Plot Summary
Sister's Ghost on the News
Kit, an ER doctor, is stunned to see her sister Josie, who was presumed dead for fifteen years, on a TV news broadcast. This shocking revelation occurs during a chaotic night at the hospital, where Kit is dealing with the aftermath of a violent beach party. The sight of Josie, with her unmistakable features, ignites a mix of disbelief and hope in Kit. She is compelled to question the official story of Josie's death in a terrorist attack on a European train, setting her on a path to uncover the truth about her sister's fate.
Memories of a Lost Childhood
Kit reflects on her tumultuous childhood, growing up with her beautiful, troubled sister Josie and their charismatic but neglectful parents. Their family restaurant, Eden, was a bustling hub frequented by celebrities, leaving Kit and Josie to fend for themselves. They formed a close bond with Dylan, a runaway who became like a brother. These memories are bittersweet, filled with moments of joy and deep-seated pain, as Kit recalls the love and loss that defined her early years.
A Mysterious New Life
Kit's investigation into Josie's possible survival leads her to New Zealand, where she hopes to find answers. She learns that Josie might have assumed a new identity, living a life far removed from the one she left behind. The search is fraught with emotional turmoil, as Kit confronts the possibility that her sister chose to disappear, leaving her family to grieve a false death. The journey is as much about finding Josie as it is about understanding the choices that led to her disappearance.
A Journey to New Zealand
Driven by the need to uncover the truth, Kit travels to New Zealand, where she believes Josie might be living. The trip is both a physical and emotional journey, as Kit navigates the unfamiliar landscape and her own conflicted feelings. She is determined to find her sister, despite the challenges and uncertainties that lie ahead. The journey is a test of Kit's resolve and her ability to confront the past while seeking closure and reconciliation.
A Stranger's Unexpected Charm
In New Zealand, Kit meets Javier, a charismatic musician who offers companionship and distraction from her quest. Their connection is immediate and intense, providing Kit with a sense of comfort and escape. Javier's presence is a welcome relief from the emotional weight of her search, and their relationship offers Kit a glimpse of happiness and normalcy. However, the encounter also raises questions about Kit's ability to let go of her past and embrace new possibilities.
Secrets of Sapphire House
Meanwhile, Mari, a woman living in New Zealand, is renovating Sapphire House, a historic mansion with a mysterious past. The house, once owned by a famous actress, is filled with secrets and echoes of its former glory. Mari is drawn to the house's history and the tragic love story of its previous owner. As she delves into the house's past, Mari uncovers hidden truths that resonate with her own life, revealing connections between her present and the secrets of the house.
A Family's Haunted Past
Mari reflects on her own family's troubled past, drawing parallels between her life and the history of Sapphire House. Her childhood was marked by neglect and chaos, similar to Kit's, and she has spent years trying to escape the shadows of her upbringing. The house becomes a symbol of Mari's desire to create a new life for herself and her family, free from the ghosts of the past. As she works to restore the house, Mari confronts her own demons and the choices that have shaped her life.
A Sister's Search Begins
Kit begins her search for Josie in earnest, visiting places where her sister might have been seen. She encounters people who may have known Josie, piecing together clues about her sister's new life. The search is both frustrating and enlightening, as Kit learns more about the person Josie has become. Each discovery brings Kit closer to understanding her sister's motivations and the reasons behind her disappearance, while also challenging her perceptions of their shared past.
A New Friend's Comfort
Throughout her search, Javier remains a constant source of support and comfort for Kit. Their relationship deepens as they share their stories and experiences, finding solace in each other's company. Javier's presence helps Kit navigate the emotional complexities of her quest, providing a sense of stability and understanding. Together, they explore the beauty of New Zealand and the possibilities of a future unburdened by the past.
A Dangerous Revelation
As Mari's renovation of Sapphire House progresses, her past threatens to catch up with her. A television crew arrives to film a feature on the house, putting Mari's carefully constructed new life at risk. The exposure could reveal her true identity and the secrets she has worked so hard to keep hidden. Mari must confront the possibility of losing everything she has built, forcing her to make difficult choices about her future and the legacy of Sapphire House.
Revelations on a Stormy Beach
Kit and Josie, now Mari, face each other on a stormy beach, where long-buried secrets come to light. Josie reveals the trauma of her past, including abuse by a family friend, which shaped her chaotic life. Kit grapples with the weight of these revelations, understanding the depth of her sister's struggles. The storm mirrors the emotional turmoil between them, as they navigate the complexities of forgiveness and the possibility of rebuilding their relationship. This moment marks a turning point, where both sisters must decide whether to let the past define them or to move forward together.
A Family Torn and Rebuilt
Kit is introduced to Josie's family, including her husband Simon and their children, Sarah and Leo. The encounter is bittersweet, as Kit sees the life Josie has built, filled with love and stability. The children, especially Sarah, remind Kit of her own childhood, sparking a mix of emotions. Simon's initial warmth turns to confusion as he learns of Josie's past, threatening the family's harmony. Kit's presence forces Josie to confront the lies she has lived by, and the family must navigate the fallout of these revelations. The chapter explores themes of identity, truth, and the bonds that hold families together.
Secrets of the Past Unveiled
Josie shares the full extent of her past with Kit, including the abuse she suffered and the choices that led her to fake her death. The weight of these secrets has shaped Josie's life, driving her to create a new identity. Kit listens, torn between anger and empathy, as she learns about the struggles her sister faced alone. This chapter delves into the impact of trauma and the lengths one might go to escape it. Josie's confession is a plea for understanding and a step toward healing, as she seeks to reconcile her past with her present.
A Sister's Painful Confession
In a moment of vulnerability, Josie confesses to Kit about her relationship with Dylan and the events leading to his death. The revelation is a shock, altering Kit's perception of both her sister and Dylan. This confession forces Kit to reevaluate her memories and the people she loved. The chapter explores themes of guilt, redemption, and the complexity of human relationships. Josie's honesty is a catalyst for change, challenging Kit to confront her own feelings and the reality of their shared past.
A New Beginning for Kit
After the emotional upheaval, Kit returns home, seeking solace in the familiar. She reflects on her journey, the truths uncovered, and the possibility of a new path. Kit considers her future, contemplating a shift in her career and personal life. The chapter highlights Kit's growth and resilience, as she embraces the lessons learned and the potential for change. It is a moment of clarity and hope, as Kit realizes that she is not alone and that she has the strength to forge a new beginning.
Love's Unexpected Intervention
In a surprising turn, Kit's family and Javier come together to support her. They stage an intervention, offering love and understanding to help Kit heal from the past. Javier's presence is a reminder of the connection they shared, and his unwavering support encourages Kit to open her heart. The chapter emphasizes the power of love and community in overcoming adversity. It is a testament to the bonds that endure and the possibility of finding happiness and fulfillment, even after the darkest times.
Characters
Kit
Kit is an ER doctor whose life is upended by the discovery that her sister Josie might still be alive. Her journey to New Zealand is driven by a need for closure and understanding. Kit is practical and grounded, shaped by a childhood marked by neglect and loss. Her relationship with Josie is complex, filled with love and resentment, and her search is as much about finding herself as it is about finding her sister.
Josie/Mari
Josie is Kit's sister, presumed dead for fifteen years. Her reappearance on a news broadcast sets off a chain of events that reveal her new life in New Zealand. Josie is a free spirit, drawn to adventure and risk, but her choices have left a trail of pain and confusion. Her decision to disappear is a mystery that Kit is determined to unravel, revealing the depths of Josie's struggles and desires.
Javier
Javier is a musician Kit meets in New Zealand. His warmth and charisma provide a welcome distraction from her search for Josie. Javier is a man of depth and sensitivity, offering Kit a glimpse of happiness and connection. Their relationship is a catalyst for Kit's personal growth, challenging her to embrace new possibilities and let go of the past.
Mari
Mari is a woman living in New Zealand, renovating Sapphire House. Her life is marked by secrets and a troubled past, mirroring the history of the house she is restoring. Mari is determined to create a new life for herself and her family, free from the shadows of her upbringing. Her journey is one of self-discovery and healing, as she confronts the choices that have shaped her life.
Simon
Simon is Mari's husband, a stable and loving presence in her life. He is unaware of Mari's past and the secrets she keeps, focused on building a future for their family. Simon's love and support are a source of strength for Mari, but also a reminder of the risks she faces if her true identity is revealed.
Dylan
Dylan was a runaway who became a surrogate brother to Kit and Josie. His presence in their lives was a source of stability and love, but his own struggles and eventual death left a lasting impact on the sisters. Dylan's memory is a haunting presence for Kit, a reminder of the love and loss that defined their childhood.
Suzanne
Suzanne is Kit and Josie's mother, a woman whose beauty and charm masked a deep neglect of her children. Her tumultuous relationship with their father and her own struggles with addiction left Kit and Josie to fend for themselves. Suzanne's presence looms large in Kit's memories, a symbol of the chaos and pain of their upbringing.
Veronica Parker
Veronica Parker was the original owner of Sapphire House, a famous actress whose life ended in tragedy. Her story is intertwined with the history of the house, and her presence is felt in Mari's journey to restore it. Veronica's life and death are a mystery that Mari is determined to unravel, revealing connections to her own life and choices.
Helen
Helen was Veronica Parker's sister, who lived in Sapphire House for decades after Veronica's death. Her life was marked by solitude and secrecy, and her journals hold the key to understanding the house's past. Helen's presence is a guiding force for Mari, offering clues to the mysteries that surround Sapphire House.
Hobo
Hobo is Kit's black cat, a feral rescue who provides companionship and comfort. His presence is a reminder of home and stability for Kit, a connection to the life she has built for herself. Hobo's loyalty and affection are a source of solace for Kit, grounding her in the midst of her search for Josie.
Plot Devices
The Nightclub Fire
The nightclub fire in New Zealand is the catalyst for Kit's discovery that her sister Josie might still be alive. The event sets off a chain of revelations and actions, driving Kit to travel to New Zealand in search of answers. The fire is a pivotal moment that brings the past into the present, forcing Kit to confront the truth about her sister's disappearance.
Sapphire House
Sapphire House is a historic mansion with a mysterious past, central to Mari's journey of self-discovery and redemption. The house represents both the secrets of the past and the potential for a new beginning. As Mari works to restore it, she uncovers hidden truths that resonate with her own life, revealing connections between her present and the history of the house.
The Search for Josie
Kit's search for her sister Josie is a central plot device, driving the narrative forward and revealing the complexities of their relationship. The search is both a physical journey and an emotional exploration, as Kit confronts the past and seeks closure. It is a quest for understanding and reconciliation, challenging Kit to let go of old resentments and embrace new possibilities.
The Journals
The journals kept by Helen, Veronica Parker's sister, are a key plot device in uncovering the history of Sapphire House. They hold the secrets of the past, offering insights into the lives of those who lived there. The journals are a bridge between the past and present, guiding Mari in her quest to restore the house and understand its legacy.
The Earthquake
The earthquake that Kit experienced as a child is a significant plot device, shaping her character and influencing her choices. It is a symbol of trauma and loss, a pivotal moment that defined her childhood and her relationship with her family. The earthquake is a reminder of the fragility of life and the need for resilience and healing.
The Beach
The beach is a central setting where pivotal moments occur, symbolizing truth and revelation. It is where Kit and Josie confront their past, and where Kit finds solace and clarity. The beach represents the ebb and flow of life, the constant change, and the potential for healing and new beginnings.
Confession
Confession is a key plot device, driving the narrative forward and facilitating character growth. Josie's confessions to Kit are pivotal moments that alter their relationship and set the stage for healing. The act of confession is a catalyst for change, challenging characters to confront their past and embrace the possibility of redemption.
Family Intervention
The family intervention is a plot device that underscores the power of love and community. It brings characters together, offering support and understanding in times of adversity. The intervention is a turning point for Kit, providing her with the strength and encouragement to face her challenges and find her path forward.
Analysis
"When We Believed in Mermaids" by Barbara O'Neal is a poignant exploration of trauma, identity, and the power of healing. Through the intertwined stories of Kit and Josie, the novel delves into the complexities of family dynamics, the impact of past traumas, and the journey toward self-discovery and redemption. The narrative highlights the resilience of the human spirit and the importance of confronting one's past to forge a new path. The themes of forgiveness, love, and the enduring bonds of family are woven throughout the story, offering readers a message of hope and the possibility of new beginnings. The novel's rich character development and evocative settings create a compelling and emotionally resonant tale that resonates with readers long after the final page.
Last updated:
FAQ
Synopsis & Basic Details
What is When We Believed in Mermaids about?
- Sisters Reunited by Chance: The story centers on Kit, an ER doctor, who sees her long-lost sister, Josie, on a news broadcast, sparking a journey to uncover the truth behind her presumed death.
- Past and Present Collide: The narrative weaves between Kit's present-day search and flashbacks to her tumultuous childhood with Josie, their neglectful parents, and a surrogate brother, Dylan.
- Secrets and New Identities: The novel explores themes of identity, family secrets, and the lengths people go to escape their past, as Kit discovers Josie has created a new life in New Zealand.
Why should I read When We Believed in Mermaids?
- Emotional Depth and Complexity: The novel delves into the complex relationship between sisters, exploring themes of love, loss, betrayal, and forgiveness with emotional depth.
- Intriguing Mystery and Suspense: The mystery surrounding Josie's disappearance and new identity keeps readers engaged, with unexpected twists and turns that reveal hidden truths.
- Rich Character Development: The characters are well-developed and relatable, each with their own unique struggles and motivations, making their journeys compelling and emotionally resonant.
What is the background of When We Believed in Mermaids?
- California Coast Setting: The story begins in Santa Cruz, California, a coastal town known for its surfing culture, which plays a significant role in the characters' lives and relationships.
- New Zealand Landscape: The narrative shifts to New Zealand, where the rugged beauty of the landscape contrasts with the characters' internal turmoil and becomes a backdrop for their personal transformations.
- Cultural and Historical References: The novel incorporates elements of 1930s Hollywood glamour and the history of New Zealand, adding depth and context to the characters' stories and the settings they inhabit.
What are the most memorable quotes in When We Believed in Mermaids?
- "This is why we have funerals. We desperately need to see the truth for ourselves, see that loved one's face, even if it's marred. Otherwise, it's just too hard to believe.": This quote highlights the human need for closure and the difficulty of accepting loss without tangible proof.
- "The only way to survive is to let go.": This line, spoken by Kit while surfing, reflects a broader theme of acceptance and the need to release control in order to move forward.
- "You have not met the right men.": This quote, spoken by Javier to Kit, encapsulates the idea that love and connection can be transformative and that past experiences do not have to define future relationships.
What writing style, narrative choices, and literary techniques does Barbara O'Neal use?
- Dual Narrative Perspective: O'Neal employs a dual narrative, alternating between Kit's first-person perspective and Mari's (Josie's) third-person perspective, creating a dynamic and multifaceted story.
- Flashbacks and Memory: The narrative is interspersed with flashbacks and memories, which provide context and depth to the characters' pasts and their present-day actions.
- Symbolism and Imagery: O'Neal uses rich symbolism and imagery, particularly related to the ocean, to evoke emotions and enhance the themes of the novel, creating a vivid and immersive reading experience.
Hidden Details & Subtle Connections
What are some minor details that add significant meaning?
- The Mountain Dew: Kit's shared love of Mountain Dew with Josie becomes a poignant reminder of their bond, a small detail that evokes a sense of nostalgia and loss.
- Fountain Pens: The recurring motif of fountain pens, used for calligraphy, symbolizes the sisters' shared creativity and their connection to Dylan, adding a layer of emotional depth.
- Mermaid Imagery: The recurring mermaid imagery, from childhood games to tattoos, represents the sisters' shared dreams and the allure of escape, highlighting their longing for a different life.
What are some subtle foreshadowing and callbacks?
- The "De Nada" Guy: Javier's initial "de nada" comment to Kit in the elevator foreshadows their later connection and the unexpected role he will play in her journey.
- The Red Dress: Kit's red dress, initially a simple garment, becomes a symbol of her transformation and her willingness to embrace new experiences, echoing a similar dress worn by her mother in the past.
- The Ocean's Pull: The recurring descriptions of the ocean's pull and the characters' need to be near it foreshadow the eventual revelation of Josie's new life and her connection to the sea.
What are some unexpected character connections?
- Dylan's Influence: Dylan's influence on both Kit and Josie is more profound than initially apparent, shaping their values and their understanding of love and loss, even after his death.
- Simon's Connection to the Past: Simon's family history in New Zealand and his connection to the land add a layer of complexity to his relationship with Mari, highlighting the intertwining of past and present.
- Javier's Shared Loss: Javier's shared experience of loss and his understanding of grief create a deep connection with Kit, making their relationship more than just a casual encounter.
Who are the most significant supporting characters?
- Dylan: Though deceased, Dylan's influence on Kit and Josie is profound, shaping their values and their understanding of love and loss. He serves as a symbol of both protection and tragedy.
- Simon: Mari's husband, Simon, represents stability and love, but his inability to fully understand her past creates a source of conflict and tension. He is a foil to the chaotic lives of the Bianci sisters.
- Sarah: Mari's daughter, Sarah, is a mirror of Kit's childhood self, highlighting the cyclical nature of family patterns and the potential for healing and growth. She is a symbol of hope and the future.
Psychological, Emotional, & Relational Analysis
What are some unspoken motivations of the characters?
- Kit's Need for Control: Kit's need for control stems from her chaotic childhood and her desire to protect herself from further loss, driving her to seek order and predictability in her life.
- Josie's Desire for Escape: Josie's desire to escape her past and create a new identity is rooted in her trauma and her need to break free from the pain and chaos of her upbringing.
- Javier's Search for Meaning: Javier's search for meaning and connection is driven by his own experience of loss and his desire to find solace and purpose in his life.
What psychological complexities do the characters exhibit?
- Kit's Compartmentalization: Kit's ability to compartmentalize her emotions is both a strength and a weakness, allowing her to function in high-stress situations but also hindering her ability to fully connect with others.
- Josie's Self-Destructive Tendencies: Josie's self-destructive tendencies are rooted in her trauma and her inability to cope with the pain of her past, leading her to make choices that ultimately harm herself and others.
- Simon's Need for Control: Simon's need for control and his adherence to rules stem from his desire to maintain order and stability in his life, making it difficult for him to accept the chaos of Mari's past.
What are the major emotional turning points?
- Kit's Recognition of Josie on TV: The moment Kit sees Josie on the news is a major emotional turning point, shattering her sense of closure and setting her on a path to confront her past.
- Josie's Confession to Kit: Josie's confession to Kit about her past and her reasons for disappearing is a major emotional turning point, forcing both sisters to confront the truth about their shared history.
- Kit's Acceptance of Love: Kit's willingness to embrace love and connection with Javier is a major emotional turning point, signaling her readiness to move beyond her past and embrace new possibilities.
How do relationship dynamics evolve?
- Sisters' Reconciliation: The relationship between Kit and Josie evolves from one of resentment and misunderstanding to one of empathy and forgiveness, as they confront their shared past and find a way to reconnect.
- Kit and Javier's Connection: The relationship between Kit and Javier deepens from a casual encounter to a meaningful connection, as they share their vulnerabilities and find solace in each other's company.
- Mari and Simon's Marriage: The relationship between Mari and Simon is tested by the revelation of her past, forcing them to confront the challenges of trust and forgiveness.
Interpretation & Debate
Which parts of the story remain ambiguous or open-ended?
- Dylan's True Motivations: Dylan's true motivations and the full extent of his struggles remain somewhat ambiguous, leaving readers to ponder the complexities of his character and his impact on the sisters' lives.
- The Future of Mari and Simon's Marriage: The future of Mari and Simon's marriage is left open-ended, leaving readers to wonder if they will be able to overcome the challenges of her past and rebuild their relationship.
- The Long-Term Impact of Trauma: The long-term impact of trauma on the characters' lives is left somewhat open-ended, suggesting that healing is an ongoing process and that the past will always be a part of their present.
What are some debatable, controversial scenes or moments in When We Believed in Mermaids?
- Josie's Decision to Fake Her Death: Josie's decision to fake her own death is a controversial moment, raising questions about the morality of her actions and the impact on her family.
- Josie's Relationship with Dylan: The nature of Josie's relationship with Dylan, particularly the revelation of their sexual encounter, is a controversial element, challenging readers' perceptions of their bond.
- Kit's Initial Rejection of Love: Kit's initial rejection of love and her attempts to maintain emotional distance are debatable, raising questions about her ability to fully embrace new relationships and move beyond her past.
When We Believed in Mermaids Ending Explained: How It Ends & What It Means
- Reconciliation and Forgiveness: The ending emphasizes the importance of reconciliation and forgiveness, as Kit and Josie find a way to reconnect and move forward despite their past.
- Embracing New Beginnings: The ending suggests that healing is possible and that it is never too late to embrace new beginnings, as Kit considers a new path and Josie rebuilds her life.
- The Enduring Power of Love: The ending highlights the enduring power of love and connection, as Kit finds solace in her relationships with her family and with Javier, suggesting that love can be a source of strength and healing.
Review Summary
When We Believed in Mermaids received mixed reviews. Many praised its emotional depth, complex characters, and evocative settings. Readers appreciated the exploration of family bonds, trauma, and healing. Some found the romance and character development compelling. However, critics felt the plot was slow-paced, predictable, or unrealistic. Several reviewers noted excessive details and flashbacks. While some considered it a captivating, well-written story, others found it lacking in tension and depth. Overall, the book seems to resonate with readers seeking emotional family dramas with elements of romance and mystery.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.