Emotional Blackmail

1. Recognize Emotional Blackmail: Demands, Threats, and Compliance

Emotional blackmail is a powerful form of manipulation in which people close to us threaten, either directly or indirectly, to punish us if we don't do what they want.

The blackmail cycle. Emotional blackmail follows a predictable pattern:

• Demand: The blackmailer makes a request
• Resistance: The target expresses unwillingness
• Pressure: The blackmailer escalates with threats or manipulation
• Threats: Consequences are spelled out if demands aren't met
• Compliance: The target gives in to avoid negative outcomes
• Repetition: The cycle continues, reinforcing the pattern

Blackmailers may use various tactics to create pressure:

• Catastrophic predictions
• Threats of abandonment or withdrawal of love
• Guilt-inducing statements
• Comparisons to others who comply

2. Understand the Four Types of Emotional Blackmailers

Punishers, who let us know exactly what they want—and the consequences we'll face if we don't give it to them—are the most glaring.

Four blackmailer types:

1. Punishers: Direct threats and aggression

   • "If you leave me, you'll never see the kids again"
   • May use anger, intimidation, or withdrawal

2. Self-Punishers: Threaten self-harm

   • "If you don't do X, I'll hurt myself"
   • Play on fears of abandonment and guilt

3. Sufferers: Use guilt and blame

   • "You're making me miserable by not doing what I want"
   • Often indirect, making targets figure out their desires

4. Tantalizers: Offer conditional rewards

   • "If you do X, I'll give you Y"
   • Dangle carrots that often remain out of reach

Understanding these types helps identify patterns and tailor responses to specific blackmail styles.

3. Identify the FOG: Fear, Obligation, and Guilt

FOG is a shorthand way of referring to Fear, Obligation and Guilt, the tools of the blackmailer's trade.

The FOG effect. Emotional blackmailers create a dense fog of uncomfortable emotions:

• Fear: Of abandonment, anger, or negative consequences
• Obligation: Feeling indebted or responsible for others' happiness
• Guilt: Believing you're wrong or selfish for resisting

This emotional cocktail clouds judgment and pushes targets toward compliance. Blackmailers may not consciously create FOG, but they learn which buttons to push for maximum effect.

Recognizing FOG is crucial for breaking free:

• Notice physical sensations (e.g., tightness in chest, nausea)
• Identify thoughts that accompany these feelings
• Challenge beliefs about responsibility and consequences

4. Recognize Your Hot Buttons and Vulnerabilities

Each hot button is like a power cell charged with our unfinished psychological business—stored-up resentments, guilt, insecurities and vulnerabilities.

Common vulnerabilities:

1. Excessive need for approval
2. Intense fear of anger
3. Need for peace at any price
4. Taking too much responsibility for others
5. High level of self-doubt

These vulnerabilities often stem from past experiences and learned behaviors. Blackmailers intuitively sense and exploit these weak spots.

To reduce vulnerability:

• Identify your specific hot buttons
• Examine the origins of these sensitivities
• Challenge beliefs that reinforce vulnerabilities
• Practice setting boundaries in low-stakes situations

5. Break the Cycle: Stop, Observe, and Strategize

When you feel as though you're sinking under the pressure of emotional blackmail, send up an SOS.

The SOS method:

1. Stop: Don't react immediately to demands

   • Use time-buying phrases: "I need to think about this"
   • Create physical and emotional distance if needed

2. Observe: Become aware of the dynamics at play

   • Notice your thoughts, feelings, and physical reactions
   • Identify the blackmailer's specific tactics

3. Strategize: Plan your response

   • Consider your options and potential outcomes
   • Prepare specific language and techniques to use

This process interrupts the automatic compliance cycle and allows for more conscious, self-respecting choices.

6. Master Nondefensive Communication Techniques

Nondefensive communication will work with anyone at any point in the blackmail transaction.

Key nondefensive phrases:

• "I'm sorry you're upset."
• "I can understand how you might see it that way."
• "That's interesting."
• "Really?"
• "Yelling/threatening/withdrawing/crying is not going to work anymore and it doesn't resolve anything."
• "Let's talk when you're feeling calmer."
• "You're absolutely right." (even if you don't mean it)

Benefits of nondefensive communication:

• Reduces emotional intensity
• Avoids escalation and power struggles
• Maintains your position without attacking
• Buys time for more productive conversation

Practice these phrases until they become automatic responses to pressure.

7. Enlist the Blackmailer as an Ally and Use Strategic Bartering

Asking for help, suggestions or information can open up possibilities you hadn't considered, and it's only human nature that other people will be happier to help carry out a decision if they've participated in making it than if they haven't.

Ally-making techniques:

1. Ask for help understanding their perspective
2. Invite them to suggest solutions
3. Use "I wonder" statements to encourage brainstorming

Strategic bartering:

• Offer to change something in exchange for their cooperation
• Creates win-win situations and shared responsibility
• Example: "I'll start a diet if you spend 30 minutes talking with me each night"

These approaches shift the dynamic from adversarial to collaborative, reducing resistance and fostering mutual understanding.

8. Preserve Your Integrity and Self-Respect

Emotional blackmail may not be life-threatening, but it robs us of one of our most precious possessions—our integrity.

Integrity checklist:

• Am I taking a stand for what I believe in?
• Am I letting fear run my life?
• Am I confronting people who have injured me?
• Am I defining who I am rather than being defined by others?
• Am I keeping promises to myself?
• Am I protecting my physical and emotional health?
• Am I betraying anyone?
• Am I telling the truth?

Maintaining integrity often requires:

• Facing short-term discomfort for long-term gain
• Risking disapproval or conflict
• Trusting your own judgment over others' demands

Remember: A relationship built on constant capitulation to blackmail is not a healthy one. Strengthening your integrity may change dynamics, but it leads to more authentic connections.

9. Disconnect Your Fear, Obligation, and Guilt Buttons

Freeing yourself from the fear of disapproval involves knowing which values and judgments belong to you and which have been imposed from the outside.

Disconnecting techniques:

1. Fear:

   • Challenge catastrophic thinking
   • Practice facing disapproval in small doses
   • Develop a strong sense of personal values

2. Obligation:

   • Examine the origins of your sense of duty
   • Define reasonable limits on responsibility
   • Practice saying "no" without extensive explanations

3. Guilt:

   • Distinguish between appropriate and undeserved guilt
   • Challenge beliefs about selfishness
   • Focus on long-term well-being over short-term relief

This work takes time and practice. Start with small changes and build confidence in your ability to resist manipulation. As you disconnect these buttons, you'll find greater freedom to make choices aligned with your true self.

Last updated: August 10, 2024