Key Takeaways
1. Trading is a Mind Game: Discipline is Paramount
To succeed in trading you need several innate traits without which you shouldn’t even start. They include discipline, risk tolerance, and facility with numbers.
Emotional Control is Key: Trading is not just about analyzing charts; it's about managing your emotions. Fear and greed can lead to impulsive decisions, causing you to deviate from your plan. Discipline is the ability to stick to your rules, even when your emotions are telling you otherwise.
Self-Awareness is Crucial: Recognize your own psychological weaknesses and biases. Are you prone to overconfidence? Do you have a tendency to chase losses? Understanding your emotional triggers is the first step toward controlling them.
Trading as a Battle: View trading as a battle against your own impulses and the market's temptations. You must be sober, calm, and focused, ready to execute your plan without hesitation. Discipline is your armor, protecting you from self-sabotage.
2. Markets Reflect Crowd Psychology, Not Pure Logic
Prices reflect intelligent behavior of rational investors and traders, but they also reflect screaming mass hysteria.
Emotions Drive Prices: While fundamental values are important, prices are ultimately driven by the collective emotions of market participants. Greed and fear create opportunities for disciplined traders who can remain calm amidst the chaos.
The Efficient Market Theory is Flawed: The idea that markets are always rational and efficient is a myth. Human emotions often lead to irrational behavior, creating inefficiencies that can be exploited by savvy traders.
Crowd Behavior is Predictable: While individual behavior is unpredictable, crowd behavior tends to follow patterns. Technical analysis helps identify these patterns, allowing you to anticipate market moves and profit from the emotional swings of the crowd.
3. Transaction Costs are Silent Killers
A new trader is like a little lamb walking into a dark forest. He is likely to be killed, and his skin—his trading capital—divided three ways, between brokers, professional traders, and service providers.
Commissions, Slippage, and Expenses: These seemingly small costs can add up to a significant drain on your trading capital. Beginners often overlook them, while professionals focus on minimizing them.
Commissions: High commissions can eat into your profits, especially if you trade frequently. Choose a broker with low fees and avoid overtrading.
Slippage: The difference between the price you expect and the price you get can be a major source of loss. Use limit orders to control your entry and exit prices.
Expenses: Keep your trading-related expenses low. Avoid expensive software, advisory services, and seminars. Invest in yourself, but only after you have generated enough profit to pay for it.
4. Technical Analysis: Reading the Market's Footprints
Technical analysis is applied social psychology, the craft of analyzing mass behavior for profit.
Charts as a Poll of Market Participants: Each price on a chart represents a momentary consensus of value among market participants. Technical analysis studies these patterns to identify trends and reversals.
Trendlines, Support, and Resistance: These are the basic tools of technical analysis. They help identify areas where the market is likely to change direction.
Indicators as Tools, Not Crutches: Indicators are useful for identifying trends and reversals, but they should not be used blindly. Understand how they are constructed and what they measure. Use them as tools to enhance your judgment, not as a substitute for it.
5. The Power of the Three M's: Mind, Method, Money
Psychology, market analysis, and money management—you have to master all three to become a success.
Mind (Psychology): This is about controlling your emotions, maintaining discipline, and avoiding self-destructive behaviors. It's about being a rational, objective observer of the market.
Method (Technical Analysis): This is about developing a system for analyzing prices and making trading decisions. It's about finding an edge in the market and using it consistently.
Money (Money Management): This is about protecting your trading capital and managing risk. It's about surviving the inevitable drawdowns and prospering in the long run.
Mastering all three M's is essential for long-term success in trading. Neglecting any one of them will significantly reduce your chances of winning.
6. Time is a Trader's Ally: Multiple Timeframes are Key
Markets keep changing, and flexibility is the name of the game.
The Factor of Five: Markets are fractal, meaning that patterns repeat across different timeframes. The Factor of Five links all timeframes, allowing you to analyze markets from multiple perspectives.
Strategic and Tactical Decisions: Use longer-term charts to make strategic decisions about whether to be bullish or bearish. Use shorter-term charts to make tactical decisions about entries and exits.
Avoid Single-Timeframe Bias: Beginners often focus on a single timeframe, usually daily, and miss important signals from other timeframes. Analyzing markets in multiple timeframes gives you a more complete picture of market behavior.
7. Money Management: The Ultimate Survival Tool
Futures do not kill traders—poor money management kills traders.
The 2% Rule: Limit your loss on any single trade to 2% of your trading capital. This rule protects you from catastrophic losses.
The 6% Rule: Stop trading for the rest of the month if your account equity dips 6% below its previous month-end level. This rule protects you from a series of losses.
Position Sizing: Calculate your position size based on your risk tolerance and the distance to your stop-loss. Do not overtrade.
Business Risk vs. Loss: A businessman's risk is a small dip in equity, while a loss is a violation of the 2% and 6% rules. Protect yourself from losses.
8. The Organized Trader: Records are Your Compass
Good traders keep good records. They keep them not just for their accountants but as tools of learning and discipline.
Trader's Spreadsheet: Track all your trades, including entries, exits, commissions, and profits/losses. Use it to rate your performance and identify areas for improvement.
Equity Curve: Plot your account balance at the end of each month. It shows whether you are in gear with the market. A rising curve is a sign of success, while a falling curve is a warning sign.
Trading Diary: Record your thoughts and feelings before and after each trade. Use it to learn from your mistakes and victories.
Action Plan: Write down your trading plan for the day ahead. It helps you stay focused and avoid impulsive decisions.
9. Trading for a Living: Freedom Requires Discipline
“You can be free. You can live and work anywhere in the world, be independent from the routine and not answer to anybody.”
Trading as a Business: Treat trading as a serious business, not a hobby or a game. Develop a business plan, set goals, and track your progress.
Freedom from the Routine: Trading offers the potential for financial independence and freedom from the traditional 9-to-5 job. However, it requires discipline, hard work, and a commitment to continuous learning.
The Importance of Self-Awareness: Trading is a journey of self-discovery. You will face your psychological weaknesses and fears. Use them as opportunities for growth.
10. The Importance of a Trading Plan: Your Road Map to Success
A trade is a bet on a price change, but there is a paradox. Each price reflects the latest consensus of value of market participants.
A Plan is Essential: A trading plan is a written document that outlines your trading goals, methods, and money management rules. It is your road map to success.
System vs. Plan: A system is a rigid set of rules, while a plan is a more flexible framework that allows for judgment. A plan is a guide, not a straitjacket.
Components of a Trading Plan: Your plan should include your market selection criteria, entry and exit rules, risk management guidelines, and record-keeping procedures.
Adaptability is Key: Be prepared to adjust your plan as market conditions change. Flexibility is essential for long-term success.
Last updated:
Review Summary
Come Into My Trading Room receives mostly positive reviews, with readers praising its focus on trading psychology, risk management, and disciplined approach. Many consider it a valuable companion to Elder's previous work, "Trading for a Living." Critics note some repetition from earlier books and a lack of detailed technical analysis. The book's emphasis on the "3 M's" (Mind, Method, Money) is frequently highlighted. Readers appreciate Elder's writing style and use of analogies, finding the book accessible and insightful for both novice and experienced traders.
Similar Books
![Reminiscences of a Stock Operator Summary](https://sobrief.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/social/cover_reminiscences-of-a-stock-operator-360px.jpg)
![The Most Important Thing Summary](https://sobrief.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/social/cover_the-most-important-thing-360px.jpg)
![The Intelligent Investor Summary](https://sobrief.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/social/cover_the-intelligent-investor-360px.jpg)
![The Candlestick Course Summary](https://sobrief.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/social/cover_2494501.jpg)
![You Can Be a Stock Market Genius Summary](https://sobrief.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/social/cover_you-can-be-a-stock-market-genius-360px.jpg)
![Antifragile Summary](https://sobrief.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/social/cover_357753.jpg)
![Trade Like a Stock Market Wizard Summary](https://sobrief.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/social/cover_trade-like-a-stock-market-wizard-360px.jpg)
![A Complete Guide To Volume Price Analysis Summary](https://sobrief.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/social/cover_2499755.jpg)
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub
digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.