Key Takeaways
1. A Promise Born of Love and Loss
“Will you write the book for me?”
A dying wish. The story begins with a poignant request from Lee, a beloved housekeeper, to Sandy, her surrogate daughter. Lee, facing her mortality, asks Sandy to write the book she always dreamed of, a book about her life, a life she claimed "nobody would believe." This request, made in the face of impending death, sets the stage for a journey of discovery and a promise that will span decades.
Unthinkable loss. Lee's request is made even more compelling by the fact that she has never shared details of her past, only hinting at a life filled with unimaginable events. Sandy, an accountant with no writing experience, is tasked with uncovering the hidden truths of a woman who has always been a mystery. This promise is not just a task, but a testament to the deep bond between them.
A legacy of love. The request is a powerful expression of love and trust, a desire to leave behind a legacy that goes beyond her role as a housekeeper. It's a testament to the profound impact Lee had on Sandy's life, a bond that transcends the traditional employer-employee relationship. This promise becomes the driving force behind the narrative, a quest to honor a woman who had given so much.
2. The Arrival of a Life-Changing Presence
"Whether the memory was all mine or crafted by storytelling, not since that summer afternoon in June 1965 when I was three and a half have I met anyone so life-changing."
A bright flash. Lee's arrival into Sandy's life is described as a pivotal moment, a flash so bright it washes out all prior memories. This dramatic introduction emphasizes the profound impact Lee had on Sandy's childhood and the family as a whole. It's as if Lee's presence created a new beginning, a before and after in Sandy's life.
Anticipation and hope. The family's anticipation of Lee's arrival is palpable, with the house in immaculate order and the children eager to meet their new housekeeper. This sets the stage for a relationship that will be far more than just a professional arrangement. It's a moment filled with hope, a desire for a positive change in their family dynamic.
A gentle soul. Lee's initial interactions with the family are marked by her gentle voice, warm smile, and genuine interest in each of the children. She is immediately seen as a kind and caring presence, a stark contrast to the previous housekeepers who had been harsh and distant. This establishes her as a nurturing figure, a second mother to Sandy and her siblings.
3. Unveiling a Past Shrouded in Secrecy
“Someday I’m going to write a book, and nobody will believe it.”
A life untold. Lee's repeated claim that she would write a book "nobody would believe" hints at a past filled with extraordinary and perhaps painful experiences. This statement serves as a constant reminder of the secrets she holds, the stories she has never shared. It's a tantalizing clue that fuels Sandy's curiosity and her determination to fulfill Lee's wish.
A wall of silence. Lee consistently deflects personal questions, offering only vague answers and redirecting the conversation. This creates a sense of mystery around her, a feeling that she is deliberately keeping her past hidden. It's a wall of silence that Sandy must eventually break through to understand the woman she loves.
A promise to uncover. Lee's request to Sandy to write her book is a significant shift, a willingness to finally share her story. This request is a challenge to Sandy, a call to delve into the unknown and uncover the hidden truths of Lee's life. It's a promise that will lead Sandy on a journey of discovery, a quest to understand the woman behind the silence.
4. The Weight of Unspoken Truths
“We’re not to ask our new housekeeper anything about her family.”
A family tragedy. The family is instructed not to ask Lee about her family, due to the tragic loss of her husband and son in a car accident. This creates an atmosphere of unspoken grief and a sense that Lee's past is a forbidden topic. It's a rule that highlights the fragility of Lee's emotional state and the family's desire to protect her.
A burden of silence. The family's compliance with this rule creates a sense of distance and prevents them from truly knowing Lee. It's a burden of silence that weighs on Sandy, a feeling that she is missing a crucial part of Lee's identity. This unspoken rule becomes a barrier that Sandy must eventually overcome.
A quest for understanding. The family's silence, while well-intentioned, ultimately fuels Sandy's desire to uncover the truth. It's a quest to understand the woman who has become so important to her, a desire to know the full story behind the woman she loves. This quest is driven by a need to honor Lee's request and to finally break through the wall of silence.
5. A Sanctuary Amidst Chaos
“I’m incredibly grateful to have a shower stall rather than a bathtub. I forgot to mention to the agency that I do not take baths. Ever.”
A safe haven. Lee finds solace and comfort in the Krilich home, a place where she is accepted and valued. The basement, with its private room and shower, becomes her sanctuary, a space where she can feel safe and at peace. This is a stark contrast to the life she had before, a life filled with trauma and loss.
A balance of needs. Lee and Lillian, Sandy's mother, form a unique partnership, each complementing the other's strengths and weaknesses. Lee's preference for dishes and ironing, and Lillian's love for cooking and laundry, create a harmonious balance in the household. This partnership is a testament to the power of mutual respect and understanding.
A refuge from the storm. The Krilich home becomes a refuge for Lee, a place where she can escape the pain of her past and find a sense of belonging. It's a place where she is not just a housekeeper, but a valued member of the family, a woman who is loved and respected. This sanctuary is a testament to the power of human connection and the importance of finding a safe haven.
6. Baseball as a Shared Language of Joy
“Someday, I’m going to write a book about my life, and no one will believe it!”
A passion for the game. Lee's love for the Chicago Cubs is a central part of her identity, a passion that she shares with Sandy and her siblings. Baseball becomes a shared language of joy, a way for them to connect and create lasting memories. It's a passion that transcends the game itself, a symbol of hope and resilience.
A break from routine. Game days become a break from the usual household chores, a time for laughter, excitement, and shared experiences. Lee's enthusiasm for the Cubs is infectious, drawing the children into her world and creating a sense of community. It's a reminder that even in the midst of chaos, there is always room for joy and celebration.
A connection to the past. Lee's love for baseball is also a connection to her past, a way for her to remember the good times and to find solace in the familiar. It's a passion that has been with her for decades, a constant source of comfort and joy. This love for the game becomes a symbol of her resilience, a reminder that even in the face of adversity, there is always something to celebrate.
7. The Unfolding of a Family's Fractured Reality
“I’m afraid she might not want to continue with us.”
A father's volatile nature. Sandy's father is portrayed as a complex and often volatile figure, whose moods and actions create a sense of unease and instability in the household. His outbursts and criticisms create a tense atmosphere, a stark contrast to the peace and harmony that Lee brings. This highlights the challenges of living in a home where love and respect are not always present.
A mother's quiet strength. Sandy's mother, Lillian, is a woman of quiet strength, who tries to maintain a sense of normalcy in the face of her husband's erratic behavior. Her reliance on prayer and her desire to create a loving home for her children are a testament to her resilience. She is a woman who is trying to hold her family together, even as it is being torn apart.
A family in turmoil. The family's vacations, while seemingly extravagant, are often marred by chaos and disappointment. These trips highlight the underlying tensions within the family, the lack of genuine connection, and the father's inability to provide the emotional support his family needs. It's a reminder that material wealth does not always equate to happiness.
8. A Journey Through Pain and Resilience
“One day, I was preparing a special dinner for my family. I thought I had green beans at home but realized I didn’t. My husband offered to run down to the grocery store. Naturally, my son Pierre wanted to ride with his daddy. On their way home, another car ran a red light. My husband and my boy were killed instantly.”
A tragic revelation. Lee finally shares the story of her husband and son's death, a moment of profound sadness and loss. This revelation is a turning point in the narrative, a glimpse into the pain that Lee has carried for so long. It's a moment of vulnerability, a willingness to finally share her deepest wounds.
A promise of silence. Lee asks Sandy not to ask about her family again, a request that highlights the depth of her pain and her desire to keep her past buried. This request is a challenge to Sandy, a test of her loyalty and her ability to respect Lee's boundaries. It's a reminder that some wounds are too deep to be easily healed.
A life of quiet strength. Despite the unimaginable loss she has endured, Lee continues to be a source of strength and stability for Sandy and her family. Her resilience is a testament to the human spirit, a reminder that even in the face of tragedy, it is possible to find a way to move forward. This resilience is a defining characteristic of Lee, a quality that makes her so admirable.
9. The Haunting Legacy of Manteno
“I think you should trust your doctor.”
A dark history. The discovery of Lee's time at Manteno State Hospital reveals a history of abuse, neglect, and experimentation. This revelation is a shocking and disturbing glimpse into the dark side of mental health care in the past. It's a reminder of the importance of compassion and respect for all individuals, regardless of their mental state.
A system of cruelty. The descriptions of electroshock therapy, hydrotherapy, and the use of restraints highlight the inhumane treatment of patients at Manteno. These details paint a picture of a system that was designed to control and punish, rather than to heal and support. It's a reminder of the importance of advocating for the rights of the vulnerable.
A search for answers. Sandy's visit to Manteno is a quest to understand the horrors that Lee endured and to find answers to the questions that have haunted her for so long. It's a journey into the past, a confrontation with the darkness that Lee had tried so hard to leave behind. This quest is driven by a need to honor Lee's memory and to finally understand the full scope of her suffering.
10. Reconnecting with a Family Lost and Found
“I’m trusting you to make sure nobody sends me any live animals.”
A family revealed. The discovery of Lee's siblings and their families is a moment of both joy and sadness. It's a reminder that Lee was not alone in the world, that she had a family who had been searching for her for decades. This revelation is a testament to the power of human connection and the importance of family ties.
A web of secrets. The reasons behind Lee's silence become clearer as Sandy learns about the abuse she suffered and the children she was forced to give up. This revelation is a testament to the complexity of human experience and the lengths people will go to protect themselves from further pain. It's a reminder that secrets are often born out of trauma and fear.
A quest for reconciliation. Sandy's desire to reunite Lee with her family is a testament to her love and respect for the woman who had been her second mother. It's a quest to heal the wounds of the past and to bring closure to a story that has been shrouded in secrecy for too long. This quest is driven by a desire to honor Lee's memory and to finally bring her home.
11. The Power of Truth and Reconciliation
“I would like to stay, but I don’t want to be a bother, so if you prefer, I can remain in the basement on my days off.”
A legacy of love. The story culminates in Sandy's efforts to honor Lee's memory by sharing her story and reuniting her with her loved ones. This is a testament to the power of love and the importance of keeping promises. It's a reminder that even in the face of death, it is possible to create a lasting legacy.
A journey of healing. Sandy's journey is not just about uncovering Lee's past, but also about her own healing and growth. It's a process of coming to terms with the complexities of human experience and the importance of empathy and understanding. This journey is a testament to the power of truth and the importance of confronting the past.
A celebration of life. The story ends with a sense of peace and reconciliation, a celebration of Lee's life and the impact she had on those around her. It's a reminder that even in the face of tragedy, it is possible to find hope and to create a better future. This celebration is a testament to the power of the human spirit and the importance of honoring the lives of those who have touched us.
Last updated:
FAQ
What is The Housekeeper's Secret by Sandra Schnakenburg about?
- Personal memoir and investigation: The book is a nonfiction memoir chronicling Sandra Schnakenburg’s journey to uncover the hidden past of Lee Metoyer, the housekeeper who became a second mother to her family.
- Themes of trauma and healing: It explores Lee’s mysterious and traumatic history, her resilience, and the profound impact she had on Sandra’s life and family.
- Family secrets and discovery: The narrative weaves together family dynamics, the process of healing, and the uncovering of long-held secrets that shaped both Lee’s and Sandra’s lives.
Why should I read The Housekeeper's Secret by Sandra Schnakenburg?
- Inspiring story of resilience: The memoir offers a powerful testament to human strength, showing how Lee survived unimaginable trauma and rebuilt her life with dignity and love.
- Unveils hidden histories: It sheds light on untold stories of mental health, institutional abuse, and family secrets, providing a compassionate look at difficult subjects.
- Emotional and heartfelt narrative: Sandra’s honest storytelling invites readers into a journey of discovery, healing, and reconciliation, making it relatable and moving.
What are the key takeaways from The Housekeeper's Secret by Sandra Schnakenburg?
- Resilience in adversity: Lee’s life exemplifies how one can endure severe trauma and still find joy and purpose, encouraging readers to recognize their own inner strength.
- Importance of family and belonging: The memoir highlights how both biological and chosen family can provide healing and support, transforming lives through acceptance and care.
- Healing through truth: Sandra’s quest to uncover Lee’s past demonstrates that facing painful truths is essential for closure and peace, and that telling one’s story can be liberating.
Who was Lee Metoyer, and what role did she play in Sandra Schnakenburg’s life?
- Housekeeper and second mother: Lee Metoyer was a Creole woman who joined the Krilich family in 1965, becoming a beloved, nurturing figure to Sandra and her siblings.
- Mysterious and traumatic past: Lee endured a brutal gang rape, institutionalization at Manteno State Hospital, and the loss of her children, all of which she kept secret for many years.
- Source of wisdom and support: Despite her trauma, Lee provided emotional stability, life lessons, and unconditional love, profoundly shaping Sandra’s upbringing and recovery from personal hardships.
How did Sandra Schnakenburg discover Lee Metoyer’s secret past in The Housekeeper's Secret?
- Discovery of Lee’s ashes: After Lee’s death, Sandra found her ashes hidden in her mother’s closet, sparking a quest to learn more about Lee’s life.
- Research and family outreach: Sandra conducted extensive research, visited Melrose Plantation, and contacted Lee’s siblings and children to piece together her history.
- Revelations through interviews: Conversations with Lee’s relatives and investigation into Manteno State Hospital revealed the full extent of Lee’s trauma and resilience.
What was Manteno State Hospital, and how did it affect Lee Metoyer in The Housekeeper's Secret?
- Mental institution background: Manteno State Hospital was a mental institution in Illinois where Lee was committed for thirteen years following her assault and trauma.
- Harsh treatments and abuse: The hospital was notorious for overcrowding, electroshock therapy, insulin shock therapy, and sexual abuse, all of which Lee endured.
- Long-term impact: Lee’s time at Manteno deeply affected her physical and mental health, led to the loss of her children, and shaped her later life and relationships.
What is the significance of the Metoyer family history and Creole heritage in The Housekeeper's Secret?
- Rich Creole lineage: Lee was descended from the Metoyer family of Louisiana, a prominent Creole family with a legacy tied to Melrose Plantation.
- Coincoin’s legacy: The book explores the story of Marie Thérèse “Coincoin,” a former slave and matriarch of the Metoyer family, symbolizing resilience and strength.
- Cultural identity and healing: Understanding Lee’s ancestry provided Sandra with deeper insight into Lee’s identity and the historical context of her struggles and achievements.
How did Sandra Schnakenburg reunite Lee Metoyer’s family in The Housekeeper's Secret?
- Locating relatives: Sandra found Lee’s siblings and children, many of whom were unaware of Lee’s fate, through research and outreach.
- Organizing a family reunion: She arranged a reunion with Lee’s son Pierre and daughter Angel, sharing memories and building new relationships.
- Facilitating healing: The reunion allowed Lee’s descendants to connect with their mother’s legacy and brought closure and healing to both families.
What major life event happened to Sandra Schnakenburg, and how did Lee Metoyer help her through it?
- Severe bike accident: Sandra suffered a traumatic brain injury and severe facial scars after being hit by a car while biking to school.
- Lee’s unwavering support: Lee became a constant presence during Sandra’s recovery, helping her with physical and emotional challenges and encouraging therapeutic activities.
- Focus on healing: Lee’s approach emphasized patience, perseverance, and emotional support, helping Sandra rebuild her confidence and cope with her new reality.
What role do puzzles and baseball play in The Housekeeper's Secret by Sandra Schnakenburg?
- Therapeutic puzzles: Working on jigsaw puzzles with Lee helped Sandra calm her anxiety, improve focus, and find meditative peace during recovery.
- Symbol of patience and bonding: Puzzles became a metaphor for healing and a shared activity that strengthened the bond between Sandra and Lee.
- Baseball as hope: Lee’s passion for the Chicago Cubs and her admiration for Ernie Banks provided joy, stability, and a symbol of resilience throughout the memoir.
How does The Housekeeper's Secret by Sandra Schnakenburg address the theme of secrecy and hidden truths?
- Lee’s guarded past: Lee’s reluctance to discuss her early life and the tragedy she endured adds mystery and tension to the narrative.
- Sandra’s investigative journey: The author’s quest to uncover Lee’s story reveals surprising and sometimes painful realities, highlighting the complexity of personal histories.
- Impact on understanding: Uncovering these secrets helped Sandra and her family appreciate Lee’s strength and the reasons behind her silence.
What are the best quotes from The Housekeeper's Secret by Sandra Schnakenburg and what do they mean?
- On love’s power: “Love recognizes no barriers. It jumps hurdles, leaps fences, penetrates walls to arrive at its destination full of hope.” (Maya Angelou) This sets the tone for the memoir’s exploration of love overcoming hardship.
- On resilience: “Lee was a remarkable survivor. Her story is as tragic as it is astonishing. Her survival, her transformation—they’re nothing short of miraculous.” This highlights Lee’s extraordinary strength.
- On hope and renewal: “Spring will come and so will happiness. Hold on. Life will get warmer.” (Anita Krizzan) This frames the memoir’s theme of hope after hardship.
- On life’s puzzles: “It’s the process of doing the puzzle that enriches the soul.” This reflects the book’s theme of valuing the journey of healing and growth over the end result.
Review Summary
The Housekeeper's Secret is a deeply emotional memoir that captivated readers with its story of love, resilience, and hidden truths. Many praised the author's skill in unraveling Lee's mysterious past while sharing her own family's struggles. Reviewers found the book to be a page-turner, beautifully written, and touching. Some noted it was more about Sandra's life than Lee's, but most appreciated the powerful narrative of survival and strength. While a few found it depressing, the majority were moved by the story's impact and inspirational message.
Similar Books
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
