpretations. By reframing, leaders can develop a more nuanced understanding of complex situations. For example, a conflict could be viewed as:
- Structural issue: Unclear roles or misaligned incentives
- Human resource problem: Unmet needs or lack of training
- Political struggle: Competition for scarce resources
- Symbolic clash: Conflicting values or cultural misunderstanding
Tailored responses. The ability to reframe enables leaders to craft more comprehensive and effective responses. They can combine structural changes, human resource interventions, political negotiations, and symbolic actions as needed.
7. Ethical leadership is rooted in core values and organizational soul
Ethics ultimately must be rooted in soul: an organization's commitment to its deeply rooted identity, beliefs, and values.
Moral compass. Ethical leaders have a clear sense of their core values and use them as guideposts for decision-making. They consistently demonstrate integrity by aligning their actions with their stated principles.
Organizational soul. Beyond individual ethics, great leaders cultivate a shared sense of organizational purpose and values. They nurture the "soul" of the organization through:
- Articulating a meaningful mission
- Reinforcing core values in daily operations
- Creating a culture of ethical behavior
- Balancing multiple stakeholder interests
Ethical dilemmas. Leaders often face difficult trade-offs with no clear right answer. Ethical leaders:
- Reflect deeply on the moral dimensions of decisions
- Seek input from diverse perspectives
- Make principled choices, even at personal cost
- Communicate the reasoning behind tough decisions
8. Great leaders craft compelling narratives that inspire and unite
Storytelling is our most basic and powerful form of communication. It transmits emotionally charged information in a form that is accessible, attractive, and memorable to others.
Personal narrative. Effective leaders develop a clear personal story that communicates:
- Their values and motivations
- Key experiences that shaped them
- Their vision for the future
Organizational story. Leaders also craft a compelling narrative for their organization that:
- Honors its history and traditions
- Makes sense of current challenges
- Paints an inspiring picture of future possibilities
Ongoing dialogue. Great leaders recognize that storytelling is not a one-time event, but an ongoing process. They continually refine and retell their stories to:
- Reinforce key messages
- Adapt to changing circumstances
- Incorporate new chapters as the journey unfolds
Last updated:
FAQ
What is How Great Leaders Think: The Art of Reframing by Lee G. Bolman about?
- Multiframe leadership model: The book introduces a four-frame model—structural, human resource, political, and symbolic—that helps leaders interpret and address complex organizational challenges.
- Reframing as a core skill: Bolman emphasizes the importance of shifting perspectives (reframing) to generate new insights and avoid leadership pitfalls.
- Integration of culture and ethics: The book explores how leaders can build soulful, ethical organizations by attending to culture, values, and meaning.
- Real-world application: Through storytelling and case studies, the book demonstrates how great leaders think and act using these frames.
Why should I read How Great Leaders Think by Lee G. Bolman?
- Comprehensive leadership toolkit: The book provides practical frameworks and scenarios for handling diverse leadership challenges, going beyond traditional advice.
- Learn from real leaders: Case studies of leaders like Howard Schultz, Alan Mulally, Lou Gerstner, and Ron Johnson offer actionable lessons grounded in real experiences.
- Avoid common leadership failures: Bolman explains why even smart, experienced leaders fail and how reframing can prevent such mistakes.
- Focus on ethical and soulful leadership: The book addresses the spiritual and ethical dimensions of leadership, helping readers create meaningful organizations.
What are the key takeaways from How Great Leaders Think by Lee G. Bolman?
- Reframing is essential: Leaders must learn to view situations from multiple perspectives to make better decisions and avoid cognitive traps.
- Four leadership frames: Understanding and applying the structural, human resource, political, and symbolic frames is crucial for effective leadership.
- Multiframe thinking leads to success: Research and case studies show that leaders who use multiple frames are more effective and adaptable.
- Ethics and culture matter: Building organizations with strong values, culture, and meaning is as important as strategy and structure.
What is the concept of "reframing" in How Great Leaders Think by Lee G. Bolman?
- Definition of reframing: Reframing is the ability to shift mental models or frames to see situations differently, enabling leaders to better understand complex realities.
- Avoiding narrow thinking: It helps leaders break out of fixed perspectives and creatively redefine problems.
- Practical application: The book uses real-world scenarios to show how reframing leads to more effective leadership decisions.
- Leadership impact: Leaders who reframe can adapt to changing circumstances and avoid being "clueless" in challenging situations.
What are the four leadership frames in How Great Leaders Think by Lee G. Bolman and what do they mean?
- Structural frame: Focuses on roles, goals, policies, and organizational design; leaders act as architects to create efficient systems.
- Human resource frame: Centers on people’s needs, skills, and relationships; leaders empower and support individuals for growth and commitment.
- Political frame: Views organizations as arenas of competing interests and power; leaders build coalitions, manage conflict, and negotiate.
- Symbolic frame: Emphasizes culture, meaning, and inspiration; leaders use stories, rituals, and vision to unite and motivate.
How does multiframe thinking improve leadership effectiveness in How Great Leaders Think by Lee G. Bolman?
- Comprehensive understanding: Using multiple frames helps leaders develop a fuller, more accurate picture of organizational challenges and opportunities.
- Avoids leadership blind spots: Leaders who rely on a single frame risk missing critical aspects, leading to poor decisions and failures.
- Evidence-based results: Research cited in the book shows that multiframe leaders are more effective and adaptable.
- Enhanced problem-solving: Multiframe thinking enables leaders to diagnose problems better and choose appropriate actions.
How does How Great Leaders Think by Lee G. Bolman describe the role of symbolic leadership?
- Creating meaning and culture: Symbolic leaders use stories, rituals, and symbols to create shared meaning and a strong organizational culture.
- Inspiring through vision: They embody values and communicate compelling visions that give people purpose and belonging.
- Case study example: Howard Schultz’s revival of Starbucks is highlighted as a model of symbolic leadership, reconnecting employees and customers to the company’s heritage.
- Sustaining organizational soul: Symbolic leadership helps organizations develop a deep identity and sense of mission.
What is the "curse of cluelessness" in How Great Leaders Think by Lee G. Bolman, and how can leaders avoid it?
- Definition: The curse of cluelessness refers to smart leaders failing because they misread situations and persist in ineffective actions.
- Real-world examples: The book contrasts Ron Johnson’s failure at JCPenney with Lou Gerstner’s success at IBM to illustrate this concept.
- Solution through reframing: Developing reframing skills and multiframe thinking helps leaders see what’s really going on and avoid cognitive ruts.
- Continuous learning: Leaders must remain open to feedback and willing to shift perspectives to overcome cluelessness.
How does How Great Leaders Think by Lee G. Bolman address building and sustaining great teams?
- Soulful teams concept: Successful teams share a deep spirit or soul, nurtured through shared culture, rituals, and stories.
- Leadership roles in teams: Leaders build great teams by managing membership rituals, encouraging diverse contributions, and sustaining symbolic activities.
- Case study: The Data General Eagle Group’s success is attributed to leadership diversity, humor, and informal cultural players who fostered cohesion.
- Beyond skills and structure: Team spirit and shared identity are as important as technical skills and formal roles.
What political skills does How Great Leaders Think by Lee G. Bolman say leaders need to succeed?
- Agenda setting: Leaders must clarify their goals and develop strategies that balance competing interests.
- Political mapping: Understanding key players, their power, and interests is essential for navigating organizational politics.
- Networking and negotiation: Building coalitions, persuading stakeholders, and bargaining effectively are crucial skills.
- Case study: Anne Mulcahy’s turnaround of Xerox demonstrates the importance of political acumen in leadership.
What ethical perspectives and leadership values are discussed in How Great Leaders Think by Lee G. Bolman?
- Four-frame ethics: Each frame embodies a core ethical value—structural (excellence), human resource (caring), political (justice), and symbolic (faith).
- Case studies of ethics: The book contrasts ethical leadership at Johnson & Johnson and Medtronic with lapses at JCPenney.
- Soul and spirit in organizations: Ethical leadership requires clarity of values and courage to act on them, fostering organizations with deep identity and purpose.
- Building ethical organizations: Leaders contribute these gifts to create meaningful, just, and sustainable organizations.
How do stories and worldviews shape leadership in How Great Leaders Think by Lee G. Bolman?
- Leader’s worldview: Leaders’ thinking is shaped by their concepts, beliefs, values, and self-image, influencing how they interpret situations.
- Interplay of stories: Personal stories interact with organizational narratives, shaping shared vision and guiding collective action.
- Examples of storytelling: Alan Mulally’s “One Ford” story and Lou Gerstner’s use of IBM’s history illustrate the power of storytelling in leadership.
- Risks of poor storytelling: Ineffective or mismatched stories, as seen with Ron Johnson at JCPenney, can lead to leadership failure.
What are the best quotes from How Great Leaders Think by Lee G. Bolman and what do they mean?
- “Good thinking is the starting point for good leadership.” This highlights the book’s core message that effective leadership begins with how leaders perceive and interpret situations.
- “If you only have a hammer, every problem looks like a nail.” This quote underscores the danger of relying on a single frame or perspective.
- “Organizations are not machines; they are temples, jungles, and families.” Bolman uses this metaphor to illustrate the four frames and the complexity of organizational life.
- “The soul of leadership is the courage to reframe.” This emphasizes the importance of adaptability and perspective-shifting in successful leadership.
Review Summary
How Great Leaders Think receives mixed reviews, with an average rating of 3.82/5. Readers appreciate its insights on leadership frames (structural, human resource, political, symbolic) and practical applications. Some find it helpful for navigating organizations and reflecting on leadership styles. Critics argue it oversimplifies ideas and lacks depth. Positive reviews highlight its readability and real-world examples, while negative reviews cite repetitive content and outdated concepts. Overall, the book is seen as a useful tool for understanding different leadership perspectives, though opinions vary on its effectiveness.
Similar Books
About the Author
Other books by Lee G. Bolman
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
