Key Takeaways
1. Embrace Fear and Ambiguity to Live a Fuller Life
"Fear is the enemy—most of all, fear of largeness."
Fear limits us. It prevents us from living fully and authentically. By recognizing fear as our primary obstacle, we can begin to overcome it. This involves acknowledging our fears, understanding their origins, and consciously choosing to act despite them.
Ambiguity is inevitable. Life is inherently uncertain and complex. Embracing ambiguity allows us to:
- Be more open to new experiences and perspectives
- Develop greater resilience and adaptability
- Cultivate deeper wisdom and understanding
By learning to tolerate and even appreciate ambiguity, we can live more richly and engage more fully with the mysteries of existence.
2. Nourish Your Soul and Respect the Power of Eros
"Eros is the life force—desire that wishes most to connect, to build, to combine, to fuse, to generate with the other."
Soul nourishment is essential. In our materially abundant yet spiritually impoverished world, we must actively seek ways to feed our souls. This involves:
- Cultivating meaningful relationships
- Engaging in creative pursuits
- Connecting with nature
- Exploring spiritual practices
- Reflecting on life's deeper questions
Eros is a powerful force. It goes beyond mere sexuality to encompass the vital energy that drives us to create, connect, and grow. Respecting and channeling this force involves:
- Acknowledging its presence in various aspects of life
- Recognizing its potential for both creation and destruction
- Integrating it consciously into our personal and creative endeavors
3. Step into Largeness and Risk Growth Over Security
"Jung's homey proverb that most of the time, 'we walk in shoes too small for us,' reminds us that the necessity of adaptation to the voices around us, the demands of our environment, require that we mostly live through adaptive psychologies rather than being guided by an instinctually driven center that wishes embodiment through us into the world."
Embrace your potential. Many of us live constrained lives, limited by fear, societal expectations, or past traumas. Stepping into largeness means:
- Recognizing our true capabilities and desires
- Challenging self-imposed limitations
- Pursuing ambitious goals and dreams
Growth requires risk. Choosing growth over security involves:
- Leaving comfort zones
- Embracing uncertainty
- Facing fears head-on
- Learning from failures and setbacks
By prioritizing personal growth and development over the illusion of security, we can lead more fulfilling and authentic lives.
4. Live Verbs, Not Nouns: Embrace Life's Dynamism
"All of life is a grand, blooming ambiguity. The more we know about it, the more we realize we do not know."
Life is process, not stasis. Viewing life as a series of verbs rather than nouns helps us:
- Embrace change and impermanence
- Focus on actions and experiences rather than fixed identities
- Remain open to new possibilities and perspectives
Dynamism is inherent in existence. By recognizing and aligning with life's dynamic nature, we can:
- Adapt more easily to changing circumstances
- Find flow and momentum in our pursuits
- Cultivate a sense of aliveness and engagement
Embracing life's dynamism allows us to move through the world with greater flexibility, creativity, and resilience.
5. Find and Follow Your Path of Creativity and Passion
"For Agee, wonder presents itself through the question 'Who am I?' He is his mother's son, his father's orphan, but the question abides, for we all know we are more than our relationships, our roles, our functions—but what are we, then?"
Discover your unique path. Each person has a distinct creative potential and set of passions. Finding and following this path involves:
- Self-reflection and introspection
- Experimenting with various interests and pursuits
- Paying attention to what energizes and inspires you
- Trusting your intuition and inner guidance
Embrace "foolish" passions. Often, our truest passions may seem foolish or impractical to others. Embracing these can lead to:
- Greater personal fulfillment
- Unexpected opportunities and discoveries
- A deeper sense of authenticity and purpose
By honoring our creative impulses and following our genuine passions, we can live more meaningful and satisfying lives.
6. Write Your Own Story and Engage Life's Spiritual Crises
"Either way we are called to die. Only through this death can our natural creativity enact its developmental plan."
Authorship of life. Taking responsibility for writing our own story involves:
- Recognizing and challenging inherited narratives
- Making conscious choices aligned with our values
- Reframing past experiences in empowering ways
- Actively shaping our future direction
Spiritual crises as opportunities. Engaging with life's spiritual crises can lead to:
- Deeper self-understanding
- Renewed sense of purpose
- Personal transformation and growth
- Enhanced resilience and wisdom
By viewing spiritual crises as invitations to growth rather than obstacles to avoid, we can use these challenging experiences as catalysts for positive change and self-discovery.
7. Fight Fate While Loving It: Amor Fati
"Loving one's Fate means that we live as fully as we can the life to which the gods have summoned us."
Embrace the paradox. Amor fati involves both accepting our circumstances and actively shaping our lives. This dual approach helps us:
- Find meaning in difficult situations
- Take responsibility for our choices and actions
- Cultivate resilience and adaptability
Balance acceptance and striving. Practical ways to embody amor fati include:
- Acknowledging limitations while exploring possibilities
- Finding opportunities for growth within constraints
- Cultivating gratitude for life's challenges and gifts
- Focusing on what we can control while accepting what we cannot
By loving our fate while still actively engaging with life, we can find a balance between acceptance and personal agency.
8. Live Fully in the Shadow of Mortality
"An aroused awareness of mortality is not the same as fear of mortality. Daily we are summoned to be mindful of mortality in order not to tumble into triviality, or be unconsciously governed by fear of that which is our most natural fact."
Embrace mortality as motivation. Awareness of our finite existence can:
- Sharpen our focus on what truly matters
- Inspire us to live more fully and authentically
- Encourage us to pursue meaningful goals and relationships
Transcend fear of death. By facing our mortality, we can:
- Cultivate a deeper appreciation for life
- Live more presently and intentionally
- Find meaning beyond our individual existence
Mindfulness of mortality, when approached with courage and wisdom, can lead to a richer, more purposeful life rather than paralysis or despair.
9. Accept That Your Journey Is Your Home
"One never reaches home. But where paths that have an affinity for each other intersect, the whole world looks like home for a time."
Home is not a destination. Recognizing that our journey is our true home allows us to:
- Find belonging in the process of growth and exploration
- Embrace change and impermanence
- Cultivate a sense of home within ourselves
Create meaning through the journey. Practical ways to embrace this perspective include:
- Focusing on personal growth and self-discovery
- Cultivating meaningful relationships and experiences along the way
- Finding purpose in the ongoing process of life rather than fixed outcomes
- Embracing both the joys and challenges of the journey as integral to our "home"
By accepting that our journey is our home, we can find deeper fulfillment and meaning in the ongoing process of life, rather than constantly seeking an elusive destination.
Last updated:
FAQ
1. What is "What Matters Most: Living a More Considered Life" by James Hollis about?
- Exploration of authentic living: The book examines how to live a more thoughtful, authentic life by confronting fears, embracing ambiguity, and reconnecting with the soul’s deeper needs.
- Existential and psychological focus: Hollis discusses the human condition of exile and disconnection, inviting readers to engage with their inner depths to find meaning amid modern disorientation.
- Integration of myth and psychology: Drawing on Jungian psychology, mythology, and personal narrative, Hollis explores how archetypal energies and myths influence our lives.
- Invitation to reflection: The book is structured as a series of reflections, encouraging readers to reconsider their values and what truly matters most.
2. Why should I read "What Matters Most: Living a More Considered Life" by James Hollis?
- Deep psychological insight: Hollis offers profound reflections on the human psyche, especially the challenges of the second half of life, helping readers understand their inner conflicts and unconscious patterns.
- Practical guidance for transformation: The book provides a roadmap for navigating spiritual crises, embracing suffering, and moving toward personal authenticity and wholeness.
- Encouragement to reclaim personal story: Readers are motivated to write their own life stories consciously, rather than living out inherited or imposed narratives.
- Rich literary and philosophical context: The book weaves in poetry, philosophy, and mythology, enriching the reader’s understanding of universal human experiences.
3. What are the key takeaways from "What Matters Most: Living a More Considered Life" by James Hollis?
- Fear governs life: Recognizing and confronting fear is essential for reclaiming agency and choosing growth over diminishment.
- Tolerance of ambiguity: Psychological and spiritual maturity depend on embracing uncertainty and complexity rather than seeking simplistic answers.
- Soul nourishment is essential: Material abundance does not equate to spiritual fulfillment; identifying what truly feeds the soul is crucial.
- Growth over security: The journey toward authenticity requires risking growth, even at the cost of comfort and security.
4. How does James Hollis define and address fear in "What Matters Most: Living a More Considered Life"?
- Fear as the primary enemy: Hollis asserts that fear—not others or fate—governs much of our lives, driving defensive adaptations that limit our potential.
- Two core existential fears: Overwhelmment (the world is too big) and abandonment (being left alone) shape identity and relationships, often unconsciously.
- Societal impact of fear: Fear fuels political division and fundamentalism, and overcoming it is essential for both personal and collective healing.
- Courage and heroism: Only boldness and conscious confrontation of fear can deliver us from its grip, honoring the soul’s summons.
5. What does James Hollis mean by "living a considered life" in "What Matters Most"?
- Reflective self-examination: Living a considered life means regularly questioning one’s values, choices, and inherited beliefs rather than living on autopilot.
- Reclaiming personal authority: It involves moving beyond cultural conditioning and unconscious scripts to make choices aligned with the soul’s deeper needs.
- Embracing ambiguity and complexity: A considered life tolerates uncertainty and resists the lure of simplistic answers or rigid ideologies.
- Ongoing journey: Hollis frames the considered life as a continuous process of growth, not a fixed destination.
6. How does "What Matters Most: Living a More Considered Life" by James Hollis address ambiguity and certainty?
- Ambiguity as maturity: The capacity to tolerate ambiguity is seen as the hallmark of psychological, social, and spiritual maturity.
- Critique of certainty: Hollis critiques the “fascist mind” that seeks clear-cut answers and suppresses complexity, leading to fundamentalism and diminished life.
- Historical and personal examples: The book uses stories like those of Giordano Bruno and Galileo to illustrate the dangers of denying inconvenient truths.
- Embracing contradictions: Honest engagement with life’s contradictions leads to a more authentic and considered existence.
7. What is the role of Eros in "What Matters Most: Living a More Considered Life" by James Hollis?
- Eros as life force: Eros represents the archetypal energy of desire, connection, creativity, and vitality in human experience.
- Balance with Logos: Eros must be balanced with Logos (separation and differentiation) to avoid dysfunction or spiritual impoverishment.
- Gendered expressions: The book discusses how men and women typically express Eros differently, and the consequences of being estranged from this energy.
- Healing wounded Eros: Symptoms like depression and anxiety often reflect neglected Eros, and therapy aims to restore authentic connection to this life force.
8. How does James Hollis explain spiritual crises in "What Matters Most: Living a More Considered Life"?
- Definition of spiritual crises: These occur when our sense of self, roles, or values are overwhelmed by experiences that challenge our current understanding.
- Causes of crises: Trauma, discrepancies between expectations and reality, and conflicts between false and natural selves can trigger spiritual crises.
- Responses to crises: Possible responses include collapse, regression, distraction, or transformation, with transformation being the path to growth.
- Therapeutic potential: Spiritual crises, though painful, can lead to greater consciousness, humility, and a life path aligned with the soul’s needs.
9. What does James Hollis mean by "stepping into largeness" in "What Matters Most: Living a More Considered Life"?
- Living beyond adaptations: Stepping into largeness means moving beyond the limited, adaptive selves shaped by fear and conditioning.
- Permission and fear: Many people lack internal permission to be their true selves, and overcoming this fear is essential for growth.
- Cultural critique: Hollis critiques cultural and religious practices that discourage personal authority and maturity.
- Ongoing process: Embracing largeness is a continuous journey, requiring courage and resolve.
10. How does "What Matters Most: Living a More Considered Life" by James Hollis address the tension between growth and security?
- Choice between growth and security: Every day presents the choice to pursue growth or cling to security; both cannot be fully achieved simultaneously.
- Second half of life: The book highlights midlife as a summons to spiritual growth and deeper meaning beyond social roles and achievements.
- Enemies of growth: Fear and lethargy are identified as primary obstacles to personal development and individuation.
- Embracing risk: Growth requires risking authenticity and enduring repeated “deaths” of old selves and assumptions.
11. How does James Hollis discuss fate, destiny, and freedom in "What Matters Most: Living a More Considered Life"?
- Fate vs. destiny: Fate is described as the given conditions of our lives, while destiny is what we are summoned to become.
- Tragic vision: Hollis draws on ancient tragedy to show how character and limited vision influence choices within fate’s constraints.
- Freedom within limits: Despite determinism, there is existential freedom to choose attitudes and responses, as exemplified by figures like Sisyphus and Viktor Frankl.
- Amor fati: Loving one’s fate involves both fighting against limitations and embracing life as it is, a paradoxical but empowering stance.
12. What are the best quotes from "What Matters Most: Living a More Considered Life" by James Hollis and what do they mean?
- “Find the relay man; hold your position but lean toward the gap...” This metaphor from baseball illustrates the importance of disciplined passion and engaging fully with life’s challenges.
- “The psyche has a better plan for our lives than our ego’s plan, or our culture’s plan.” This quote highlights the need to surrender ego control to deeper, unconscious wisdom for authentic growth.
- “Unless ye die, ye shall not live.” A biblical allusion emphasizing that transformation requires letting go of old identities to embrace new life.
- “The journey is our home.” This encapsulates the book’s core message that meaning is found not in destinations but in the ongoing process of living consciously and authentically.
Review Summary
What Matters Most by James Hollis receives mostly positive reviews, with readers praising its wisdom and insights into living a meaningful life. Many appreciate Hollis's Jungian perspective and his exploration of the challenges faced in the second half of life. Some find the writing style dense and occasionally difficult, but most agree the content is thought-provoking and valuable. Readers highlight the book's focus on embracing ambiguity, facing fears, and living authentically. Critics note the heavy use of psychoanalytic concepts and occasionally obscure language.
Similar Books
About the Author
Other books by James Hollis
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
