Plot Summary
Graffiti and Croutons Mystery
Atlas Corrigan, a successful restaurateur, finds his restaurant vandalized with graffiti and missing croutons, a peculiar theft that stirs memories of his own troubled youth. This incident coincides with a chance meeting with Lily Bloom, his past love, reigniting old feelings and hopes for a renewed connection. As Atlas reflects on his past and the possibility of a future with Lily, he decides against involving the police, understanding the desperation that might drive such acts.
Awkward Encounters and Lingering Feelings
Lily Bloom, a single mother and florist, is caught off guard by a chance encounter with Atlas, which revives emotions she thought were buried. Despite her chaotic life and the shadow of her ex-husband, Ryle, Lily finds a spark of happiness in seeing Atlas again. This meeting prompts her to reflect on their shared past and the potential for a future together, even as she navigates the complexities of her current life.
Texting Etiquette and Teenage Memories
Unsure of how to reconnect with Lily, Atlas turns to his young friend Theo for advice. Encouraged by Theo's insights, Atlas sends a simple text to Lily, which leads him to reminisce about their teenage years and the unspoken bond they shared. This nostalgia fuels his desire to rekindle their relationship, despite the years that have passed and the changes in their lives.
Boundaries and Unwanted Flirtations
Lily's life is a balancing act between her responsibilities as a mother and her career as a florist. Her interactions with Ryle, her ex-husband, are fraught with tension as he struggles with boundaries and lingering feelings. Determined to maintain her independence, Lily confronts Ryle about his overstepping, prioritizing her and her daughter Emerson's well-being despite the challenges of their co-parenting arrangement.
Vandalism and Family Secrets
The mystery of the vandalism deepens when Atlas discovers a young boy, possibly the culprit, sleeping outside his restaurant. This boy's actions and appearance remind Atlas of his own past. A call from his estranged mother reveals the boy is his younger brother, Josh, who has run away. This revelation prompts Atlas to seek out Josh, determined to provide him with the stability he never had.
First Date and Unexpected Sleep
Eager to reconnect, Lily and Atlas plan a date, but exhaustion overtakes Lily, leading her to fall asleep in the car. Understanding her fatigue, Atlas cancels their dinner plans and lets her rest, using the time to read her journal and reflect on their shared history. This unconventional date strengthens their bond, as Atlas's patience and understanding reassure Lily of their potential future together.
Brotherly Revelations and Custody Concerns
After their date, Atlas learns more about Josh's difficult life on the streets, a result of their mother's neglect. Determined to help, Atlas takes Josh in and faces the challenge of gaining custody. This situation brings Atlas and Lily closer, as they support each other through their respective challenges and consider the possibility of a shared future.
Confrontations and Unspoken Tensions
Lily's relationship with Atlas becomes a point of contention with Ryle, whose anger resurfaces upon learning about it. Despite the tension, Lily remains resolute in protecting her daughter Emerson from Ryle's volatility. This confrontation underscores the ongoing struggle to maintain civility for Emerson's sake while ensuring her own safety and stability.
Unexpected Allies and New Beginnings
Lily finds unexpected support from her friends Allysa and Marshall, who stand by her during a tense intervention with Ryle. Their presence empowers Lily to set firm boundaries and demand respect, marking a turning point in her journey. This support allows Lily to envision a future where she can thrive without fear, reinforcing her decision to prioritize her and Emerson's well-being.
Family Ties and Difficult Choices
Confronted by his estranged mother, Sutton, Atlas must navigate the complexities of family loyalty and responsibility. Determined to provide a better life for Josh, Atlas seeks custody, offering Sutton a chance to remain in Josh's life. This decision reflects Atlas's growth and commitment to breaking the cycle of neglect, as he reconciles with his past while focusing on building a stable future for Josh.
Love Letters and Life Changes
Atlas writes a poignant letter to Lily, reflecting on their shared history and his enduring love. This letter captures the essence of their relationship and solidifies their connection, prompting Lily to embrace the possibility of a life with Atlas. The letter becomes a symbol of their commitment, paving the way for significant life changes as they consider moving in together.
Vows and Promises of Forever
The culmination of their journey is celebrated in a heartfelt wedding ceremony, where Atlas and Lily exchange vows that reflect their deep love and commitment. Surrounded by friends and family, they promise to support each other through life's challenges, embracing the future with optimism and gratitude. The wedding symbolizes the strength of their bond and the fulfillment of their shared dreams, as they embark on a life together filled with love, hope, and endless possibilities.
Characters
Atlas Corrigan
Atlas is a successful chef and restaurant owner, haunted by his troubled past. His encounter with Lily reignites old feelings, and he is determined to rekindle their relationship. Atlas's compassionate nature is evident in his decision not to report the vandalism, understanding the desperation behind it. The revelation of his younger brother, Josh, motivates him to provide a stable environment, reflecting his deep-seated desire to protect and nurture those he cares about.
Lily Bloom
Lily is a strong, independent woman juggling motherhood and her flower shop. Her unexpected reunion with Atlas stirs emotions she thought were long buried. Despite her complicated relationship with her ex-husband, Ryle, Lily is determined to create a stable life for her daughter, Emerson. Her past with Atlas provides a sense of hope and possibility, as she navigates the challenges of co-parenting and the potential for new love.
Ryle Kincaid
Ryle is Lily's ex-husband and Emerson's father. His lingering feelings for Lily complicate their co-parenting relationship. Ryle's struggle with anger and control issues creates tension, as he grapples with the reality of their divorce. Despite his flaws, Ryle's love for his daughter is evident, though his actions often blur the lines of appropriate boundaries.
Josh
Josh is Atlas's younger brother, who has been living on the streets due to their mother's neglect. His anger and distrust are evident, yet beneath his tough exterior lies a vulnerable child seeking stability. Josh's actions, though misguided, are a cry for help, and his relationship with Atlas offers a chance for redemption and a better future.
Sutton
Sutton is Atlas and Josh's mother, whose neglect and manipulation have left deep scars on her children. Her reappearance in Atlas's life brings turmoil, as she seeks to maintain control over Josh. Sutton's actions are driven by self-interest, and her inability to provide a stable environment for Josh highlights her shortcomings as a parent.
Plot Devices
Vandalism as a Catalyst
The repeated vandalism of Atlas's restaurants serves as a catalyst for uncovering family secrets and driving the narrative forward. It reveals the existence of Atlas's younger brother, Josh, and highlights the desperation and neglect he has faced. The vandalism prompts Atlas to take action, leading to a deeper exploration of his past and a commitment to providing a better future for Josh.
Journals as a Connection
Lily's journals serve as a powerful connection between her and Atlas, offering insight into their shared past and deepening their emotional bond. The entries provide a window into Lily's thoughts and feelings, allowing Atlas to understand the impact of their relationship. The journals act as a narrative device, bridging the gap between their teenage years and their present lives, and highlighting the enduring nature of their connection.
Letters as Emotional Bridges
The use of letters in the narrative serves as a powerful tool to bridge past and present emotions. Atlas's heartfelt letter to Lily captures the essence of their relationship, offering insight into his feelings and hopes for the future. The letters act as a narrative device, allowing characters to express their deepest emotions and solidify their connections, ultimately driving the story forward.
Custody as a Catalyst for Change
The struggle for custody over Josh serves as a catalyst for Atlas's personal growth and development. It forces him to confront his past and make difficult decisions for the sake of his brother's future. This plot device highlights the themes of family, responsibility, and redemption, as Atlas navigates the complexities of his relationship with Sutton and his commitment to providing a stable environment for Josh.
Analysis
"It Starts with Us" by Colleen Hoover delves into the complexities of love, resilience, and healing. Through the intertwined lives of Atlas, Lily, and their families, the narrative explores themes of redemption, personal growth, and the enduring power of love. The story highlights the importance of confronting one's past to build a better future, emphasizing the strength found in vulnerability and the courage required to embrace change. Hoover's portrayal of complex relationships and emotional struggles offers readers a poignant reflection on the challenges and triumphs of navigating life's uncertainties, ultimately conveying a message of hope and the transformative power of love.
Last updated:
FAQ
Synopsis & Basic Details
What is It Starts with Us about?
- Second chance romance blooms: It Starts with Us follows Lily and Atlas as they navigate the complexities of rekindling their relationship after years apart, while dealing with the lingering presence of Lily's ex-husband, Ryle.
- Family and past collide: The story explores themes of family, both chosen and biological, as Atlas grapples with the sudden appearance of his younger brother, Josh, and Lily navigates co-parenting with Ryle.
- Personal growth and healing: Both Lily and Atlas confront their past traumas and insecurities, working towards personal growth and healing as they navigate their individual challenges and their potential future together.
Why should I read It Starts with Us?
- Emotional depth and complexity: Colleen Hoover masterfully portrays the characters' inner struggles and emotional complexities, creating a deeply moving and relatable reading experience.
- Second chance love story: The novel offers a compelling second chance romance, exploring the challenges and joys of rekindling a past love while navigating present-day obstacles.
- Themes of resilience and hope: It Starts with Us highlights the importance of resilience, personal growth, and the power of hope in overcoming past traumas and building a better future.
What is the background of It Starts with Us?
- Sequel to It Ends with Us: It Starts with Us is a direct sequel to Colleen Hoover's "It Ends with Us," continuing the story of Lily and Atlas and picking up right where the first book concluded.
- Contemporary setting: The story is set in modern-day Boston, with characters navigating the challenges of careers, relationships, and family in a contemporary urban environment.
- Focus on personal relationships: The background is primarily focused on the personal relationships and emotional journeys of the characters, rather than historical or political events.
What are the most memorable quotes in It Starts with Us?
- "I want to help you uncomplicate it.": This quote from Atlas to Lily encapsulates his desire to support her and navigate the complexities of her life, highlighting his caring and protective nature.
- "You're my favorite person, Lily. And now you know why.": This quote from Atlas's letter to Lily reveals the depth of his feelings and the impact she has had on his life, emphasizing the importance of their connection.
- "I'm not saying I want you to see her any less. I just want my key back. I value my privacy.": This quote from Lily to Ryle highlights her need for boundaries and her determination to protect her independence, showcasing her strength and resilience.
What writing style, narrative choices, and literary techniques does Colleen Hoover use?
- Dual perspective narration: The story is told from the alternating perspectives of Lily and Atlas, allowing readers to gain insight into their individual thoughts, feelings, and motivations.
- Emotional and introspective prose: Hoover's writing style is characterized by its emotional depth and introspective nature, delving into the characters' inner struggles and vulnerabilities.
- Use of letters and journal entries: The inclusion of letters and journal entries provides a unique way to reveal the characters' past experiences and unspoken feelings, enhancing the emotional impact of the story.
Hidden Details & Subtle Connections
What are some minor details that add significant meaning?
- The misspelled "ass whole": The misspelling of "asshole" as "ass whole" in the graffiti at Bib's is a subtle nod to Atlas's mother's way of saying the word, highlighting the lasting impact of his childhood experiences.
- The stolen croutons: The seemingly random theft of croutons from Bib's is a callback to Atlas's own past desperation and hunger, emphasizing his empathy for the vandal.
- Lily's "Surprise Lily" nail polish: The detail of Lily's "Surprise Lily" nail polish, which Atlas remembers from their youth, adds a layer of nostalgia and highlights the enduring nature of their connection.
What are some subtle foreshadowing and callbacks?
- Atlas's "We finally reached the shore": Atlas's use of the "Finding Nemo" quote is a callback to their shared childhood and foreshadows their journey of reconnection.
- Lily's tattoo: The tattoo on Lily's shoulder, a heart surrounded by scars, is a callback to Ryle's bite and a subtle reminder of the abuse she endured, while also symbolizing her enduring love for Atlas.
- The recurring mention of the color blue: The recurring mention of the color blue, particularly in relation to Atlas's bedroom wall, subtly foreshadows the depth of his emotions and his connection to Lily.
What are some unexpected character connections?
- Theo and Josh's friendship: The unexpected connection between Theo and Josh, who attend the same school, adds a layer of complexity to Atlas's life and highlights the interconnectedness of the characters.
- Marshall's understanding: Marshall's unexpected empathy and understanding of Lily's situation, stemming from his own past experiences, reveals a deeper connection between them and provides Lily with much-needed support.
- Sutton's past with Atlas: The revelation of Sutton's past with Atlas, including the day trip to Cape Cod, adds a layer of complexity to their relationship and highlights the lasting impact of their shared history.
Who are the most significant supporting characters?
- Theo: Atlas's young friend, Theo, provides insightful advice and a unique perspective, often acting as a voice of reason and offering comic relief.
- Allysa: Lily's best friend, Allysa, offers unwavering support and a dose of reality, helping Lily navigate her complex relationships and make difficult decisions.
- Marshall: Allysa's husband, Marshall, provides a sense of stability and understanding, offering a male perspective and support to both Lily and Atlas.
Psychological, Emotional, & Relational Analysis
What are some unspoken motivations of the characters?
- Atlas's need for stability: Atlas's unspoken motivation is to create a stable and loving environment for Josh, stemming from his own unstable childhood and desire to break the cycle of neglect.
- Lily's desire for independence: Lily's unspoken motivation is to protect her independence and ensure her daughter's safety, driving her to set boundaries with Ryle and seek a relationship with Atlas on her own terms.
- Ryle's fear of abandonment: Ryle's unspoken motivation is his fear of abandonment and his desire to control Lily, which manifests in his anger and overstepping of boundaries.
What psychological complexities do the characters exhibit?
- Atlas's imposter syndrome: Despite his success, Atlas struggles with imposter syndrome, questioning his worthiness of Lily's love and his ability to provide for Josh.
- Lily's fear of vulnerability: Lily's past experiences with abuse have made her hesitant to be vulnerable, causing her to question her worthiness of love and happiness.
- Ryle's emotional immaturity: Ryle's inability to control his anger and his tendency to blame others for his actions reveal his emotional immaturity and his struggle to take responsibility for his behavior.
What are the major emotional turning points?
- Atlas reading Lily's journal: Atlas reading Lily's journal entries is a major emotional turning point, allowing him to fully understand her past and the depth of her feelings for him.
- Lily's confrontation with Ryle: Lily's confrontation with Ryle on the rooftop is a major emotional turning point, as she finally asserts her independence and refuses to be controlled by his anger.
- Atlas's conversation with Sutton: Atlas's conversation with Sutton is a major emotional turning point, as he confronts his past and makes the decision to take custody of Josh, breaking the cycle of neglect.
How do relationship dynamics evolve?
- Lily and Atlas's reconnection: Lily and Atlas's relationship evolves from a chance encounter to a deep and meaningful connection, as they navigate their past traumas and build a future together.
- Lily and Ryle's co-parenting: Lily and Ryle's co-parenting relationship evolves from a tense and volatile dynamic to a more structured and boundary-driven arrangement, as Lily prioritizes her and Emerson's well-being.
- Atlas and Josh's bond: Atlas and Josh's relationship evolves from a strained and distrustful dynamic to a bond of brotherhood, as they learn to trust and support each other through their shared experiences.
Interpretation & Debate
Which parts of the story remain ambiguous or open-ended?
- Ryle's future: The story leaves Ryle's future somewhat ambiguous, with the reader left to wonder if he will truly change or if he will continue to struggle with his anger and control issues.
- Sutton's redemption: Sutton's future is also left open-ended, with the reader left to question if she will ever truly be able to provide a stable and loving environment for Josh.
- The long-term impact of trauma: The long-term impact of trauma on the characters' lives is left somewhat ambiguous, with the reader left to wonder if they will ever fully heal from their past experiences.
What are some debatable, controversial scenes or moments in It Starts with Us?
- Lily's decision to hide Atlas from Ryle: Lily's decision to hide Atlas in the closet from Ryle is a debatable moment, as it highlights the complexities of her situation and the lengths she is willing to go to avoid conflict.
- Atlas's confrontation with Ryle: Atlas's confrontation with Ryle at his restaurant is a controversial scene, as it raises questions about the appropriateness of violence and the boundaries of personal responsibility.
- Lily's decision to allow Ryle visits: Lily's decision to allow Ryle visits with Emerson, despite his past behavior, is a debatable moment, as it highlights the challenges of co-parenting and the complexities of forgiveness.
It Starts with Us Ending Explained: How It Ends & What It Means
- Lily and Atlas's commitment: The ending of It Starts with Us solidifies Lily and Atlas's commitment to each other, as they move in together and plan for a future filled with love and support.
- Breaking the cycle of abuse: The ending emphasizes the importance of breaking the cycle of abuse and creating a safe and loving environment for future generations, as Atlas takes custody of Josh and Lily prioritizes Emerson's well-being.
- Hope for the future: The ending offers a message of hope and resilience, as the characters navigate their individual challenges and embrace the possibility of a brighter future together, highlighting the transformative power of love and forgiveness.
Review Summary
It Starts with Us received mixed reviews, with fans praising the closure and Atlas's perspective, while critics deemed it unnecessary and a cash grab. Many felt it lacked the emotional depth of its predecessor. Some appreciated the realistic portrayal of post-abuse life, while others criticized the bland romance and overuse of flashbacks. Ryle's continued presence was controversial. Readers were divided on whether the book was a satisfying continuation or an unneeded epilogue, with some praising Atlas's character development and others finding him one-dimensional.
It Ends with Us Series
Similar Books
About the Author
Other books by Colleen Hoover
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.