Key Takeaways
1. Love's Nature: Beyond Simple Desire
“Love is the desire to have the good forever.”
More than just attraction. The Symposium explores love as more than mere physical attraction or romantic desire. It delves into the philosophical nature of love, revealing it as a fundamental human drive for something more profound. Love is not just about wanting something, but about wanting to possess the good, and to possess it eternally.
Love as a lack. Socrates, through Diotima, argues that love is born from a sense of lack. We desire what we do not have, and this desire is what fuels our pursuit of love. This lack can be of beauty, goodness, or even immortality. This concept challenges the common notion of love as a feeling of fullness or completeness.
Love's purpose. Love is not just a feeling, but a force that drives us towards something greater. It is a desire for the good, and this desire is what motivates us to seek out beauty, knowledge, and virtue. Love, therefore, is not just about personal fulfillment, but about the pursuit of a higher purpose.
2. Two Aphrodites, Two Loves: Heavenly vs. Common
“Common Love is genuinely ‘common’ and undiscriminating in its effects; this is the kind of love that inferior people feel.”
Dual nature of love. Pausanias introduces the idea that there are two types of love, corresponding to two Aphrodites: the Heavenly Aphrodite and the Common Aphrodite. This distinction highlights the different motivations and values that can drive love.
Common Love. This type of love is based on physical attraction and is indiscriminate. It is a fleeting and superficial love that seeks immediate gratification. It is associated with the younger Aphrodite, born of Zeus and Dione, and is driven by base desires.
Heavenly Love. This love is directed towards the mind and character of the beloved. It is a more enduring and noble love that seeks virtue and wisdom. It is associated with the older Aphrodite, born of Uranus, and is driven by a desire for intellectual and moral growth. This love is more selective and seeks a deeper connection.
3. The Power of Love: A Cosmic Force
“So Love as a whole has great and mighty – or rather total – power, when you put all this together.”
Love's universal influence. Eryximachus expands the concept of love beyond human relationships, arguing that it is a cosmic force that governs all aspects of the universe. Love is not just a human emotion, but a fundamental principle that shapes the natural world.
Love in medicine and music. Eryximachus uses his expertise in medicine and music to illustrate how love operates in these fields. In medicine, love is the force that brings harmony to the body, while in music, it is the force that creates concord between different notes. This demonstrates love's role in creating balance and order.
Love in the cosmos. Love is also the force that governs the seasons and the movements of the stars. When love is well-ordered, it brings harmony and balance to the universe. When it is lawless and violent, it causes destruction and chaos. This highlights love's power to shape the world around us.
4. The Myth of the Androgynes: Seeking Wholeness
“Each of us is a matching half of a human being, because we’ve been cut in half like flatfish, making two out of one, and each of us is looking for his own matching half.”
Original human nature. Aristophanes presents a myth about the original human beings, who were androgynous creatures with two faces, four arms, and four legs. These beings were powerful and threatened the gods, so Zeus split them in half, creating the two genders we know today.
The search for wholeness. This myth explains why humans are driven by a desire to find their other half. Love, in this context, is the longing for wholeness and the reunion with our original nature. This desire is not just about physical attraction, but about a deep-seated need for completion.
Different types of love. The myth also explains the different types of love that exist. Those who were originally split from androgynous beings are attracted to the opposite sex, while those who were split from male or female beings are attracted to the same sex. This highlights the diversity of human love and desire.
5. Love as a Ladder: From Physical to Divine Beauty
“When someone goes up by these stages, through loving boys in the correct way, and begins to catch sight of that beauty, he has come close to reaching the goal.”
Progressive understanding of beauty. Diotima describes love as a ladder that leads from the love of physical beauty to the love of divine beauty. This journey involves a gradual process of intellectual and spiritual growth.
Stages of love. The first stage is the love of a single beautiful body. This then expands to the love of all beautiful bodies. Next, one learns to appreciate the beauty of minds, then the beauty of practices and laws, and finally, the beauty of knowledge. This progression highlights the importance of intellectual and moral development in the pursuit of love.
Ultimate beauty. The final stage of love is the contemplation of beauty itself, which is described as absolute, pure, and unchanging. This is the ultimate goal of love, and it is through this contemplation that one can achieve true virtue and immortality. This concept elevates love to a spiritual and transcendent experience.
6. Socrates' Method: Questioning to Uncover Truth
“It’s the truth you can’t argue against, my dear friend Agathon.”
Socratic questioning. Socrates uses his characteristic method of questioning to challenge Agathon's initial claims about love. Through a series of carefully crafted questions, he exposes the contradictions and inconsistencies in Agathon's arguments. This method highlights the importance of critical thinking and self-examination in the pursuit of truth.
Exposing ignorance. Socrates' questioning reveals that Agathon, despite his eloquent speech, does not fully understand the nature of love. This demonstrates the importance of humility and the recognition of one's own ignorance in the pursuit of knowledge.
The pursuit of truth. Socrates' method is not just about winning an argument, but about uncovering the truth. He uses questioning as a tool to guide his interlocutors towards a deeper understanding of the subject at hand. This highlights the importance of intellectual honesty and the willingness to challenge one's own beliefs.
7. Alcibiades' Confession: Love's Conflicting Power
“He’s the only person in whose company I’ve had an experience you might think me incapable of – feeling shame with someone; I only feel shame in his company.”
Alcibiades' drunken praise. Alcibiades, in his drunken state, delivers a passionate and revealing speech about Socrates. He describes Socrates as a Silenus figure, outwardly unattractive but inwardly full of wisdom and virtue. This highlights the deceptive nature of appearances and the importance of looking beyond the surface.
Conflicting emotions. Alcibiades confesses that he is both attracted to and repelled by Socrates. He is drawn to Socrates' wisdom and virtue, but he is also frustrated by his inability to seduce him. This highlights the complex and often contradictory nature of love and desire.
The power of Socrates. Alcibiades reveals that Socrates has a profound effect on him, making him feel shame and dissatisfaction with his own life. This demonstrates the transformative power of love and the ability of a truly virtuous person to inspire others to seek a higher path.
8. The Symposium's Legacy: Enduring Questions on Love
“Well, Phaedrus and the rest of you, this is what Diotima said, and I was convinced.”
Unresolved questions. The Symposium does not provide definitive answers to the questions it raises about love. Instead, it presents a variety of perspectives and leaves the reader to grapple with these complex issues. This highlights the enduring nature of these questions and their relevance to human experience.
The nature of love. The dialogue explores the nature of love as a desire, a lack, a cosmic force, and a path to spiritual enlightenment. These different perspectives highlight the multifaceted nature of love and its ability to encompass a wide range of human experiences.
The pursuit of wisdom. The Symposium ultimately emphasizes the importance of the pursuit of wisdom and virtue as the highest form of love. It suggests that true love is not just about personal fulfillment, but about the pursuit of a higher purpose and the desire to become a better person.
Last updated:
FAQ
What's "The Symposium" by Plato about?
- Central Theme: "The Symposium" is a philosophical text by Plato that explores the nature and purpose of love through a series of speeches given by different characters at a banquet.
- Setting: The dialogue takes place at a party hosted by the playwright Agathon, where Socrates and other notable figures of Athens discuss love.
- Structure: Each guest delivers a speech in praise of Eros, the god of love, offering various perspectives on love's role in human life and society.
- Philosophical Inquiry: The text delves into different dimensions of love, including physical attraction, spiritual connection, and the pursuit of beauty and truth.
Why should I read "The Symposium" by Plato?
- Philosophical Insight: The book provides deep insights into ancient Greek philosophy and the concept of love, making it a foundational text in Western thought.
- Cultural Context: It offers a glimpse into the social and intellectual life of Athens, showcasing the interactions and ideas of prominent historical figures.
- Literary Value: Plato's use of dialogue and character development makes the text not only a philosophical treatise but also a compelling narrative.
- Timeless Themes: The exploration of love, beauty, and the human condition remains relevant, prompting readers to reflect on these enduring questions.
What are the key takeaways of "The Symposium" by Plato?
- Nature of Love: Love is portrayed as a complex and multifaceted force that drives human behavior and aspirations.
- Different Perspectives: Each character presents a unique view on love, from physical desire to the pursuit of intellectual and spiritual fulfillment.
- Socrates' Contribution: Socrates, through the teachings of Diotima, introduces the idea of love as a ladder of ascent towards the divine and the eternal.
- Philosophical Method: The dialogue exemplifies the Socratic method of inquiry, encouraging critical thinking and the examination of one's beliefs.
What are the best quotes from "The Symposium" by Plato and what do they mean?
- "Love is the desire to have the good forever." This quote encapsulates the idea that love is a pursuit of eternal goodness and beauty, transcending mere physical attraction.
- "Love is neither mortal nor immortal." This reflects the notion that love exists in a liminal space, bridging the human and the divine.
- "The object of love is not beauty, as you suppose." Diotima's teaching suggests that love seeks reproduction and immortality through beauty, emphasizing a deeper, philosophical understanding of love.
- "Love is the pursuit of wholeness." Aristophanes' speech highlights the idea that love is a quest to reunite with one's other half, symbolizing the human longing for completeness.
How does Plato define love in "The Symposium"?
- Eros as a Spirit: Love is depicted as a spirit that mediates between the divine and the mortal, facilitating communication and connection.
- Desire for Beauty: Love is fundamentally a desire for beauty, which leads individuals to seek out and cherish what is beautiful.
- Ladder of Love: Diotima describes love as a ladder, starting from physical attraction and ascending to the love of pure, abstract beauty and truth.
- Love's Dual Nature: Love is neither wholly good nor bad but exists in a state of need, constantly striving for what it lacks.
What is the significance of Diotima's speech in "The Symposium" by Plato?
- Philosophical Depth: Diotima's speech provides a profound philosophical framework for understanding love, emphasizing its role in the pursuit of wisdom and immortality.
- Ladder of Ascent: She introduces the concept of the "Ladder of Love," where one progresses from physical attraction to the love of pure beauty and truth.
- Love as a Creative Force: Diotima suggests that love drives the desire to create and give birth, both physically and intellectually, as a means of achieving immortality.
- Influence on Socrates: Her teachings significantly influence Socrates' understanding of love, shaping his philosophical inquiries and dialogues.
How does "The Symposium" by Plato explore the concept of beauty?
- Beauty and Love: The dialogue links beauty with love, suggesting that love is a desire for beauty and that beauty inspires love.
- Different Levels: Beauty is explored on multiple levels, from physical attractiveness to the beauty of the soul and the beauty of ideas.
- Philosophical Ideal: Diotima's speech elevates beauty to a philosophical ideal, encouraging the pursuit of eternal and unchanging beauty beyond the physical realm.
- Role in Human Life: Beauty is portrayed as a guiding force in human life, motivating individuals to seek truth, wisdom, and fulfillment.
What role does Socrates play in "The Symposium" by Plato?
- Central Figure: Socrates is a central figure in the dialogue, known for his philosophical insights and method of inquiry.
- Diotima's Teachings: He shares the teachings of Diotima, which provide a deeper understanding of love as a pursuit of beauty and truth.
- Challenging Assumptions: Socrates challenges the assumptions of other speakers, prompting them to reconsider their views on love.
- Philosophical Method: His approach exemplifies the Socratic method, encouraging critical thinking and dialogue as a means of exploring complex ideas.
How does "The Symposium" by Plato depict the relationship between love and wisdom?
- Love as a Philosopher: Love is depicted as a philosopher, constantly seeking wisdom and beauty, and existing between ignorance and knowledge.
- Desire for Knowledge: Love drives the desire for knowledge and understanding, motivating individuals to pursue wisdom and truth.
- Diotima's Insight: Diotima's speech emphasizes that love is a lover of wisdom, highlighting its role in the philosophical quest for understanding.
- Connection to the Divine: The pursuit of wisdom through love is portrayed as a path to the divine, offering a glimpse of eternal beauty and truth.
What is the significance of Aristophanes' speech in "The Symposium" by Plato?
- Myth of the Androgyne: Aristophanes presents the myth of the androgynous beings, who were split in half and now seek their other halves to become whole.
- Love as Wholeness: His speech suggests that love is a quest for wholeness and completeness, as individuals seek to reunite with their lost halves.
- Humorous Yet Profound: While humorous, Aristophanes' speech offers a profound commentary on the human condition and the nature of love.
- Symbolic Meaning: The myth symbolizes the human longing for connection and unity, reflecting the deeper philosophical themes of the dialogue.
How does "The Symposium" by Plato address the concept of immortality?
- Reproduction and Immortality: Diotima explains that love seeks immortality through reproduction, both physically and intellectually.
- Intellectual Legacy: The dialogue suggests that creating lasting works of art, philosophy, or virtue is a form of achieving immortality.
- Eternal Beauty: The pursuit of eternal beauty and truth is portrayed as a path to immortality, transcending the limitations of mortal life.
- Philosophical Perspective: Immortality is not just about physical survival but about leaving a lasting impact through wisdom and virtue.
What is the role of the banquet setting in "The Symposium" by Plato?
- Social Context: The banquet setting provides a social context for the dialogue, reflecting the cultural practices and intellectual life of Athens.
- Symbolic Gathering: The gathering of notable figures symbolizes the exchange of ideas and the pursuit of wisdom through dialogue.
- Structure of Speeches: The setting allows for a structured series of speeches, each offering a different perspective on love and contributing to the overall philosophical inquiry.
- Atmosphere of Celebration: The festive atmosphere underscores the theme of love as a unifying and celebratory force, bringing people together in shared exploration.
Review Summary
The Symposium is a celebrated Platonic dialogue exploring the nature of love through speeches at a drinking party. Readers praise its literary quality, philosophical depth, and historical significance. The work presents diverse perspectives on love, from physical desire to spiritual aspiration. Many find Aristophanes' myth of soulmates particularly memorable. While some struggle with the ancient context and homoerotic themes, most appreciate the dialogue's enduring insights into human relationships and the search for meaning. Socrates' speech, relaying wisdom from Diotima, is often seen as the philosophical climax.
Plato's Dialogues Series
Similar Books
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub
digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.